Showing posts with label Territorial dispute between China and Vietnam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Territorial dispute between China and Vietnam. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

China and Vietnam sign agreement to cool sea dispute

Oct 12 (Reuters) - China and Vietnam signed an agreement seeking to contain a dispute over the South China Sea that has stoked tensions between the two Communist-ruled neighbours divided by a history of distrust, China's official news agency said on Wednesday.

Diplomats signed the six-point agreement on Tuesday, while the General Secretary of the Vietnamese Communist Party, Nguyen Phu Trong, held conciliatory talks with Hu Jintao, who is China's Communist Party chief and president.

Vietnam and China -- as well as the Philippines, Brunei, Malaysia and Taiwan -- stake conflicting claims of sovereignty over parts of the South China Sea, a potentially oil and gas rich body of water spanned by key shipping lanes.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Vietnam and China to strengthen relations despite territory dispute

Wed, 21 Jul 2010
DPA

Hanoi - The top diplomats of Vietnam and China on Wednesday pledged to strengthen relations despite territorial conflicts over the South China Sea.

As current chair of the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN), Vietnam would "do our best to strengthen strategic relations between ASEAN and China generally, and between Vietnam and China in particular," Deputy Prime Minister Pham Gia Khiem told Chinese Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi.

Yang was in Hanoi to meet ASEAN foreign ministers and attend the ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF) on Thursday and Friday.

Regular meetings would be held to move "stagnant issues" forward, Khiem said, including the dispute over maritime borders in the South China Sea.

"I can say the relations between two sides are heading for open opportunities," Yang said. "We are ready to strengthen relations with Vietnam."

Vietnam and China can look back on 60 years of diplomatic ties, but are in conflict over maritime territorial claims in the South China Sea, in particular the disputed Paracel and Spratly Islands.

Chinese patrols have seized dozens of Vietnamese fishing boats over the past two years, leading to repeated diplomatic protests.

Vietnam has attempted to persuade other ASEAN members with similar disputes to negotiate as a bloc, but China has insisted on dealing bilaterally.

"Vietnam doesn't want to be pushed into the camp of being seen as confronting China," said Carl Thayer, a Vietnam expert at the Australian National Defence University.

The new approach was a "cooperative, rather than a confrontational, approach to conflict," he said.

On Tuesday, ASEAN foreign ministers called for a Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea, and eventually a Regional Code of Conduct.

Such a document would commit all signatories to respect the freedom of sea and air traffic movement in and above the South China Sea.

ASEAN members Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam have their own, partly conflicting claims to the Spratly archipelago, as does non-ASEAN-member Taiwan. Vietnam also claims the Paracel islands further north.

The remaining ASEAN member countries are Myanmar, Indonesia, Cambodia, Laos, Singapore and Thailand.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

ASEAN unity is a bulwark of sovereignty, says [Viet] Defence Minister

Defence Minister Phung Quang Thanh.

19/11/2009
VietNamNet/VNE

VietNamNet Bridge – Minister of Defense Phung Quang Thanh talked with the media about the results of the recent ASEAN Defense Minister’s Meeting in Thailand and looked ahead to Vietnam’s pending chairmanship. “Maintaining ASEAN unity is critical to our defense,” he said.

Q: What do the ASEAN countries think regional security? [ASEAN is the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, a ten nation grouping that includes Vietnam].

Defense Minister Phung Quang Thanh: We Ministers of Defense met three times and agreed that the development of the ASEAN community should rest on three pillars: politics-security, economics and culture. The group’s regional security faces both traditional challenges (wars and armed conflicts) and non-traditional challenges that no single country can solve without the help of other member states and other friendly nations.

Anticipating its role as ASEAN’s chairman in 2010, Vietnam proposed that in regional security, the most important thing is to maintain a peaceful environment. For conflicts of sovereignty over sea areas and islands in the East Sea, it is essential to implement the ASEAN Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the East Sea, and not to use force or threat of force to solve conflicts. Regional instability will affect the whole world because through this region passes the world’s second most important sea route. Some 150 to 200 ships transit it daily.

Vietnam emphasizes expanding non-traditional security cooperation, for example combating piracy (e.g., in the Malacca Straits), trafficking in persons, drug trafficking, search and rescue at sea, maneuvers, building the army and training.

Q: What do other ASEAN members think about traditional security?

Thanh: Traditional security covers wars, territorial and armed conflicts, conflicts over sovereignty, etc. Some ASEAN members have territorial conflicts, for example Thailand and Cambodia’s argument over the Preah Vihear temple site. The conflict in the East Sea involves five countries. Countries have to cooperate with each other and commit to implement the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the East Sea that China signed with ASEAN, and refrain from using force or threats to use force or transgressing on the territory of others. They have to negotiate peacefully to solve ‘problems left by the history.’

Vietnam’s policy is reducing confrontation, strengthening cooperation. Vietnam won’t join any military alliance or any military organization. We don’t allow other countries to set up their military bases in Vietnam or use our territory against others.

Q: What are the ASEAN countries going to do about conflicts in the East Sea?

Thanh: Worries were expressed in sideline talks at the meeting, but our common viewpoint is that the current trend is toward peace and cooperation. Vietnam and its neighbors share the objective of developing both our economies and our defensive capability to preserve a peaceful, stable environment that serves economic development.

Building the unity of the ASEAN countries is the most important at present, a common view on defending the sovereignty of all our nations.

Q: How are the person-to-person relations among ASEAN defense officials?

Thanh: I think it is very important to build up personal relationships between Defense Ministers. We meet twice each year and we are very friendly with each other. This is a chance to discuss solutions and opportunities for cooperation, to enhance mutual understanding and to build mutual trust. Building personal ties also serves the common goal.

Besides ASEAN, Vietnam’s relationships with the Ministers of Defense of Russia, India, South Korea, Japan and the US are also very good. In mid-December, I will visit the US and France to strengthen bilateral cooperation.

Q: Was naval cooperation in the bloc discussed at the meeting?

Thanh: Naval cooperation among ASEAN countries is excellent. We cooperate with Thailand and Cambodia on joint patrols of the sea lanes. Hotlines have been set up between Vietnam’s navy and the navies of Thailand, Cambodia, Malaysia and the Philippines.

We’re going to emphasize cooperation with Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines and Brunei in this field. Defense and naval cooperation will promote cooperation in other fields, especially in keeping peace and security in the sea.

Q: What’s the role of the navy in Vietnam’s defense strategy?

Thanh: Our plans to build up revolutionary, regular, seasoned and gradually modernized armed forces are public knowledge. Gradual modernization means that as our economy grows, the army will be step by step equipped to defend the country. Any nation that’s developing its economy also thinks about strengthening its army, but not about engaging in an arms race.

We give top priority to the navy and the air and air defense force and then to other services.

Monday, February 16, 2009

China and Vietnam face strains as war memory fades

By John Ruwitch

LANG SON, Vietnam, Feb 15 (Reuters) - The tall black tablets at the Lang Son cemetery list hundreds of dead Vietnamese soldiers. Next to some names are the words "chong Phap" or "chong My" -- "fighting France" or "fighting America" -- indicating how they died.

Most read "Bao ve to quoc", or "protecting the fatherland", an oblique reference to a month-long war that began when China invaded Vietnam on Feb. 17, 1979 to punish Hanoi for toppling the Beijing-backed Khmer Rouge in Cambodia two months earlier.

Thirty years on, the Vietnamese-Chinese border war in which at least 60,000 soldiers were killed is a memory both governments are happy to suppress. But in these tough economic times, Vietnam and China could face new strains to add to their long and often acrimonious history.

Since normalisation in 1991, China and Vietnam have made impressive progress in forging better ties, said Brantly Womack, a China-Vietnam expert at the University of Virginia.

Two-way trade last year grew to $21 billion, for instance.

"China and Vietnam had no more reason to be friendly than Russia and Poland, and Russia and Poland ... are still each others' worst enemy," he said.

"With Vietnam and China, they don't exactly love each other, but they've certainly figured out how to get along. It's been mutually beneficial."

The fact the engravings in Lang Son do not spell out that the soldiers died "fighting China" illustrates Hanoi's cautious approach toward Beijing.

For its part, the stability-obsessed Chinese leadership has made a concerted effort in recent years to build constructive ties. But the coming months will be challenging.

Both export-fed economies, dependent on high-speed growth, are facing their sternest test since economic reforms were launched decades ago and the global financial uncertainty raises the potential for heightened tension.

Even in good times, the efforts of Vietnamese and Chinese policymakers to be nice has limits. Both governments claim ownership of the Spratly and Paracel islands in the South China Sea, which are thought to sit on valuable oil and gas deposits.

Hanoi and Beijing have agreed not to upset the status quo, but both are firm in their claims of sovereignty.

In addition, both ruling Communist parties are constrained by the spectre of nationalist unrest if they appear soft on the issue. In 2007, hundreds of Vietnamese youth protested at the Chinese embassy in Hanoi after China reportedly set up a county government responsible for the disputed archipelagos.

DISPUTED ISLANDS

Beyond protests and rhetoric, the territorial dispute is a tangible political risk.

Last July, China pressured Exxon Mobil Corp (XOM.N) to pull out of an oil exploration deal with Vietnam that it saw as a breach of Chinese sovereignty. In May, BP Plc (BP.L) halted plans to conduct exploration work off the southern Vietnamese coast, citing territorial tensions.

"The biggest problem is the islands," said Duong Danh Dy, a former Vietnamese diplomat who did three tours in China from the 1960s to the 1990s.

"If the United States' global position falls, if Japan's economy weakens further, I fear that China's position on the South China Sea could harden," he said. "If things continue as they are now, then bilateral relations will be fine."

Another worry this year, particularly for Hanoi, is trade.

Vietnam went from a $70 million trade surplus with China in 1997 to a deficit of $9.1 billion in 2007, according to Vietnamese statistics. Two-way trade reached $15.9 billion in 2007 before leaping to $21 billion last year.

"There is a big problem because what Vietnam's been doing in the last couple of years is running approximately a surplus with the developed countries that equals the deficit it's been running with China," said Womack.

"And it's not going to run that surplus anymore."

Furthermore, as China's export markets evaporate, desperate manufacturers will be looking for markets and Vietnam may be an attractive option compared with many of China's other neighbours.

Lang Son trade official Nguyen Quoc Hai said the Vietnamese government wanted to increase exports rather than try to block Chinese goods from flooding in.

But at the Vietnamese border town of Tan Thanh, three Chinese traders in a market overflowing with Chinese-made rice cookers, DVD players and clothes said it had become harder to get items through the checkpoint.

Still, empty Vietnamese trucks queue to cross over and pick up Chinese goods.

"Border trade is definitely increasing," one trader said.

(Additional reporting by Nguyen Nhat Lam in Hanoi and Ben Blanchard in Beijing; Editing by Dean Yates)

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Sacrava's Political Cartoon: The 2 Fishes & The Spratly Islands

Cartoon by Sacrava (on the web at http://sacrava.blogspot.com)

Beijing threatens ExxonMobil over deal with Vietnam in South China Sea

Wednesday, July 30, 2008
World Tribune (USA)

China issued a sharp warning to the world’s largest corporation, ExxonMobil, over an oil deal with Vietnam. Hanoi has indirectly responded that its agreement is in force and will proceed.

A Hong Kong newspaper says Beijing’s diplomats have threatened retaliation if ExxonMobil goes ahead with a preliminary agreement with the Vietnamese state oil firm PetroVietnam. The deal covers exploitation in the South China Sea off Vietnam's south and central coasts, according to the Sunday Morning Post.

Beijing claims a huge swath of the South China Sea just east of the Indochina peninsula and west of the Philippines and has acted to control sea lanes and oil rights in the area with several military skirmishes. The most serious occurred in 1976, when China invaded and captured the Paracel Islands from Vietnam. In 1988, Chinese and Vietnamese navies clashed at Johnson Reef in the Spratly Islands, sinking several Vietnamese boats and killing more than 70 sailors.

The Hong Kong newspaper quoted unidentified sources saying Exxon Mobil was confident of Vietnam's sovereign rights to the blocks it was now seeking to explore. But it is clear that ExxonMobil could not dismiss China's warnings out of hand given the rapidly increasing Chinese market for crude oil and oil products.

The newspaper said China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to queries about the situation, and an Exxon Mobil spokesman refused comment. However, Vietnamese Foreign Ministry spokesman Le Dung came back with the assertion “that Hanoi's dealings with foreign oil partners fell entirely within Vietnam's legal rights and sovereignty.”

Last year, Chinese media targeted an agreement between Vietnam and BP near the Spratlys maintaining that those islands had been an “indisputable part of Chinese territory since ancient times.” The Spratlys, like other island groups in the region, are uninhabited rocky outcroppings and coral but are in an area that may contain large oil and gas deposits.

The islands also lie directly across the major shipping route for oil from the Persian Gulf to markets in China, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan.

China is an ancient enemy of Hanoi dating back over centuries even though the two countries were allied after the Chinese Communists came to power in 1949. That lasted through the two Vietnam wars, one between the French and the Vietnamese and the other the U.S. engagement. But it fell apart in 1979 when the two countries fought a brief border war after Vietnam occupied Cambodia — another instance of an ancient and bitter rivalry — and overthrew the pariah Khmer Rouge regime, a staunch ally of Beijing.

China-Vietnam relations have since improved with the Vietnamese adopting what many call the post-Deng Xiaoping China model of development. On June 21, the Vietnamese Communist Party newspaper Nhan Dan reported Vietnamese Communist Party General Secretary Nong Duc Manh had successfully concluded an official visit to China at the invitation of the Chinese Party General Secretary and President Hu Jintao.

In fact, Vietnam and China have agreed to cooperate in oil and gas exploration in the Gulf of Tonkin just off the northern Vietnamese major port of Haiphong. But still, last year BP halted plans to conduct exploration work off the southern Vietnamese coast, citing territorial tensions caused by Chinese claims. And in December, China chided Vietnam after protests in front of the Chinese Embassy in Hanoi proclaimed that the Spratly and Paracel islands belonged to the Vietnamese.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

China warns Exxon over Vietnam deal-newspaper

20 Jul, 2008
REUTERS

HONG KONG: China has warned Exxon Mobil Corp to pull out of an exploration deal with Vietnam, describing the project as a breach of Chinese sovereignty, a Chinese newspaper report said on Sunday, citing unnamed sources. The article, which cited "sources close to the US firm", said Chinese diplomats in Washington had made repeated verbal protests to Exxon Mobil executives in recent months, and warned them its future business interests on the mainland could be at risk.

The protests involve a preliminary co-operation agreement between state oil firm PetroVietnam and Exxon Mobil covering exploration in the South China Sea off Vietnam's south and central coasts, the article said. It did not state when the co-operation agreement was signed. The report quoted the unnamed sources as saying Exxon Mobil was confident of Vietnam's sovereign rights to the blocks it was exploring, but it could not dismiss China's warnings out of hand.

The newspaper said China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to queries about the situation and an Exxon Mobil spokesman refused to discuss any approaches from China. But it quoted Vietnamese Foreign Ministry spokesman Le Dung as saying it needed to be "clearly asserted" that Hanoi's dealings with foreign oil partners fell entirely within Vietnam's legal rights and sovereignty. China and Vietnam have a number of festering disagreements about territory.

The two countries dispute sovereignty over the Spratly Islands, a string of rocky outcrops in the South China Sea suspected of containing large oil and gas deposits and also claimed by Taiwan, Brunei, Malaysia and the Philippines. China supported the Vietnamese Communists in their decades-long war against South Vietnam and its US sponsors. But Vietnam has traditionally been wary of its larger Asian neighbour and in 1979 the two countries fought a brief border war after Vietnam occupied Cambodia and overthrew the murderous Khmer Rouge regime that favoured Beijing.

Though Vietnam and China have agreed to cooperate in oil and gas exploration in the Gulf of Tonkin in the north, last year BP Plc halted plans to conduct exploration work off the southern Vietnamese coast, citing the territorial tensions. And in December China chided Vietnam after protests in front of the Chinese Embassy in Hanoi proclaiming that the Spratly and Paracel islands belonged to the Vietnamese.