Monday, May 02, 2011

Thai-Cambodian border clash an ‘embarrassment for ASEAN’

Mon, 05/02/2011
Mustaqim Adamrah
The Jakarta Post, Jakarta

Thai and Cambodian military forces continue to exchange fire in their border area as both countries lay claim to the Preah Vihear Temple and its surrounding area although they have committed to a cease-fire a number of times. Indonesian and Cambodian journalists, including The Jakarta Post’s Mustaqim Adamrah, had a chance to interview Thai Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya during his visit to Jakarta last week. Below are excerpts of the interview.

Question: Thailand and Cambodia have repeatedly pledged to maintain a cease-fire in February and last Thursday. So why did clashes occur again two weeks ago, with the latest last Friday?

Answer: To reaffirm for the record, we never started the clashes. We have no reason to be unfriendly to Cambodia.

First, we are major exporters to Cambodia. Our exports to Cambodia make up 90 percent of bilateral trade [between Thailand and Cambodia]. So, it’s on our interest to keep trading with and exporting to Cambodia.

Second, we are becoming major investors in [Cambodia] in many fields: electricity generation, [manufacturing] industry, tourism, healthcare and construction.

Third, we welcome 150,000 Cambodian workers to Thailand under a bilateral memorandum of understanding.

Fourth, we are becoming a major donor to Cambodian development, education, social, health and infrastructure development.


Fifth, there’s a growth in Thai tourism to Cambodia and at the same time, we are a transit point as international airlines come to Thailand and visitors take regional airlines to Cambodia. So Thailand is an entry point for Cambodian tourism.

Sixth, we started and initiated the ASEAN master plan of connectivity: physical infrastructure, roads, railways, ICT [information and communication technology], electricity and other things, inclusive of the Mekong River development, as well as people-to-people contact.

We and Cambodia are two kingdoms, one destination. Two months ago, we had an agreement with Cambodia for Cambodians to enter Thailand without the need for visas.

The Thai side of the border is heavily populated. Why should we fight when the munitions fall on Thai villages? The Cambodian side is sparsely populated.

It would be silly for us to keep shooting when we know very well that artillery from Cambodia will fall on villages, temples and schools as has been shown on television.

Last time we had to evacuate about 20,000 people. We had to build houses, repair temples and schools, and we had to build more bunkers.

The physical side [construction] is not as important as the morale of the people. Between 30,000 and 40,000 people have been displaced. Instead of spending time looking after their animals, growing rice and tapioca, they have to sleep on temple floors. The damage is not only on the dollar. It’s frightening to hear the gunfire.

What triggered the additional clashes at two separate temples — 150 kilometers away from Preah Vihear — where February’s skirmishes occurred?

From our point of view, the position of the two military units is about 50 meters apart.

Ten days ago, we found out that the Cambodians had moved closer to the Thai side and started to dig bunkers. So we told the Cambodian soldiers to move back and that’s when they started to shoot.

How has Indonesia played out its role as chair of ASEAN? Is it failing to do its job, especially in light of the latest clashes?

We highly appreciate the role of Indonesia — the seriousness, the sense of purpose and the goodwill. So we do whatever we can [to cooperate].

I don’t think [Indonesia is failing] because its responsibility is more or less behind the scenes. No one expected that fighting would break out 150 kilometers away [from the original flash point].

The conflict between the two countries is a waste of time. It’s a waste of resources for the Indonesian government, for Cambodia and for Thailand.

We have to respect and honor the role and involvement of Indonesia. Thailand is not in a position to embarrass the Indonesian government.

It’s sad for ASEAN that the two countries keep on fighting. I’m ashamed. It’s an embarrassment to ASEAN that this conflict has dragged us to the UN.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

10:39PM Toronto, Canada

BEN LADEN IS DEAD!

AH HUN SEN, YOUR TURN IS NEXT!

Anonymous said...

If Siam would not have ignored 1962International Court of Justice ruling probably there was no need for Indonesia to intervene.

Cambodia did its part and held back for not responding in arm clashes with aggressors from Siam for all these years.

To say the least it's Cambodia fault to fight back is absurd and too ignorant for Siam.

Siam Prince signed and its King approved the border treaty with French for Cambodia then in 1907 why now Bangkok played dumb.

Is it not a lese majeste?

Anonymous said...

Idiot diplomacy spoke crazy look like siem is parent while khmer is child. All your words lied in your diplomacy forum career. siem govt back by siem military. if khmer want to talk with military much more better than siem govt. all fighting until now is khmer fight first. how dare diplomacy person spoke untrue in career of diplomacy. if military said ok to fight how dare siem govt said no???? Military do mistake siem govt pain black color afterward to be white. siem govt is priceless to leader in country. Thai people should think how to build reputation in region and international stage again because now your govt is very poor to lead country. I think your good thinking to vote for country. I said it is not for khmer country. Khmer welcome all ways siem doing. Siem now is like football game that seem to lost all time not win because players are not understand each other and dont pass well each other to lead the country but unlucky very much for Asean which siem is in bloc.

Anonymous said...

The fact is the Siem thuggish leaders never respect the world court decision! Then who is the enforcer of the world Court decision? If not United Nations or the UNSC then who? Someone or somebody need to tell the Siem thuggish leaders straight in the face that what they have done is wrong!

Anonymous said...

Mustaqim Adamrah doesn't know how to ask question!