Showing posts with label Double standards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Double standards. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Memories of evil stir as Duch trial opens

Kaing Guek Eav, better known as Duch, faces court Tuesday on the first day of his trial for crimes against humanity and war crimes. (Photo by: AFP/POOL)

Wednesday, 18 February 2009
Written by Neth Pheaktra and Cat Barton
The Phnom Penh Post

First prosecution of former Khmer Rouge leader gives many regime victims an uneasy look back into the past, but also a glimpse of hope.

VANN Nath, perhaps one of the Khmer Rouge regime's most famous survivors, has waited decades for the trial of his former tormentor, Tuol Sleng prison chief Kaing Guek Eav.

As the landmark event began Tuesday, Vann Nath, who was one of only a handful to walk out of the torture centre after the regime was toppled in 1979, said: "I have been waiting for this day for 30 years and now the day is here".

"Last night, I did not sleep well because I was thinking a lot about my time at Tuol Sleng," added Vann Nath, who was spared execution because of artistic abilities, which his jailors put to use painting portraits of Khmer Rouge leader Pol Pot.

"I dreamed about going to the Khmer Rouge tribunal to join this hearing because it is very important for all people," he said.

For many victims, the opening of the trial at the UN-backed court marks the hoped-for end of a long wait for an explanation and an apology for their suffering.

"I lost all my relatives in the regime. I am an orphan," said Kuch Gnorn, 50, now a monk.

"I really want to know why the Khmer Rouge killed their own people. It makes me angry - so much violence in this Buddhist country of Cambodia," he added.

Francois Roux, the French lawyer representing the 66-year-old former maths teacher-turned-torturer, said his client, who is charged with war crimes and crimes against humanity, would like to answer his victims.

Kaing Guek Eav, who is better known as Duch, "would like to apologise to victims, but not today," Roux said after the hearing.

"He will apologise not only to victims of S-21 but to all Cambodians. He will explain everything, but ... in the future. So I make the request to victims, please, don't close the door yet."

Though largely procedural, with no witness testimony or statements from Duch, Tuesday's hearing still brought long-buried emotions to the surface for many in attendance.

Luch Bunthort, 54, from Kampong Thom province, who had travelled to the court, said: "I have been waiting for this hearing for years. I never thought that it would happen. ... I lost three members of my family during the regime".

Later in the day, the sky above rained for the first time after a long dry season, which many interpreted as a portent of the sorrow opening up old wounds.

"Cambodians everywhere are crying," court spokesman Reach Sambath told the Post.

Dredging up old memories for the new trial, even in the name of finding closure, comes with attendant risks.

"I hope that survivors who do attend or who watch the hearings or read about them in papers understand that everything is not going to be solved [Tuesday]," said Sara Colm, of Human Rights Watch.

"This kind of hearing can re-open old wounds so ... I'm thinking about the victims, and I hope the beginning of the proceedings delivers justice for them in their minds and their hearts," she said, adding that proper support - from friends, family or professional organisations - was essential for victims.

But many observers still question what the trial will ultimately achieve.

"On the one hand, it is good that the trials are finally commencing. But why start with Duch, who was a cog, albeit a willing cog, in a machine created and ordered by others?" asked historian Philip Short, author of Pol Pot: History of a nightmare.

"And why try Duch when all the KR Zone secretaries, the district chiefs ... the local chhlorp leaders, and so many others whose hands are steeped in murder, are not going to face any kind of justice? The politically imposed double standard is flagrant," he added.

For Short, the trials of [leaders] Nuon Chea, Ieng Sary and Khieu Samphan will be far more important than Duch's trial, in that they - and particularly the first two - were in the top echelons of the leadership that created the KR machine.

"Duch may cast light on how the machine operated. Nuon Chea and Ieng Sary, if they choose to do so, could cast light on why it operated that way. That said, I don't have any great hopes that either will reveal, except inadvertently, much truth about what they did," he said.

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

The Astonishing Double Standards of the CCP

(Teh Eng Koon/AFP/Getty Images)

Apr 28, 2008
By Zhang Tianliang
Epoch Times Staff

The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has often accused Western countries of having a double standard concerning human rights issues, when in fact the CCP should really be blaming itself.

While branding many other governments as holding "hegemonic foreign policy and domestic democracy," the CCP takes care to implement a completely opposite policy: They are servile with foreigners and relentless with its own people.

Take for instance the regulations the CCP promulgated governing the prevention and control of AIDS at ports and border checkpoints. The regulations stipulate that Chinese citizens who stay overseas for longer than one year are subject to an AIDS examination upon their arrival in China. However, foreigners and the Chinese with acquired foreign citizenship are exempted from these quarantine procedures.

In addition, in China's official report on national food safety and quality published on August 17, 2007, it indicated that over 99 percent of exported food products were up to standard, while for domestic food products the same rate was only 77.9 percent. This is another striking example of the regime's discrimination against its own people.

During the great famine of 1958 that lasted until 1962, over 30 million Chinese people starved to death. During the famine, the CCP spent 2.3 billion yuan (US$ 328 million) as aid to other communist countries. Had the money been used for food, many could have been saved.

The CCP has also implemented double standards over its foreign policies. It often harshly criticized democratic countries while siding with rogue countries. China has published documents concerning the human rights situation in the U.S., but it has never published anything about human rights conditions in North Korea, the Sudan or Myanmar. On the contrary, the CCP has often sided with Serbia and Iraq totalitarian governments at critical moments. However, when some 200,000 Chinese in Cambodia were massacred by the Khmer Rouge in the 1970s and in 1998 when many Chinese in Indonesia were killed, raped and had their homes set afire by rioters, the CCP just remained silent.

Not only does the CCP adopt double standards, many Chinese people have been trained to embrace a similar ideology when expressing their patriotism.

For instance, some Chinese have frequently showed strong resentment for the "Tibetan Separatists" as though safeguarding the nation's sovereignty and territorial integrity was their supreme mission, regardless of the fact that the Dalai Lama has repeated over and over again that he has no intention of having Tibet declare independence. Contrary to that, the same group of Chinese people have never expressed any rejection to Mao Zedong's handing over Mongolia (1.5 million square kilometers in size) and Jiang Zemin's giving the northern frontier to Russia (1 million square kilometers in size).

Another example is the fury and rage some Chinese have cast towards CNN commentator Jack Cafferty after his so-called "anti-China" remarks. In contrast to this, they have remained silent about the announcement made by the Xinhua News Agency, mouthpiece of the CCP, that starting from February 22 this year, Beijing would begin issuing "temporary residence permits" to ensure the security of the upcoming Olympic Games. Without such permits, any Chinese who are not Beijing permanent residents will be swept out of the city like garbage. It seems that these Chinese people haven't realized that such a permit is actually a more severe form of discrimination against their fellow countrymen whose humble wish is just to watch the Olympics in Beijing.

When Japan invaded China during World War II, it led to twenty million Chinese casualties. Nowadays, many Chinese people still get all worked up and upset when talking about Japan. Nonetheless, ever since the CCP seized power in 1949, repetitive political movements in China have caused the unnatural deaths of at least 80 million Chinese. Even though that death toll is four times as high as that caused by the Japanese, it is totally ignored by the "angry Chinese" who seem to have a form of selective amnesia.

Many Chinese were particularly unhappy with the apparent betrayal of Empress Dowager Cixi of Qing Dynasty who issued the order "Please the invaders using everything we have" to settle the Eight-Nation Allied Army's Invasion in 1900. However, Cixi's wrongdoing is just the tip of the iceberg when compared to what the CCP has done since its takeover. According to a recent article by Chinese economist Zuo Dapei titled "Chinese Banks Have Become the Super Cash Dispensers for Foreign Investors," the selling of 13 Chinese banks and insurance firms to foreign investors at very cheap prices caused losses of more than a trillion yuan (US$142 billion) worth of national assets during 2006 alone. In the face of such betrayal, the "angry Chinese" have pretended to be blind again.

When facts like the ones above are brought to light, we cannot help feel deeply worried about the future of our country. Many people's thinking may not be sufficiently rational to analyze and make an effort to understand all of the facts before making their judgments. Some may seem to suffer from Schizophrenia, venting their sentiments in the name of "patriotism." Others may be just trying to please the CCP in hopes of political gains. If the "angry Chinese" do not really care about China's future or their fellow countrymen's welfare, their "patriotism" has no constructive meaning at all. Instead, it can only hurt the nation.