Saturday, September 04, 2010

Cambodia's Human Dump versus Cambodia's Human Dumb

Cambodia's Human Dump
www.Joe.ie

Cambodia has taken its rightful place alongside Thailand, Vietnam and Singapore on the Southeast Asian stop-off trail between Ireland and the land Down Under. Beyond occasional street beggars however, few will witness the full extent of the poverty many Cambodians suffer under.

Steung Meanchey, one of Cambodian capital Phnom Penh’s city dumps, isn’t on the list of attractions most visitors stop off at.

What differentiates Steung Meanchey from other landfill sites around the world is that up until a couple of months ago it had several thousand people living on top of its stinking, smoldering rubbish.
The dump site has, of late, been swamped on all sides by the sprawl of the growing city it serves – largely because of Cambodia's rapidly urbanising population. Competition for space coupled with a government policy of expelling residents and then selling off any piece of land foreign companies or individuals express interest in means there is an ever-increasing number of families forced to live in slums.

Those driven onto or around the periphery of Stueng Meanchey scrape together a living of sorts by sifting through newly arrived truck loads of rubbish for salable recyclables, so the dump acts as both home and workplace. Although Steung Meanhcey has now stopped taking new rubbish, it was still operational when JOE.ie paid a visit.

It stank. The smell makes you want to vomit. It makes you want to tear off your nose and gouge out your sinuses. It’s the sort of smell that makes your eyes water and your breath come in short repulsive gasps and that’s before you even get to the dump itself.
Normally, despite the poverty and hardship seen within its borders, the Cambodian spirit will be writ large across the faces of its people in the form of ever-present, infectious smiles. That optimism-against-the-odds attitude however, looks to have been beaten out of the people of Stueng Meanchey.

The majority of people living in Southeast Asia are close to the poverty line, but Cambodia is at the bottom of the pile by some distance. The dump’s haunted residents are the poorest of the poor – living in a squalor lost to the western world a century ago – and they know it.

Ragged, beaten figures paw hopelessly through the mounds of rubbish in dizzying heat while, bizarrely, herds of long-haired, foul-smelling goats from God knows where scramble bleating through the filth. Sickly, toxic smoke leaking from rumbling underground fires compounds the Dante-esque look of the place.
Living in one of the ramshackle huts perched directly on top of the rubbish heap was a group of young Khmers. The dwelling consisted of a raised platform made out of wooden pallets and posts topped by tattered sheets of blue plastic. It was open at the front and a young woman who looked to be about 18 stood leaning against one of the up-rights.

The shack was tiny – the size of a box-room, and appeared to house four people. A phenomenally scruffy young guy of about 15 popped his head up from the filthy mat he had been napping his day away on and gave a sporadically toothed smile.

The other occupants were two children – one was a small girl who sat staring in clothes which were little more than dirty rags and the other was an infant of less than a year old. The youngest was lying naked on the platform dead to the world. Hundreds of flies crawled undisturbed all over her.
Sandar, the eldest girl, was sister to the teenage guy and mother to the two children. They had been living on Stueng Meanchey for four years. She explained that yes – it was a dangerous place to live and rats sniffed, scratched and nibbled at them while they slept. Yes – disease was, of course, rampant because sanitation was non-existent.

Sandar could have been quite pretty but Stueng Meanchey had left its mark on her. Her face bore a raw looking scar she got when a fellow scavenger accidentally tossed a molten piece of plastic her way. There was little point in wishing the group well before leaving. Their future would be as horrible, debased, and nightmarish as their present.
The authorities have recognised that the dump’s comparatively central location means it could have value for development and as such has started expelling residents and banning scavenging. A new dump has been established further from the centre of Phnom Penh although there too the homeless and the desperate are barred from using it as a means of earning a living.

With their homes and income gone and a total absence of anything resembling a welfare system, the former residents have been left longing after the days when they were permitted to live and work on a filthy, smoldering pile of rubbish that for most of us would look like hell on earth.

To see Cambodia's Human Dumb, please click on "Click to Read More..."

Cambodia's Human Dumb







49 comments:

Anonymous said...

But things will get better for these poor people, their leader is going to build the highest building in Asia so they have jobs building it and when it is finished they will have saved enough money to buy one of the appartments and live happy ever after.

Anonymous said...

The Clown Family.

Anonymous said...

It make me very very pitifull and painfull when i saw a very very dirty's child feet in this news..but I can do nothing... I don't want to blame aneone EXCEPT KHMER ROUGE REGIME and THE BLIND'S.....

Anonymous said...

They need to put this photo on CTN and Phnom Penh post.

Anonymous said...

Very sad than P Pot period.
No edcation, living with desease, Hunger, starves. Why? The government let all these happen in the middle of the city. Can they prevent those kids away from the trast.They are inocent.Please help and protect them

Anonymous said...

It is a huge different between knowing and ignoring.

It doesn't matter if these pictures show anywhere. What matter most is the government has a responsibility to act swiftly to eradicate poverty and working hard to improve community services in Cambodia especially child well being. HS doesn't care about Khmer people at all but only himself,his family and clans. This is not hard to prove as it's well illustrated in the first family photo to show the nation to promote his fake concept of family harmony. The irony is he has forgotten about how hungry and miserable he was once as a pagoda boy, and the life of destitute and proletarian who used to hate and envied the riches capitalist. He definitely can stop the ugly cycle of poverty in Cambodia if he really wants to. but he simply choose not to do it and leave it to the NGO to deal with the issue. Why? Because:

1- he needs evidence to prove to the world that Khmer nation are very poor, so he would be able to beg and obtain more aids money for him and his clan's pockets
2- He has no genuine concerns about the welfare of his own people as himself and families are very wealthy and very busy to make more and more wealth
3- It would jeopardize his corruption plan (not the anti-corruption plan)should he decide to intervene on the issue
4- these poor people are perfectly handy and available for him to be used for his demagogy campaign. All he has been doing was to just project a few drops of money or allocate land concession to them.

The photos should be a timely reminder to those who are involved with any type of corruption at all level in the government and the crooks who are exploited the ill system. There will be one day, it's rather be sooner than later, you all have to pay back your debt to these innocents and unfortunate beings; who have been suffered in their living life at the expense of your glamorous and flamboyant lives.

Anonymous said...

I would suggest the KI-Media to publish such type of information more, such action is a machanism to facilitate of creating a platform for helping those unfortunated.

Anonymous said...

6:03 PM, you are half right that the Government should responsible for this but their parents should be more responsible to send them to school. We know parrents need income, However, at his age, children should not responsible for earning income to feed family. Parents need job. Government responsible for creating job opportunity. In order to do so, government need stability to incourage investors to create this job. If opposition party help to create stability, it will be good for nation. Every country has poor people. As I know even rich US, some US citizens even could not afford to see doctors. I heard one US lady declare to marry anyone to have healthcare insurance.

Anonymous said...

6:43 it is true that the press went nut blowing up that story but in the U.S. there are social services that the poor can utilize. It is up to the people whether or not to use it.
In Cambodia, the disparity between the rich and the poor is a gap that bigger than the entire Asia continent. It have been kept a secret but the Viets and the Chinese have been mining and finding gold in Cambodia. Now dealers around the world are flocking into China to buy cheap and quality gold product that originated from Cambodia. You have no idea how much these corrupted bastards have....

Anonymous said...

They do not deserve this at all... How much can a human suffering go?

Anonymous said...

It always exists in any kigndom or republic of banana but in Pol Pot era it was 100 times worse, I lived.
It doesn't mean CPP govement is good because teacher salary, minimum salary are extremly low comparatively to other countries.
Public servants are very corrupted, it avoid ecomony to grow up.

Anonymous said...

3:22PM,
All poor people living in the slum of PPehn have no chance to smell that job. They will hire only Yuons to work, because Hun Xen said so.

Anonymous said...

6:43PM
So you are suggesting your statement is the other half right, is that right?

* I agree with you that parents have as equal responsibility to take care of their children. But tell me first, how can these poor parents afford to take the responsibility when they all have been deprived of their basic human rights, the fundamental rights that they are entitle to be looked after by their government. They are the neglect citizens as much as the people who have been evict from their home or wrongly accused of the crime they did not committed...

Is there adequate social services are being established for them, apart some NGO and good Samaritans who operate out of the mercy of the tyrant government?
I bet you deliberately ignore about the social injustice in Cambodia.

How many deals with foreign and local investors have this government sealed with 99 years contract? and yet you claim that the opposition do not help to create stability in the country.

You're just a bunch of the irresponsible being like the government by presenting such invalid points. I know you are trying to save the incompetent government's face with what ever reason I couldn't care less, but you must try harder to convince readers with substantial argument not this shallow thinking.

Anonymous said...

this kind of site existed in the philipines, in thailand, etc, and yet that didn't stop them from having skyscrapers, tourists, etc, really! stop the bias on cambodia!

Anonymous said...

9:45PM,
Cambodia should show more development than those countries you mentioned because there are more PhDs in the ruling body of government.

Anonymous said...

9:45 PM,
The difference between Cambodia and countries such as the Philippines, Vietnam & Thailand is that the latter three nations have extremely much larger & diversified economies, much more modern & adequate infrastructures & public/social support systems.

I'm not going to say that the Philippines, Vietnam and Thailand have perfect political leaders, but in the case of the Philippines & Thailand, the people have more power in challenging political decisions when they deem themselves are the process of disfranchisement by their government.

With Vietnam, it's different. Their government may perhaps be a one-party communist system but they have taken strides to reduce poverty and have taken heavy measures to provide public housing, work training and raise the standard of living.

Anonymous said...

8:23 PM, you said "Now dealers around the world are flocking into China to buy cheap and quality gold product that originated from Cambodia" is a lie. As I know the largest gold mine still not process yet. 1 tone of mineral gold can produce only around a few grams of pure gold and Cambodia is discovered around 8 million tones of mineral gold. China is very big compare to small cambodia, cambodian resources do not have much enough for China to use it as you said. I know the poor in US is better than here, it is just an example of same suffereing poor. US is collected with more clever people. I don't blame too much on government. you know how many Cambodian living in US, how about standard of living those cambodian comparing with other national like Korea, Japan or China who like in same country US? are they better or worse? you know what i mean.

Anonymous said...

8:23 PM, you said "Now dealers around the world are flocking into China to buy cheap and quality gold product that originated from Cambodia" is a lie. Do you ever visit China? I guess no. As I know the largest gold mine still not process yet. 1 tone of mineral gold can produce only around a few grams of pure gold and Cambodia is discovered around 8 million tones of mineral gold. China is very big compare to small cambodia, cambodian resources do not have much enough for China to use it as you said. I know the poor in US is better than here, it is just an example of same suffereing poor. US is collected with more clever people. I don't blame too much on government. you know how many Cambodian living in US, how about standard of living those cambodian comparing with other national like Korea, Japan or China who like in same country US? are they better or worse? you know what i mean.

KhmerIsrael said...

Never under estimate human depravity!

Anonymous said...

politically speaking people will do what they want to do, whether they are rich, poor, or what have you in between, etc... that's why i think only the rule of law is important, really!

Anonymous said...

call for gov't social reform; cambodia is not the only country with this kind of problem on the planet, you know! there are more to cambodia than some political ambitious group, really!

Anonymous said...

The pictures worth a thousand words.

KhmerIsrael said...

In the books of the bible there is a book name, Job. Job was a wealthy man and he feared God and defended the poor and widows. Yet, despite of his righteous acts, he himself ended up in the Dump. His family was destroyed only his wife was with him.

He was at the end of his rope and wishing to never been born. I mean he had boils all over his body and living at the dump as a refused. But through it all he never lost his integrity toward his Creator. In the end of his trial, God restored to him more than he had before it was taken away from him.

This is one book of the bible I would suggest for monks or anyone to read concerning suffering and injustice. Because in it you will see the Adversary behind human injustice.

You can get access to bible on line at biblegateway.com. Read it in the new King James Version or American Standard Bible.

Remember, "By the fear of the LORD do men depart from evil." If they don't, the injustices will never end.

Anonymous said...

If Pol Pot did not slaughter his own people, I think Pol pot's time was more better than these pictures. So keep voting for Ah Hun Sen then you will suffer more under his stupid rule.

Anonymous said...

_ _
;-;

Anonymous said...

Comment:
you know how many Cambodian living in US, how about standard of living those cambodian comparing with other national like Korea, Japan or China who like in same country US? are they better or worse? you know what i mean.

Why Khmer People do not help each other like Thai, Vietnamese or other Foreigners?

Why they only think for themself?

Do not complain for the Government as the Government is a Mirror of the People!

You do not care for other so other do not care for you!

Why Foreigners are looking down to Cambodian People?
Why they say that they ALL stupid and lazy?

Of course NOT all of us like this but I say:
TOO MANY are like this, sellfish and greedy.

Easy for Others like the Chinese, Thai or Viet to dominate us. We are weak when we do not work together as Khmer People.

If we not change than they will take more from our land. They will be rich in our country and we will be poor in our own country as we are to stupid to do the Right Thing and start to learn from Others.

Is changing the Government a Solution?
Have a look at the corrupt Funcinpec Party. They destroyed themself. This IS stupid.

People have to change the way they think.
THIS is a Solution.

Always complain about the Government, specially the Khmer in USA which run away like rabbits. This People are no use for Cambodia as they only complain but do nothing to change for a better Life.

They become FAT and when they visit Cambodia people think they are rich.

They are only fat, not rich und the REAL Americans looking down on them.

You know what I mean??

Anonymous said...

11:47 PM, you said what I mean. I agree we have to change ourselves first, not very time blame government. Government member is made of individual, if individual changes, it will automatically changes. This is solution. One of bad about Khmer is team spirit is not good. We have knowledgible people but they don't know how to work together as team. This is very unfortunate

Anonymous said...

This is what happen to Khmer peoples under the Cambodian People's Party Hun Sen Khmer Rouge Regime.

Anonymous said...

Democratic Kampuchea Pol Pot Khmer Rouge Regime's leaders and members:
Pol Pot
Nuon Chea
Ieng Sary
Ta Mok
Khieu Samphan
Son Sen
Ieng Thearith
Kaing Guek Eav aka Samak Mith Duch
Chea Sim
Heng Samrin
Hor Namhong aka Samak Mith Yaem
Keat Chhon
Ouk Bunchhoeun
Sim Ka aka Samak Mith Muth
Hun Sen...

Committed:
Tortures
Brutality
Executions
Massacres
Mass Murder
Genocide
Atrocities
Crimes Against Humanity
Starvations
Slavery
Force Labour
Overwork to Death
Human Abuses
Persecution
Unlawful Detention


Cambodian People's Party Hun Sen Khmer Rouge Regime's leaders and members:
Hun Sen
Chea Sim
Heng Samrin
Hor Namhong aka Samak Mith Yaem
Keat Chhon
Ouk Bunchhoeun
Sim Ka aka Samak Mith Muth...

Committed:
Attempted Murders
Attempted Murder on Chea Vichea
Attempted Assassinations
Attempted Assassination on Sam Rainsy
Assassinations
Assassinated Journalists
Assassinated Political Opponents
Assassinated Leaders of the Free Trade Union
Assassinated over 80 members of Sam Rainsy Party.

Sam Rainsy LIC 31 October 2009 - Cairo, Egypt
"As of today, over eighty members of my party have been assassinated. Countless others have been injured, arrested, jailed, or forced to go into hiding or into exile."
  
Executions
Executed over 100 members of FUNCINPEC Party
Murders
Murdered 3 Leaders of the Free Trade Union 
Murdered Chea Vichea
Murdered Ros Sovannareth
Murdered Hy Vuthy
Murdered 10 Journalists
Murdered Khim Sambo
Murdered Khim Sambo's son 
Murdered members of Sam Rainsy Party.
Murdered activists of Sam Rainsy Party
Murdered Innocent Men
Murdered Innocent Women
Murdered Innocent Children
Killed Innocent Khmer Peoples.
Extrajudicial Execution
Grenade Attack
Terrorism
Drive by Shooting
Brutalities
Police Brutality Against Monks
Police Brutality Against Evictees
Tortures
Intimidations
Death Threats
Threatening
Human Abductions
Human Abuses
Human Rights Abuses
Human Trafficking
Drugs Trafficking
Under Age Child Sex
Corruptions
Bribery
Embezzlement
Treason
Border Encroachment, allow Vietnam to encroaching into Cambodia.
Signed away our territories to Vietnam; Koh Tral, almost half of our ocean territory oil field and others.  
Illegal Arrest
Illegal Mass Evictions
Illegal Land Grabbing
Illegal Firearms
Illegal Logging
Illegal Deforestation

Illegally use of remote detonate bomb on Sokha Helicopter, while Hok Lundy and other military officials were on board.

Lightning strike many airplanes, but did not fall from the sky.  Lightning strike out side of airplane and discharge electricity to ground. 
Source:  Lightning, Discovery Channel

Illegally Sold State Properties
Illegally Removed Parliamentary Immunity of Parliament Members
Plunder National Resources
Acid Attacks
Turn Cambodia into a Lawless Country.
Oppression
Injustice
Steal Votes
Bring Foreigners from Vietnam to vote in Cambodia for Cambodian People's Party.
Use Dead people's names to vote for Cambodian People's Party.
Disqualified potential Sam Rainsy Party's voters. 
Abuse the Court as a tools for CPP to send political opponents and journalists to jail.
Abuse of Power
Abuse the Laws
Abuse the National Election Committee
Abuse the National Assembly
Violate the Laws
Violate the Constitution
Violate the Paris Accords
Impunity
Persecution
Unlawful Detention
Death in custody.

Under the Cambodian People's Party Hun Sen Khmer Rouge Regime, no criminals that has been committed crimes against journalists, political opponents, leaders of the Free Trade Union, innocent men, women and children have ever been brought to justice. 

Anonymous said...

This picture of the slump is all over the world. You cannot expect any government to solve everything.

Sure eliminating government corruption does help with social equity. But still the parents are responsible for providing for the children, that's not Hun Sen's job.

Hun Sen is not God. He cannot solve everything problem Cambodian face.

The problem is Cambodians family structure is broken. The father chase after another woman. Or the mother thinks it is okay to sell the daughter.

The concept of human worth, or human value is not so high in Cambodia.

If you do value human worth, and if these pictures bother you then do something. Don't wait on Hun Sen.

Anonymous said...

I agree with 9:00.

6:43,
if the parent can afford their childs education...they wouldn't be in the slump in the first place. Hello!

As far as Mr. "You know what I mean" guy, I have no comment for his frog in the well comment.

Thank you to 1:07 for keeping us abreast.

Anonymous said...

this could happen under any regime, especially if people don't change or reform the social service. i don't care what you say, because it could happen under any gov't if they don't change their thinking and reform, etc...

Anonymous said...

somebody has gotten to do the dirty work. that's why finishing school is very important, or you end up homeless like this, ok! i don't care who you are, you're not immuned to this kind of site, ok!

Anonymous said...

rich people who are frugal still pick trash, you know. it's hard to tell when people are not honest. don't judge the book by its cover, it won't work that way! and children should be in school anyway or they won't have future at all, you know! i only feel sad for blind or disabled people, not the one who is capable! get a life, ok! where is your humiliation? your life is what you choose! wake up, people!

Anonymous said...

children, stay in school or you end up like this!

Anonymous said...

Yes, I agreed - that in any countries, there will be these poor people, but at least the govt. create an institution condusive enough for people to move out from these kinds of condition. It is not the govt. in Phnom Penh, where the rich think that they are god given rights for them to be rich and that they didn't have to take care those poor. In addition, if the rich want to give anything to the poor, they want to make sure that the TV and news crues will be their to capture them and put them on TV. Thus, their give was not pure give out of their kindness, but rather from their political greed. While their act is unjust, but they still want to make people believe that they are just and compassion toward the poor...how ignorance these "new rich Khmer" are. They have no shame and very soulless...no true compassion from their heart toward these poor people....waik-up rich Khmer...don't be greedy...can you try to walk in their footstep for one minute...that is all I ask of you...

Anonymous said...

cambodia needs to put a social service into place so disadvantaged people can go apply for assistance like in america. i think gov't needs to look into create the welfare system to help people get out of this situation as welfare is not permanent. i think it's the lack of such human service we all took for granted i the west that cambodia lacks. cambodia needs to reforms in many fields, really! it's the mentality of the people, not the gov't because if people don't reform, any administration will still have problem with this social issue, i think! people are too quick to exploit this situation for their political gain, etc... until this happen, people will not stop begging for handout, really!

Anonymous said...

If the outcomes of 1975 came out differently in Cambodia, Hun Sen and his family would be exactly just like these people in the photos.

Anonymous said...

Under ah Hun Sen Leadership they will lead khmer to a new dumpster; they even own your life too...
Keep voting on CPP you will have more dumps and dumpsters every where in the country that you love.

Anonymous said...

get used to it; it's called change in time as nothing and no one can last forever on this planet, you know! don't be so selfish and evil and expect changes! changes don't necessarily be bad; cambodia needs changes!

Anonymous said...

while the currupted official drives lexus, and while illegal youns run free in cambodia.

Real khmer struggle to make ends meet.

Anonymous said...

Hun Sen is the Leader whom has lead the country into poverty (ក្រីក្រតោកយ៉ាក)and makes his friends and Yuon very very riches and makes khmer people very very poor living below the poverty line.

Hun Sen it's an upportunity your to resign with honor, before people get mad and chop you and your friends alives!

Anonymous said...

We have social services measures for dealing with these poor folks - we are building more high security fences and hiring body guards...

Anonymous said...

3:48AM

Is it your nature or your job to confuse people?

I have seen your style of comments in most issues on KI bulletin board, especially with most debating and controversal articles like this.
I can see you've tried hard pretending to be an individual writer, however your ideas and principles are very common to grasp.
I don't think you do it for fun, but with perpetual goals.
I understand that number of writers in this blog are only a small fraction if comparing to the readers.
You patriotism don't seem to validate your actions and styles.

Unless you do this for a job, I urge you to be ethical with your conduct by not confusing readers in colliding with your comments.

. said...

This individual @3:48 AM seems to have been using tons of word "Really" almost in every sentence of his/her comments here on KI-Media...Just wonder what "really" he/she is "really" up to, "really"???

Anonymous said...

Please restore balance!
Thank you!

KhmerIsrael said...

Yeah, he "really" stipulated the education thing. Well, I happened to read stories of millionair who don't even know how to read in America. Or never went to college. The difference is the open opportunity and a level playing field.

God created this world and his intention was and is that every person on this earth should have access to land without having to pay nothing for it. But because of man's evil inclination we make merchandise of what God had intended as free for all.

God intended that family members help one another. God created family first, not government. But I see that government wants to take over people's lives. Especially here in the United States. Family unit is more important than big government.

Anonymous said...

Anybody watch Slumpdog indian movie.We doenot alway blame the gorvernment.We want the leader of the country do something for these kids.Less education,less food they will become ,prostutute,steal ,theif,murder...Less health care,they will have hiv, hepatitis,tubercilosis,hapatitis... by these dirty dump to contergious t he the other people.
Donot blame the parent.No parents in the world want to stop their children to be healthy,be able to have education.Unless they have option,Very out of date.

I just feld very sad for our kids.

Anonymous said...

(8:05)
I am really confused with this "really" he/she person...really.
This is the same person who always say: "There is more to Cambodia then you and I.....Really!"
ROTFLMAO¡¡¡