Friday, November 26, 2010

"I think the government and the owners of the Diamond Island have to be responsible for the tragedy": Sat Narith, student at the National University of Cambodia

Question raised on accountability for stampede on national mourning day

by Zhuli Ngoun Sovan

PHNOM PENH, Nov. 25 (Xinhua) -- When Meas Neang bent down and plug joss sticks into the burner on the altar, the sorrow seemed so heavy that she could hardly stand up again.

"I am not blaming any small and big officials, I just wonder why 'happiness turned to anguish'," said the 57-year-old woman, who came from Kandal province to Phnom Penh to dedicate lotus buds and incense sticks to those killed in Monday's stampede.

She was worried that she might lose her younger brother forever in the tragedy, which, in the final day of the traditional Water Festival, claimed at least 347 lives and injured more than 300 others.

"My brother has gone missing since the stampede. He said he came to enjoy the Water Festival in Phnom Penh and asked me for 100,000 riel ($25) to enjoy the festival," she said, tears in eyes. And after that she had never heard anything about him. "I cannot find him, we asked our relatives, no one has seen him. And it has been three days."


The mourning rite site is right at the entrance of the bridge connecting Diamond Island and the mainland of the capital city. Monday night on that bridge, thousands of joyful people began to panicked on some rumor that the "bridge is collapsing," and the subsequent stampede killed hundreds of them.

As Thursday was announced the National Mourning Day for the dead, since early morning thousands of mourners have lined up and paid their homage to the dead, laying lotus, flowers, bananas, food and burning buddhist joss sticks to pray for the dead to rest in peace.

The official mourning rite begun at 7 a.m. as Prime Minister Hun Sen and his wife Bun Rany Hun Sen showed up and offered incense sticks, followed by the top and lower-ranking government officials, senators, parliamentarians, monks, civil servants, private companies, ordinary people and students.

The entrance of the bridge has been piled with lotus, flowers, incense sticks and dozens of wreaths.

All schools, government agencies and private enterprises across the country fling flags at half-mast and all the places of amusement will keep closed till midnight.

As the initial shock, worry and sorrow faint, however, people began to raise questions why a tragedy like this happened.

"I just can't understand why so many people were killed; I wonder why the throngs were intertwined together and were hard to separate them; I also wonder now that the festival was very big and very crowded, why the security guards do not warn the people about the danger, " said Neang.

Sat Narith, 21, a student at the National University of Cambodia, said that she was very grieved with the unexpected accident in her country. "I would like to share my condolence with the families of the dead. I don't have any friend or relative suffered from the stampede, but I, as a Cambodian, came to mourn the dead," said she.

"I think the government and the owners of the Diamond Island have to be responsible for the tragedy," said she, adding that the government should strengthen its security forces to prevent such accident from happening again in the future. "They should warn people about the danger when it is too crowded," Narith said.

Om Yinteang, vice-chairman of the anti-terrorism unit and vice-chairman of the special committee for the accident investigation said Thursday that 395 injured are being hospitalized in various hospitals in the capital city and among them 20 to 25 percent are still in critical condition.

Drew McDowell, an American working in Phnom Penh, told reporters he was a Buddhist believer, after he offered the incense sticks to the altar.

"I am here to mourn the dead and one friend of mine was injured, "said the country manager of NGO-Village Earth in Cambodia.

His friend, a 14-year-old girl, used to be in the coma for two hours after surviving the stampede, and was still in the hospital. "now she can't walk properly yet, but she's recovering," he said.

He seemed still not able to accept what happened three days ago. "I work with young people in Cambodia for one and a half year and so many young Cambodia people just had died terribly. I still can't believe," said he.

Yes, a lot of motions had been taken by the government to look at in this accident, he said; and though not sure who should be blamed for this fault, he insisted "it's a lesson to be learnt for the government for the future -- they should not encourage so many people to converge at a small place like this bridge."

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

they should be partly responsible and society too must be partly responsible, etc... this is a tragic accident, you know! you can blame on the builders of the bridge, the development of koh pich, the changes of economy, the people from the provinces who weren't educated to undstand that the swaying of the bridge was normal, etc, and the one who yelled out fire in the crowded theater, etc, etc, you see! everyone has a part and responsibility in this, if you look at the bigger picture of things the way they were, really! so learn from it, ok! improve things next time as life goes on next year and more...

Anonymous said...

yes, in cambodia, we say money can't buy love, happiness, life, peace, anything that are abstract, etc, etc, but it's better than nothing, you know!

Anonymous said...

I agree with this comment entirely.
Usually in overseas, all business must buy insurance for public liability. This public liability is to cover all accidents occured in business area and other accidents caused by business providers. Without having this public liability, authority must confiscicate this business and put it for public tender to colect moneys to pay to all their damages.

Areak Prey

Kulen Monorom said...

Your Majesty Samdech Ta former King Norodom Sihanouk,

Prime Minister Samdech Hun Sen,

Thank you for your both kindness and understanding.
What we need is prevention methods, not to let this type of accident happen again in the future.

It also makes me very worried to see so much alcohol allowed to enter or be produced in our beloved Kingdom of Cambodia? What about “ YA BA “ and other types of DRUGS from Thailand and Vietnam?

Can His Majesty Samdech Ta and Samdech Hun Sen stop all sorts of drugs coming to Cambodia? The accident may not be related to drugs and alcohol but just some thing that I could not sleep peacefully from now on to the future, in the names sake of true Khmer citizen.

Can Samdech Hun Sen kindly ask all 5 million Vietnamese illegal immigrants to peacefully return to Vietnam, so Koh Pich will not be too crowded more and more every day, every month and every year to come.
All Vietnamese illegal immigrants can easily come in and settle inside Cambodia even though they already have their own country Vietnam.

When Cambodia is too crowded, definitely we Khmer people can not go to settle inside Vietnam, can we?
Please Vietnamese, you said you came to rescue us from Pol Pot, and you don’t want to return home, it is not right according to 23rd October 1991 Paris Peace Agreement, can all of you go back to your country now.

Vietnamese illegal immigrants, you see because 5 million of you are inside Cambodia, it makes us too crowded and we wasted our lives at Koh Pich without good reasons.

Your Vietnamese Communism expansionist mind in Cambodia, is to give an excuse to China mainland to occupy your Spratly Islands, Parcel Islands, the whole of your Eastern sea border and perhaps the Northern border sooner or later.

5 million Vietnamese illegal immigrants in Cambodia, please go back home to defend your country from Chinese mighty economic invasion.

May I pray to God and the Lord Jesus Christ that those who have lost loved one will be comforted.

My condolences to all the victim's family.

Regards,

Kulen Monorom
(The rice farmer's son)

Anonymous said...

Peaceful solution is the right direction. Vengeance and anger are not the solution. Vengeance and anger are type of the war, too. They are out of date. Resignation of Police Chief, and Phnom Penh Mayor ( Chauvay Krong) are the first step.

love from Khmer

Anonymous said...

The responsible of the stampede is the guy who created the panic on the bridge.

Anonymous said...

The government. Water festival is the government sponsored event and the government and PP municipality have the responsibility to keep everyone safe. period.

Anonymous said...

Heh guys! Does "National University of Cambodia" exist or not? Which one in particular? Please correct me if I am wrong...!