Thursday, January 15, 2009

70 officers promoted to 1-golden-star general: An army of generals?

Hun Sen surrounded by a plethora of CPP generals (Photo: Global Witness)

January 15, 2009
KI-Media

On December 31, 2008, Tea Banh, the ministry of Defense, promoted 70 officers to the rank of 1-golden-star general, The Cambodia Daily reported. In March of 2006, Tea Banh indicated that 643 officers occupied the rank of 1 to 4-golden-star generals in Cambodia. This number would provide a ratio of 1 general per 179 soldiers. In comparison, in 2004, the entire US army counts only 876 generals, i.e. 1 general per 1,346 soldiers.

36 comments:

Anonymous said...

The high ratio in the US because there are only a few smart generals. And they have dumb power.

That is why now they want to try "smart power", as Hillary puts it. Perhaps they should import the Cambodian generals.

Kuoy Pichet

Anonymous said...

What do you know about US armed forces? You should not comment on something that you don't know. It makes you sound like an idiot.

Anonymous said...

I agreed with 1:22, and I like to add that that is why the US lost the Vietnam war also. Therefore, our army deserved better than the US.

Anonymous said...

It would be intersting to know the qualifications of these generals, as well as their missions. I hope these generals are not just sitting behind their desks collecting the pay cheques and brutalize their own citizens that they suppose to protect.

Anonymous said...

You're wrong 2:18AM. US did not lose the Vietnam war. US simply don't want to be seen as inhuman. They have all the weapons - chemical, biologiical and nuclear to wipe out the whole vietnamese population from the Earth, OK. So don't be brainwashed by the Yuons claim thay vietcongs defeated US army.

Anonymous said...

D'accord avec 2:29 l'armée Us n'a pas voulu s'ils voulaient je peux vous garantir ils micro ondider le nord voir même détruire le barrage . Voila les faits

Anonymous said...

D'accord avec 2:29 l'armée Us n'a pas voulu s'ils voulaient je peux vous garantir ils micro ondider le nord voir même détruire le barrage . Voila les faits

Anonymous said...

AH ! AH ! AH! AH! AH! AH! AH!

Anonymous said...

Moi? Wrong? 2:29? Do you really think that Russia and China will allowed the US to used WMD in the Vietnam war?

Stop the nonsense excuses, will ya?

The US doesn't got what it take to defeat the Vietcong. No one does, not the French, not China, not Mongolia, ...

Anonymous said...

Isn't there a saying that goes, "if you can't beat them, join them"?

Anonymous said...

That's correct, and the US had already join them, I wonder when Cambodia will follow the US role model?

Anonymous said...

Khmer people should learn how to fight from Vietnam. It was Vietnam who defeated the much better equipped U.S. army. All the American troops are good at is kill civilians from 30,000 feet in the sky, like they killed our people from their B52's. They're cowards when it comes to man-to-man combat. I'm sorry to all of you who love Americans, but they're not the best in everything. Sorry.

Anonymous said...

I don't understand why many people in the poor or third world countries can not see the fact that America is the strongest nation. I guess they - being weak or loser - don't want to admit it that's all. Or maybe, that is their way of thinking, that's why the remain a third world country.

America dominates the World stage. It won world war ii, it defeated the Japanese, the German, later remove Soviet domination.

Look at the Soviet today, their empire crumbled and most of their allies defected NATO. What about China. She is getting stronger, but she is no match to America, and she know that, otherwise she will reclaim Taiwan a long time ago.

Khmer people should start thiking and acting like the Westerns if they want to be successful, else they will remain poor and keep begging the Westerners, or even lose the country to the yuons.

Anonymous said...

5:03pm - AMERICA IS FAR FROM BEING PERFET, BUT IT IS FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR BETTER THAN CAMBODIA AND VIETNAM, DON'T YOU THINK. IF YUONS CAN DEFEATE AMERICA LIKE SOME OF YOU SAY, YUONS WOULD ANNEX CAMBODIA, LAOS AND PART OF THAILAND LONG TIME AGO.

Anonymous said...

3:02PM - That's not what you refer to in your first comment, don't tweak the subject just to drag on the conversation. Act like a smart guy. By the way, I am almost certain that you are the same person as 1:22PM (Kuoy Pichet). Why do you stop revealing your id? Losing confident in your own thought?

Anonymous said...

With all the stars, They still can't serve and protect its nation and its people.

What are those stars used for?: curruptions, abuses, killings, and stealing the nation and its people poor?

Anonymous said...

Oh yeah, 6:07? On the same token, we can say the something about the US: If they are king of the world, they would have annexed all the commies already.

Anonymous said...

America may be the strongest country in the world today, but it is falling apart. Just look at the financial crisis it is going through.

Furthermore, America has a $10 trillion national debt, and $2 trillion of that is owed to China. China can make America bankrupt at any time just by liquidating its US debt securities.

That's why they allowed the U.S. to borrow so much money. They don't need to nuke the U.S. to destroy it. China can do so by pulling the rug from under the Americans' feet and cause them to self-destruct through chaos and anarchy.

Everyone knows that China, which has a growing economy while everyone else is in recession, will be the world's next superpower. China's philosophy is based on nationalism and moderation. That's why it is the oldest living civilization in the world.

- Khmer Patriot, Ph.D.

Anonymous said...

7:02

Unlike like Vietnam or Thailand, the rich and democratic countries such as France, England, German, US, …etc don’t want to annex small and poor countries. Why? because these countries truly respect their constitutions, and their constitutions state that all their citizens must be treated EQUALLY.

For example, if US annexes Laos, then US has to treat Laosians as their own people with all the privileges and benefits that American people have. Laos has no use for US. Why would US wants to give these expensive privileges and benefits to the people of Laos? That’s why US and other rich countries do not annex smaller or poor countries. In these days, many countries in the World want to be annexed by US. Even Cambodia begs to be annexed by US, the latter will not do it.

Vietnam and Thailand on the other hand always dream to annex our country because they will never treat Khmer people as good as their own people.

Anonymous said...

For US, they don't worry whose going to overthrow the government.

For Cambodia, the reason do that because HUN SEN can have a solid root to prevent someone or other groups to overthrom him.

And this is the path to dictatorship.

Kloy Jean,

Anonymous said...

Good to hear from you Khmer Patriot. I disagree with your assessment on US. I think it is erroneous to rate the financial health of a country by simply looking at the amount of debt that country owes. We have to also look at other factors including the country wealth and the capacity to generate revenue …etc.

Look at Khmer Rouge government during 1975-79, it did not owe the money to any country. Does it mean the KR government or our country under the KR government was rich? A business man who has an annual revenue of $500K and a debt of $700K is still much richer and better off than a farmer with an annual revenue of $2500 and a debt of $25K.

No doubt, China is becoming richer in these days, but she is still one of the poor country in the world if you look at the average income per person. Also, her economy would be in a big trouble if US and its allies do not allow China products to their countries.

Anonymous said...

Who said the KR didn't owed any debt? Just how did they get all of the cannons and guns to fight the war.

And if the KR government was that good, why did so many people drop dead left and right from starvation and diseases?

Anonymous said...

No one is saying the KR is good.
We don't know for a fact, but it appeared that the KR traded rice for the weapons from China. I was living in the Eastern Zone, and every year right after the harvest season, the KR brought in trucks to take all our rice aways. That's how people in our region starved.

Anonymous said...

So what you are saying in essence it the KR used rice to pay back their debt. Isn't that the same?

Furthermore, they preferred to pay back their debt over feeding their citizen first. Is that what you are telling us?

Anonymous said...

Relax 9:06PM. You're way off. Cool down your temper and may be you understand the discussion better.

Anonymous said...

Paying the debt with rice is still a money. They didn't print out their money or have their assets in Swiss bank or world bank but rice was a currency during KR's rule. And Pol Pot didn't kill his own people like that. The YOUN was behind the string and cause chaostic and paranoi amongst KR top leaders. YOUN agents all over the country during the rule of Pol Pot.

Former KR soldier,

Anonymous said...

9:42PM what the fuck are you talking about? Ah Pol Pot and the fucking Khmer Rouge kille it owm people with the help of ah Chin and ah Youn Vietnamese, fool!

Mother fucker controled the whole country and take no resposible? your mother must think you shit! Shit head!!!!You was borner through ass hole!!!!

Anonymous said...

11:30 PM,

I can see how you are so dumb and uneducated by talking unprofessionally. Man this is modern time, don't bother to use barbarain style like that. Foul language doesn't make you proud.

Khmer PP,

Anonymous said...

You mother flower are twisted in the head, all i know if america chooses to declare war it shall happen. if america wants that country, it shall happen....but america dont choose to do it. its inhumane. oh, about the chemical that they use during vietnam war because they dont have a choice. the Youns are using khmer land to get thru south vietnam.

Anonymous said...

hey, there's a method to this, in case you're not aware. in cambodia, it is necessary to have a lot of people lining up in official position because history or experience have shown that it is importance because when something happen to one at least they have more. plus, it is good for hands-on training as well. hey, somebody has gotten to be different; this is cambodia, in case you've not aware. people tend to do differently in cambodia than the rest of the world, perhaps. i don't think anything's wrong with that as long as it is not illegal. so, for once, stop your jealousy or hate so the world can be a better place. thank you. god bless cambodia.

Anonymous said...

Mr.Prahok Khmer Mean Kdor Pkai 3 Dea na!!!

Anonymous said...

WOW!
YOU MEAN TO TELL ME THAT THE WHOLE CAMBODIAN ARMY IS A ONE K'DAR GENERAL? THIS IS A TOTAL NUMBER OF CAMBODIAN ARM FORCE.
I WONDER WHOSE DICTATING WHO.
HOW ABOUT THE CHAIN OF COMMAND? LOL

These one k'dar general is useless and pathetic.. if you ask me. Just another Kvack deterent tools to intimidate the general public. Doesn't fool absolutely no one, but
themselves.
The Thai army must be shivering right about now. LMFAO!!!!!!!!!!!!! ~• •~
u
^==^

Anonymous said...

I don't care about these stupid dumb shit Cambodian generals. They know absolutely nothing about warfare, defending the homeland, military tactics & strategy, leadership nor anything else. They are only a bunch of uneducated idiots playing dress up in uniforms and thinking they are all pretty with their worthless stars and caps. They absolutely have no qualifications and are only there in the military to siphon international aid money into their pockets along with their incompetent Tea Banh. These guys don't even try to earn their ranks through service, sacrifice and duty. It's all fake, for show, and to me, this is humiliating and hilarious.

Anonymous said...

HOW TO BE A GENERAL:
U.S. vs Cambodia

United States army general:
-graduates from high school
-Commissioned as a 2nd Lt upon graduation from a national military academy (i.e. West Point)and earns bachelors degree in their field of study. studied military history, international relations and politics as well as their field of study
-earns graduate degree at 4-year institution.
-strong infantry and airborne training. developed strong leadership skills.
-serves many years through the ranks
-have strong capabilities in military science
-distinguish themselves through valor, performance of conduct, duty, sacrifice and years of service
-seek out an assignment to a military specialty in a combat arm or in an area where there are rapid promotions.
-experience in war time
-advanced schooling through the Command and General Staff College and similar military institutions
-20 years or more in their quest to attain the status of general

Cambodian army general:
-little or no military training and if any, it's from one in Vietnam
-be friends of the CPP
-uneducated
-learn how to siphon international aid money and be prepared to never pay stipends to soldiers
-learn how to play dress up and act cute in their uniforms and meaningless medals, stars, etc.
-smoke and do nothing all day
-don't have to learn any military science or history or anything because once war starts, they'll pocket their money and run away and leave everything else for the poor soldiers
-once and a while go to Svay Pak and have sex with under aged girls
-your stars get rewarded to you so fast and without any merit because it's like tossing bread crumbs to the crows
-doesn't give a shit about defending the homeland, a sense of duty, earning rank through service and performance
-corrupt as hell
-BASICALLY IF YOU ARE A CAMBODIAN GENERAL, YOU ARE A MEANINGLESS AND WORTHLESS PILE OF DUNG.

Anonymous said...

12:14 PM




That was well said. Khmer government has too many CHIEFS not enough Indians to do the work. Now who is telling who what to do? Im scratching my head right now.

Anonymous said...

It's Cambodia!!! A country with pathetic people only royal to greed and power. A disgrace race!!!