Saturday, November 27, 2010

Paying a high price for cheap sex

Prostitutes outside a brothel in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Photograph: Rob Elliott/AFP/Getty Images
MAGAN' WORLD: Manchán Magan’s tales of a travel addict

Saturday, November 27, 2010
IrishTimes.com

HOW MUCH for a really good hooker in Cambodia these days? For a young one, just down from her remote mountain village.

As a travel supplement aimed at helping travellers get the best from their holidays it would be remiss of us not to cover this important tourism growth area. After all, 22 per cent of foreign visitors to Cambodia in 2000 were there for sex; no doubt some may have been Irish Times readers. So, in the interests of catering to readers of all tastes, let’s seek out the best value for yam-yam and bam-bam.

It might help first to take a quick glance at international sex trafficking statistics, as a large proportion of Cambodian sex workers are trafficked in from Vietnam and northern Thailand. The pretty little girl you buy is likely to have been either kidnapped by neighbours or sold by desperate relatives for a few hundred euro.

She will probably have been held in the brothel you found her in, or in some squat belonging to the pimp from whom you bought her, but one needn’t think of it as imprisonment.


She is, in theory, free to leave at any time, once she has paid back the expenses incurred in bringing her there. These debts aren’t as terribly crippling as you might imagine – a large proportion will have been cleared in the first few months, when she was first sold as a virgin for top dollar to a few lucky foreigners, after that her value quickly plummets, so that within a few months you could pick her up for less than €50 if you know how to bargain. Or even as low as €10 if you wait until she is strung out on heroin, and possibly infected with HIV.

By then the brothel has little use for her, and would be glad to sell her freedom to you for a nominal fee to cover any remaining charges for room and board, or any abortions she may have had to undergo due to “carelessness”.

It’s odd that although one may go to Cambodia seeking sex, one finds instead a last vestige of slavery, not the brutish, bewhiskered 19th century type involving scurrilous men in knee-length breeches and boots, but something more subtle and innocuous. The United Nations estimates that between 700,000 and 4 million people are cajoled from their homes and sold into slavery worldwide each year. Some 80 per cent are women, girls and young boys trafficked into commercial sexual exploitation. They are lured with false promises of low-skilled jobs in waitressing, modelling or domestic help, at ever younger ages: the average age of trafficked prostitutes in some Asian brothels is 14.

There’s unlikely to be a famous Harriet Tubman or Frederick Douglass-type figure leading an heroic revolution of enslaved sex workers to liberty, because such is the debased status of women in many Asian societies that some will have voluntarily agreed to their enslavement to help feed a hungry family or provide medicine for a sick relative. Once the money has been earned, in theory they are free to return home, but in practise a village community is unlikely to allow them forget their act of generosity. They will be stigmatised, unable to marry. Their sacrifice is for life – although that might not in fact be very long: many die of Aids by their 20s, or are so severely afflicted with post-traumatic stress disorder that they drink or drug themselves to an early grave.

The leading causes of death among trafficked women are homicide, suicide, drug/alcohol related problems and HIV. In fact, the homicide rate among trafficked women is 17 per cent higher then the average.

But, I’ve drifted off-topic. To get back to finding a really good prostitute in Cambodia. First off, I am told it’s best to say you are going on a golfing holiday.

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

What can you do to change the situation. It is hard to defend, but they sale their honors, because of the living situation and not for fun.
The different between the caucasian and asian like us are, you caucasian want sex for fun, contrary we serve sex for a better life.
You right to blame our society, but please look back to the situation of your country before 50 years ago. You also have had your own social and political problems.

Anonymous said...

I think all those girl are Youn. They're came to do these business in Cambodian make our culture look bads Khmer gov't must shut down all the Hookers places. I know most of the tourist go to Cambodian or Asian they go there for sex only those animals they like Asian women it Yam,Yam and delisious.

Casey Nelson (pseud.) said...

I call bullshit.

The stats quoted are 10 years old and bear absolutely no relation to the tourism situation in Cambodia today.

And when exactly was that photo taken? I don't know every corner of the city but I haven't seen a brothel like that in Phnom Penh in many years. I suspect it was taken about as long ago as those decade old stats quoted in the article.

Anonymous said...

Yes bullshit, sure!

Prostitution is the world´s oldest business and exists any time, anywhere.

Of course the economic situation has it´s role but prostitution is also a quick way to make a lot of money.

I know hookers here in Phnom Penh with expansive cell phones, living in modern appartements and having new motorbikes.

So what?

Casey Nelson (pseud.) said...

I checked it out.

That photo is more than 11 years old, taken in March 1999.

The stats on Cambodia quoted in the article, if they were ever true, are more than 10 years old.

The situation in today's Cambodia is completely different.

Manchan Magan has duped the Irish Times into printing this bogus article wildly misrepresenting the situation and maligning Cambodia for reasons unknown - whether through ignorance, malicious intent or just make money selling words, I'm not sure.

He should be ashamed of himself.

BTW, nobody says they are going on a golf holiday to Cambodia.

Anonymous said...

For my experiences for these in Cambodia that is the country loading a lot of trafficking cases committed by the master mind of the high ranking officers.

Anonymous said...

You all are in denial. Just like some of you are still in denial that Hun Sen is a Viet puppet.
It is still very prominent, it just a little harder to find.
Please, the f*cking chief of police goes to some farmer house and ask to have sex with the farmer daughter....

Anonymous said...

ហ៊ុនសែនវាមិនដែលគិតថាខ្លួនវាជាខ្មែរទេ

ហើយវាគិតថាខ្មែរមួយម៉ឺននាក់មិនស្មើនឺងយួនមួយ

ក្បាលផង។​

ការស្លាប់និងរង្គ្រោះរបស់ប្រជាជនខ្មែរលើក​

នេះមិនមែនតែលើកទីមួយទេគឹលើកទីបួនហើយ

សម្រាប់ប្រជាជនខ្មែរទូទាំងពិភពលោក។

ហ៊ុនសែនវាជារដ្ឋាភិបាលខួរក្បាលបង្កងធ្វើអីក៍មិន

កើតភ្នែកក៍ខ្វាក់អវិជ្ជាថែមទៀតនៅក្នុងខួរក្បាលវា

មានតែបណ្ដាំបីមាត់របស់ អាក្រពើ​ ហ៊ូ ជីមិញ​

លួច កាប់ និងសម្លាប់ ដើម្បីសម្រេចគោល

នយោបាយរបស់វាវាបានប្រើធម៍ត្រជាក់និងក្ដៅលា

យឡំគ្នា។អាឆ្កែ ជក់ម៉ា វាជាអភិបាលក្រុងបែរ

ជាមិន​ដឹងរឿងហេតការណ៍ទៅវិញ​ អាក្បាលទំ

ពែកដេកតែចុយស្រីយួន។ ចំណែកអាទូច

នរកវិញ ជាស្នងការនគរបាលក្រុង ​គ្មានការ

រៀបចំសន្តិសុខដល់ប្រជាជនទាល់តែសោះ

ជាពិសេសនៅថ្ងៃបុណ្យទានផ្សេងๆ ។

សូមដួងវិញ្ញាណនក្ខន្ឋពលរដ្ឋខ្មែរទាំងអស់

មេត្តាតាមព្យាបាទកាច់បំបាក់កពួកអាកញ្ចះយួន

នេះផងដើម្បីឲ្យកូនខ្មែរជំនាន់ក្រោយបានទទួល

បាននូវសន្តិភាព សេរីភាព និង ភាពចំរុង

ចំរើនដល់សង្គមខ្មែរទាំងមូលផង៕


ដើម្បីបំបាត់ពូជអាយ៉ងនៅស្រុកខ្មែរត្រូវបំបាត់

អាយ៉ងនៅយៀកណាមជាមុនសិន

Anonymous said...

គិតទៅអាពួកប្រឆាំងបើបានឃើញពលរដ្ធខ្មែរ
ធ្វើជាស្រីពេស្យាវាអរណាស់ពីព្រោះប្រពន្ធពួកវាមិន
ចុយក្តិតមីប្រពន្ធទៀត។

Anonymous said...

i'm bi, and mostly gay, i don't have to worry about this!

Anonymous said...

First to the bisexual person; there are niche for everything - the European men especially like your types!

Your statement is completely self-absorbed and selfish. You have no concern about members of your community or society at large. But you go out on your gay pride parade ask the community to accept you and your rainbow coalition - what a hypocrite!

And now to the deniers; so that picture was stock, maybe taken 11 years ago, but did you already forget John Walsh's America's Most Wanted Air last month?

You think denial can put problems under a rug and clean up Khmer image? Khmer imaged has been dirty already, the best way to clean up the image to make sure the government and the Cambodian people change their attitudes on the values of woman.


Just because you're Cambodian, it does not mean you were task with the duty to defend every aspects of Cambodian society- especially, Human Trafficking! Sometimes patriotism kills, this is one example of how narrowed-minded patriots do more harm to their country then good.

Casey Nelson (pseud.) said...

Yeah I saw Americas Most Wanted. It was pretty bad, sensationalistic and in parts downright insulting if not racist, "Every Cambodian child is for sale" it said. Give me a break. Check out the recent Newsweek article on the subject. Much more balanced, informed and more interested in honest reporting than sensational one liners. 

Though much has been done in the last decade, there is of course still a problem with human trafficking and sexual slavery in Cambodia and it needs to continue to be addressed, but it is nothing like the above article depicts. There have been huge changes in the last 10 years. There are no brothels in Phnom Penh like in the picture. That was cleaned up years ago. The above article is about as accurate as a 10 year old article about the situation in Iraq, and that would be a lousy basis for understanding the current situation and developing ways of addressing it.

Anonymous said...

STOP CHILD SEXUAL EXPLOITATION. You will be jailed in Cambodia or at home. Constructive motivation is encouraged.

Anonymous said...

This are VC Vietnam Youn Bitches. They are not Khmer. Sent their nasty ass vietnam whore back to Hanio. Go back you dog eater bitches! LL Khmer

Colononial man said...

Big Dick Manchan Magan, go fuck your mom's ass, you stupid damn fuck. You know why there is prostitution in developing or poor countries because of colonialism. You and your folks, the "long nose" and developed west occupied our less developed countries and sucked all our natural resources ( Asia, Africa, Latin Amrica...). You, the colonial powers stole all our cultural heritage to put in ur museum at your countries. In fact, all colonial powers must be tried by International courts. And you, the West, resources suckers, must pay back all you have taken from your colonialised countries. Understood, stupid damn fuck!. Please don't show your crocodile's tears. These innocent girls resort to prostitution because of poverty and ignorance as result of your west's colonies. If you blame this problem, you must curse your grand-parents!!!