By Vong Sokheng and Charles McDermid
Phnom Penh Post, Issue 15 / 22, November 3 - 16, 2006
The October 18 dismissal of Prince Norodom Ranariddh from the helm of Funcinpec has the reshuffled leadership bullish about its "new image" and allegedly overhauled alliance with the ruling CPP — but some longtime loyalists, politicians and opposition leaders are still saying the party's over.
What retired King Norodom Sihanouk, founder of Funcinpec and Ranariddh's father, referred to as a "coup d'parti," has set off a firestorm of allegations and acrimony and has self-proclaimed Royalists of all stripes sounding off about what that term actually means in the new political arena.
Meanwhile, the Ministry of Interior has yet to approve Ranariddh's bid to launch the Norodom Ranariddh Party, which would become the third political party claiming to be Royalist.
"Now, the most Royalist party is the CPP — without them this country could not be called the Kingdom of Cambodia," Prince Sisowath Sirirath, Funcinpec's new Second Deputy President, told the Post on October 31. "They are the true Royalists because without Samdech Hun Sen how can the monarchy survive?"
Such pronouncements, in this case from a Royal Family member and former Ambassador to the US, make for heated debate, questionable logic and have many observers pointing to manipulation on the part of the CPP. Despite a public announcement by Nhiek Bun Chhay on October 31 that there was "no influence of the CPP" at the party's congress, Sirirath said such overlap is unavoidable.
"We are partners with the CPP, so any decision is made jointly with Hun Sen," Sirirath said. "He's the top of the hill in political matters."
Sirirath was quick to dispel any rumors of a rift between branches of the Royal Family.
"When Prince Ranariddh was removed he and some others said it was a coup from the Sisowath branch against the Norodoms," he said. "But he just happens to be a Norodom. My mother and grandfather were Norodoms. It's so sad that he doesn't know his own history."
Funcinpec Secretary General Nhiek Bun Chhay made a similar statement at Funcinpec headquarters on October 31.
"It is not right to accuse me of setting up a coup to expel [those of] Norodom blood out of politics. You can see that we still have members of Royalty in Funcinpec," he said. "We ousted the prince because our objective is to reform the party. We have no intention to abolish the monarchy."
Sirirath is Ranriddh's cousin and son of the late Prince Sisowath Sirik Matak, who was complicit in the 1970 Lon Nol coup that ousted Head of State Prince Norodom Sihanouk. Sirirath was formerly married to Princess Norodom Arun Rasmey, Sihanouk's niece [KI-Media note: Princess Arun Rasmy is the youngest daughter of King-Father and the late Mam Manivan Phanivong], who is now the wife of newly installed Funcinpec president Keo Puth Rasmey.
"The problems inside Funcinpec are not about the Royalist members or non-Royalist members. The removal of Prince Ranariddh was a political strategy of the CPP who wanted to strengthen its power in the coalition government by kicking out the members of Funcinpec that would stand up against the CPP," said Prince Sisowath Thomico, head of the fledgling Sangkum Jatiniyum Front Party. "Everyone knows that the only person in Funcinpec with the influence and popularity to work against the CPP is Prince Ranariddh. In Khmer society, only the monarchy can stand up to the CPP but it needs a nationalist movement behind it."
Recently expelled senior minister Serei Kosal, a long-time Ranariddh loyalist and a former general of Funcinpec forces, claims that the prince's removal was the result of internal treachery and a brazen power grab by Bun Chhay. A Funcinpec statement released after the National Assembly voted to replace Kosal and nine other Funcinpec lawmakers, said they were "unqualified" for their positions.
"History will consider the events of October 18 as a coup. It is the result of a betrayal by Nhiek Bun Chhay, Lu Lay Sreng and Prince Sirirath — Keo Puth Rasmey is not important," Kosal said on October 30. "The real Funcinpec is finished. Its mission is over. I do not support their betrayal and I was never part of the October 18 faction. Now we must transfer our mission to the real Royalist party, the Norodom Ranariddh Party."
In the 1970s Kosal helped form the Neak Sar "White Dragon" resistance movement against the Khmer Rouge and, later, the Sereika movement fighting Vietnamese occupation. In 1988 he was one of only two military leaders to be personally awarded the prestigious medal of national defense from Sihanouk, then head of Funcinpec. The other was Nhiek Bun Chhay.
"I've worked for Funcinpec since 1979. We will always remember the events of 1997 and the sacrifices of Funcinpec members who died," he said. "I've known [Nhiek Bun Chhay] since the resistance. He must always be the top, the big man. His behavior hasn't changed. He is only interested in self-benefit. I was expelled because only I can anger him."
"He's the biggest liar in the world. The champion of liars," Kosal said.
Kosal's hard-line loyalty is rare at a time when criticizing Ranariddh — for issues ranging from corruption to extra-marital affairs — has become a common political pursuit. It remains to be seen what current members of Funcinpec will join the prince's potential new party.
"We're trying to clean up the image of the party. The Ranariddh loyalist faction is like a cancer — we need to decide whether to operate or let it die," Sirirath said. "We are slowly approaching each individual and we'll ask if they're with us or if they want to leave. No decisions have been made yet. The major removal was the prince himself."
Opposition leader Sam Rainsy, a former Funcinpec member, is distancing himself from the whole affair, and eager to capitalize on any splintering of political opponents.
"He got what he deserved," Rainsy said of Ranariddh on November 1. "He led the party to one defeat after another. He led in an autocratic way and indulged in corruption. He is a prince without principles."
What retired King Norodom Sihanouk, founder of Funcinpec and Ranariddh's father, referred to as a "coup d'parti," has set off a firestorm of allegations and acrimony and has self-proclaimed Royalists of all stripes sounding off about what that term actually means in the new political arena.
Meanwhile, the Ministry of Interior has yet to approve Ranariddh's bid to launch the Norodom Ranariddh Party, which would become the third political party claiming to be Royalist.
"Now, the most Royalist party is the CPP — without them this country could not be called the Kingdom of Cambodia," Prince Sisowath Sirirath, Funcinpec's new Second Deputy President, told the Post on October 31. "They are the true Royalists because without Samdech Hun Sen how can the monarchy survive?"
Such pronouncements, in this case from a Royal Family member and former Ambassador to the US, make for heated debate, questionable logic and have many observers pointing to manipulation on the part of the CPP. Despite a public announcement by Nhiek Bun Chhay on October 31 that there was "no influence of the CPP" at the party's congress, Sirirath said such overlap is unavoidable.
"We are partners with the CPP, so any decision is made jointly with Hun Sen," Sirirath said. "He's the top of the hill in political matters."
Sirirath was quick to dispel any rumors of a rift between branches of the Royal Family.
"When Prince Ranariddh was removed he and some others said it was a coup from the Sisowath branch against the Norodoms," he said. "But he just happens to be a Norodom. My mother and grandfather were Norodoms. It's so sad that he doesn't know his own history."
Funcinpec Secretary General Nhiek Bun Chhay made a similar statement at Funcinpec headquarters on October 31.
"It is not right to accuse me of setting up a coup to expel [those of] Norodom blood out of politics. You can see that we still have members of Royalty in Funcinpec," he said. "We ousted the prince because our objective is to reform the party. We have no intention to abolish the monarchy."
Sirirath is Ranriddh's cousin and son of the late Prince Sisowath Sirik Matak, who was complicit in the 1970 Lon Nol coup that ousted Head of State Prince Norodom Sihanouk. Sirirath was formerly married to Princess Norodom Arun Rasmey, Sihanouk's niece [KI-Media note: Princess Arun Rasmy is the youngest daughter of King-Father and the late Mam Manivan Phanivong], who is now the wife of newly installed Funcinpec president Keo Puth Rasmey.
"The problems inside Funcinpec are not about the Royalist members or non-Royalist members. The removal of Prince Ranariddh was a political strategy of the CPP who wanted to strengthen its power in the coalition government by kicking out the members of Funcinpec that would stand up against the CPP," said Prince Sisowath Thomico, head of the fledgling Sangkum Jatiniyum Front Party. "Everyone knows that the only person in Funcinpec with the influence and popularity to work against the CPP is Prince Ranariddh. In Khmer society, only the monarchy can stand up to the CPP but it needs a nationalist movement behind it."
Recently expelled senior minister Serei Kosal, a long-time Ranariddh loyalist and a former general of Funcinpec forces, claims that the prince's removal was the result of internal treachery and a brazen power grab by Bun Chhay. A Funcinpec statement released after the National Assembly voted to replace Kosal and nine other Funcinpec lawmakers, said they were "unqualified" for their positions.
"History will consider the events of October 18 as a coup. It is the result of a betrayal by Nhiek Bun Chhay, Lu Lay Sreng and Prince Sirirath — Keo Puth Rasmey is not important," Kosal said on October 30. "The real Funcinpec is finished. Its mission is over. I do not support their betrayal and I was never part of the October 18 faction. Now we must transfer our mission to the real Royalist party, the Norodom Ranariddh Party."
In the 1970s Kosal helped form the Neak Sar "White Dragon" resistance movement against the Khmer Rouge and, later, the Sereika movement fighting Vietnamese occupation. In 1988 he was one of only two military leaders to be personally awarded the prestigious medal of national defense from Sihanouk, then head of Funcinpec. The other was Nhiek Bun Chhay.
"I've worked for Funcinpec since 1979. We will always remember the events of 1997 and the sacrifices of Funcinpec members who died," he said. "I've known [Nhiek Bun Chhay] since the resistance. He must always be the top, the big man. His behavior hasn't changed. He is only interested in self-benefit. I was expelled because only I can anger him."
"He's the biggest liar in the world. The champion of liars," Kosal said.
Kosal's hard-line loyalty is rare at a time when criticizing Ranariddh — for issues ranging from corruption to extra-marital affairs — has become a common political pursuit. It remains to be seen what current members of Funcinpec will join the prince's potential new party.
"We're trying to clean up the image of the party. The Ranariddh loyalist faction is like a cancer — we need to decide whether to operate or let it die," Sirirath said. "We are slowly approaching each individual and we'll ask if they're with us or if they want to leave. No decisions have been made yet. The major removal was the prince himself."
Opposition leader Sam Rainsy, a former Funcinpec member, is distancing himself from the whole affair, and eager to capitalize on any splintering of political opponents.
"He got what he deserved," Rainsy said of Ranariddh on November 1. "He led the party to one defeat after another. He led in an autocratic way and indulged in corruption. He is a prince without principles."
3 comments:
You hits the nail on the head, Mr. Sam Rainsy.
So, please stop believe or cooporate whith this stupid prince again.
RM
Come on you do not thing all khmer are stupid! we are not all sereiy Kosal or either Nheck Bunchay!
Nobody can use the word betrayal or treason ( in democracy we have the right to speak and make choise of political point of view and action!)(in a kingdome only one person that can say any body is betray or not is the King himself!)
Ranarith is not a traet to Hun Sen you fool1
Nheck Bunchay ca not replace or take power from Hun Sen you dombo!
personaly Nheck bunchay give no dime with or without Ranarith!
Ranarith is a threat to the King!
If he is FUCPIG for life, and if FUCKPIG run the country, Where is the KING?
the king would be a nothing jugoff!
Do not joint Ranarith you stupid betrayal to the king!!!
Right on sereyroth! why those Norodomb so domb?
Are some royalist try to overthrow the trown?
Post a Comment