Wednesday, April 22, 2009

My Letter to Samdech Ta Norodom Sihanouk

My Letter to Samdech Ta N. Sihanouk,

From analytical analysis's point of view, Samdech Ta is just a Father of himself and remote Cambodian farmers in current Cambodia politics. But in reality, real Samdech Ta's flesh and bone have already been fleshed out by Hun Sen. There is analogy study of Taksin Shinawatra who has tried to de-popularize Thai King Phumibol in the meantime that Hun Sen is trying to de-popularize Khmer King Sihanouk.

It is logical to the concept of political competition that "one cave should exist only one tiger". The cave of political popularity cannot be two in the political arena.


I am really appreciate with the political narrative Samdech Ta recalls during his heyday. Of course, Somdech Ta's information is useful for younger generation like me and other Cambodian friends. Personally, I have learned about Somdech Ta's political career at least from few different sources:

  • 1. From the elders who admired Somdech Ta as their hero and extraordinary man in their life span. Some elders boasted themselves about their lucky to see Samdech Ta in person, some boasted themselves about their lucky to have touched Samdech Ta's hand and they felt cold, tender and unforgettable etc. Some elders boasted about their lucky to get white scarf as their precious gift from Samdech Ta. They also showed me this white scarf as it is still kept in their sacred alter to worship. There are many other extraordinary appearances, words and kindness about Samdech Ta.

When I was young, I dream of Samdech Ta's face and kindness as he is named "Samdech Euy". We are his Koun Chao (children & grand children) has to pay respect and be humble to him.

In that time, I was too amazed by the fame and narratives told by the elders.

  • 2. I learned about Somdech Ta from school. It is unbelievable that though Samdech Ta sided with Pol Pot to fight against CPP along the Cambodia-Thai border. The text book in that time condemned only Pol Pot, Ieng Sary and Kiev Samphan as the main devils. This hatred propaganda spread entirely and it had always seduced the young adults to go carry guns and kill all those Khmer Rouge leaders. However, I learned at school is not different from the narrative of elders about Samdech Ta. Samdech Ta's figure was always exceptional.

  • 3. I learned about Samdech Ta from my own research and reading. Many analytical books describe Samdech Ta in different volumes. However, their intellectual and analytical writing has left some significant remarks about Samdech Ta N. Sihanouk:

  • 3.1. He is a king father, the universal monarchy of Cambodians. He is the hero of war, peace and uncertainty. He is also the King, the prime minister, the prisoner, the singer, dancer, movie maker, and blogger. He is also the father of independence as well as the father of Khmer Rouge brutality.
  • 3.1. He is the populist and demagogic political leader, the sweetest public speaker, the flip-flopper, the manipulator, the cheater, and the revenged...etc

  • 3.2. He has played a great role model as a Cambodian political leader who has always used populist strategy, anti-democratic principle, violence-prone leadership style, and personal-centric decision making etc

  • 3.3. Many later Cambodian leaders have used the style of King Father as their role model. For example, current Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen has copied almost every aspect of leadership from Samdech Ta namely using his so-called personal funds to build schools, roads, bridges, hospitals, and temples by inscribing his name and spouse there.

Like elders told me, Samdech Ta is very kind because he gave all his personal property from the smallest gifts to the building of national infrastructures such as schools, roads, hospitals and temples etc. Now, elders have not mentioned this charity activity referring to Samdech Ta anymore, peoples have always admired Prime Minister Hun Sen for his charity activities. So, we can see the Samdech Ta and Prime Minister Hun Sen have used the same strategy to legitimize the power. But what is new for all of us is the political shift changing from Monarchical Charity to Ordinary People Charity (or from King Sihanouk to ordinary Hun Sen).

Will Cambodia live with this leadership style to another unpredictable years or not? Cambodia will be better through this leadership example or not?

Samdech Ta is not different from Hun Sen and his team works who have always used the same political rhetoric. For instance, they said "Pol Pot desired to get Khmer Krom back that why Vietnam attacked them, Cambodian people in abroad are good in speaking but have done nothing to Cambodian nation, the speakers are good in speaking but the doers are still doing to care Cambodia nation", or many other rhetoric which is considered childish rhetoric to fool the Cambodian farmers.

This simple childish rhetoric has been used since the reign of Samdech Ta, and it has been continually used by Lon Nol, Pol Pot, and current Hun Sen.

So, how long this childish rhetoric will be used in Cambodia politics? To be a good Cambodian leaders, do this rhetoric is important or nonsense?

From analytical analysis's point of view, Samdech Ta is just a Father of himself and remote Cambodian farmers in current Cambodia politics. But in reality, real Samdech Ta's flesh and bone have already been fleshed out by Hun Sen. There is analogy study of Taksin Shinawatra who has tried to de-popularize Thai King Phummibol in the meantime that Hun Sen is trying to de-popularize Khmer King Sihanouk.

It is logical to the concept of political competition that "one cave should exist only one tiger". The cave of political popularity cannot be two in the political arena.

But Thaksin is facing difficult challenge, while Hun Sen is freely riding on his victorious seat.

Samdech Ta can spend his last breath to favor whoever has given him a shade as part of Cambodian practice, paying gratitude is authentic. But Samdech Ta has also faced the reality that this shade is not a genuine shade for him any more.

I wish Samdech Ta can see this reality and do something meaningful for his last blink in this world.

KY

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

ស្តេចសៀមខិតខំឈ្លានពានប្រទេសដទៃ ស្តេចខ្មែរ
ធ្វើអ្វីក្រៅពីរាំនិងច្រៀង ?

Anonymous said...

My Samdech Ta, u r my best model, u r Preah Bat Dhammik who save Cambodian people. The ones who insulted u, they will go into hell. Long live

Kon chao

Anonymous said...

Who was the head of the killer in Cambodia during the 70 to 79? These yes no questions are very simple.
1 Were there any Vietcong in khmer border during the 60? Yes or no.
2 Did you see the trucks carrying the very heavy thing from kg Som seaport to the border khmer-Vietnam? yes or no.
3 Were there any Vietcong fighting with the Lon Nol sodiers start from 70 to the end of war?
yes or no .
If the ansvers are yes you'l know who was the head of killer .

Anonymous said...

Sounds like Hinn Sithan.

Anonymous said...

Kon chao 2:31 PM.

you got your face stucked up in your sdach ta ass too long.betcha enjoyed it much.

Preah Bat Dhammik my ASS..

Anonymous said...

Samdech Ta, You should do something for your next generation to record you in mind and your name will leave on ... You Sing and you make of many albums it's made your compatriot laugh and condemned you.No one King in the world did like you.Do something good for your Nation not just pray in front of monks it not enough. YOU CAN KNEW BY YOURSELF WHAT YOU DO IN THE PAST BAD OR GOOD ? ARE YOU MURDER OR SAVER ???

Anonymous said...

Hi all guys above,
It is very nice story. Nice story of Samdach King Norodom Sihanouk. The message above does not mean to insult Samdach Ta (Grandfather King). Samdach Ta could not compete with Samdach Hun Sen (His step son), so Samdach Ta wants to live away from his belove country.

Please post your above message in Samdach Ta's website.

From New generation, Phnom Penh Cambodia.

Anonymous said...

In HUN SEN regime, Sihanouk is a well-respected or sacred man. However, in the soon-coming regime, Sihanouk is a traitor. Cambodian people has suffered repeatedly since Sihanouk entered political world.

Anonymous said...

You are sound like pol pot!
ពួកអ្នកឯងប៉ុន្មាននាក់ហ្នឹងដួចពលពតអិញ្ចឹង។
ពុំដែលចង់មានស្តេចនៅក្នុងប្រទេសទេ។នេះហើយ
ដែលគេហៅថាជនអគតិ។ហើយចូលចិត្តតែច្រ
ណែននិន្ទាគ្នាមិនចេះចប់ទេ។បើខ្នួនឯងរកពុំបាន
រួចទៅច្រណែននឹងអ្នកគេរកបាន។ខ្មែរភាគច្រើន
ណាស់ដែលរស់នៅបរទេសហើយច្រណែនខ្មែរនឹង
ខ្មែរគ្នាឯង។ដួចជាសាពត៍មាន,វិទ្យុ,ខ្មែរមិន
សង្ឃឹមថាខ្មែរនៅបរទេសកសាងប្រទេសទេ។
ចេះតែច្រណែននឹងខ្មែរនៅក្នុងស្រុកប៉ុណ្ណឹងឯង។
មិនដែលបាននិយាយប្រាប់បរទេសអំពីរឿង
ខ្មែរសាសខ្លួនឯងនៅក្នុងស្រុកឲ្យគេបានដឹងទេ។
ពុំដែលប្រាប់បរទេសថាបងប្អូនខ្មែររបស់ខ្ញុំនៅឯ
ក្នុងស្រុកគឺជួបការលំបាកណាស់។គឺមានតែធ្វើការ
វាយប្រហារទៅលើរាជរដ្ធាភិបាលថែមទៀត។
នេះហើយខ្មែរនៅក្រៅស្រុកហើយម្នាក់ៗអួតឲ្យ
ក្តែងៗថាខ្លួនជាខ្មែរចង់កសាងប្រទេសឲ្យបានរុង
រឿងប៉ុន្តែម្នាក់ៗរកតែពេលសម្រាកពីការអារពុំបាន
ផងបើដួច្នេះទុកឲ្យរាជរដ្ធាភិបាលលោកគាត់ធ្វើទៅ
ហើយចាំតែជួយគាំទ្រទៅវាស្រេចទៅហើយ។

Anonymous said...

King has a reason to sing his soul out. He had done enough. It's time for singing. lalalalala

Anonymous said...

នែ!អាចម្កួត6:13pm sound like f c p ម្នាក់ដែលតាមលិតពងអា Hun Zenរាល់ថ្ងៃ​។សុំឲ្យបើកភ្នែកមើលព្រុំដែនខ្មែរយួន ខ្មែរសៀម ជីវភាពរបស់ប្រជាពលរដ្ឋ ដីធ្លីកម្រិតសិក្សារបស់កូនខ្មែរ​ ព្រៃឈឺ​ ។ល។នឺង។ល។

Anonymous said...

Samdach Ta Chkout Li Lear, he can oly fool the poor unducated Cambodians, especially the elders. Unfortunately, the mojority of the people in our country are unducated, I don't mean to look down on our own peple, but this is the reality. I don't have to give too much reason, if somebody put himself in the position that he never does anything wrong in his life, he is a crook. No human being can do that.

Kolbout Khmer

Anonymous said...

អស់លោក​មានបានមើល Les 9 vies de Sihanouk ដែរឬទេ ? ។​ បើមិនបានមើល​និងស្តាប់ សូមអញ្ជើញមើលផងទៅ ក្រែងភ្លឺភ្នែកខ្លះ ។ ពីព្រោះ Les 9 vies de Sihanouk ផ្សាយ ឡើងដោយអ្នកកាសែតបរទេសទេ ។

Anonymous said...

9:32 and 6:13
I ' ve already seen but further more my both eyes still seeing Sihaknuk is the khmer killer also Hun Sen does.so to you both please go to see brain doctor you need two .
Thanks you

Anonymous said...

hello, that is a sign of deep cultured of the local people. i bet you once people become better educated like a real rigorous education like in the west, then people will stop being ignorant like this. i think local people ought to be given opportunity to get good worldly education so they can help society and help cambodia to become better. it's called thinking outside of the box. god bless cambodia.

Anonymous said...

i encourage all khmer people to learn to think analytically and critically for themselves. believing others based on rumour and etc, is like being a zombie or a person under a spell or something. must avoid it at all cost because not only it helps with personal growth, it also help the country and society as well when we think logically.

Anonymous said...

I am very dumb found by these comments and languages use by these KI blogers. To think ourselves as Khmer and only to look down on our own is not Khmer characteristic at all. These kind of behavior is only serve to defeat ourselves.

Anonymous said...

Kon chao 2:31 PM is a brown-noser!

How does it smell?

Anonymous said...

King sihanouk should be summoned to the KR tribunal as he was involved with the KR from the start.

Anonymous said...

កុំជេគ្នាអីយើងសុទ្ធតែខ្មែរដូចគ្នា ។ សូមពិចារណារឿងមួយ តើនរណាជាអ្នកបង្កើតចលនាខ្មែរក្រហម? អ្នកដែលផ្តើមគំនិតបង្កើតខ្មែរក្រហម គឺជាអ្នកដែលទទួលខុសត្រូវទាំងស្រុងក្នុងការសំលាប់​ប្រជាជនខ្មែរ ៕​ស្តិចសាច់​

Anonymous said...

ah sdach janggout that hated his own people. He will go nine stages to hell for sure and don't ever you return from yuor lord china!
die soon ah sdach skuot! this time i will use your khmer rouge thmil that use to say agaist khmer, to keep you king is no benefit and to distroy you king there is no lost..

Anonymous said...

Haha 1:21pm. the phrase "to keep you is no benefit and to destroy you is no loss" should be used on all khmer rouge cadre including king sihanouk. Let them taste their own medicine. Remember what goes around comes around. The khmer rouge created that phrase so we need to use it on them.