Showing posts with label Mekong hydropower projects. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mekong hydropower projects. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Mekong River to be thirsty for fresh water

Farmers in the Mekong River Delta are facing the encroachment of salt water. Photo: Farmers in Tien Giang province cut down paddy trees which are dried by salt water as food for cattle.

27/05/2009

VietNamNet/TT

VietNamNet Bridge – China’s construction of big hydro-power dams on the Mekong River will be a great threat to the future of the river, a significant water source for Southeast Asia, a United Nations report said. Senior experts analysed the impacts on Vietnam’s Mekong River Delta.

According to AP, China has built eight dams on the upper Mekong River in Yunnan province. It recently finished the construction of the 292m Xiaowant Dam, the world’s highest arch dam. The UN report released on May 21 said that this dam’s capacity is equivalent to the entire capacity of all reservoirs in Southeast Asia.

At the same time, Laos has begun to build 23 dams on the lower Mekong River and its estuaries. This work is scheduled to finish in 2010.

The UN report stated that only the Xiaowant Dam can change the water volume and the running speed of water, creating a reduction of water quality and biodiversity in the Mekong River, which runs through six countries.

Young Woo Park, the UN Environment Programme director, warned the six governments to pay attention to the Mekong River, otherwise the future water resources of these countries may be threatened.

Ky Quang Vinh, director of the HCM City-based Centre for Observation of Natural Resources and the Environment, analysed the impacts of Chinese dams on the lower section of the Mekong River, particularly the Mekong River Delta of Vietnam.

He said: Dams of 15m height are quite big. It is unimaginable that the Xiaowant Dam is 292m. This dam may help draw water to serve some dry regions in China or to produce hydro-power. However, a vast area will be submerged, which will cause changes in the eco-system in this region. Some flora and fauna species may disappear, including rare ones.

The Mekong River is being cut into pieces, not only by the Xiaowant Dam in China, but dams in other countries like Laos, Thailand and Cambodia. These Southeast Asian countries plan to build 11 hydro-power dams on the main branch of the Mekong River. These dams will prevent flows of fish and cause disorder in the river, threatening the lives of millions of people who live along the river.

China’s dams on the upper Mekong River have caused serious environmental problems for the lower section like in Myanmar, northern Thailand and northern Laos. The decline of fish reserves and the change of the water level will make the lives of local people harder.

The Mekong River ranks behind only the Amazon in diversity of aquatic animals. It is one of the richest baskets of fresh-water fish in the world, which supports over 60 million people. It is estimated that the river yields income of more than $3 billion a year.

The construction of dams on the main stem of the river will threaten the extinction of rare animals, for example the Irrawaddy dolphin, Mekong giant catfish and others. Eco-regression will be a global disaster.

In Vietnam, there will be eco-changes. A huge volume of fish often moves to the Cuu Long River (the section of Mekong River in Vietnam) during the flood season. Dams prevent the flow of fish to Vietnam. In addition, ecological balance will shift. Perhaps the Mekong River Delta will not have a flood season anymore because there will not be enough water.

More dangerously, the river will be seriously short of fresh water. It happened in the recent dry season and will be more serious in the coming years. The water volume has also decreased. Measurements conducted last October showed that the flow was 28,000 cu.m per second while it was 40,000 cu.m in the past.

In the 2009 winter-spring crop, the flow of the Tien and Hau Rivers was only 1,600 cu.m per second, 100 cu.m per second less than required. In some areas in the lower section of the Cuu Long River, farmers lacked fresh water for irrigation. In coastal areas of Tien Giang, Ben Tre, Tra Vinh, Soc Trang, Bac Lieu and Ca Mau, salt water encroached 70km into the mainland.

In Vi Thanh town, Tien Giang province, for the first time the local people had to use salt water for 3-4 days continuously because tap water providers didn’t know that their sources of water were contaminated with salt water.

Prof. Ngo Dinh Tuan, chairman of the Institute for Southeast Asian Water Resources and Environment’s Scientific Council, said:

In the 1950s, China announced its strategy to move water from the south to the north. Since then they have constructed many dams on the Mekong River. These dams initially serve hydro-power production but according to many experts, they will serve to transfer water from the Mekong River to the Yangzi Jiang River and then to the dry northern region of China.

Other countries like Laos, Cambodia and Thailand are also building dams on the river. It is estimated that around 20 dams will be built on the river and these dams will greatly influence Vietnam, at the lower section of the Mekong River.

If China builds dams to serve power production, the first impact would be a remarkable reduction of aquatic resources and the volume of alluvium in the Mekong River Delta, resulting in landslides to balance the alluvial volume. It would be very dangerous for people who live in the lower section.

If China builds dams to transfer water from the Mekong River to the northern region, it would be very dangerous because the water volume going down to the lower section would be reduced considerably.

Some institutions were established to deal with these problems, for example the Mekong River Committee of Vietnam and the International Mekong River Committee, which groups up Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia and Thailand. However, the role of these institutions is modest.

Anyways, the Mekong River Committee of Vietnam partly contributes to prevent adverse impacts on the lower section of the Mekong River. We have to take initiative in joining voices with the world in preventing countries on the upper part of the river from overexploiting water resources. We have to accept the construction of dams to produce hydroelectricity but we have to protest the transfer of water from the river to other regions, otherwise the impacts would be very serious, especially when Vietnam has to suffer from impacts of climate changes.

We need a national strategy on this issue. I think we have to build doors at the estuaries of nine branches of the Mekong River in Vietnam to prevent the encroachment of salt water. We also have to build reservoirs to stock up on water for the dry season.

This is a big issue that the government should address soon. It is not only a problem for the Cuu Long River, but the Red River as well, because China has also built dams on the upper Red River.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Questioning the MRC’s “Sustainable hydropower development”

Statement
24 September 2008

Extensive hydropower development continues to threaten the ecological integrity of the Mekong River Basin almost a year after 201 organizations and individuals from 30 countries called on the Mekong River Commission (MRC) to sound the alarm on the serious consequence of hydropower dam development on the lower Mekong River. The MRC has continued to fail in promoting the findings of its own scientific research to the public and to the region’s governments that points towards the fact that extensive hydropower development will threaten the river ecosystems and the livelihoods of riparian communities.

Instead, the MRC has delayed action and only initiated further research, planning exercises, and dialogues, leaving a vacuum of accountability that has allowed hydropower developers to take their projects forward unchallenged.

It is now time that the MRC’s role is reviewed to ensure it is acting in the manner befitting an objective, scientific river basin management organization that it was set up to be. An important first step would be for the MRC to publicly call for a dam development moratorium until scientific evidence of the individual and cumulative impacts of dam development is in the public domain and all party stakeholders including public consensus has been achieved on the best way forward. Otherwise, the MRC’s role in the future is in doubt.

Unfortunately, historical precedent indicates that reform may be beyond the MRC. The MRC’s precursors – known as the Mekong Committee from the 1950s until the Mekong Secretariat in 1994 – have actually supported damming the Mekong River’s mainstream and major tributaries by developing various hydropower masterplans.

The MRC’s recent behind-closed-doors role in advising the Lao government on the Don Sahong Dam would suggest that little has changed; the MRC has yet to publicly release its study of the Don Sahong’s draft Environmental Impact Assessment report, despite a request by letter from civil society in March 2008.

That the MRC continues to withhold scientific information of critical interest to the public interest is of serious concern, and undermines the trust that it hopes to build with civil society groups. The only way for the MRC to prove that it is capable of generating objective scientific data is to open its results and conclusions to public scrutiny. The MRC’s unwillingness to do so is beyond comprehension, but not beyond suspicion.

Throughout the region, the many hydropower projects now planned for the Mekong basin are justified by electricity planning processes that are kept behind closed doors whcih are biased towards developing large power projects. These planning processes have not promoted energy efficiency, demand side management measures, nor renewable and decentralized energy technologies to their full potential. Although environmentally sustainable and socially desirable solutions to meeting the Mekong region’s energy needs do exist, they are not being considered in any regional energy plan at the expense of promoting the region’s financial economy.

The MRC has declared itself a supporter of “sustainable hydropower development”, but has failed to define the term or even to ensure compliance to its 1995 Mekong Agreement, as demonstrated by the suffering caused by Vietnam’s hydropower dams on the Sesan River to downstream communities in Cambodia and its failure to adhere to its commitment “to make every effort to avoid, minimize and mitigate harmful effects (Article 7).” Implementation of the 1995 Mekong Agreement together with globally recognized best-practice standards for energy and water sector development is urgently needed. The World Commission on Dams framework, which provides a comprehensive set of principles and guidelines from planning to decommissioning of dam projects, can help to better define how hydropower development should occur.

Large hydropower dams – especially on the Mekong River’s mainstream – reflect an outdated development model. In the Mekong region and around the world, the larger body of evidence points to the unsustainable cost of large dam development and the costs inflicted on communities once dependent on these rivers

The experience of hydropower throughout the Mekong Region has been that of unsustainable and unjust development. From Chiang Khong in Northern Thailand to Ratanakiri and Mondulkiri Provinces in Cambodia, tens of thousands of dam-affected villagers have suffered the loss of their fisheries, irregular water flows, poor water quality, and the loss of their rivers biodiversity without consultation, compensation or redress.

The Mekong River is a fisheries-rich river on which millions of people living under the poverty line depend for their food security; and that is also a significant contributor to the region’s economy. Before moving forward with its Hydropower Programme, the MRC - and its funders - must publicly declare the standards that they will work to uphold and how they will be clearly accountable to the regional public. Only, once standards are declared and there is review and recognition of the MRC’s past failures, can the MRC begin working towards the sustainable river management urgently needed by the millions who rely on the river as their lifeblood.

For more information, please contact:

The Rivers Coalition in Cambodia (RCC):
  • Mr. Chhith Sam Ath, Executive Director of NGO Forum, T: +855 012928585 or E: samath@ngoforum.org.kh
  • Mr. Tep Bunnarith, Executive Director of CEPA, T: +855 12895624 or E: tep@cepa-cambodia.org
  • Mr. Mak Sithirith, Executive Director of FACT, T: +855 12906279 or E: maksithirith@yahoo.com
  • Mr. Kim Sangha, Coordinator of 3SPN, T: +855 12629221 or E: sesan@online.com.kh
Thai People’s Network for Mekong (TPNM):
  • Ms. Pianporn Deetes, Living River Siam (SEARIN) : T: +66 081-4220111 or Email: pai@loxinfo.co.th
  • Mr. Montree Chantawong, Foundation for Ecological Recovery (FER): T: +66 081950-0560 or Email: nokmontree@hotmail.com

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Finland funds Mekong hydropower projects ... despite of the fact that they could seriously affect the livelihood of Cambodian people?

Finland funds Mekong hydropower projects

10-11-2007
VNA (Hanoi)

VIENTIANE —The Finnish government plans to fund a total of 2 million euros (US$2.87 million) over four years to help develop a hydropower programme in the Mekong River Basin.

The agreement was signed on Wednesday between the Mekong River Commission (MRC) and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Finland at the MRC headquarters in Vientiane, Laos.

Of the total amount, some 1 million euros will be used to fund the MRC’s hydropower programme, and another 750,000 euros for the second phase of a capacity-building project and for a water management trust fund (250,000 euros).

The funding will be spread among the Mekong River countries, including Thailand, Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar, said Lars Backstrum, the Finnish ambassador to Thailand, Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar.

Officer-in-charge of the MRC Secretariat, Do Manh Hung said the second phase of its capacity building programme will offer 40 professionals the opportunity to work, train and learn at the MRC over a period of four years.

This group will include young professionals from the hydrology sector in all four MRC countries and also lecturers from universities in the region.