Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Bridge Inquiry Aims To Find What Government ‘Missed’

The head of the organization, Ou Virak, told “Hello VOA” on Thursday that interviews with nearly 50 witnesses showed too few police were stationed near the bridge. (Photo: by Men Kimseng)
Sok Khemara, VOA Khmer
Washington, DC Monday, 20 December 2010
“The response of the police was much lacking.”
The Cambodian Center for Human Rights is continuing its investigation of the Nov. 22 Diamond Bridge catastrophe, but it lacks the authority to summon government officials and police for questioning.

The head of the organization, Ou Virak, told “Hello VOA” on Thursday that interviews with nearly 50 witnesses showed too few police were stationed near the bridge.

The center is holding its own investigation into the disaster, which killed 353 people, after the government’s official report was concluded in under a week and found no fault with Water Festival organizers, city planners or security officials.

“In our view, the government report missed a lot of angles,” Ou Virak said. “That’s why CCHR is trying to seek information through other aspects of the situation, including watching videos and interviewing victims and witnesses.”


The organization was following more leads and had “found much more than the government when it ended its investigation,” he said. “But we don’t have the authority to summon anyone for questioning like the government.”

Like the government report, CCHR found witnesses who said the main cause of the deadly stampede came when people began shouting that the swaying bridge would collapse. But it also found there had been “no preparation” for such a crowded bridge and that police were not stationed near the choke point.

The group also found reports that electric shocks went through the crowd, he said, a claim it is continuing to investigate.

Witnesses said the police had done little on the mainland side of the bridge to keep the crowd from amassing on the bridge, as a concert got underway on Diamond Island, on the other side. Witnesses also said a barricade for vehicles had become a source of congestion for foot traffic.

Overall, Ou Virak said, the disaster showed an “absence of good governance,” where officials have not taken responsibility for the incident, and where underpaid police were not at their stations.

In the aftermath of the tragedy, officials had blamed the incident on the crowd, saying that uneducated people “from the countryside” had panicked. Ou Virak called this “irresponsible.” Meanwhile, the National Assembly did not step forward in its own inquiry, he said.

Ou Virak was also critical of the response to the stampede, where, he said, police stacked the injured with the dead, creating more fatalities.

The response of the police was much lacking,” he said, “and the police were not prepared or trained properly to understand early rescue.”

Tun Srey Pov, who survived the bridge incident and also spoke on “Hello VOA” Thursday, said there were not enough police to contain a situation that rapidly got out of hand.

“If they had had enough security or enough control, there would not have been a deadly stampede that caused more than 300 people to be killed,” she said. “I want to know for sure.”

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

where is MR police chief TOUCH NAROT where is he hiding his face now? waiting for thing to settle down a bit more?

Anonymous said...

It is true, even my daughters also told me that the cop's head withdraw their troops before 8 PM and they all went to have drinks and asked for money from the sellers. They did not come close by the bridge for help.

Anonymous said...

Human Rights,your duties is to find out the truth that who killed 2 415 654 innocent khmers between 1970-2010.And the immigrant vietcong who ertered into Cambodia in 1993,

Wishing you the Best Wishes for 2011.

May Buddha bless all people in this planet.

Anonymous said...

6:51PM, till now you don't have a clue of who killed all the Khmer? Not even between 1975-1979? Then you gotta be the dumbest ass punk on the face of the earth.

Anonymous said...

នៅឆ្នាំ១៩៧០មានពលរដ្ធយួនស្លាប់រាប់មិនអស់
ដោយសារទាហ៊ានលន់នល់សម្លាប់លុះដល់របប
ពលពតក៏មានពលរដ្ធយួនស្លាប់រាប់មិនអស់ដែរគឺ
ដោយសារខ្មែរក្រហមពីឆ្នាំ១៩៧៥ទៅទល់ឆ្នាំ១៩៧៩
បានសម្លាប់។ប៉ុន្តែយួននៅតែមកជួយពលរដ្ធខ្មែរនៅជុំនាន់ពលពតទៀត។គិតទៅបក្សពួកប្រឆាំងយកតែរឿងដែលកន្លងហួសរាប់រយឆ្នាំមកហើយមកនិយាយ
ជារាងរាល់ថ្ងៃ។ពួកនេះមិនបានមើលឃើញនៅប្រទេសជប៉ុនដែលអាមេរិកាំងទម្លាក់គ្រាប់បែកហើយ
បានសម្លាប់ប្រជាជនជប៉ុនរាប់ស៊ែននាក់ម្តេចក៏
ប្រជាជនជប៉ុនមិនយករឿងហ្នឹងមកនិយាយជារាង
រាល់ថ្ងៃទៅ?បើចង់ឲ្យពលរដ្ធខ្មែរមានកំហឹងជារាង
រាល់ថ្ងៃត្រូវតែយករឿងពលពតមកនិយាយទើប
មានខ្មែរចងគំនំជានិច្ចបើបក្សប្រឆាំងយកតែរដ្ធា
ភិបាលសព្វថ្ងៃមកនិយាយគឺពិតជាគ្មាននរណាមួយ
ស្តាប់អស់លោកទេមានតែជេរអស់លោកថែមទៀត
ផង។អស់លោកប្រឆាំងមិនដែលធ្លាប់រស់នៅជុំនាន់
ពលពតមិនបានដឹងថាជុំនាន់នោះមានការលំបាក
ប៉ុណ្ណានោះទេ?បើខ្ញុំនិយាយអំពីជុំនាន់ពលពតវិញ
គឺយកពេលមួយអាទិត្យទើបបាននិយាយចប់។

Anonymous said...

well, if that's the case, then the purpose of this is to push or encourage reforms in cambodia system in dealing with crisis, accidence, service to the public, responsibility, accountability, etc... if not, then, what is the purpose of doing this? got to be inquisitive all the time in learning and education, training, etc..., ok! yes, sometimes, it takes sacrifice, mistakes, crisis, etc, for things to reform or change for the better and so forth. i think it's part of life, really! good thing to want to improve things in cambodia, always!

Anonymous said...

2:00AM in modern world there need not go throught crisis to leurn! It call education, observe and commonesen!

try not to acksept free PhD! and send your children to a real school and do not buy the diploma!

Anonymous said...

Dear Khmer,
Youn children born in Cambodia in 1979 are growing and ready to take
full controle of Cambodia after 2013. They plan to eliminated 80% of older CPP MP. Hun Sen will order to put those young viet children in ballot as #1 and #2 and #3 respectively. Early 2013 Hun Sen will force the old timer CPP MPs to retire permanently so he can replace them with those young Viet children born in Cambodia. You'll will see some viet children never live in Cambodia but they will be in ballot as well.

You can see the commenter above,10:32PM, is an example. He can write Khmer perfectly.

I can't stand to see Khmer lost land to youn.
CPP inside member