Showing posts with label King-Father's immunity removal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label King-Father's immunity removal. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Deaf dialog between the Royal Palace and the UN

10-09-2007
By Kong Sothanarith
Cambodge Soir

Translated from French by Luc Sâr

King-Father’s invitation to UN officials for a discussion over the Khmer Rouge era did not receive any reply.

“Finally, nobody from the ECCC UN came,” King-Father noted on a report submitted by Kong Sam Ol, the minister of the Royal Palace, dated Saturday 08 September. A round table and 23 seats, two of which were reserved for King-Father and Queen-Mother, were prepared on this Saturday 08 September. 4 servants at the Royal Palace were standing ready for action, and a TV crew was ready to record the discussion. All of this was done in vain, the UN ECCC delegation did not show up on Saturday, as proposed by King-Father last 30 August. Source at the Royal Palace did not comment on this issue, but Oum Daravuth, a member of King-Father’s cabinet who was quoted by international radio stations, said that “for the UN officials, this is an act which closes all discussion with Norodom Sihanouk.” “I think that the letter sent by the UNAKRT clearly showed the tribunal position, and it clearly indicated that the ECCC officials cannot take part in planned conversation,” Peter Foster, UN ECCC spokesman who was invited by King-Father, commented by email. The content of the letter cited is not yet made available to the public until now.

Former King to Tribunal: Expect No Cooperation

The Royal Palace was devoid of UN's ECCC guests (Photo: Cambodge Soir)

Heng Reaksmey, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
07 September 2007


Former king Norodom Sihanouk has told the Khmer Rouge tribunal he has nothing to say to the judges, following the declination of an invitation to the palace by tribunal officials.

In hand-written notes on a tribunal letter addressed to him, Sihanouk swore on the "Five Supreme Monks" he had nothing to add to the tribunal's investigations of Khmer Rouge leaders.

He scribbled his message underneath an official letter of from Michelle Lee, which declined an earlier invitation for a meeting, and circulated the letter with his notes.

Sihanouk said he had already talked as much about the Khmer Rouge period as he planned, and would not speak further, not even to judges.

International tribunal jurists this week declined an invitation by the king to meet him Saturday, claiming there was no judicial protocol for them to do so.

Sihanouk positioned himself at the head of a coalition that included the Cambodian communists, who would come to be known as the Khmer Rouge, in the early 1970s, following his ouster by a US-supported coup.

Monday, September 10, 2007

[Molière's Drama in Phnom Penh Royal Palace:] Sihanouk refuses to testify at Cambodian trials

10/09/2007
Australian Broadcasting Corporation

Cambodia's former king says he will not testify at the country's Khmer Rouge genocide tribunal after being snubbed by court officials.

Norodom Sihanouk had requested a weekend meeting with officials to explain his conduct during the Khmer Rouge regime, which saw as many as two million people killed.

The 84-year-old former monarch said, on his website Monday, that he had been told that his invitation to a tribunal spokesman had been refused because the spokesman was not authorised to hold such a meeting.

Amid allegations questioning his allegiances at the time, he says he had told the officials that the meeting was the only chance for the court to get his input.

Norodom Sihanouk said last year that he would go before the court, despite his criticism of the tribunal, which he previously branded a "comedy and a hypocrisy."

The former king lost five children and 14 grandchildren during the Khmer Rouge regime, regarded as one of the worst atrocities of the 20th century.

Up to two million people died of starvation and overwork or were executed under the 1975-79 communist regime, which abolished religion, schools and currency, and exiled millions to vast collective farms.

Will Sihanouk Appear at Khmer Rouge Trials?

Then-Prince Norodom Sihanouk (R) during a meeting with Khmer Rouge leaders in Cambodia's "so-called" liberation zone, in April 1973.

By Marwaan Macan-Markar

BANGKOK, Sep 10 (IPS) - Cambodia’s colourful former king Norodom Sihanouk has emerged as the central figure in the latest controversy to plague the special tribunal established to prosecute the surviving members of the genocidal Khmer Rouge regime.

And the 85-year-old royal, who has carved a name for himself as a man who relishes the spotlight, has waded into the dispute in his own inimitable way. He chose to reveal his thoughts on the question that has gripped Phnom Penh: whether Sihanouk should or should not be called to appear before the United Nations-backed war crimes trial.

On Aug. 30 he took his first thrust by issuing an unusual invitation to the U.N. officials associated with the tribunal, including the international spokesman for the tribunal, Peter Foster, to visit the palace for a conversation on ‘’the affairs of the Khmer Rouge and Sihanouk.’’ The means of communicating the invitation was typical Sihanouk: it was posted on the personal web site that he maintains. The rendezvous in the royal court was set for Sep. 8 and expected to last for three hours, from 9 a.m. till 12 noon.

Sihanouk -- who stepped down as the monarch in October 2004 in favour of his son, Norodom Sihamoni -- took the liberty on that web posting to reveal how he views the Extraordinary Chambers in the Court of Cambodia (ECCC), as the tribunal is officially called. ‘’After this (meeting) it will no longer be necessary for me to present myself before the U.N.’s ECCC,’’ Sihanouk stated in his invitation. And if the U.N. officials failed to show up, he noted that he ‘’will not accept to see, speak or correspond with the U.N.’s ECCC.’’

As was expected, the U.N. officials did not participate in this royal conversation on the tribunal. ‘’I was not authorised to participate in this meeting, nor were other U.N. officials,’’ Foster said during an interview from Phnom Penh. ‘’We responded by saying that only the judges involved in the trial will be able to determine who will be a witness. The judges will do so based on procedural rules.’’

But like a character from a Shakespearian drama, Sihanouk continued to protest too much. In standing up for his cause, the former monarch ‘’complained that the ECCC wanted him to ‘take an oath to tell the truth, nothing but the truth on the subject of arch criminals’,’’ reported the ‘Phnom Penh Post’ English-language newspaper last Friday. ‘’I do not have to swear an oath after (the one I swore) with Buddha, to debase myself to take an oath in front of the ECCC.’’

Those familiar with Sihanouk’s penchant for grand gestures and a life peppered with drama are hardly surprised by this latest offering. Following his being crowned the monarch of his South-east Asian nation in 1941, at the tender age of 18 years, he has abdicated twice, served as king twice, held the post of prime minister twice and served as president once. His record in the world of the arts and entertainment has been as varied, dabbling as a film-maker, song writer, painter, saxophonist and a crooner of ballads.

What is equally well-known is the link Sihanouk maintained with the Khmer Rouge, responsible for an orgy of death during 1975 to 1979 when it took control of Cambodia after a prolonged battle with a pro-American puppet regime in Phnom Penh. The extreme Maoist group killed close to 1.7 million Cambodians, nearly a quarter of the country’s population at the time. The victims were executed, died from forced labour or starvation as the Khmer Rouge tried to turn the country into an agrarian utopia.

Sihanouk himself lost family members to the Khmer Rouge and was kept under house arrest by the genocidal regime between 1976 till 1979. Yet against those details are the roles he played in the four years up to the Khmer Rouge triumph in 1975 -- urging the Cambodian people to join the Khmer Rouge, in addition to serving as the head of state for the Khmer Rouge in the first year it held power. And when the Khmer Rouge was driven out of power by the invading Vietnamese troops, Sihanouk fled to the forests with the extreme Maoists and took on a new role as the global defender of the Khmer Rouge regime in exile.

It is this phase of Sihanouk’s life that has been brought into focus and raised the possibility of him going before the ECCC. The latter officially began work in July this year after long delays and hurdles placed in its way, including regular challenges posed by the Cambodian government of Prime Minister Hun Sen.

The push to get Sihanouk appear before the ECCC was triggered by a relatively unknown non-governmental organisation (NGO) based in the United States, the Cambodian Action Committee for Justice and Equity (CACJE). In late August, it made a request to authorities in Phnom Penh to strip Sihanouk of his immunity as a former monarch in order to be called before the tribunal.

The Hun Sen administration rose to Sihanouk’s defence by delivering a harsh rebuke. The premier called the request to strip Sihanouk ‘’very barbaric’’ and one that ‘’could have the result of jeopardising the peace and unity’’ of the country.

But human rights groups questioned the motives of the government, arguing that war-ravaged Cambodia’s quest to create a society governed by the rules of law and justice will be undermined if the former monarch is placed above the law and insulated from the ECCC. ‘’This could set a bad precedence, since the ECCC is expected to set new and high standards of justice for Cambodia,’’ says Lao Mong Hay, senior researcher on Cambodia at the Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC), a regional rights lobby.

‘’The request does not mean he has to face trial as a defendant or as an accused, but it is to remove an unconstitutional clause in the constitution and make the former king available if the judges need him to appear,’’ Lao explained during an interview from Hong Kong, where AHRC is based. ‘’This is very important for the trial, since many Cambodians who lost family want to know about the past; how and why the Khmer Rouge pursued their murderous policies.’’

‘’It is a chance for the former king to clear his name if he did nothing wrong,’’ adds Lao. ‘’And he has been on the record in the past saying that he would be willing to face the trial like the former Khmer Rouge leaders.’’

Saturday, September 08, 2007

King-Father would not speak further about the Khmer Rouge period, not even to judges

Former King to Tribunal: Expect No Cooperation

Heng Reaksmey, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
07 September 2007


Former king Norodom Sihanouk has told the Khmer Rouge tribunal he has nothing to say to the judges, following the declination of an invitation to the palace by tribunal officials.

In hand-written notes on a tribunal letter addressed to him, Sihanouk swore on the "Five Supreme Monks" he had nothing to add to the tribunal's investigations of Khmer Rouge leaders.

He scribbled his message underneath an official letter of from Michelle Lee, which declined an earlier invitation for a meeting, and circulated the letter with his notes.

Sihanouk said he had already talked as much about the Khmer Rouge period as he planned, and would not speak further, not even to judges.

International tribunal jurists this week declined an invitation by the king to meet him Saturday, claiming there was no judicial protocol for them to do so.

Sihanouk positioned himself at the head of a coalition that included the Cambodian communists, who would come to be known as the Khmer Rouge, in the early 1970s, following his ouster by a US-supported coup.

Friday, September 07, 2007

Peter Foster Affair: Michelle Lee contacts the royal palace directly [-It looks like King-Father's public forum will never be heard by Cambodians]

07-09-2007
By Pen Bona
Cambodge Soir

Translated from French by Luc Sâr

By mail, the Deputy Director of ECCC/Coordinator UNAKRT was trying to moderate the reach of Peter Foster’s statement.

“From now on, it is necessary to clear up all eventual misunderstanding caused by Mr. Foster’s statement which was reported by The Cambodia Daily newspaper on 29 August,” Michelle Lee said. In a letter dated 06 September, sent to Kong Sam Ol, the minister of the royal palace, Michelle Lee indicated that Peter Foster, the UN spokesman of the Khmer Rouge Tribunal, did not have any intention of attacking the honor of His Majesty the King-Father. “Nevertheless, I regret to bring to your knowledge the fact that Mr. Foster, as the UNAKRT (UN Assistance for the Khmer Rouge Tribunal) spokesman, is not authorized to exercise legal duties, and that, consequently, he is not authorized to follow up on the invitation made by His Majesty the King-Father,” Michelle Lee said, while adding that, in fact, only the ECCC judges have the competency to determine who should be heard as witness, and by doing so, they are obliged to respect the applicable procedural rules.

Through a communiqué posted on 30 August 2007, Norodom Sihanouk invited Peter Foster and other UN representatives to come and talk publicly with him on the Khmer Rouge affair on 08 September, at the royal palace. This invitation came at the heel of Peter Foster’s statement quoted by The Cambodia Daily, in which he announced the possibility of a summon of King-Father to appear at the Khmer Rouge Tribunal as a witness. King-Father immediately announced his position through his handwritten comments on the margin of Michelle Lee’s letter which was made public. “I have nothing to add to it. Consequently, I will have nothing more to say to these judges,” Sihanouk concluded.

King Father Sihanouk holds ECCC at bay

Samdech Head of State Norodom Sihanouk visits Cambodian Liberated Zone: on Stung Treng-Phnom Penh Highway, Samdech Norodom Sihanouk, Princess Monique Sihanouk, Deputy-Prime Minister Khieu Sam Phan, and Mr. Hu Nim stop at a milestone. The inscription in the Cambodian Language says Phnom Penh 525 km. (Photo: Virtual Vietnam Archive)

By Cat Barton
Phnom Penh Post, Issue 16 / 18, September 7 - 20, 2007
"He is the Father of the Nation" - Son Soubert

"If he were to face cross examination as a witness the King Father could be made to reveal something people would rather remain hidden. It could be like opening Pandora's box." - Lao Mong Hay
King Father Norodom Sihanouk has held so many positions since 1941 that the Guinness Book of World Records identifies him as the politician who has occupied the world's greatest variety of political offices.

Now, his latest position as King Father has raised a new controversy regarding whether he can be required to testify about his knowledge of the Khmer Rouge era at the long-delayed trial.

Although some contend that Sihanouk's continuing head of state immunity is "illegitimate, unconstitutional and indefensible," leading members of the CPP and FUNCINPEC both said the former King is protected by the principle of lèse majesté and cannot be called to testify.

"He is the Father of the Nation," said Son Soubert, King Norodom Sihamoni's appointee at the Constitutional Council. "Even though he is retired, he retains the status of Head of State and so the King Father is not obliged to testify at the court unless he decides to from his own will."

Sihanouk, 85, retired by officially abdicating as King on October 7, 2004. His son Norodom Sihamoni was later named King to succeed him.

Upon his abdication, the Cambodian parliament conferred upon Sihanouk the title of "Great and Valorous King" enabling him to retain the same privileges and immunities as those constitutionally conferred upon the reigning monarch. This was subsequently enshrined in the Law on the Titles and Privileges of the Former King and Queen of Cambodia on October 29, 2004.

This week the Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) issued a statement saying that parliament cannot confer such immunity. "Our constitution bestows on the King, the reigning King, immunity," said Lao Mong Hay, senior researcher at AHRC. "No one else has this immunity. Even with a constitutional amendment there would be no moral authority to the immunity obtained, and to go down this path would set a very dangerous precedent."

Sihanouk has not yet been called upon by prosecutors at the ECCC to testify.

But he stirred up the matter himself August 30 by sending an unusual invitation to Peter Foster, the United Nations Assistance to the Khmer Rouge Trial (UNAKRT) spokesman. The invitation asked Foster and anyone else interested at the UN to come to the Royal Palace for a "conversation" on "the affairs of the Khmer Rouge and Sihanouk." The invitation is for Saturday September 8, from 9 to noon.

"After this it will no longer be necessary for me to present myself before the UN's ECCC," the invitation said. The note added that if the UN did not accept the invitation to meet Saturday, the King Father "will not accept to see, speak or correspond with the UN's ECCC."

Foster said this week the UN responded to the King Father's invitation on Thursday, but the contents of the response weren't made public.

"I have not been authorized to take part in such a discussion," Foster told the Post on September 5. "It is not up to me personally - this is not an issue between me and the King Father, it is a judicial issue."

In a September 5 statement, the King Father complained that the ECCC wanted him to "take an oath to tell the truth, nothing but the truth on the subject of arch criminals."

"My 'oath'...I have taken already, today, in front of five superior Buddhist Monks and especially in front of statues and statuettes of Buddha. I do not have to swear an oath after [the one I swore] with Buddha, to debase myself to take an oath in front of the ECCC."

"Concerning the Khmer Rouge atrocities when Pol Pot, Ieng Sary, and Khieu Samphan were in power....I know that these Khmer Rouge took away five of my children, 14 of my grand-children, the Prince N. Phurissara and [his] family, Prince S. Methavi and [his] family."

The King Father concluded by saying "I have already said everything. That means all that I know. I have nothing else to say to the UN's ECCC and so that they stop bothering me with this 'Khmer Rouge Tribunal Affair' I don't owe anything to the UN's ECCC."

But King Father Norodom Sihanouk has plenty to tell.

According to the Historical Dictionary of Cambodia, when his regime was overthrown by Lon Nol in 1970, Sihanouk was out of the country on his way to Beijing. The Chinese government offered him support to fight his way back to power.

From Beijing, he urged Cambodians to take up arms against Lon Nol and became president of the nominal Royal Government of National Unity of Kampuchea (GRUNK). Sihanouk spent most of 1970 to 1975 in Beijing.

When the Khmer Rouge captured Phnom Penh in April 1975, Lon Nol had already fled, but Sihanouk did not return to Cambodia immediately. He returned in September, according to the same source, as leader of GRUNK. But the KR dissolved GRUNK in 1976 and Sihanouk was largely under house arrest throughout this period.

In 1979 the king avoided capture by Vietnamese-backed invading forces by fleeing Phnom Penh with the withdrawing Khmer Rouge. He resurfaced in Beijing. He urged the United Nations not to recognize the new government of Heng Samrin. He later moved to Pyongyang as the guest of Kim Il Sung. Sihanouk returned to Cambodia in November 1991 and he became King in September 1993.

The King Father's invitation to Foster was triggered by an August 29 news report in which Foster said that it was up to the court's judicial officers to decide who to call as witnesses and who to indict. He was responding to the call by a little known U.S. based human rights NGO called the Cambodian Action Committee for Justice and Equality (CACJE) which issued a statement August 20 calling for the King's immunity to be overturned.

CACJE is run by Sourn Serey Ratha, former Editor-in-Chief of Beehive Radio. On its website, www.ssrth.wordpress.com, is a letter it sent to "Mr Norodom Sihanouk," questioning Sihanouk's role in the emergence of the Khmer Rouge. It claims he betrayed his people, provided "cheap" leadership and changed allegiances in an attempt to maintain a lavish Royal lifestyle.

"You never speak the truth," the letter reads. "Your actions should be judged by the Khmer people....In the next life you should be reborn in a country you have pleased more than Cambodia - Vietnam maybe."

Sihanouk had said previously that he would be willing to testify at a court so his new position represents a change of heart, said Mong Hay.

Soubert said Sihanouk's invite reflects a long-standing distrust of the ECCC.

"He believes that [the ECCC] will not really bring justice to Cambodia," he said. "He has always said he would rather have a court in The Hague."

Prince Sisowath Thomico, a member of FUNCINPEC, also said the King Father doesn't have much faith in the ECCC.

"He is protected by constitutional immunity so it would be unlawful for him to testify," Thomico said. "It is a problem of procedure - can the UN sponsored court even receive his testimony?"

Thomico said that the process of documenting what Sihanouk experienced and knew during the Khmer Rouge regime, even if it is done in an informal meeting, would further the broader aim of creating a historical record and furthering national unity.

But a conversation about what happened is not the same as being questioned under oath in a court room, said Mong Hay.

"This invitation is a political gesture on part of the king," he said. "It is not part of court procedure. If not done in court, the interviews or evidence provided at the time should not be taken to account, they will have no legal validity."

Mong Hay said the King Father doesn't want to testify because he might face difficult cross examination by foreign lawyers. "If he were to face cross examination as a witness the King Father could be made to reveal something people would rather remain hidden. It could be like opening Pandora's box." The fact the government has sprung to the defence of the King Father's right to immunity is a further indication he may have something to hide, said Mong Hay.

The President of the National Assembly, Heng Samrin, defended the King Father's right to immunity. Cheam Yeap, CPP parliamentarian, said it would be illegal to make him testify and that the King Father's offer to invite interested parties to meet with him is sufficient.

UN ECCC officials send a letter back to the Hero-King

09-April-1973 - Samdech Head of State Norodom Sihanouk visits Cambodian Liberated Zone: Cambodian liberation combatants joyfully welcome Samdech Head of State Norodom Sihanouk. (Photo and Caption by Virtual Vietnam Archive)

Tribunal Officials Send Letter to Former King

Mean Veasna, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
06 September 2007


Tribunal officials have sent a letter to former king Norodom Sihanouk, the first correspondence through official channels following the monarch's invitation for talks.

It was unclear if the letter was an official decline to an open invitation to the Palace Sept. 8, but UN tribunal spokesman Peter Foster told the Cambodia Daily Thursday he had no authority to take part in discussions outside the purview of the court.

Controversy has surrounded the former king lately as to whether he is immune to tribunal proceedings seeking to prosecute former leaders of the regime.

Sihanouk sat at the head of a coalition that included the Cambodian communists prior to their takeover of the country in 1975. He has not been summoned to the courts—as defense or witness.

A palace official said Thursday the tribunal members should be honored by the invitation of the former king, a national "hero."

Thursday, September 06, 2007

King-Father: Stop pestering me with this “KR-Sihanouk Affair”!

Translated from French by Luc Sâr

Cambodian Studies
“Witness, indict, oath”
By N. Sihanouk

According to the recent editions of an English-language newspaper in Phnom Penh, the ECCC UN wanted to summon me as “witness,” if not to “indict” me. And even more recently, the ECCC UN wanted that N. Sihanouk takes an oath in front of the ECCC UN!!!

We are, today, Wednesday 05 September 2007, a Buddhist holy day where I must observe the Obosothsel.

In the morning and in the afternoon of this Obosothsel Day (the 8 precepts of Buddha), I pray in loud voice, in front of 5 revered superior monks (Mékon (provincial head monk), deputy-Mékons, Chau Athicars (Abbots), either the Head monk of the Ratanakiri province, deputy-Head monks in this same province and pagoda Chiefs in the same province), I take the oath not to kill, lie, or cheat (among others).

The ECCC UN wants me to take an oath to tell the entire truth, and only the truth (in regards of the super-criminals [Khmer Rouge]).

My oath, I already took it today, in front of 5 superior Buddhist monks, and most of all, in front of the statues and small statues of Buddha. After Buddha, I thus don’t have to lower myself to take an oath in front of the ECCC UN.

Regarding the Khmer Rouge atrocities, when the Pol Pot, Ieng Sary, Khieu Samphan controlled the State (Democratic Kampuchea) Power, I knew that these Khmer Rouges were involved in the disappearance of 5 of my children, 14 of my grandchildren, Prince N. Phurissara and his family, Prince S. Methavi and his family.

I did not see the Khmer Rouge committing their atrocities, (inflicting) bad treatments, or even (issuing) threats against one or several people, or a group of people.

I already said it all, i.e. all that I know.

I don’t have another thing to tell the ECCC UN. Stop pestering me with this “KR-Sihanouk Affair”!

I don’t owe anything to the ECCC UN.

(Signed) Norodom Sihanouk

Norodom Sihanouk “did not see the Khmer Rouge atrocities”

06-09-2007
By Kong Sothanarith
Cambodge Soir

Translated from French by Luc Sâr

Norodom Sihanouk talks again about his possible appearance at the Khmer Rouge Tribunal

King-Father Norodom Sihnaouk “will not lower himself to take oath” in front of the tribunal in charge of judging the former Khmer Rouge leaders. In his “Cambodian Studies” publication dated Wednesday 05 September, Sihanouk indicated that he did not see, with his own eyes, the Khmer Rouge crimes, and he recalls that his family was severely affected when 5 of his children and 14 of his grandchildren disappeared. King-Father’s writing came out while the UN failed to reply to his invitation. “I did not see the Khmer Rouges committing their atrocities, or (inflicting) bad treatments, or even (issuing) threats against one or several people, or a group of people. I already tell all. I have nothing else to say to the ECCC UN. […] I owe nothing to the ECCC UN,” King-Father insisted again. On 30 August, King-Father invited Peter Foster, KR Tribunal spokesman, as well as other “UN foreigner volunteers,” to come to the Royal Palace to discuss, in front of cameras, about the Khmer Rouge issue. Peter Foster did not reply to his invitation, because of the process (taken by King-Father) was not official, Peter Foster said.

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

HRP supports King-Father in the immunity affair

HRP Pen Sovann (L) and Former monarch Norodom Sihanouk (R)

Wednesday, September 05, 2007
Everyday.com.kh
Translated from Khmer by Heng Soy

Kem Sokha’s Human Rights Party (HRP) is the latest party to provide its reaction to oppose a US-based organization (CACJE) that wants the National Assembly to revoke King-Father’s immunity so he can be brought to trial by the KR Tribunal. In a statement issued in the afternoon of 04 September, and signed by Pen Sovann, HRP party standing president, HRP considers CACJE’s action as a severe violation of the national constitution and a scorn on the honor of King-Father also. Pen Sovann told the Kampuchea Thmei newspaper that it is very unfair for a foreign-based organization to raise an issue that Cambodians are not pleased with. Pen Sovann said that he supports King-Father who wants to clarify to the KR Tribunal in order to provide justice to the Cambodian people, and to avoid such false accusations. When questioned as to why HRP is so late to react on this issue, Pen Sovann said that the party had to wait for a meeting to evaluate and consider all the possibilities because HRP party members were too busy at the local levels and did not have time to meet each others.

No immunity for Sihanouk

HONG KONG, Sep. 5
LAO MONG HAY
Posted at UPI Asia Online
Column: Rule by Fear


Over the last two weeks, the Cambodian government has mounted vitriolic attacks against a request for former King Sihanouk, now 84, to be stripped of his immunity and face trial in the mixed Cambodian-U.N. tribunal set up to try senior Khmer Rouge leaders.

The government branded the request by the Cambodian Action Committee for Justice and Equity, a U.S.-based non-governmental organization, a "public agitation" that "could have the result of jeopardizing the peace and unity" of Cambodia "and play into the hands of those who would seek to return [the country] to its former state of war and chaos." Prime Minister Hun Sen called the request "very barbaric" and said that the top state institutions could not stand by and watch it set a fire blazing in the heart of the Cambodian people.

Other leading state institutions joined the government in "absolutely rejecting" and "condemning" the request. They glorified Sihanouk's services to the nation, which included giving Cambodia its independence, territorial integrity, unity and national reconciliation. They also claimed he had suffered when he had been overthrown by a coup in 1970 and when he had been under the rule of the Khmer Rouge between 1975 and 1979. Sihanouk "had suffered more than most rulers," Hun Sen claimed.

In line with Cambodian law and assistance agreements between the Cambodian government and the United Nations, Peter Foster, the tribunal's U.N. spokesman, in his comment on the same request, was reported as saying that it was up to the tribunal to decide whom to call as a witness and whom to indict. He added that Sihanouk could be called as a witness.

Following this statement, the government issued a warning on Aug. 31 that "Cambodia will kick out the Khmer Rouge Tribunal if it brings Great, Valorous King Sihanouk to trial." Moreover, it asserted that there should not be a summons to Sihanouk to appear in court as a witness. If the judges or prosecutors of that tribunal "issue such a summons, we shall kick out that tribunal," it added, claiming that any such summons would "humiliate" what it called the "symbol" of Cambodia.

Sihanouk became king of Cambodia in 1941 and abdicated in 1955. In 1960, he became head of state with executive power but was not crowned king at that time. In 1970, he was overthrown in a coup, which engulfed Cambodia during the Vietnam War and led to the Chinese-backed Khmer Rouge's armed struggle alongside and with support from the Vietnamese communist forces.

Sihanouk, while in China in the immediate aftermath of being overthrown, became the head of the Khmer Rouge-dominated government in exile. From China, Sihanouk used his popularity to mobilize the Cambodian people to "go into the maquis (jungle)" to join the Khmer Rouge. The latter's army then grew from strength to strength and won power in 1975, and Sihanouk remained head of state of the Khmer Rouge regime until 1976.

In 1982, Sihanouk again became head of state of the Cambodian resistance movement against the Vietnamese-installed government in Cambodia. At the end of the latter war, in 1993, he was re-crowned king. Although he abdicated again in 2004, the Cambodian Parliament named him "Great Valorous King" in recognition of his lifelong dedicated service to the country and achievements and conferred upon him the same privileges and immunities as those constitutionally conferred upon the reigning monarch, which includes immunity from prosecution.

This act of Parliament conferring immunity was unconstitutional, however, as the Constitution of Cambodia confers this immunity only upon the reigning monarch and not upon anyone else. Nor has that act any moral legitimacy, for under its Constitution, Cambodia is supposed to be governed by the rule of law under which all are equal before the law and no one is above the law.

Furthermore, many Cambodian people still believe that Sihanouk was instrumental in the Khmer Rouge's victory and was therefore also responsible for the suffering of the Cambodian people under the Khmer Rouge's rule. They also want justice and to know the truth about their horrible past history in which Sihanouk must have had a hand due to his association with the Khmer Rouge.

Sihanouk's immunity from prosecution is illegitimate, unconstitutional and indefensible. Any use of it by Sihanouk himself or with government support to evade any court action only strengthens the belief in his share of responsibility for the suffering of the Cambodian people under the Khmer Rouge's rule. It is an obstruction of justice and jeopardizes the rights of Cambodia's people, who have endured enough grief. It will prevent the Cambodian nation from addressing their past through the tribunal.

The Khmer Rouge Tribunal thus should not be intimidated by the Cambodian government's latest threat and should maintain its independence. It should challenge Sihanouk's immunity and summons him to appear whenever truth, justice and/or the rights of the people so require.
--
(Lao Mong Hay is currently a senior researcher at the Asian Human Rights Commission in Hong Kong. He was previously director of the Khmer Institute of Democracy in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, and a visiting professor at the University of Toronto in 2003. In 1997, he received an award from Human Rights Watch and the Nansen Medal in 2000 from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.)

Political Cartoon: Our King

Cartoon by Sacrava (on the web at http://sacrava.blogspot.com)

Sihanouk Not Immune to Tribunal, Rights Group Says [- PPenh regime overlooked the Cambodian Constitution in King-Father's immunity case?]

Sok Khemara, VOA Khmer
Original report from Washington
04 September 2007


Because he is not the ruling monarch, former king Norodom Sihanouk has no constitutional protection against the tribunal courts, a leading rights group said Monday.

Parliament has granted Sihanouk special status as "Great Valorous King," which was meant to grant him "the same privileges and immunities as those constitutionally conferred upon the reigning monarch," the group said in a statement.

But "the Asian Human Rights Commission strongly urges the Cambodian government, the National Assembly, the Senate and the Cambodian People's Party not to attempt to defend former king Sihanouk's immunity from prosecution, as it is both unconstitutional and indefensible," the group said. "They should lend support to the Khmer Rouge tribunal."

If truth or justice requires it, the group said, "Sihanouk should be summoned" as a defendant or witness.

If the people want full immunity for the former king, "there should be an amendment, stipulated clearly in the constitution, to avoid criticism like this one," opposition lawmaker Son Chhay said.

"I'm just asking, do they want to let the court process or not," government spokesman Khieu Kanharith said, without elaborating. "Why do you jam a stick in the wheel of the cart?"

KRT officials won't meet King-Father; Experts: Gov't honorary status does not protect King-Father constitutionally

UN Tribunal Officials Will Not Meet Former King

Heng Reaksmey, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
04 September 2007


UN officials from the Khmer Rouge tribunal said Tuesday they will not to meet former king Norodom Sihanouk at the Royal Palace next week, citing his open invitation as unofficial.

In a cautious response to VOA Khmer's e-mailed questions, tribunal international spokesman Peter Foster said he would not respond to the Sihanouk's invitation, which was posted on the former monarch's Web site last week.

Sihanouk post-scripted the invitation with a warning that this would be the only chance ahead of Khmer Rouge trials to meet with him.

Parliament has bestowed honorary king status to Sihanouk, which government officials say grants him immunity against the tribunal.

Legal experts, however, say the honorary status does not protect the king constitutionally.

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Khieu Kanharith on AHRC: "This HR group is dumb, they don’t want to look at the entire article ...they don’t even know how to read the law yet..."

Reactions to AHRC statement on King-Father's immunity

03 September 2007
By Huy Vannak
Radio Free Asia

Translated from Khmer by Socheata

A Hong-Kong-based human rights organization (Asian Human Rights Commission) issued a statement of Monday, calling the Cambodian government, the National Assembly, the Senate, and all political parties not to attempt to defend former King Sihanouk's immunity from prosecution by the Khmer Rouge Tribunal.

In its statement, AHRC said that the Cambodian Constitution protects the reigning king only. AHRC added that the Law on the Titles and Privileges of the Former King and Queen of Cambodia that was promulgated on October 29, 2004 does not protect former King Sihanouk's immunity from prosecution.

Regarding AHRC’s statement, as well as other demands requesting the removal of King-Father’s immunity, SRP MP Son Chhay proposed an amendment to the constitution in order to clarify the protection of the privileges of the former king.

Son Chhay said: “There is an interdiction regarding the former monarch, this law was ratified outside of the constitution, therefore, in my opinion, in order to guarantee and protect so that such requests could no longer be made, the National Assembly should amend the (constitution) article about the privileges of the king, and extend these privileges to the former monarch as well, in order to resolve this issue.”

In reaction to AHRC statement, Khieu Kanharith, the spokesman for the government, said: “This human rights group is dumb, they don’t want to look at the entire article, if they don’t even know how to read the law yet, why do they talk? The Cambodian constitution protects the reigning king, but the conferring (to King Sihanouk of) the title of ‘Great Valorous King’ is the decision of the Parliament, it’s the most important. If they are so lazy, they shouldn’t talk too much so they wouldn’t be ashamed, unlike the true human rights organizations (would have done).”

Funcinpec MP Monh Saphan said that he is defending the Hero-King also.

On 20 August, the Cambodian Action Committee for Justice and Equity (CACJE) sent a letter to Heng Samrin, National Assembly president, asking him to hold a plenary session of the National Assembly to remove the immunity of the former monarch, King Norodom Sihanouk.

On 30 August, the Hero-King issued a letter through his website in which he invited the foreign officials of the KR Tribunal to come and meet him so that he can reveal to these officials, the events which took place under the KR regime.

Nevertheless, Peter Foster, a KRT official, indicated today that the ECCC could not comment on this issue because it has not yet received the official letter from the former monarch.

Norodom Sihanouk: “it must be the USA, the Lonnolians, and other pro-Lon Nol countries which should be tried by the KRT and not me”

Norodom Sihanouk indignant again

03-09-2007
By CS
Cambodge Soir
Translated from French by Luc Sâr

King-Father let it be known, once again, about his exasperation facing the unfolding of this (KR) lawsuit.

In his letter dated 03 September, King-Father is revisiting again his court appearance as a witness facing the Khmer Rouge Tribunal (KRT). He wrote: “it must be the USA, the Lonnolians, and other pro-Lon Nol countries which should be tried by the KRT and not me.” He added: “it was the USA which, unintentionally, allowed the Khmer Rouge to develop themselves and to become powerful up to the point of taking over the State power.” He ended: “and it was by making me responsible of their historical defeat in April 1975, in Cambodia, that some foreigners – who came to Phnom Penh in 2007 to bring to trial and to condemn a handful of super-criminal Khmer Rouge still alive – are taking the liberty to unfairly annoy me in the name of their UN ECCC!”. “Long life KAFKA!” he hailed in his conclusion.

Monday, September 03, 2007

AHRC: Immunity from prosecution for former King Sihanouk is illegitimate, unconstitutional and indefensible

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
AS-211-2007
September 03, 2007


A Statement by the Asian Human Rights Commission

CAMBODIA: Immunity from prosecution for former King Sihanouk is illegitimate, unconstitutional and indefensible

On August 24, 2007, the Cambodian Government, the National Assembly, the Senate, the ruling Cambodian People's Party and its coalition partner FUNCINPEC, in unison decried a request for former King Sihanouk to be stripped of his immunity and face trial in the Khmer Rouge Tribunal. The request had been made to the National Assembly by a little-known US-based Cambodian association called the Cambodian Action Committee for Justice and Equity. In their respective statements, they glorified Sihanouk's service to the Cambodian nation, which gave it its independence, territorial integrity, unity and national reconciliation. They also claimed Sihanouk had suffered when he had been overthrown by a coup in 1970 and when he had been under the Khmer Rouge's rule between 1975 and 1979. Sihanouk "had suffered more than most rulers," Prime Minister Hun said.

The government branded the request as being a "public agitation" that "could have the result of jeopardizing the peace and unity" of Cambodia "and play into the hands of those who would seek to return (the country) to its former state of war and chaos." Hun Sen called the request "very barbaric" and said that the top State institutions could not stand by and watch it set a fire blazing in the heart of the Cambodian people. Also in unison, all the State institutions "absolutely rejected" and "condemned" the request.

Sihanouk was crowned King in 1941 and abdicated in 1955 in favour of his father, King Suramarit, two years after having achieved independence for his country from France. In 1960 he became Head of State, with executive power, although he was not crowned king at that time. In 1970 he was overthrown in a coup staged by his Commander-in-Chief, General Lon Nol. His overthrow engulfed Cambodia in the Vietnam War and led to the Chinese-backed Khmer Rouge's open armed struggle alongside the Vietnamese communist forces. Sihanouk, while in China in the immediate aftermath of being overthrown, became the head of the Khmer Rouge-dominated government in exile. From China, Sihanouk was using his popularity to mobilise the Cambodian people to "go into the maquis (jungle)" to join the Khmer Rouge, who were emerging to fight against the Lon Nol regime with the help of the Vietnamese communist forces. He remained Head of State of the Khmer Rouge regime until 1976, one year after the Khmer Rouge's victory. In 1982 he again became Head of State of the Cambodian resistance movement against the Vietnamese-installed government in Cambodia. At the end of this war, in 1993, he was re-crowned king. Many Cambodian people still believe that Sihanouk was instrumental in the Khmer Rouge's victory, and was therefore also responsible for the suffering of the Cambodian people under the Khmer Rouge's rule.

In early October 2004, King Sihanouk abdicated, this time in favour of his son, King Sihamoni. Upon his abdication, in recognition of his life-long dedicated service to the country and achievements, the Cambodian Parliament conferred upon Sihanouk the title of "Great Valorous King" that granted him the same privileges and immunities as those constitutionally conferred upon the reigning monarch, as provided for in Article 7 of the constitution of the country. This was then enshrined in the Law on the Titles and Privileges of the Former King and Queen of Cambodia that was promulgated on October 29, 2004, by King Sihamoni. In their opposition to the request to strip Sihanouk of his immunity from prosecution, the top State institutions cited Article 7 which states, among other things, that "the person of the king is inviolable." They all held that the request would violate both the 2004 law and this article of the constitution.

The Asian Human Rights Commission holds that the Constitution of Cambodia, in its letter and spirit, confers inviolability including the immunity from prosecution upon the person of the reigning monarch, and not upon anybody else. No act of parliament can confer the same inviolability upon former King Sihanouk. Only a constitutional amendment could do that, although the immunity so conferred would still have no moral legitimacy.

The October 29, 2004 law that is being cited lacks legitimacy and is unconstitutional, and cannot therefore be used to enable former King Sihanouk's immunity from prosecution. There should be no obstacles preventing the Khmer Rouge Tribunal from summoning him to appear, if truth, justice and/or the rights of any concerned person should so require. Should Sihanouk himself or any or all of above-mentioned top State institutions obstruct its order based on this alleged immunity, the tribunal should challenge the constitutionality of this immunity at the Constitutional Council of Cambodia. After all, trials in Cambodia are no longer conducted in the name of the King, but "in the name of the Cambodian people" as stipulated in Article 129 of the Constitution. With the democratization of justice, even the reigning monarch's immunity is itself an anachronism, and that of former kings is simply indefensible.

The Asian Human Rights Commission strongly urges the Cambodian Government, the National Assembly, the Senate and the Cambodian People's Party not to attempt to defend former King Sihanouk's immunity from prosecution, as it is both unconstitutional and indefensible. They should lend support to the Khmer Rouge Tribunal, and should truth, justice and/or the rights of any concerned person require it, Sihanouk should be summoned to appear before it as a defendant or as a witness. As Cambodia is supposed to be a democratic country that is governed by the rule of law according to its constitution, equality before the law should be steadfastly upheld, and no one, including former King Sihanouk, should be above the law.

# # #

About AHRC: The Asian Human Rights Commission is a regional non-governmental organisation monitoring and lobbying human rights issues in Asia. The Hong Kong-based group was founded in 1984.

Khieu Kanharith: Hun Sen regime can terminate ECCC; So much for Hun Sen's claim of non-governmental interference in the KR Trial!

September 03, 2007
Cambodian government can terminate ECCC: official

Cambodian Information Minister and government spokesman Khieu Kanharith has said that the government could "terminate" the Extraordinary Chambers in the Court of Cambodia (ECCC) if its international judges charge retired King Norodom Sihanouk for any Democratic Kampuchea (DK) era entanglements, the Cambodia Daily newspaper reported Monday.

The ECCC operates under Cambodian law, which guarantees Norodom Sihanouk immunity, Khieu Kanharith said Sunday, adding that any attempt to violate that immunity would be "illegal" and thus justify disbandment.

"The government is able to terminate the ECCC," he was quoted as saying.

The tribunal has made no public move to investigate Norodom Sihanouk or to call him as a witness, the newspaper said.

Questions about Norodom Sihanouk's possible role in the ECCC were brought up on Aug. 20 by a statement from the little-known NGO Cambodian Action Committee for Justice and Equality, which called for stripping the retired King's immunity so he could be charged by the ECCC, it said.

The Cambodian government and Prime Minister Hun Sen last week came to Norodom Sihanouk's defense, citing his constitutional immunity.

Sihanouk, 85, stepped down as king in 2004 and his son Norodom Sihamoni succeeded him.

Source: Xinhua

Saturday, September 01, 2007

Hun Sen Gov't to ECCC: Touch our Hero-King Sihanouk and we will kick you out of Cambodia


Should justice for the KR victims carry less weight than King-Father's honor?
Please share your thoughts by leaving a comment - Thank you!

Government warns the ECCC about bringing King-Father to trial

31 August 2007
By Phan Sophan Radio Free Asia
Translated from Khmer by Socheata

A Cambodian government official today warned that Cambodia will kick out the KR Tribunal (KRT) if it brings the Hero-King Norodom Sihanouk to trial.

Khieu Kanharith, spokesman for the government, issued this statement after a KRT official said that the KRT co-judges or co-prosecutors could invite the former monarch to act as witness.

Khieu Kanharith indicated: “There is no such order! And there must not be any humiliation (inflicted) on the symbol of Cambodia either. If they dare set such order, we agree to kick this tribunal out.”

Regarding this issue, on Thursday 30 August, the Hero-King published a letter posted on his website, inviting foreign KRT officials for a meeting so he can reveal to them all the events which took place under the KR regime.

The invitation of the former monarch was made after a newspaper (The Cambodia Daily) quoted Peter Foster, the spokesman of the KRT, as saying that the co-judges and co-prosecutors of the KRT could invite the former monarch to act as a witness, but that whether, the Hero-King will come or not is another issue altogether.

Peter Foster made this comment after some overseas Cambodians asked the National Assembly to remove the immunity of the former monarch so that he can provide clarification on the accusations made that he used to be a leader of the Democratic Kampuchea regime which is accused of killing almost 2 million Cambodians.

Peter Foster. The KRT public affair officer, told RFA on Friday afternoon: “I know that he (Sihanouk) published his letter on his website. However, the ECCC did not officially receive a copy from him yet up to now.”

In his letter issued Thursday, the Hero-King indicated that he will invite Peter Foster and UN officials for a 3-hour meeting on 08 September, at the Royal Palace, and the event will be filmed to show the clarifications that the Hero-King agree to make. He indicated also that after this meeting, he has no need to go to the tribunal to provide further clarifications.

At the end of his letter, the Hero-King said if the UN officials accept the invitation, but they do not agree on the meeting date set on 08 September, he will not accept to see, nor talk to, nor correspond with the ECCC’s UN anymore.