A resident of Phnom Penh's Rik Reay, or Happy Community, Hang Sochi Ao, 9, stands in the wreckage of his house on Sunday. Sixteen houses out of the original 219 in the community were torn down and zinc fences were put up around the area Sunday as the community is set for relocation by Bassac Garden City, which plans to develop the area. (Photo by: HENG CHIVOAN)
Resident Khin Sreang, 40, in front of the fence. The Khmer text warns people that the fence is electrified and that it could kill them. (Photo by: HENG CHIVOAN)Monday, 16 March 2009
Written by Chhay Channyda and May Titthara
The Phnom Penh Post
Several villagers at Rik Reay commune forced to demolish homes to make way for fencing around development project, following protest at Canadia Bank.
HOUSES belonging to several residents at Phnom Penh's Rik Reay community along the Bassac River in Chamkarmon district Sunday were torn down and residents and journalists threatened with violence.
Villagers and journalists were barred from entering the area by police and staff of the developer, Bassac Garden City, which has - with the municipality's help - begun to fence off some land. Bassac Garden City has been linked in the past to Canadia Bank.
A villager representative, high school teacher Chan Bunthol, said he had received a death threat and could not risk going to work at Preah Sisowath High School in case the company tore down his house while he was away.
"This mistreatment is to force us to agree to their compensation package," he said. "I am now worried for my personal security because I heard a company staffer on the walkie-talkie saying they would kill me because I am a community leader. I want to tell you that if I die, it was not at the hands of anyone else but because I was murdered by the staff of Bassac Garden City."
Residents were forced to pull down 16 houses out of the 219 on the land. Bassac Garden City staff and police intimidated villagers and members of the press to prevent them entering the area and sprayed coloured dye on camera equipment.
Another representative, Heng Samphos, who has lived at Rik Reay since 1990, said the company had planned to develop the area since 2007.
He said some families had lived there since the 1980s. Sixty families have not agreed compensation.
"The company used violence as a negotiation tactic, and now they come to destroy our houses without warning," he said. "At 6:30 this morning, the chief of Tonle Bassac commune came and ordered us to demolish our houses so they could erect a fence. He said they have a government order but he didn't show us."
Last Thursday residents protested outside Canadia Bank's main office in Phnom Penh to demand the bank stop erecting fences around the community. But the bank denied it was involved and said it had simply provided the developer with a loan.
"Canadia Bank always says this development project has nothing to do with them, and that they merely loaned money to Bassac Garden City, but we do not believe them - in reality this belongs to Canadia Bank," Heng Samphos said.
Pung Kheav Se is the chief executive officer at the Overseas Cambodian Investment Corporation Ltd (OCIC) and is also the head of Canadia Bank. He confirmed Bassac Garden City is one of OCIC's projects but denied Canadia Bank was involved in the development.
"Canadia Bank provided a loan to Bassac Garden City, but we haven't built fences around the community. That is officials from the municipality and the commune, who are following the government's instruction," Pung Kheav Se said.
A government directive dated January 30 outlined two options for residents to leave what it referred to as their "temporary homes". The directive, which mentions Pung Kheav Se by name and refers to a January 24 letter from Prime Minister Hun Sen endorsing the development, was signed by Prak Sokhon, a secretary of state at the Council of Ministers, and was addressed to Phnom Penh Governor Kep Chuktema.
One offer is a house in Damnak Trayoeng village and US$10,000, of which the municipality will provide US$1,000 and the developer the rest.
The second option is "onsite housing", which the company will build on 16,200 square metres of land in the community in the "amount of US$5 to $6 million".
Heng Samphos said they were being offered a price well below market value: "Just US$20,000 for one house - and if we agree to that they will give us one flat and US$10,000. We just want the fair market price."
Resident Meas Vanna, 37, agreed to take $20,000 and demolish her own house.
"They gave me $5,000 deposit, and once I have torn it down I can get the rest of the money from Canadia Bank," she said. "The reason I agreed to sell is because their staff said if I don't agree they will tear down my house without compensation. So it is better to sell than be forced to move without being paid, even though I know this money is insufficient to buy a new house."
A monitor for a local housing NGO, the Housing Rights Task Force, decried the fence-building as intimidation: "Residents have legal rights," said Bun Rachana.
HOUSES belonging to several residents at Phnom Penh's Rik Reay community along the Bassac River in Chamkarmon district Sunday were torn down and residents and journalists threatened with violence.
Villagers and journalists were barred from entering the area by police and staff of the developer, Bassac Garden City, which has - with the municipality's help - begun to fence off some land. Bassac Garden City has been linked in the past to Canadia Bank.
A villager representative, high school teacher Chan Bunthol, said he had received a death threat and could not risk going to work at Preah Sisowath High School in case the company tore down his house while he was away.
"This mistreatment is to force us to agree to their compensation package," he said. "I am now worried for my personal security because I heard a company staffer on the walkie-talkie saying they would kill me because I am a community leader. I want to tell you that if I die, it was not at the hands of anyone else but because I was murdered by the staff of Bassac Garden City."
Residents were forced to pull down 16 houses out of the 219 on the land. Bassac Garden City staff and police intimidated villagers and members of the press to prevent them entering the area and sprayed coloured dye on camera equipment.
Another representative, Heng Samphos, who has lived at Rik Reay since 1990, said the company had planned to develop the area since 2007.
He said some families had lived there since the 1980s. Sixty families have not agreed compensation.
"The company used violence as a negotiation tactic, and now they come to destroy our houses without warning," he said. "At 6:30 this morning, the chief of Tonle Bassac commune came and ordered us to demolish our houses so they could erect a fence. He said they have a government order but he didn't show us."
Last Thursday residents protested outside Canadia Bank's main office in Phnom Penh to demand the bank stop erecting fences around the community. But the bank denied it was involved and said it had simply provided the developer with a loan.
"Canadia Bank always says this development project has nothing to do with them, and that they merely loaned money to Bassac Garden City, but we do not believe them - in reality this belongs to Canadia Bank," Heng Samphos said.
Pung Kheav Se is the chief executive officer at the Overseas Cambodian Investment Corporation Ltd (OCIC) and is also the head of Canadia Bank. He confirmed Bassac Garden City is one of OCIC's projects but denied Canadia Bank was involved in the development.
"Canadia Bank provided a loan to Bassac Garden City, but we haven't built fences around the community. That is officials from the municipality and the commune, who are following the government's instruction," Pung Kheav Se said.
A government directive dated January 30 outlined two options for residents to leave what it referred to as their "temporary homes". The directive, which mentions Pung Kheav Se by name and refers to a January 24 letter from Prime Minister Hun Sen endorsing the development, was signed by Prak Sokhon, a secretary of state at the Council of Ministers, and was addressed to Phnom Penh Governor Kep Chuktema.
One offer is a house in Damnak Trayoeng village and US$10,000, of which the municipality will provide US$1,000 and the developer the rest.
The second option is "onsite housing", which the company will build on 16,200 square metres of land in the community in the "amount of US$5 to $6 million".
Heng Samphos said they were being offered a price well below market value: "Just US$20,000 for one house - and if we agree to that they will give us one flat and US$10,000. We just want the fair market price."
Resident Meas Vanna, 37, agreed to take $20,000 and demolish her own house.
"They gave me $5,000 deposit, and once I have torn it down I can get the rest of the money from Canadia Bank," she said. "The reason I agreed to sell is because their staff said if I don't agree they will tear down my house without compensation. So it is better to sell than be forced to move without being paid, even though I know this money is insufficient to buy a new house."
A monitor for a local housing NGO, the Housing Rights Task Force, decried the fence-building as intimidation: "Residents have legal rights," said Bun Rachana.
11 comments:
the bottom line is people should be compensated fairly. there is nothing wrong with cambodia being developed, it is the unfair compensation that is the culprit, not the development itself. please understand the difference. people are not that dumb anymore! thank you.
people that had lived there for a long time like since the 1979 or since the 1980s and 1990s should get a fair compensation for relocation, especially when they have lawful prove of their living there since that time. it's all about fairness and humane treatment; nothing wrong with cambodia getting a chance to redevelop into a modern society or making cambodia developed like the rest of the world. don't get the two mixed up! thank you.
What proof? They have been living on State's land, and now the State need their land back for development.
POL Pot and HUn Sen are the same ...they both killed Khmer and detroy Khmer ..
it is the state's land, however, that's not the point here. there ought to be a fair compensation for these people's relocation by gov't interference. can't just ignore thing like this, especially if it a mass relocation or something. that said, i think the people should be happy enough to get some compensation instead of being too greedy and want more. think about it, when there are too big a mass of people, how could they compenate everybody at a fair market price? that's impossible, after all, it was a state land to begin with, not a private property that you inherited from your ancestors! so, i hope people will consider a fair compensation and not let greed blind them to the point of problematic! god bless all.
20,000 usd is very fair. What do you propose, 1:05?
This is the works of Ah Pouk Scam Rainxy and greedy over-seas Khmer potato diggers. Samdech Hun Sen would never let his people suffer. let the world know.
you piece shit cpp killing machine 12:42.
don't you start talking about state land, your government sell all state properties in Cambodia.
You mf.
4:47am, yes, i think $20,000 US dollars is fair dealing given these people lived on state own property in the first place. i hope they are not too greedy to want more. if they use this money wisely like starting a small business and so on, instead of gambling, splurging and wasteful spending, then it is a lot of money by cambodian standard. please continue to educate people so they can understand. this is just my opinion, too. thank you and god bless all.
Oh, don't listen to pouk Ah Scam Rainxy. Nothing will ever be fair to them unless they can rule the country alone and have asset of at least a million usd each.
អ្នកខ្លះនៅក្នុងមតិបញ្ចេញយោបល់នេះពុំ
មែនជាខ្មែរទេគឺអ្នកញ៉ុះញ៉ង់ឲ្យខ្មែរបែកបាក់គ្នា
កាន់តែខ្លាំងឡើង។ដួច្នេះសូមអ្នកទាំងនោះ
កុំសង្ឃឹមថាអ្វើឲ្យខ្មែរបែកបាក់គ្នានៅក្នុង
ជុំនាន់នេះ។ខ្មែរជុំនាន់នេះមិនដួចជុំនាន់ពីដើមទេ
មួយៗចេះតែធ្វើឲ្យខ្មែរទាស់គ្នាហើយជនបរទេស
ចូលយកដីអោះដួចកាលសៀមយកយួនយកនោះទេ។ខ្មែររាល់ថ្ងៃដឹងអ្នកណាធ្វើឲ្យខ្មែរបានសុខ
ហើយអ្នកណាធ្វើមិនឲ្យខ្មែរបានសុខគឺប្រជាជន
ខ្មែរដឹងគ្រប់ពេលវេលាទាំងអស់
អ្នកដែលទម្លាប់ញ៉ុះញ៉ង់គឺរស់នៅពុំបានសុខទេ។
Post a Comment