Phnom Penh Post, Issue 15 / 23, November 17 - 30, 2006
The Ministry of Health (MOH) has issued a warning that it will take legal action against private clinics in Phnom Penh if their ambulances continue to ignore regulations and race to pick up people who have suffered traffic accidents.
Only ambulances from public hospitals have the authority to provide emergency services for traffic accident victims on Phnom Penh streets, according to Chi Mean Hea, the MOH's deputy director-general for health.
He says the four emergency ambulance services the public should summon are run by Calmette, Kossamak, Sihanouk and Phnom Penh Municipal hospitals.
But don't hold your breath. The Post duly phoned all four services. Only Calmette's 119 answered - and on an earlier occasion that number also went unanswered.
Mean Hea's warning is in a letter he wrote on October 18 to Deputy Prime Minister Sar Kheng, the Minister of Interior, seeking his help to curb the activities of private ambulances "to ensure safety and strengthen the emergency services for the public."
Private ambulances are only allowed to transport patients from their employing clinic to a hospital, or from the clinic to their homes, Mean Hea said.
He said the MOH has banned private emergency services from treating road accident victims since 2003, but some clinics have ignored the regulation.
"We know that some clinics have operated with individual traffic police officers to get clients to their clinic," Mean Hea said. "For one client the officer who provides information about the traffic accident would get $5 or $10."
He said the quality of private clinics' ambulances was uncertain. Some lacked necessary skills and their equipment was not of the high standard of the public-hospital ambulances.
"We know of people who had traffic accidents and were taken to a clinic where the treatment was wrong, then transferred from the clinic to Calmette hospital at the point of death," Mean Hea said. "Other victims lose money and are poorer."
Heng Taykry, secretary of state at the MOH and director of Calmette Hospital, similarly told the Post on November 8 that traffic police summon private-clinic ambulances to accidents because they can make money.
He said some private clinics provide only minimal treatment for several days while they find out if the accident victim is rich or poor.
"If the victims are poor and don't have money to pay them they transfer them to the public hospital - but some victims are nearly dead by the time they arrive," Taykry said.
Mean Hea said clinics that persisted in providing illicit emergency services for traffic accidents face the likelihood of being shut down.
Tin Prasoaur, chief of Phnom Penh Municipal Traffic Police, denied the allegations of corruption between police officers and the private clinics.
"I cannot accept the allegation of bribery in cases of traffic accidents; it is up to the request of the victim, and the police officers always call the nearest emergency services," he said.
Taing Vengseng, owner of Chantrea Clinic, told the Post his clinic stopped sending ambulances to pick up traffic accident victims when the MOH reissued its regulation recently.
"I am not a doctor," he said. "I am a businessman and making money, therefore I considered that all services had to be provided to the public as competition in the market."
Vengseng said accusations that the clinic extorted money from the victims and bribed police officers were not true.
But he said his clinic always used to give $5 for a cellphone card to police or motodup who phoned them about a traffic accident.
He said it was better to give phone cards to people who directed business to his ambulance than to advertise in newspapers or on TV and radio.
"Many people who have traffic accidents are poor and unconscious and we treat them for several days while we wait for their family, and we take the risk in making money or losing it," Vengseng said.
According to the MOH there are 679 medical consulting rooms in Phnom Penh, of which 434 are legal and 245 illegal. There are 16 clinics, of which two are illegal.
The legal ambulance services that the MOH says should be called to traffic accidents are:
Calmette Hospital, covering Prampi Makara, Daun Penh, Russei Keo, Phnom Penh International Airport, and embassies in Phnom Penh. The speed dial is 119, the phone number 023 724 891, (012 974 119 does not yet work) and walkie-talkie number 14320.
Kossamak Hospital, covering Toul Kok, Dangkau, and Russei Keo. The phone number is 016 219 119 and walkie-talkie number 14675.
Sihanouk Khmer and Soviet Friendship Hospital, covering Chamkarmon and Meanchey districts. The phone number is 012 827 119 and walkie-talkie 15194.
Phnom Penh Municipal Hospital, covering the center of Phnom Penh. Its phone number is 011 819 119.
The Post tried to contact all these numbers. Only Calmette's 119 was answered.
On an earlier occasion, Calmette's 119 also went unanswered when a Post staffer at the scene of an accident called it repeatedly. The staffer took the accident victim to Calmette by taxi, went to the ambulance phone room and asked the sole attendant why the phone had not been answered. She said perhaps she had been in the toilet.
Only ambulances from public hospitals have the authority to provide emergency services for traffic accident victims on Phnom Penh streets, according to Chi Mean Hea, the MOH's deputy director-general for health.
He says the four emergency ambulance services the public should summon are run by Calmette, Kossamak, Sihanouk and Phnom Penh Municipal hospitals.
But don't hold your breath. The Post duly phoned all four services. Only Calmette's 119 answered - and on an earlier occasion that number also went unanswered.
Mean Hea's warning is in a letter he wrote on October 18 to Deputy Prime Minister Sar Kheng, the Minister of Interior, seeking his help to curb the activities of private ambulances "to ensure safety and strengthen the emergency services for the public."
Private ambulances are only allowed to transport patients from their employing clinic to a hospital, or from the clinic to their homes, Mean Hea said.
He said the MOH has banned private emergency services from treating road accident victims since 2003, but some clinics have ignored the regulation.
"We know that some clinics have operated with individual traffic police officers to get clients to their clinic," Mean Hea said. "For one client the officer who provides information about the traffic accident would get $5 or $10."
He said the quality of private clinics' ambulances was uncertain. Some lacked necessary skills and their equipment was not of the high standard of the public-hospital ambulances.
"We know of people who had traffic accidents and were taken to a clinic where the treatment was wrong, then transferred from the clinic to Calmette hospital at the point of death," Mean Hea said. "Other victims lose money and are poorer."
Heng Taykry, secretary of state at the MOH and director of Calmette Hospital, similarly told the Post on November 8 that traffic police summon private-clinic ambulances to accidents because they can make money.
He said some private clinics provide only minimal treatment for several days while they find out if the accident victim is rich or poor.
"If the victims are poor and don't have money to pay them they transfer them to the public hospital - but some victims are nearly dead by the time they arrive," Taykry said.
Mean Hea said clinics that persisted in providing illicit emergency services for traffic accidents face the likelihood of being shut down.
Tin Prasoaur, chief of Phnom Penh Municipal Traffic Police, denied the allegations of corruption between police officers and the private clinics.
"I cannot accept the allegation of bribery in cases of traffic accidents; it is up to the request of the victim, and the police officers always call the nearest emergency services," he said.
Taing Vengseng, owner of Chantrea Clinic, told the Post his clinic stopped sending ambulances to pick up traffic accident victims when the MOH reissued its regulation recently.
"I am not a doctor," he said. "I am a businessman and making money, therefore I considered that all services had to be provided to the public as competition in the market."
Vengseng said accusations that the clinic extorted money from the victims and bribed police officers were not true.
But he said his clinic always used to give $5 for a cellphone card to police or motodup who phoned them about a traffic accident.
He said it was better to give phone cards to people who directed business to his ambulance than to advertise in newspapers or on TV and radio.
"Many people who have traffic accidents are poor and unconscious and we treat them for several days while we wait for their family, and we take the risk in making money or losing it," Vengseng said.
According to the MOH there are 679 medical consulting rooms in Phnom Penh, of which 434 are legal and 245 illegal. There are 16 clinics, of which two are illegal.
The legal ambulance services that the MOH says should be called to traffic accidents are:
Calmette Hospital, covering Prampi Makara, Daun Penh, Russei Keo, Phnom Penh International Airport, and embassies in Phnom Penh. The speed dial is 119, the phone number 023 724 891, (012 974 119 does not yet work) and walkie-talkie number 14320.
Kossamak Hospital, covering Toul Kok, Dangkau, and Russei Keo. The phone number is 016 219 119 and walkie-talkie number 14675.
Sihanouk Khmer and Soviet Friendship Hospital, covering Chamkarmon and Meanchey districts. The phone number is 012 827 119 and walkie-talkie 15194.
Phnom Penh Municipal Hospital, covering the center of Phnom Penh. Its phone number is 011 819 119.
The Post tried to contact all these numbers. Only Calmette's 119 was answered.
On an earlier occasion, Calmette's 119 also went unanswered when a Post staffer at the scene of an accident called it repeatedly. The staffer took the accident victim to Calmette by taxi, went to the ambulance phone room and asked the sole attendant why the phone had not been answered. She said perhaps she had been in the toilet.
3 comments:
A simple solution:is for the rich to carry with them a card that reads: "I am rich, I can pay."
SiS
Even in the Emergency, Khmer people are treat like Dogs. How in their blood & brainless law to decide who should pick up the victims.
IT OUGHT TO BE PICK UP THE VICTIM BY THE ANY AMBULANCE TO THE NEAREST HOSPITAL! Saving a life is not a political game...
CPP is such a morons.
This is outrageous! Yeh..If I were to have a car accident and I lay there motionless and can't speak due to my serious injury and AH Tin Prasoaur, chief of Phnom Penh Municipal Traffic Police want to hear my request from the grave?
So when AH Tin Prasoaur have a fucken serious accident and AH Taing Vengseng, owner of Chantrea Clinic will have to hear his fucken request from the grave too!
The only solution is AH HUN SEN need to open up this lucrative business to free market competition now!
Post a Comment