Friday, October 19, 2012

Bun Thoeun’s Response to a Call for ‘Khmer Unity’




“If the CPP cannot even overhaul the NEC, it is almost impossible for the CNRP to unite with it.” 

The opening up of the Ho Chi Minh Trail across the interior of supposedly neutral Cambodia had been a decisive factor in the escalation of the fighting and hostility that were to follow in Indochina, as well as the subsequently rapid disintegration of Cambodia in both physical and political terms; a country that had hitherto been a peaceful bystander to a quarrel. Prince Sisowath Sirik Matak only learned of Sihanouk's [his cousin] deal with the North Vietnamese on a secret trip to Hanoi to protest the presence of the Viet Minhs' sanctuaries  across several Cambodian provinces - School of Vice [credit: google]
Joint-GIs-South Vietnamese offensive operations were launched deep inside Cambodian territory to disrupt the Viet Minhs' supplies lines following Sihanouk's overthrow - School of Vice [image: google]

To All Khmer Yeurng (all of Khmer citizens):

Please don't talk nonsense. You don't know what you are talking about. Stop being manipulated by other Anonymous mentioned. You need to be quiet and let's focus on Unity. We want CNRP and CPP to reunite as one without fighting each others in order to change the leaders. We wish all Khmer/Cambodian citizens or members of major parties CNRP and CPP to merge after the merger of SRP and HRP including other small parties like Khmer Democrats, KPPM, etc.

So, stop fighting each others. We need to work together to save our Khmer Nation.

It is [about] timing. Khmer folks both at home and abroad (USA, Australia, NZ, France, Canada, S. Korea, Japan, and so on), please stop fighting each other and, please take the positive outlooks and stop hating other because of the Vietnamese/Yuon manipulation and don't let our neighbors Yuon/Viet and Siam/Thai see our weaknesses.

So, watch out for one another no matter what may happen. Please think and be careful.

Thanks for listening.

-Khmer Yeurng.

.................................

Dear Khmer Yeurng,

I deeply understand your wishes.

I am a Khmer and I don't want to deplore a dead person, but to form a solid solidarity, we must know the characters, and the principles of what those persons (leaders) stand for.

The rise of the Khmer Rouge to power was largely stemming from Sihanouk's anger – he called on Khmer people to go to prey [forest= underground] marquis and fight Lon Nol/ Sirik Matak, who had destroyed Vietnam's reseau immediately after Sihanouk's fall. At the time, Cambodia was literally Vietnamese free.




If Sihanouk was a nationalist, he should have left Lon Nol/ Sirik Matak alone, and called on Khmer people to support Lon Nol/ Sirik Matak instead because they were protecting Cambodia against Vietnam’s aggression.

In addition, Vietnam's manipulation was also attributable to the Khmer Rouge's ascent. Vietnam clearly aimed at making the Khmer Rouge and the Khmer Vietminh demolish all of Lon Nol's supporters. Vietnam got more than what it had wished for thanks to its tactic of creating "suspicions" between Khmers. That's why the killings during the Pol Pot era were so rampant because of Vietnam's manipulations.

Another major mistake that Sihanouk made was his expulsion of the UN’s mission in Cambodia after the CPP lost the 1993 election. Sihanouk put the throne above Cambodia's survival.
 “In brief, Sihanouk’s bad deeds heavily outweigh his good deeds.”
Concerning the unification between the CNRP and CPP, it totally depends on the CPP.

If the CPP cannot even overhaul the NEC, it is almost impossible for the CNRP to unite with it.

If the CPP is truly not under Vietnam's control, it must be able to do what is right. We should never underestimate Vietnam's determination to swallow Cambodia. Vietnam will [not] relieve its grip on Cambodia unless there is formidable external pressure [sanctions] coming from the powerful countries that could end up adversely impacting or harming its economy, such as boycotting their imports from Vietnam..

We, as Khmers, must prove to those powerful countries Vietnam’s bad intentions towards Cambodia so that they could appreciate our actual predicament and help us out accordingly.

In brief, Sihanouk’s bad deeds heavily outweigh his good deeds. And it is understandable that Khmer people are cheering his death. He was/is/ and always will be a traitor; 3 million Khmers dead, and Cambodia is currently a satellite [hostage] of Vietnam.

Whoever implemented the bilateral treaties with Vietnam, instead of implementing the 1991 Paris Peace Accords, and allowing the mass influx of Vietnamese settlers into Cambodia to destroy most of Khmer natural resources – making Khmers a minority in the near future in their own country - and giving a Vietnamese the right to control Khmer Soul - Angkor Wat - are the real traitors.


-Bun Thoeun

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

To properly judge a person, an event, Khmer people must know the truth first.
Look at the present situation in Cambodia, the nationalists became traitors and the traitors became heroes.
We got to find ways to provide Khmer people the truth, and KI has done an excellent job of doing it.

Anonymous said...

Ho Chi Minh Trails were known to most people who read and remember the history of the Vietnam War or the Second Indochina War. But, not commonly known was the Sihanouk Trails, 1/3 of the total military supplies go to fuel the war in Vietnam by the cover of neutrality of Cambodia under the leadership of Sihanouk. China was and is forever at Sihanouk's at time of his needs because he sold his people and country for his boss in Peking.
From Ban Dung, Geneva to Pol Pot, Ranaridh and Hun Sen, all are his sons and all have put Cambodia in to the course of tragedy in which ultimately will resulted that Cambodia will be known as a great empire as it once was but now a Vietnamised country.

As the call for unity??? to whom would all Khmer to unify with ?? no one with a nationalistic idea and voice can go in and plya fair politic, Sam Raingsy, Mam Sonando, and a few more who dared, where are they now?? there are a few million Vietnamese also waiting in the wing to ensure that this time there grip will irreversible. COMINTERN set up the Indo China Federation back in the 40's and assigned Ho to run it. Khmer heros and herines had baeen fighting this for 3 generations now. We are in neck deep because Sihanouk and Khmer Rouge helped the Vietnamizaton of Cambodia by killing those who can read, write and dare to say something negative. Read the history people.

Anonymous said...

To unite with CPP, you mind as well tell vietnam to go ahead and rule Cambodia and the people forever. hun sen and his government are not trust-worthy. hun sen has owed yuon so muh for putting hin in power for the past 30 years and will never go against yuon's ambition and intention to swallow Khmer land.

Anonymous said...

The CPP under Hun Sen will only unite with the rest of the oppositions if they can come out from this so-called unity still controlling everything in Cambodia. They will never set up any laws or governing body that would ensure a free and fair election. They have no real intention of playing by the rules and respect the outcomes of the game if these outcomes are not in their favor. Forces will be their ultimate weapons to use to accomplish their goals. To them the end will always justify the means.

Wishing for a unity with the CPP of Hun Sen is perhaps a little naive considering the kind of grip on power Hun Sen is enjoying right now and the disarray in which the various oppositions are.

What is more practical is the unity of the various oppositions to fight a common and yet more powerful party, the CPP. The SRP and the HRP show great leadership and good examples by forging a union, though late, it is still a good beginning, and I hope such a union lasts so that an exemplary precedence can be set to encourage more smaller parties to join in.

Cambodian political problems are deeply rooted in the behaviours, mindset and characteristics of Cambodians themselves, especially the so-called leaders not to mention the manipulation and interference by Vietnam and have been with Cambodia for many years. The only time we don't fight among each other is when we are totally controlled by foreigners. As a race we seem to be not able to understand what it means to compromise and learn to forgive each other for the sake of the nation.

Like it or not there are still many Cambodians who love King Father Norodom Sihanouk despite what he did in the past and they are the force to be reckoned with. You will never solve Cambodia's problems and tragedy without including them and other groups in your formula. To do otherwise is to push them further into the hands of Hun Sen who is practically a political genius when it comes to political manipulation and division.

The Sihanoukists will have more and better reasons to join the opposition, but closing the door to them will only push them further into the welcoming hands of PM Hun Sen.

Cambodian political and social problems will be with us for a number of years to come. True democracy, good governance, accountability to the people, respect for freedom and human rights, separation of power and the independence of the courts are a long way to go for Cambodia and these goals will never be reached until we have a reasonable size of truly educated population that will not wait for their leaders to hand down to them these precious attributes of a truly democratic nation, but demand with strong voice and action what they deserve to receive. Sam Rainsy and Kem Sokha look like good leaders that deserve a chance to govern, but, as a people, we need to make sure later that when they govern the country, they follow closely the rules and laws they have vowed to respect and espouse before taking office; otherwise, they will end up, who knows, just like any other bad leaders we have known so far.

As a people, if we expect to have a good leader, we should be prepared to kick them back inside the proper lines when they steer out occasionally and totally kick them out completely when they are hopelessly aimless and not knowing where to go.

Pissed Off

Anonymous said...

Correction"

"...and respecting the outcomes of the game..."

Pissed Off

Anonymous said...

4:58 AM Pissed off,

Excellent analysis.

Anonymous said...

2:57am

You research it well. In addition, at the finally moment, Lon Nol did not want to overthrow the king but Sirik Matak said to Lon Nol that "you have no choice, you must sign the decree of overthrowing the king or else I will shoot you" cited in one of the texts. Your are right, Sirik Matak knew that Cambodia was going to be swallowed by the Vietminh and so he had to react the way he did at that moment. in conclusion, it was king ta who sold Cambodia to Vietminh and then later, couldn't get out of it and began to make trouble with Vietminh in term of betraying and deceiving him and the people of Cambodia but by then it was already too late. He was playing with fire and he got burnt. In the end, Sirik Matak shot himself in the head and said 'I trusted the America but the American betrayed me and my people, I hope and wish the US can fine peace under this sky after of what they had done to us', whereas Lon Nol he was encouraged (with force) to get of Cambodia at the last minutes, when he did not want to anyway. Nevertheless, in the end, he of ageing and stroke.

Anonymous said...

he died of ageing...

Anonymous said...

I agree w/ most of the above poster.
To call on Khmer unity is easier said then done. No matter how much water you pour on Hun Sen's head, it will never absorb. He have a one tracked mind; his way or the highway.
I wish the two party can unite, but I just don't see it.

Som Nash said...

Like him or not, whether you think he could have done better, or made the worst decision, you will understand how king Sihanouk played his politic with China and Vietnam.

It's because of his strong alliance with China that Vietnam could not and has not completely control Cambodia.

May people who hate Sihanouk choose to overlook this fact. And they are the very same people who are the most paranoid about Vietnamese colonization of Cambodia.

Keo Cham said...

True, now that Sihanouk is dead, the die-hard pro Vietnamese faction can start its history revision.

After 1975(fall of Saigon) Vietnamese prisoners in North Vietnamese re-education camp were told Sihanouk was their only obstacle to completely controlling Cambodia - but in 30 years, they say, Cambodia will be theirs. So they should not fight each other anymore and unite for the country's sake.


Now the it has been 30 years later, we see Vietnamese everywhere and the King is dead. We saw the pro-Vietnamese faction has even altered it's language, including demonizing the word "Youn" to erase any history and attempt to re-invent a new history of "thousand" years Vietnam-Cambodia friendship.

True Khmer history are not even taught, for fear of "offending" their savior.

Now, the pro-communist faction will be even more embolden to attempt to rewrite history, with the death of Sihanouk.


Anonymous said...

Don't worry about the history of Cambodia.

Many books about Cambodia have been written by internationally recognized experts and published so nobody can rewrite history with false fact.

Anonymous said...

It doesn't matter how they rewrite it but the truth will always be the truth and God knows that. Anyone attempt to re-write or re-invent from what was real, they will surely be punished. With thousands of youtube documentation and other textbook resources, there will be no way they can do that. So, it doesn't matter, even if they create history of their own, e;g everyone knows that they took Laos, Champa, KhmerKrom and Cambodia. But, the saddest thing is, we might lose our identity and culture, however, who know they might change it into a multicultural nation with full of respect and acceptance just like in the west. So, we look at it closely, Laos, Cham and khmerkrom did not have war for ages now because of a one leader of Vietminh and maybe we will be better of without all the wicked khmer leaders anyway, since all political leaders don't want to join hands.

Anonymous said...

Do Koh Tral island and other islands belong to Khmer or Viet according to King Norodom Sihanouk and his regime after Cambodia gain indepandant from France?

Can any professional people out there including KI media, VOA, RFA confirm with evidences strongly that Koh Tral island and other islands were belong to Khmer during Sihanouk's regime reconized by UN?

It is very important to clearification any doubt to young khmer generation? Can you professional people out there help young khmer generation to clear out the doubt about Koh Tral island and other islands? Please do it for your country and nation and the khmer generation to know the facts and the truth about khmer history that it banned from teaching at Cambodia school!

Anonymous said...

All islands near srok khmer were once to belonged khmer nation but because of the agreement (continue to help Hun sen to stay in power) made between hun and vietminh, that is why hun had to give kosh trol to Vietminh. It is like history repeats itself like, during king Jayvarman (IIV, or something), he married to a viet woman and later gave khmer krom to vietnam and later, the French made it official in the world map. When, in fact it has always been khmers'. Today, khmer krom people are still fight for their identity/rights of being khmers' not viets'. Now, hun sen is doing the same thing, he is marrying to a viet woman, as well as being married to the vietminh's leader and is giving away kosh trol. 'If we look into the past, we will see the future' and if we don't learn from the past, history will repeat itself', simple as that.

Anonymous said...

Khmer Krom will have their own state soon, thanks to the world evolution.

The evil nation Vietnam cannot kill those 10 million Khmer Krom.

That's why it is imminent that Khmer Krom will stand tall and will make Ah Runteas Banh Pi Anh crazy.

កុលបុត្រមហានគរខ្មែរ said...

Burn his body over there (China). Don't bring back to Cambodia. He was a Traitor to Khmer people. The Khmer people have suffered enough by him. He did not respect even his own mother. He was an evil king . He should be alive until he can serve his punishement in the Khmer Rouge trail. Please don't forget he was the person who killed Lok Protean Sam Rainsy's father.

Pang Sokheoun, Secretary-General of SRP in Sweden.កុលបុត្រមហានគរខ្មែរ

Anonymous said...

you are right. You statement is correct and reflected on the truth. Sihanouk had done more bad things than good things.

Sihanouk should not allow to get the state burial. He should be burn in the trash can and throw his ash in the trash.

Many of my families died because of him.

Anonymous said...

Sihanouk is a mass murderer of his own people.

We all should get rid all kings and that included his dumb son, xihamoni

Anonymous said...

Bun Thoeun brought out the important points. Sihanouk betrayed khmer people all the way. Make serious mistakes over and over until the end of his life. All khmer must know the truth what our king and leaders did and have done to the country. I admire Sisowath Sirimatak , he chose to die in the country, he was a brave man.

Anonymous said...

I agree! Sihanouk have plenty of times to correct his mistake and put Cambodia back on the world map, but instead he choose to take this last opportunity to the grave.
If anything, he should leave a written diary about what it is that he like/dislike about his adopted son...Hun Sen. And what the country need in order to satisfy a country as a whole.

He dissapoint me then, yet he still disappoint now.
RIP!

Anonymous said...

Sirimatak was too naive to be any near the King in term of political savviness. He had patriotism and it blinded his vision of what was coming to him and the country.

Anonymous said...


I know that you are one of a CPP members because no one would put their real ID in this page. But the information that is given by you is very crucial as to the real facts of life and that is why your CPP team is so paranoid that the SR team might take revenge on your evils' actions but don't worry because SR is not a killer like some, you know what I mean? only a ruthless killer and a coward would do that in this world e.g. if you play with fire, you will be burned or whatever you play with shall die by it'. So, your CPP team will pay for your own cause, just for a reality check.Oh, and the more you try to pretend to be someone that you are not, the more we will find out about you and your evil action. Definitely from the KR tactic like always, that is accused, abused and killed (tactic from the VC and all enemies to exterminate). Oh and my the way, the king's body is already here, right in the palace and there is nothing you can do about it. Bloodsucker!!!

Anonymous said...

6:26 AM
What did you say ( has not completely control CAMBODIA )? feel sad for KHMER
5:46 AM
Do not worry about the history of CAMBODIA .Are you drunker ? no history = no ancestor
9:34 AM
Are you used some one name ?
Please DO NOT talk nonsense !

Anonymous said...

Koh Tral island has heap of sea foods and big crabs, big octopus, big fishes...heap heap heap of sea foods. You should go and visite Koh Tral island and eat sea foods there...yummy and very cheap too compare to Cambodia market.

If you want to eat fresh and juicey sea foods, you should visite Koh Tral island...Yummy sea foods...but Khmer people, they don't like sea foods any way!

Anonymous said...

Ly Deuk + Suon Kamchil = Krom Tmart

Anonymous said...

Xihanouk and CPP are both stupid. They were stupid then and they are stupid now.

Both loser.

==============================

We all know Yuon and Ah Siam wants Cambodian land. Why did Ah Sihanouk make it so easier for them by contributing to the 3 million killed?

The reason are the following: horrible movie producer, womanizer, playboy with many unwanted children such as Ranarid, unducated,bad temper,killers of his opponent and on and on.

History will show that he is "evil"

Anonymous said...

2:30 am.the K-i, I agree 100%,
most people judge without studying the fact.
in the 1970. I was 17. I do not
know what the prey Marqui is.
So how many khmer rouge soldiers who joint the khmer rouge due to this
word-marqui.
Khmer Rouge and CPP existed before
what is called prey Marqui.
Before getting into the ring why not study your opponent strength. do not just get mad and fight.
same as Lon Nol people. if you cannot fight with sihanouk do not fight. So Bun thoeurn 's idea is not logical.

Anonymous said...

8:56 PM

Look at the King of South Vietnam.

When they toppled him, did he ask Cambodia for help to regain his power?

He put his national interest first. He stayed quite. He did not kill his own people like Sdach playboy Lob Lob Sihanouk.

Unknown said...

Sdach Pearl is Sihanouk ,he is the Yuon Heroe !!!!!

Unknown said...

Sihanouk died and went to the hell !!!he was Sdach Pearl named the prophecy of Khmer Buddist Monk !!!Sihanouk died differently from Pol Pot !!!Pol Pot died in New Year Day or Happy Day but Sihanouk died in Phchom Ben Day or Hell Day !!!

Anonymous said...

1:00 AM

No trial for Preap In, Sau Ngoy.

Therefore, no trial for Sihanouk.

He goes straight to hell.

Anonymous said...

9:14pm,
Everyone wants hi/her own way and power if possible. South Vietnam King had no way. Just like Sihanouk in 1993 ,he had no way to become politician so become King though he did not want to be.

Anonymous said...

WE UNITED WE TIED!!!
WE DIVIDED WE DIE!!!

PhD (Pour Heineken Drink)

Anonymous said...

Samdach Decho Hun Sen always willing to give Koh Tral island and more khmer lands and Khmer sea area to Vietnam but Samdach Sihanouk rejects any treaties that Samdache Decho Hun Sen made illigaly with Vietnam. Samdach Sihanouk defends Koh Tral Island and Khmer land and sea area until he got heart attack by Samdach Decho Hun Sen bullying him very badly.

So who is Khmer patriot? and who is Khmer traitor? in term of Koh Tral island and Khmer sea area. You are all out there can use your brain to think and judge these issues by yourself.