Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Need answer on Cambodian extortionate hospital system

Hi,

I am a frequent reader of your posts as well as your partners blog. Today I am writing because I want to know the policy of Cambodian hospital and its staffs member. My relative was sick and admitted himself in the hospital in Phnom Penh. He paid them each time they present a bill to him and so the staffs there treat him well. When he is nearly out of money, he told them honest that he have no money left to pay them and wished to go home with just medicine so he can take care of himself at home but they say it is ok for him to get the full medical treatment in the hospital. So he stays there for almost a week and he gets better until he ask again to go home and also told them that he need to find money to pay them.


The doctor who treated him know very well that he is short of money. So yesterday they argued over the bill because they want him to pay them which is fine, he will pay but he need to get out of the hospital to find the money however, they won't release him out until he pay them in full which is ridiculous! How can a person find the money while in the hospital? He told them he need to go out to find the money and pay them when he can, just give him times to make the money but the doctor and his team won't listen. They demand he pay now but how can he?! Now they want to sue him for not paying and this is outrageous policy!

My relative is willing to pay but he need to get discharge from the hospital to work and make money to pay back. How can these group of medical team expect him to pay them when they keep him in the hospital?

Is this common in Cambodia? Do Dr and hospital sue patient who cannot pay immediately all the time? I just need to find justice for my relative. The doctor is writing up report that he is a disruptive patient, causing trouble to their work etc which is so untrue! How can a professional be so unreasonable? Now my relative is stress over this and he is still in the hospital but they won't give him any more medicine or treat him at all. They are ignoring his pain. I know that my relative is at fault for not paying but circumstance make him unable to pay because he runs out of money and need to get back to work to make money and pay. Why don't they understand? Are there any organization or anything I can do to help him out to win this case because tomorrow Monday morning, they are going to the police station to sue him.

Thank you for reading my complaint and I hope to hear back from you soon.

Rea

----------

Dear Rea,

It is sad that Cambodian hospital system is so corrupt that doctors and hospital staff have so often become predatory and extortionate toward their patients. In the West, doctors and medical staff have been trained to observe the medical ethics strictly- meaning the life and the health of the patients come first before money.

As far as I know, this practice is common, but it is not a hospital or the government's policy, but have been rampantly practised by corrupt and unethical doctors and medical staff.


I don't know if any NGOs can help, but you can try the Cambodian Human Rights Centre (Ouvirak@cchrcambodia.org ) or Licadho (Licadho@camnet.com.kh) or go to one of the ruling or opposition MPs to ask them to intervene.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

*Rea
you may send your comment to Dr Mam Bun Heng in Cambodia.Why you sent your comment to KI Media?.
Reak ach

Anonymous said...

Why not to Dr.Mam Bun Heng?How come
To KI MEDIA?The Khmer hospital policy is crooked and corrupted.
Hun Sen is crooked and corrupted,
the rest of them are the same.

Anonymous said...

sounds like the hospital system in cambodia can use much needed reforms as well, really! healthcare providers, etc should be made to sworn to protect life first over money, etc, really! wake up, people! doctors and nurses are supposed to save life, not taking away life or deprive people of life, really! where is the professional ethics in all of this?

Anonymous said...

Remember the Fake PHD? You can buy most of the Degree at University of Phnom Penh for $1k. There is no laws in Khmer. most wealthy kids dont have to show up in class or pass exam. just paid your teacher and you on your way to become a surgon general! LOL Khmer education is a joke. You get better education at a third party school

Anonymous said...

Hun Sen was thief, he is dishonest, he always cheats,
all of those doctors imitate Hun Sen and his family members.

If Cambodians elect honest PM, medical system would be better..

Anonymous said...

doctors and other healthcare providers are trained to do no harm to life and the patient. please use professional ethics and live by it, thank you.