http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnHMaCx1KuA
Showing posts with label NGOs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NGOs. Show all posts
Tuesday, July 10, 2012
Monday, March 19, 2012
NGO gives poor Cambodians hope
FRIENDS:The Formosa Budding Hope Association is helping poor Cambodians, many of whom have never seen a doctor, and raising Taiwan’s international profile
Mon, Mar 19, 2012
Staff Writer, with CNA
A Taiwanese humanitarian aid group said that while Taiwan may have few diplomatic allies, it is regarded by many Cambodian villagers as their best friend.
“Even if we’re suppressed in the international arena, it doesn’t mean we should not extend a friendly hand or share our expertise, especially in the field of medicine,” said Sally Yu (余慈薰), director of the Formosa Budding Hope Association’s Cambodian branch. “It’s what many people need and what Taiwan can provide.”
The non-governmental organization (NGO) she helped found offers medical and educational aid to thousands of people in Cambodia.
Labels:
Helping poor Cambodian children,
NGOs,
Taiwan
Tuesday, June 21, 2011
Silence of the Lambs: For do-gooder NGOs in Cambodia, accommodation with the regime is very profitable
For do-gooder NGOs in Cambodia, accommodation with the regime is very profitable.
Monday, June 20, 2011
By Ken Silverstein
Slate
Monday, June 20, 2011
By Ken Silverstein
Slate
On a typically warm, muggy evening in Phnom Penh earlier this year, I asked a twentysomething British woman for directions to Titanic, a restaurant overlooking the Tonle Sap River.
"Why?" she asked.
"Because I heard the food was good," I said, somewhat confused.
"Oh, because there's a massive party there tonight for the Westerners!" she breathlessly replied.
Yes, it's always a fine time to be an expatriate aid worker in Cambodia, where several thousand NGOs and aid organizations operate. By day, swarms of foreign do-gooders clog the streets of Phnom Penh in their company-provided SUVs, and by night they fill bars, restaurants, and nightclubs. Collectively, NGO workers represent a privileged caste, isolated and detached from the people who serve as the objects of their benevolence. It's all reminiscent of those clueless young GOP zealots sent to staff the Coalition Provisional Authority in Iraq, except the NGO workers in Cambodia aren't peddling Republican philosophy and the American way, but rather the ideology of altruism.
Saturday, December 11, 2010
Anti-corruption celebration in Cambodia
Labels:
Anti-corruption,
NGOs
Tuesday, March 09, 2010
Cambodian NGOs slam anti-graft bill before debate
Tue Mar 9, 2010
By Prak Chan Thul
By Prak Chan Thul
PHNOM PENH (Reuters) - Rights groups in Cambodia on Tuesday deplored an anti-corruption law that parliament will debate this week, saying it would not stop graft and offered no protection to whistle-blowers who uncovered corruption.
A coalition representing about 245 local non-governmental organisations (NGOs) told a news conference that debate on the anti-graft law -- in the works for 15 years but put quickly before parliament after being published on March 4 -- should be delayed for a month so the public could be consulted.
In particular, the groups wanted officials' assets to be declared publicly and whistle-blowers protected.
"If witnesses can't have protection, no one is going to come forward and report," said Pung Chhiv Kek, president of rights group Licadho, adding that witnesses could lay themselves open to defamation suits.
The debate is due to start on Wednesday.
Phay Siphan, a Cambodian government spokesman, rejected the criticism.
"The anti-corruption law will make the country an equitable society. The country will provide better public services and become a moral society," he said.
The main opposition Sam Rainsy Party said it joined the civil society groups in asking for a delay to the parliamentary debate.
"The draft is not good enough and was sent to parliament hurriedly," said party spokesman and lawmaker Yim Sovann.
"This law is not good, both in terms of the mechanism and the legal means to prevent corruption. There is not enough political will to fight corruption," he added.
(Reporting by Prak Chan Thul; Editing by Alan Raybould)
A coalition representing about 245 local non-governmental organisations (NGOs) told a news conference that debate on the anti-graft law -- in the works for 15 years but put quickly before parliament after being published on March 4 -- should be delayed for a month so the public could be consulted.
In particular, the groups wanted officials' assets to be declared publicly and whistle-blowers protected.
"If witnesses can't have protection, no one is going to come forward and report," said Pung Chhiv Kek, president of rights group Licadho, adding that witnesses could lay themselves open to defamation suits.
The debate is due to start on Wednesday.
Phay Siphan, a Cambodian government spokesman, rejected the criticism.
"The anti-corruption law will make the country an equitable society. The country will provide better public services and become a moral society," he said.
The main opposition Sam Rainsy Party said it joined the civil society groups in asking for a delay to the parliamentary debate.
"The draft is not good enough and was sent to parliament hurriedly," said party spokesman and lawmaker Yim Sovann.
"This law is not good, both in terms of the mechanism and the legal means to prevent corruption. There is not enough political will to fight corruption," he added.
(Reporting by Prak Chan Thul; Editing by Alan Raybould)
Labels:
Anti-corruption law,
NGOs,
SRP MP Yim Sovann
Saturday, March 06, 2010
Q+A: What's the Good Practice Project?
05 Mar 2010
Written by: Thin Lei Win
Written by: Thin Lei Win
PHNOM PENH (AlertNet) - Advocacy and aid groups in Cambodia have expressed concerns about a proposed law regulating non-governmental organisations (NGOs) in the Southeast Asian country.
The issue has raised a wider question about governance in the sector crowded with hundreds if not thousands of players.
Here are some questions and answers about a home-grown system aimed at self-regulation.
What is the Good Practice Project (GPP)?
Launched two years ago, the Good Practice Project (GPP) is an attempt by Cambodia's NGO community to clean its own house before the NGO and Associations Law comes into force. Under the GPP, NGOs undergo a voluntary certification system and agree to comply with a set of ethical principles (the Code of Ethical Principles and Minimum Standards for NGOs in Cambodia).
The NGOs must first be registered with relevant ministries and have been operating for three years at least.
Cooperation Committee for Cambodia (CCC), a two-decade old umbrella group for over 100 local and international NGOs helped developed GPP.
Why is it needed?
Twelve years after the end of a brutal civil war, Cambodia now boasts thousands of NGOs and associations. Figures vary -- the government says there are over 3,000 while an NGO umbrella group says around 1,000 exist. There has been criticism over the conduct of some NGOs and the NGO community concedes there is a need for accountability.
What is the Code of Ethical Principles and Minimum Standards for NGOs in Cambodia?
This is a set of principles and minimum guidelines for NGOs on a host of issues ranging from mission and values and governance to accountability and transparency and human resources.
GPP team members say the idea is to guide NGOs to become more professional in their everyday practice as well as to inform public and interested parties about the principles they can expect NGOs to uphold.
The NGOs who wants to be certified by the GPP has to ensure they comply with the code. The first version of the code was drafted in 1995.
How does it work?
The NGOs who have decided to get the certification need to go through a series of steps including submitting a written application and documentation such as annual audit statements, annual reports and organizational statues.
Before they receive certification as Good Practice NGOs, GPP staff will review the documents and the NGOs' programmes through field visits. Once all the criteria have been fulfilled, they will receive a certification lasting three years.
What does it mean for organizations to be certified?
In theory, the certification will act as a stamp of approval of the NGO and an assurance to the general public as well as the government over the integrity of the individuals and organizations involved and the effectiveness of its programmes.
Increasingly, it will also become an asset with the donors. Already, the Australian government's aid agency Aus AID lists the certification as a requirement when calling for NGOs to send in proposals for aid projects.
How many have been certified under the GPP?
So far only 17 have been certified out of 51 applications. These include a wide range of NGOs such as the Non-Timber Forest Products Organisation, street children charity Mith Samlanh and Salvation Center Cambodia where Buddhist monks provide spiritual and practical support to HIV/AIDS patients.
Although the number may seem miniscule given the size of the NGO community in Cambodia, GPP said it had seen an increase in applications, possibly due to concerns over the impending NGO law.
The issue has raised a wider question about governance in the sector crowded with hundreds if not thousands of players.
Here are some questions and answers about a home-grown system aimed at self-regulation.
What is the Good Practice Project (GPP)?
Launched two years ago, the Good Practice Project (GPP) is an attempt by Cambodia's NGO community to clean its own house before the NGO and Associations Law comes into force. Under the GPP, NGOs undergo a voluntary certification system and agree to comply with a set of ethical principles (the Code of Ethical Principles and Minimum Standards for NGOs in Cambodia).
The NGOs must first be registered with relevant ministries and have been operating for three years at least.
Cooperation Committee for Cambodia (CCC), a two-decade old umbrella group for over 100 local and international NGOs helped developed GPP.
Why is it needed?
Twelve years after the end of a brutal civil war, Cambodia now boasts thousands of NGOs and associations. Figures vary -- the government says there are over 3,000 while an NGO umbrella group says around 1,000 exist. There has been criticism over the conduct of some NGOs and the NGO community concedes there is a need for accountability.
What is the Code of Ethical Principles and Minimum Standards for NGOs in Cambodia?
This is a set of principles and minimum guidelines for NGOs on a host of issues ranging from mission and values and governance to accountability and transparency and human resources.
GPP team members say the idea is to guide NGOs to become more professional in their everyday practice as well as to inform public and interested parties about the principles they can expect NGOs to uphold.
The NGOs who wants to be certified by the GPP has to ensure they comply with the code. The first version of the code was drafted in 1995.
How does it work?
The NGOs who have decided to get the certification need to go through a series of steps including submitting a written application and documentation such as annual audit statements, annual reports and organizational statues.
Before they receive certification as Good Practice NGOs, GPP staff will review the documents and the NGOs' programmes through field visits. Once all the criteria have been fulfilled, they will receive a certification lasting three years.
What does it mean for organizations to be certified?
In theory, the certification will act as a stamp of approval of the NGO and an assurance to the general public as well as the government over the integrity of the individuals and organizations involved and the effectiveness of its programmes.
Increasingly, it will also become an asset with the donors. Already, the Australian government's aid agency Aus AID lists the certification as a requirement when calling for NGOs to send in proposals for aid projects.
How many have been certified under the GPP?
So far only 17 have been certified out of 51 applications. These include a wide range of NGOs such as the Non-Timber Forest Products Organisation, street children charity Mith Samlanh and Salvation Center Cambodia where Buddhist monks provide spiritual and practical support to HIV/AIDS patients.
Although the number may seem miniscule given the size of the NGO community in Cambodia, GPP said it had seen an increase in applications, possibly due to concerns over the impending NGO law.
Monday, January 18, 2010
Lords of Poverty

First published in May/June 2008 in The Phnom Penh Post as part of the Voice of Justice columns. Of my travels and extensive living outside Cambodia, I have never witnessed elsewhere such the degree of upside-down modus operandi for daily functioning as I do here in Cambodia. Many times the people who are obstructionists and create obstacles are the people who should know better (both foreigners and Khmers), not the "ignorant" people of the villages I hear people blaming; they are people who lack generosity of spirit or they have enough information, even intelligence, but lacking wisdom. Currently, the Lords of Poverty roam and strut among us here in Cambodia armed with great resources to do damage, and in the process taint the image of those who actually are doing commendable work. Through personal experience, I am against private company acting as the clearinghouse of millions of aid dollars for local NGOs. These clearinghouses have no incentive to do humanitarian work. On the contrary, they do everything to make themselves indispensable; that is to say, they use their position to acquire knowledge of local NGOs and in turn, use that knowledge to divide the NGOs to further justify their existence; these private companies have the greater incentive to give the grants to mediocre NGOs and disparage the successful ones, again to make their existence necessary: "See, how divisive and incompetent these NGOs are and how we necessary." Also, I want to emphasize that the percentage of foreign consultants should be reduced in favor of local hires... With a little bit of patience and wisdom, a local consultant can be had for a fraction of the salary of the foreign consultant. More than that, it works against the mentality of genuine capacity-building. People who are of integrity and genuine in their observations would readily agree with me that current foreign assistance and practice of hiring are inadvertently embedding the culture of dependency and the Lords of Poverty.
Let's keep that pointing finger at the government accountable; however, let's also focus on the three other fingers pointing back at us. Let's focus on the hypocrisy and outrageousness of the do-gooders – donors and civil society – in light of other dark, societal norms.
Societal norms
What arc some societal norms darkening current Cambodia? And who are the enablers of these darkening norms?
Outrageous behavior
We live in a society where outrageous behavior – by us Khmer and foreigners alike – is the norm. As donors, civil society and other "do-gooders", we enable this outrageousness, and sometimes engage in it with full confidence that we can get away with it. Take for example the event of this past Thursday at CSD where "good people" hired armed Ministry of Interior police to exact emotional violence (that easily could have turned into physical violence) on staff and others. Where do we even begin in pointing out the countless, irregular, illegal, "undue process" and outrageousness of this act?
The more outrageous acts are the norm, the more dense and obtuse we become; the less we are able to hear and understand, the more outrageous we become. It's an upward, vicious, spiraling cycle of raising the volume. "We" in this regard includes both us Khmer and foreigners.
Disproportionate reaction
Disproportionate reaction is the norm. Instead of reacting to these outrageous acts with outrage, we stay mute; we claim neutrality; or, we smile and laugh and shake our heads at the Cambodians or the crazy foreigners hiding in Cambodian society. We are so used to the outrageous (which is beyond our scope to exact control) that in order to still feel we do have sensibility, we over-react to the minutiae where in light of the totality of circumstances, it has no significance. This is why killers of millions are permitted to get away with murder and are still held in awe.
(As an aside, I'd like to make a distinction between fairness and neutrality, as they are often used interchangeably. If one is a stakeholder and has adequate information, one can no longer claim inaction as neutrality and not enable the other side. Neutrality is reserved for 3rd parties who are not in the know, nor should have interests in knowing. But to be inactive or not take a stance as a stakeholder with sufficient information is to not neutral but to inadvertently and foolishly be enabling. As I often tell my staff: As your boss. I want to be and will be fair; I do not want and will not be neutral. If one staff brings to me shoddy work, and another excellent work, do not think I will remain neutral and not make a distinction. To the contrary, if I do not praise excellence and be indifferent or dismissive of mediocrity, I am being unfair to the one who worked hard and produced excellence, and stripped all incentives for future excellence. Fairness relates to using the same measuring stick; neutrality relates to information and how far or close we are to a situation.)
Another aspect of disproportionate reaction that is a societal norm relates to the interaction between a Cambodian and a Westerner. Generally speaking, a Cambodian is passive and deferential; the Westerner assertive/aggressive and overbearing. This unbalanced equation creates a norm whereby a Cambodian will always be at a disadvantage in relation to her foreign counterpart - in a discussion, in a negotiation, in a relationship.
Empty verbiage
We Khmers are still lacking in sophistication as our verbiage too often arc viscerally empty and crude; they are understood as such and accepted as norms. We function at this level of the reality of unreality.
Foreigners are more sophisticated in masking their empty verbiage. But sophistication is only a higher art-form of facade, superficiality. One example of how foreigners have normalized the empty rhetoric is in the area of "capacity-building" or "local ownership". Foreign donors "train" and train and train and train on ownership, on building local capacity because it sounds good and right; just don't "do" ownership, as that competes into their terrain; competes into their survival; they need to justify their existence through the "incompetence", the "divisiveness" of the local NGOs, the local Cambodians. The growing pool of highly capable Cambodians is swept away by these generalizations to their detriment.
Envy
We are so envious of excellence and success and do nothing to strive toward them but rather expend our energy in being in a state of envy. If only envy could stay within the self and not spill into destructive, obstructive behavior of gossip and tearing down.
Mistrust, distrust
Mistrust arises from misrepresentation, from a disregard for the sentiments of the affected individuals or groups. It also arises from political spin. We Khmer must be more careful of this in light our culture of fear, secrecy and the paranoid produced by the Khmer Rouge years and other regimes since.
Dependency, perpetuate "Lords of Poverty" mentality
Perpetuating the status quo is perpetuating poor governance, perpetuating mismanagement, perpetuating a "lords of poverty" mentality.
In 1993, yes 99% of foreign consultants were justified; now, 5% are justifiable. The others are embedding and enabling the mentality of dependency.
Ownership – how many local NGOs are truly "owned" by that director or senior staff? Many are run (behind the scenes) by consultants and sometimes ambitious/over exuberance 2nd year law students who have the legal expertise but cannot "feel" the situation nor understand the larger vision of what is Cambodia and "Cambodian".
Disincentives of reform
The societal norms mentioned above are disincentives of genuine reform and change.
The way we at CSD try to fight against these darkening societal norms is by encouraging a little bit of attitude among the staff. Strike that. We encourage a lot of attitude. With a lot of heart. It is the necessary first step toward ownership and social development.
Theary C. SENG, former director of Center for Social Development (March 2006—July 2009), founded the Center for Justice & Reconciliation (www.cjr-cambodia.org) and is currently writing her second book, under a grant, amidst her speaking engagements.
LORDS OF POVERTY
Enablers of Hypocrisy and Mismanagement
Enablers of Hypocrisy and Mismanagement
Let's keep that pointing finger at the government accountable; however, let's also focus on the three other fingers pointing back at us. Let's focus on the hypocrisy and outrageousness of the do-gooders – donors and civil society – in light of other dark, societal norms.
Societal norms
What arc some societal norms darkening current Cambodia? And who are the enablers of these darkening norms?
Outrageous behavior
We live in a society where outrageous behavior – by us Khmer and foreigners alike – is the norm. As donors, civil society and other "do-gooders", we enable this outrageousness, and sometimes engage in it with full confidence that we can get away with it. Take for example the event of this past Thursday at CSD where "good people" hired armed Ministry of Interior police to exact emotional violence (that easily could have turned into physical violence) on staff and others. Where do we even begin in pointing out the countless, irregular, illegal, "undue process" and outrageousness of this act?
The more outrageous acts are the norm, the more dense and obtuse we become; the less we are able to hear and understand, the more outrageous we become. It's an upward, vicious, spiraling cycle of raising the volume. "We" in this regard includes both us Khmer and foreigners.
Disproportionate reaction
Disproportionate reaction is the norm. Instead of reacting to these outrageous acts with outrage, we stay mute; we claim neutrality; or, we smile and laugh and shake our heads at the Cambodians or the crazy foreigners hiding in Cambodian society. We are so used to the outrageous (which is beyond our scope to exact control) that in order to still feel we do have sensibility, we over-react to the minutiae where in light of the totality of circumstances, it has no significance. This is why killers of millions are permitted to get away with murder and are still held in awe.
(As an aside, I'd like to make a distinction between fairness and neutrality, as they are often used interchangeably. If one is a stakeholder and has adequate information, one can no longer claim inaction as neutrality and not enable the other side. Neutrality is reserved for 3rd parties who are not in the know, nor should have interests in knowing. But to be inactive or not take a stance as a stakeholder with sufficient information is to not neutral but to inadvertently and foolishly be enabling. As I often tell my staff: As your boss. I want to be and will be fair; I do not want and will not be neutral. If one staff brings to me shoddy work, and another excellent work, do not think I will remain neutral and not make a distinction. To the contrary, if I do not praise excellence and be indifferent or dismissive of mediocrity, I am being unfair to the one who worked hard and produced excellence, and stripped all incentives for future excellence. Fairness relates to using the same measuring stick; neutrality relates to information and how far or close we are to a situation.)
Another aspect of disproportionate reaction that is a societal norm relates to the interaction between a Cambodian and a Westerner. Generally speaking, a Cambodian is passive and deferential; the Westerner assertive/aggressive and overbearing. This unbalanced equation creates a norm whereby a Cambodian will always be at a disadvantage in relation to her foreign counterpart - in a discussion, in a negotiation, in a relationship.
Empty verbiage
We Khmers are still lacking in sophistication as our verbiage too often arc viscerally empty and crude; they are understood as such and accepted as norms. We function at this level of the reality of unreality.
Foreigners are more sophisticated in masking their empty verbiage. But sophistication is only a higher art-form of facade, superficiality. One example of how foreigners have normalized the empty rhetoric is in the area of "capacity-building" or "local ownership". Foreign donors "train" and train and train and train on ownership, on building local capacity because it sounds good and right; just don't "do" ownership, as that competes into their terrain; competes into their survival; they need to justify their existence through the "incompetence", the "divisiveness" of the local NGOs, the local Cambodians. The growing pool of highly capable Cambodians is swept away by these generalizations to their detriment.
Envy
We are so envious of excellence and success and do nothing to strive toward them but rather expend our energy in being in a state of envy. If only envy could stay within the self and not spill into destructive, obstructive behavior of gossip and tearing down.
Mistrust, distrust
Mistrust arises from misrepresentation, from a disregard for the sentiments of the affected individuals or groups. It also arises from political spin. We Khmer must be more careful of this in light our culture of fear, secrecy and the paranoid produced by the Khmer Rouge years and other regimes since.
Dependency, perpetuate "Lords of Poverty" mentality
Perpetuating the status quo is perpetuating poor governance, perpetuating mismanagement, perpetuating a "lords of poverty" mentality.
In 1993, yes 99% of foreign consultants were justified; now, 5% are justifiable. The others are embedding and enabling the mentality of dependency.
Ownership – how many local NGOs are truly "owned" by that director or senior staff? Many are run (behind the scenes) by consultants and sometimes ambitious/over exuberance 2nd year law students who have the legal expertise but cannot "feel" the situation nor understand the larger vision of what is Cambodia and "Cambodian".
Disincentives of reform
The societal norms mentioned above are disincentives of genuine reform and change.
The way we at CSD try to fight against these darkening societal norms is by encouraging a little bit of attitude among the staff. Strike that. We encourage a lot of attitude. With a lot of heart. It is the necessary first step toward ownership and social development.
Theary C. SENG, former director of Center for Social Development (March 2006—July 2009), founded the Center for Justice & Reconciliation (www.cjr-cambodia.org) and is currently writing her second book, under a grant, amidst her speaking engagements.
Labels:
Foreign aid,
NGOs,
Theary Seng
Monday, October 19, 2009
NGOs slate Asean leadership
Poor attendance for second Peoples' Forum
19/10/2009
ACHARA ASHAYAGACHAT
Bangkok Post
This was in contrast with the forum's launch in Bangkok in February.
The absence of official representation yesterday raised doubts if the regional grouping is really serious in creating a "caring and sharing community".
The concern was fuelled not only by the lack of government interest in discussing Asean civil society organisations but also by claims that some Asean governments have been meddling with the NGO process of selecting delegates to participate in the "Interface Meeting" with leaders on Friday. Corinna Lopa, of Southeast Asia Committee for Advocacy, said the total absence of government representatives at the Asean Peoples' Forum (APF) discussions, in comparison with their active participation in the first APF in Bangkok six months ago, was a disappointment.
"We would like to condemn some governments' efforts to sabotage the Interface process by making it optional for leaders to participate in the face-to-face meeting with the NGOs," said Ms Lopa, who also represents Solidarity for Asian Peoples Advocacies. Asean Secretary-General Surin Pitsuwan and Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya joined the first APF meeting but were not present yesterday on the first day of the three-day event. NGOs from Brunei, Burma, Cambodia, Laos, Malaysia and Vietnam have appointed their representatives to meet the leaders during the Interface Meeting.
The meeting was organised to promote interaction between Asean leaders and civil society representatives after the launch of the Asean Charter in December last year. One NGO representative from each country was to participate in talks with Asean leaders. The APF was to be the venue for the NGOs to select representatives.
At the first Interface Meeting in February, Cambodian and Burmese leaders threatened to boycott the gathering if it was attended by NGO representatives critical of the two governments.
Chalida Tajaroensak, of People's Empowerment, said the meeting would be meaningful only if the representatives were chosen by NGOs.
"We are dismayed Asean governments can spare 20 minutes for youth representatives and have a working lunch with the business sector, but they have shortened talks with the civil society to 10 minutes," Ms Chalida said.
Chanida Bamford, of the APF steering committee, said despite interference, the selection of the NGO representatives for Indonesia, the Philippines and Thailand would be transparent.
Despite the absence of Burmese and Cambodian representatives at the February meeting, Asean NGOs raised problems such as human rights and Burma's democratisation process for discussion, prompting intervention in the selection process by some governments.
19/10/2009
ACHARA ASHAYAGACHAT
Bangkok Post
At the first Interface Meeting in February, Cambodian and Burmese leaders threatened to boycott the gathering if it was attended by NGO representatives critical of the two governments.CHA-AM : The 2nd Asean Peoples' Forum has started without key representatives from the government and Asean Secretariat.
This was in contrast with the forum's launch in Bangkok in February.
The absence of official representation yesterday raised doubts if the regional grouping is really serious in creating a "caring and sharing community".
The concern was fuelled not only by the lack of government interest in discussing Asean civil society organisations but also by claims that some Asean governments have been meddling with the NGO process of selecting delegates to participate in the "Interface Meeting" with leaders on Friday. Corinna Lopa, of Southeast Asia Committee for Advocacy, said the total absence of government representatives at the Asean Peoples' Forum (APF) discussions, in comparison with their active participation in the first APF in Bangkok six months ago, was a disappointment.
"We would like to condemn some governments' efforts to sabotage the Interface process by making it optional for leaders to participate in the face-to-face meeting with the NGOs," said Ms Lopa, who also represents Solidarity for Asian Peoples Advocacies. Asean Secretary-General Surin Pitsuwan and Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya joined the first APF meeting but were not present yesterday on the first day of the three-day event. NGOs from Brunei, Burma, Cambodia, Laos, Malaysia and Vietnam have appointed their representatives to meet the leaders during the Interface Meeting.
The meeting was organised to promote interaction between Asean leaders and civil society representatives after the launch of the Asean Charter in December last year. One NGO representative from each country was to participate in talks with Asean leaders. The APF was to be the venue for the NGOs to select representatives.
At the first Interface Meeting in February, Cambodian and Burmese leaders threatened to boycott the gathering if it was attended by NGO representatives critical of the two governments.
Chalida Tajaroensak, of People's Empowerment, said the meeting would be meaningful only if the representatives were chosen by NGOs.
"We are dismayed Asean governments can spare 20 minutes for youth representatives and have a working lunch with the business sector, but they have shortened talks with the civil society to 10 minutes," Ms Chalida said.
Chanida Bamford, of the APF steering committee, said despite interference, the selection of the NGO representatives for Indonesia, the Philippines and Thailand would be transparent.
Despite the absence of Burmese and Cambodian representatives at the February meeting, Asean NGOs raised problems such as human rights and Burma's democratisation process for discussion, prompting intervention in the selection process by some governments.
Labels:
ASEAN summit,
Burma,
Cambodia,
NGOs
Friday, June 05, 2009
An unlikely hero
June 5, 2009 INSEAD
Somaly Mam is a driven, dynamic, inspiring and indefatigable leader. Those are some of the qualities that make her one of Time Magazine’s 100 most influential people and a CNN Hero.
Somaly Mam is also an unlikely hero. She is a victim of human trafficking and was sold into a brothel in Cambodia at the age of 12.
Nearly a decade later, she escaped with the help of a French aid worker and in 1993 went to Paris. She returned to Cambodia two years later and founded “Agir Pour les Femmes en Situation Précaire” (AFESIP) or “Acting for Women in Distressing Circumstances.”
Now at 39, she and her organisation have freed thousands of children and women, educated them and provided vocational training in Cambodia and other countries in Asia. Her foundation campaigns around the world against human trafficking. She spoke recently to INSEAD Knowledge, shortly before giving a talk at INSEAD’s Asia campus in Singapore.
“We explain (to the victims of human trafficking) how to stand up and fight. Stand up and show (them) that we have hope around the world,” says Mam.
Despite all she has been through, Mam radiates hope. Her biggest frustration is dealing with corruption. Human traffickers and organised crime groups have influence over the courts and the police, setting her work back. “They have money, so they can buy anything,” she says.
Mam’s own organisation works at the grass-roots level, helping the women and children who are the victims of human trafficking.
She believes global problems require the involvement of both local non-governmental and major international organisations, but often, she says, when they try to coordinate there seems to be more talk than action. Also, Mam’s timetable is different to that of many big NGOs. For her, each day is precious, but for large organisations a day or a year isn’t a very long time. “When you are in the brothel, one day is (too) long,” she says.
AFESIP needs money, but also volunteers and help in educating the rest of the world. “No woman, no child wants to be abused,” she says. “If you pass them in the red light district, don’t look down on them,” she says.
Beyond that, combating human trafficking will require educating men. “If we really want to end the problem we have to end the demand.”
The women and children helped by AFESIP get shelter, education and vocational training so they can escape the brothels for good. “I want them to be lawyers because, with what they’ve been through, they can’t be corrupted,” says Mam.
She praises the work Lexis-Nexis has done with her foundation because the company has given not only money, but also expertise in grant writing, technical support and the time of company professionals. One senior manager spends half his time helping her.
Mam and her foundation have very visible support from global celebrities, including Angelina Jolie and Susan Sarandon, and says their power and connections help raise awareness.
“It’s not just money that I need. I need them to come and see my world. This world is so big. I can save 5,000 girls but there are so many more.” And Mam says, the children targeted by the traffickers are getting younger.
Mam claims that dealing with donors and government officials is more nerve-wracking than death threats. “You have to know how to talk to them, but I’ve never been educated,” she says. “(It’s) hard work making the people understand me. That is my challenge.”
On the ground in Cambodia, Mam works to save girls one at a time. “My goal? Save the children and make them happy.”
Somaly Mam is also an unlikely hero. She is a victim of human trafficking and was sold into a brothel in Cambodia at the age of 12.
Nearly a decade later, she escaped with the help of a French aid worker and in 1993 went to Paris. She returned to Cambodia two years later and founded “Agir Pour les Femmes en Situation Précaire” (AFESIP) or “Acting for Women in Distressing Circumstances.”
Now at 39, she and her organisation have freed thousands of children and women, educated them and provided vocational training in Cambodia and other countries in Asia. Her foundation campaigns around the world against human trafficking. She spoke recently to INSEAD Knowledge, shortly before giving a talk at INSEAD’s Asia campus in Singapore.
“We explain (to the victims of human trafficking) how to stand up and fight. Stand up and show (them) that we have hope around the world,” says Mam.
Despite all she has been through, Mam radiates hope. Her biggest frustration is dealing with corruption. Human traffickers and organised crime groups have influence over the courts and the police, setting her work back. “They have money, so they can buy anything,” she says.
Mam’s own organisation works at the grass-roots level, helping the women and children who are the victims of human trafficking.
She believes global problems require the involvement of both local non-governmental and major international organisations, but often, she says, when they try to coordinate there seems to be more talk than action. Also, Mam’s timetable is different to that of many big NGOs. For her, each day is precious, but for large organisations a day or a year isn’t a very long time. “When you are in the brothel, one day is (too) long,” she says.
AFESIP needs money, but also volunteers and help in educating the rest of the world. “No woman, no child wants to be abused,” she says. “If you pass them in the red light district, don’t look down on them,” she says.
Beyond that, combating human trafficking will require educating men. “If we really want to end the problem we have to end the demand.”
The women and children helped by AFESIP get shelter, education and vocational training so they can escape the brothels for good. “I want them to be lawyers because, with what they’ve been through, they can’t be corrupted,” says Mam.
She praises the work Lexis-Nexis has done with her foundation because the company has given not only money, but also expertise in grant writing, technical support and the time of company professionals. One senior manager spends half his time helping her.
Mam and her foundation have very visible support from global celebrities, including Angelina Jolie and Susan Sarandon, and says their power and connections help raise awareness.
“It’s not just money that I need. I need them to come and see my world. This world is so big. I can save 5,000 girls but there are so many more.” And Mam says, the children targeted by the traffickers are getting younger.
Mam claims that dealing with donors and government officials is more nerve-wracking than death threats. “You have to know how to talk to them, but I’ve never been educated,” she says. “(It’s) hard work making the people understand me. That is my challenge.”
On the ground in Cambodia, Mam works to save girls one at a time. “My goal? Save the children and make them happy.”
Labels:
Afesip,
Corruption in Cambodia,
NGOs,
Sex slavery,
Somaly Mam
Thursday, May 21, 2009
A future in the balance
Thursday, 21 May 2009
Written by Rod Brazier
The Phnom Penh Post
THE Cambodian People's Party (CPP) has consolidated its position as the dominant political force in Cambodia. Until the global financial crisis struck, political stability had led to a dramatic increase in investor interest, generating a surge in investment and economic growth.
The CPP won a resounding victory in the July 2008 national elections, elections which were recognised by the international community as free and fair. The CPP enjoys widespread support today owing to the stability and economic growth that have occurred in recent years. Outside, it's not well understood that this government is truly very popular, despite some authoritarian tendencies.
That's because Cambodia has made remarkable progress over the past 15 years. Starting from a very low base, key indicators of human welfare, such as maternal and child mortality, have improved dramatically.
The opening of the economy in the 1990s gave initial impetus to economic growth and job creation. The main drivers of growth have been the garment sector, tourism, construction in Phnom Penh and Siem Reap, and public spending.
Remittances from garment factory workers to the rural country-side have been an important source of income transfer to those areas, while the very large agricultural and fisheries sectors act as buffers against economic turmoil.
All round, a very good picture for a country that was still at war with itself little more than a decade ago.
The political consolidation by the CPP over the last several years has changed the context in which Cambodia will develop over the next few years. One-party rule has replaced fractious politics. Growth and development are top priorities.
The emphasis on economic growth holds promise for increasing prosperity for ordinary Cambodians, but possibilities for re-emergence of an open pluralistic polity are greatly reduced.
In addition, the global financial crisis threatens to undermine the anti-poverty gains of recent years and to exacerbate the nascent social tensions arising from the visible gap between rich and poor.
Therefore, the main challenges for the country over the next few years will be to sustain the current pace of economic development and reduce poverty, while addressing the worst abuses arising from a system of governance that has resisted reform in the past.
I have a few scattered observations about Cambodia, gleaned from almost three years in Phnom Penh. Many of you have been here longer than I have, so forgive me if any observations are shallow.
The international community is woefully under-informed about Cambodia
Compared to the international communities in neighbouring countries, the international community here in Phnom Penh is terribly ignorant about the political economy of Cambodia.
I hasten to add that I include myself in this category. As a group - for there are very few exceptions - we know very little about the politics that matters in Cambodia. There is, of course, the noisy, quarrelsome discourse that is carried out in the headlines between the government and the opposition. Despite the high volume and frankness of the exchanges, I don't think this is where the action is politically. To me, the internal politics of the CPP are more intriguing and far more consequential, for several reasons:
Relations between the CPP and NGOs - both local and international - have been occasionally thorny. Broadly, though, relations are improving, and I see two reasons for this:
Reading the latest draft, one can't find so much that's objectionable. One clause on political activity is problematic, and the sanctions for some types of non-compliance are rather heavy, but it is still a draft. I have begged my colleagues to view it as a draft and to take up the government's offer to consult. But perceptions are stubborn, and some letters have been written that have been counter-productive. The Asia Foundation has not signed those letters because we want to enter consultations in good faith.
Inequality and under-investment in education are growing as concerns
Cambodia is probably on a very positive and well-trodden Asian path to development. In several respects, though, it is deviating in ways that could threaten long term development prospects:
It's only a little more than a decade since Battambang was captured briefly by the Khmer Rouge. Cambodia is small, and positive developments here are seldom heard in the din of the 24-hour news cycle. This is unfortunate. A vivid demonstration of this is the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) report.
The EIU published two reports in March 2009. One was the regular Country Report about Cambodia. Nothing in that report was objectionable.
In fact it was a sober, sensible report that no one in this room would likely find controversial.
The report that has caused so much anger here is called Manning the Barricades, a 32-page report that mentions Cambodia once.
Manning the Barricades with global coverage that purports, among other claims, to rank countries by the risk of political instability. Some of the indicators included were: inequality, state history, trust in institutions, and corruption. These are reasonable.
The government erred badly in complaining so loudly about this report because the complaints brought prominence to a single mention of Cambodia on page 16 of the report that would otherwise have gone largely unnoticed. The rush by business groups and others to condemn the EIU was equally unhelpful and merely nourished an incorrect perception.
Sustaining rapid economic growth: not a straight shot
The CPP's legitimacy depends largely on maintaining rapid improvements in the quality of life. Basic, first generation economic reforms are in place, but the high-growth trajectory of recent years will hit limits imposed by rampant corruption and cronyism. Extracting continued rapid growth will require painful choices by the Cambodian leadership that will impinge on the interests of entrenched party elites. This is where the rubber will hit the road for reform: when economic growth is crimped by cronyism.
This problem is most dramatically illustrated in problems related to land issues. Foreign investors say that uncertainties over land are the single biggest concern, and often the reason that potential new investors walk away. It's worth noting that the prime minister himself has warned countless times about the dangers of continued land-grabbing. Yet it persists. Other similar pressures will emerge over time to test the government's commitment to market-led growth.
The government must reduce these vulnerabilities by fixing fundamental policy weaknesses. A key to improving economic governance will be to nurture and empower the small group of Western-educated technocrats within the Ministry of Economy and Finance, and scattered throughout other ministries and departments.
This group is more outward looking and reform-minded and is believed to have close ties to the pragmatic Prime Minister Hun Sen. We need to nurture and support these people, for they will face heavy challenges in the coming years that will determine the pace and trajectory of economic reform and development in Cambodia.
I have spent some time listing weaknesses and vulnerabilities. But we must also acknowledge the enormous strides that the Cambodian people have taken.
From civil war and unimaginable sorrow and misery just a generation ago, to a normal, developing country encountering the typical range of challenges that every other country in the region has faced. The good news is that others have shown it is possible to overcome these impediments.
But it is long, slow work and, in some respects, the early years are the easiest. I am cautiously optimistic about Cambodia. The focus of government has shifted from winning the political contest and seizing power to governing well and staying popular by delivering infrastructure and services.
This is a watershed transition that hasn't been noted enough. In the words of my friend His Excellency Roland Eng, who said five years ago: "We used to talk politics, now we talk policy."
---------------
The Asia Foundation's Cambodia country director Rod Brazier has been in Cambodia for three years. He is leaving the Kingdom shortly to take up a position with the Australian government in Canberra. On April 24, 2009, he spoke to the American Cambodian Business Council. What follows is an excerpted version of his speech to AmCham members.
Written by Rod Brazier
The Phnom Penh Post
"The CPP's legitimacy depends largely on maintaining rapid improvements in the quality of life. Basic, first generation economic reforms are in place, but the high-growth trajectory of recent years will hit limits imposed by rampant corruption and cronyism. Extracting continued rapid growth will require painful choices by the Cambodian leadership that will impinge on the interests of entrenched party elites. This is where the rubber will hit the road for reform: when economic growth is crimped by cronyism."A few final reflections on the situation in Cambodia from the Asia Foundation's outgoing country director.
THE Cambodian People's Party (CPP) has consolidated its position as the dominant political force in Cambodia. Until the global financial crisis struck, political stability had led to a dramatic increase in investor interest, generating a surge in investment and economic growth.
The CPP won a resounding victory in the July 2008 national elections, elections which were recognised by the international community as free and fair. The CPP enjoys widespread support today owing to the stability and economic growth that have occurred in recent years. Outside, it's not well understood that this government is truly very popular, despite some authoritarian tendencies.
That's because Cambodia has made remarkable progress over the past 15 years. Starting from a very low base, key indicators of human welfare, such as maternal and child mortality, have improved dramatically.
The opening of the economy in the 1990s gave initial impetus to economic growth and job creation. The main drivers of growth have been the garment sector, tourism, construction in Phnom Penh and Siem Reap, and public spending.
Remittances from garment factory workers to the rural country-side have been an important source of income transfer to those areas, while the very large agricultural and fisheries sectors act as buffers against economic turmoil.
All round, a very good picture for a country that was still at war with itself little more than a decade ago.
The political consolidation by the CPP over the last several years has changed the context in which Cambodia will develop over the next few years. One-party rule has replaced fractious politics. Growth and development are top priorities.
The emphasis on economic growth holds promise for increasing prosperity for ordinary Cambodians, but possibilities for re-emergence of an open pluralistic polity are greatly reduced.
In addition, the global financial crisis threatens to undermine the anti-poverty gains of recent years and to exacerbate the nascent social tensions arising from the visible gap between rich and poor.
Therefore, the main challenges for the country over the next few years will be to sustain the current pace of economic development and reduce poverty, while addressing the worst abuses arising from a system of governance that has resisted reform in the past.
I have a few scattered observations about Cambodia, gleaned from almost three years in Phnom Penh. Many of you have been here longer than I have, so forgive me if any observations are shallow.
The international community is woefully under-informed about Cambodia
Compared to the international communities in neighbouring countries, the international community here in Phnom Penh is terribly ignorant about the political economy of Cambodia.
I hasten to add that I include myself in this category. As a group - for there are very few exceptions - we know very little about the politics that matters in Cambodia. There is, of course, the noisy, quarrelsome discourse that is carried out in the headlines between the government and the opposition. Despite the high volume and frankness of the exchanges, I don't think this is where the action is politically. To me, the internal politics of the CPP are more intriguing and far more consequential, for several reasons:
- The CPP is extremely disciplined and little internal friction ever becomes apparent - at least in decipherable ways - in public. A few ripples appeared on the surface after the sudden death of Hok Lundy last November, but otherwise very little specific information about internal dissension ever becomes known outside tight circles. The workings of the CPP are especially mysterious to those of us who do not speak Khmer.
- The CPP's grip on power means that mid-term change and reform is likely to emerge from within the CPP rather than through formal competition with the other parties.
- Those of us who engage with different parts of the government see great variation from one ministry to the next - there are many opportunities to work cooperatively and fruitfully with the government on reform activities. Partners need to do their homework on who should be engaged beyond those listed on the government organagrams.
"I am cautiously optimistic about Cambodia. The focus ... has shifted from winning the political contest and seizing power to governing well and staying popular by delivering infrastructure and services."The government is not hostile towards all NGOs
Relations between the CPP and NGOs - both local and international - have been occasionally thorny. Broadly, though, relations are improving, and I see two reasons for this:
- The CPP is more confident as it ascends politically and so feels less vulnerable to criticism.
- Reform-minded officials see value in close relations with some NGOs, both as sources of feedback on performance and as providers of expertise. We see this very vividly in our interaction with the Ministry of Interior, where the appetite for cooperation seems to be insatiable. We also see it in our work with the Ministry of Women's Affairs (MOWA) on counter-trafficking. Of course, there are dinosaurs and hold-outs.
Reading the latest draft, one can't find so much that's objectionable. One clause on political activity is problematic, and the sanctions for some types of non-compliance are rather heavy, but it is still a draft. I have begged my colleagues to view it as a draft and to take up the government's offer to consult. But perceptions are stubborn, and some letters have been written that have been counter-productive. The Asia Foundation has not signed those letters because we want to enter consultations in good faith.
Inequality and under-investment in education are growing as concerns
Cambodia is probably on a very positive and well-trodden Asian path to development. In several respects, though, it is deviating in ways that could threaten long term development prospects:
- Inequality. Newly Industrialising Countries (NICs) have typically seen gini co-efficient, a numerical expression of inequality used by social scientists, narrow; it's getting wider in Cambodia. Eventual social consequences but also political and welfare concerns should be a cause for concern in this area.
- Education. Investment in education is dismal. All the latest and finest academic work shows that governments can make no better single investment than in education. Dollar for dollar investment in education brings greater benefit to a country and its people than any other. I don't see Cambodia investing enough in its people's education. Certainly, we see a hunger for personal improvement and a new generation of bright and ambitious young Cambodians seems to be emerging. But not all will be able to secure international education.
It's only a little more than a decade since Battambang was captured briefly by the Khmer Rouge. Cambodia is small, and positive developments here are seldom heard in the din of the 24-hour news cycle. This is unfortunate. A vivid demonstration of this is the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) report.
The EIU published two reports in March 2009. One was the regular Country Report about Cambodia. Nothing in that report was objectionable.
In fact it was a sober, sensible report that no one in this room would likely find controversial.
The report that has caused so much anger here is called Manning the Barricades, a 32-page report that mentions Cambodia once.
Manning the Barricades with global coverage that purports, among other claims, to rank countries by the risk of political instability. Some of the indicators included were: inequality, state history, trust in institutions, and corruption. These are reasonable.
The government erred badly in complaining so loudly about this report because the complaints brought prominence to a single mention of Cambodia on page 16 of the report that would otherwise have gone largely unnoticed. The rush by business groups and others to condemn the EIU was equally unhelpful and merely nourished an incorrect perception.
Sustaining rapid economic growth: not a straight shot
The CPP's legitimacy depends largely on maintaining rapid improvements in the quality of life. Basic, first generation economic reforms are in place, but the high-growth trajectory of recent years will hit limits imposed by rampant corruption and cronyism. Extracting continued rapid growth will require painful choices by the Cambodian leadership that will impinge on the interests of entrenched party elites. This is where the rubber will hit the road for reform: when economic growth is crimped by cronyism.
This problem is most dramatically illustrated in problems related to land issues. Foreign investors say that uncertainties over land are the single biggest concern, and often the reason that potential new investors walk away. It's worth noting that the prime minister himself has warned countless times about the dangers of continued land-grabbing. Yet it persists. Other similar pressures will emerge over time to test the government's commitment to market-led growth.
The government must reduce these vulnerabilities by fixing fundamental policy weaknesses. A key to improving economic governance will be to nurture and empower the small group of Western-educated technocrats within the Ministry of Economy and Finance, and scattered throughout other ministries and departments.
This group is more outward looking and reform-minded and is believed to have close ties to the pragmatic Prime Minister Hun Sen. We need to nurture and support these people, for they will face heavy challenges in the coming years that will determine the pace and trajectory of economic reform and development in Cambodia.
I have spent some time listing weaknesses and vulnerabilities. But we must also acknowledge the enormous strides that the Cambodian people have taken.
From civil war and unimaginable sorrow and misery just a generation ago, to a normal, developing country encountering the typical range of challenges that every other country in the region has faced. The good news is that others have shown it is possible to overcome these impediments.
But it is long, slow work and, in some respects, the early years are the easiest. I am cautiously optimistic about Cambodia. The focus of government has shifted from winning the political contest and seizing power to governing well and staying popular by delivering infrastructure and services.
This is a watershed transition that hasn't been noted enough. In the words of my friend His Excellency Roland Eng, who said five years ago: "We used to talk politics, now we talk policy."
---------------
The Asia Foundation's Cambodia country director Rod Brazier has been in Cambodia for three years. He is leaving the Kingdom shortly to take up a position with the Australian government in Canberra. On April 24, 2009, he spoke to the American Cambodian Business Council. What follows is an excerpted version of his speech to AmCham members.
Labels:
Cambodia's future,
CPP regime,
Cronyism,
Development,
Inequality,
NGOs,
Rod Brazier
Saturday, May 10, 2008
Civil Society Pushed For Approval Of Anti-Corruption Laws
Anti-corruption campaign by civil society at the end of 2006. On 16th May a march similar to this will be organised to present the petitions to the National Assembly.9th May 2008
By Chea Makara
Radio Free Asia
Translated from Khmer by Khmerization
On the web at http://khmerization.blogspot.com
Click here to read the original article in Khmer
Civil society on 9th May released a statement that they will present petitions with over one millions thumbprints and signatures to the National Assembly to request that this institution speed up the ratification of the Anti-Corruption Laws.
Mr. Pok Puthearith, who is in charge of collecting the thumbprints and signatures, said that the petitions will be presented to the government and the National Assembly on the 16th of May. He said that about more than 100 representatives from 40 civil societies will march from the headquarter of the Legal Right Protection in Cambodia to the National Assembly.
In response to the push for the speed up of the ratification of Anti-Corruption Laws, Mr. Cheam Yeap, MP for the Cambodian People's Party said that the delay in the approval of these laws was due to the disagreements on 5 points of the laws. He said: "There were 5 sticking points that I knew of. The first reason for the delay was the definition of the word 'corruption'. We want a clear definition so as not to leave any loopholes for judges to make unwise decisions or to commit injustices. Secondly was in relation to the Anti-Corruption Commission which many people want it to be independent (of the government). We also want it to be independent. Thirdly was in relation to the declaration of assets (of officials before and after holding public positions). Fourthly was in relation to the Secretariat of the Anti-Corruption Commission which some people want to give this commission overwhelming powers. In our constitution, there are only three powers and that is the Executive, the Legislative and the Judiciary. So if we give too much power to this body it will become the fourth power. That's why there is a further delay. And the fifth reason of the delay was the penalty/punishment."
However, Mr. Cheam Yeap said that the Anti-Corruption Laws will be approved in the fourth term of the government.
In relation to the Anti-Corruption Laws, Mr. Khieu Kanharith, the government spokesman, said that not only that the government officials should be subject to declaration of their assets, the parliamentarians and members of the civil society must also declare their assets as well. He said: "The members of parliament must also declare their assets. But I wish to propose that members of the civil society must also declare their assets. What do they think about this? Whoever has salary of more than 1,000,000 ($US250) riels must be subject to scrutiny."
It must be noted that the Anti-Corruption Laws have been drafted more than 10 years (in fact 14 years to be exact) ago but until now they have not been introduced and approved by the parliament yet.
Friday, January 18, 2008
In Cambodia, too much aid slips under the net
January 19, 2008
Glenda Korporaal
The Australian
Glenda Korporaal
The Australian
SITTING in a roadside cafe in the Cambodian capital Phnom Penh, Australian Chris Minko is grabbing the glasses and the salt and pepper shakers, moving them around the cheap laminated table top to make his point.
Minko, who has lived in Cambodia for the past 11 years, is furious about the waste, mismanagement and even corruption in the world aid dollars he sees spent in places such as Cambodia, a country struggling to get on its feet after decades of political unrest, including the genocide of almost 2 million people in the late 1970s by the Pol Pot regime.
Cigarette in hand, he uses the objects on the table to show how well-meant aid money often flows from one well-heeled organisation to another, all with different vested interests, many of them overlapping and with different agendas, all taking their cut along the aid trail, with only a fraction of the original amount flowing to the people it is meant to help.
Minko sees it all first-hand in Phnom Penh, one of the great charity and non-government organisation capitals of the world, where many hundreds of NGOs are based; a city where beggars scuttle along streets full of the latest shiny sport utility vehicles.
The Co-operation Committee for Cambodia's latest agency guide lists more than 600 local and international NGOs in a country of about 14 million people. "The amount of money being made here by Westerners is horrifying," Minko says bluntly. "And it is all so patronising and arrogant."
He argues too much Australian aid money is inefficiently used as it moves from aid agency to aid agency, each taking its administrative cut to fund its expatriate staff's houses, maids, four-wheel-drives and children's expensive education, plus its overseas head offices.
He would like nothing more than to make his point with the new Labor Government in Canberra, which has promised to boost Australian aid from its present $3.2 billion a year.
"There are excellent AusAID initiatives for landmine survivors in Cambodia, you can't deny that,' he says. "But I have watched the abuse of Australian taxpayers' funds and other aid funding here in Cambodia," he says. "We need to draw attention to this middle-man structure, to the fact that a lot of Australian funds go to funding other foreign NGOs when they should be going directly to Cambodian NGOs.
"Often by the time the money goes through the different tiers of NGOs there isn't much left when it hits the local level."
Minko knows that his outspokenness has probably cost him some financial support for his own project in Cambodia. Since arriving here with Australian Volunteers International, he has been a driving force in setting up the Cambodian National Volleyball League for the Disabled, for Cambodians who have lost limbs as a result of landmine accidents.
The volleyball league, which operates on a tiny budget, provides a small but supportive sports outlet for a fraction of the country's 40,000 landmine victims.
Started in 2002 with eight teams, the CNVLD now has 16 teams involving some 350 athletes in a competition which runs from May to October, and which also organises wheelchair racing for the disabled.
The league's latest success was hosting the sport's World Cup in the Cambodian capital in December (the first ever World Cup staged in the country) where the home team came in a very creditable third after Germany and Slovakia.
Minko is particularly proud to be involved in a low-budget organisation audited by KPMG (with no cars or villas) which has won a UN best practice award for its operation. Unlike many other organisations, it relies heavily on local staff and works in co-operation with the government while avoiding, he insists, the usual corruption traps.
His program is backed by the ANZ Bank in Cambodia which provided support for the organisation of the World Cup last month.
Minko aims to leverage the success of the volleyball league to set up an Association of Southeast Asian Nations' centre for disabled sports in Phnom Penh and to get his Cambodian team (which can beat the country's able-bodied athletes at volleyball) to the world No 1 ranking.
He has the support of the Cambodian government, including offers of land for a new multisport centre in Phnom Penh, which he believes can be built for about $5 million. He argues corporate sponsorship will be one of the ways of the future for his organisation.
But as the new government in Canberra looks at stepping up the national aid budget, having criticised the Howard government for being too stingy, there is a need to make sure overseas aid is spent efficiently and effectively.
Minko says the corporate sector can play its part by ensuring the charities and NGOs it supports are well run and professionally audited with a focus on controlling administrative costs and delivering services and outcomes.
He has already ruffled feathers in the aid industry which he argues is a closed shop to people like himself who are interested in providing practical help to people in places such as Cambodia but who are not players in the international game.
As Australia looks to boost its aid budget, paying attention to some critical comments from well-informed outsiders could have far more practical impact than listening to the do-gooding rants of another grandstanding rock star.
Minko, who has lived in Cambodia for the past 11 years, is furious about the waste, mismanagement and even corruption in the world aid dollars he sees spent in places such as Cambodia, a country struggling to get on its feet after decades of political unrest, including the genocide of almost 2 million people in the late 1970s by the Pol Pot regime.
Cigarette in hand, he uses the objects on the table to show how well-meant aid money often flows from one well-heeled organisation to another, all with different vested interests, many of them overlapping and with different agendas, all taking their cut along the aid trail, with only a fraction of the original amount flowing to the people it is meant to help.
Minko sees it all first-hand in Phnom Penh, one of the great charity and non-government organisation capitals of the world, where many hundreds of NGOs are based; a city where beggars scuttle along streets full of the latest shiny sport utility vehicles.
The Co-operation Committee for Cambodia's latest agency guide lists more than 600 local and international NGOs in a country of about 14 million people. "The amount of money being made here by Westerners is horrifying," Minko says bluntly. "And it is all so patronising and arrogant."
He argues too much Australian aid money is inefficiently used as it moves from aid agency to aid agency, each taking its administrative cut to fund its expatriate staff's houses, maids, four-wheel-drives and children's expensive education, plus its overseas head offices.
He would like nothing more than to make his point with the new Labor Government in Canberra, which has promised to boost Australian aid from its present $3.2 billion a year.
"There are excellent AusAID initiatives for landmine survivors in Cambodia, you can't deny that,' he says. "But I have watched the abuse of Australian taxpayers' funds and other aid funding here in Cambodia," he says. "We need to draw attention to this middle-man structure, to the fact that a lot of Australian funds go to funding other foreign NGOs when they should be going directly to Cambodian NGOs.
"Often by the time the money goes through the different tiers of NGOs there isn't much left when it hits the local level."
Minko knows that his outspokenness has probably cost him some financial support for his own project in Cambodia. Since arriving here with Australian Volunteers International, he has been a driving force in setting up the Cambodian National Volleyball League for the Disabled, for Cambodians who have lost limbs as a result of landmine accidents.
The volleyball league, which operates on a tiny budget, provides a small but supportive sports outlet for a fraction of the country's 40,000 landmine victims.
Started in 2002 with eight teams, the CNVLD now has 16 teams involving some 350 athletes in a competition which runs from May to October, and which also organises wheelchair racing for the disabled.
The league's latest success was hosting the sport's World Cup in the Cambodian capital in December (the first ever World Cup staged in the country) where the home team came in a very creditable third after Germany and Slovakia.
Minko is particularly proud to be involved in a low-budget organisation audited by KPMG (with no cars or villas) which has won a UN best practice award for its operation. Unlike many other organisations, it relies heavily on local staff and works in co-operation with the government while avoiding, he insists, the usual corruption traps.
His program is backed by the ANZ Bank in Cambodia which provided support for the organisation of the World Cup last month.
Minko aims to leverage the success of the volleyball league to set up an Association of Southeast Asian Nations' centre for disabled sports in Phnom Penh and to get his Cambodian team (which can beat the country's able-bodied athletes at volleyball) to the world No 1 ranking.
He has the support of the Cambodian government, including offers of land for a new multisport centre in Phnom Penh, which he believes can be built for about $5 million. He argues corporate sponsorship will be one of the ways of the future for his organisation.
But as the new government in Canberra looks at stepping up the national aid budget, having criticised the Howard government for being too stingy, there is a need to make sure overseas aid is spent efficiently and effectively.
Minko says the corporate sector can play its part by ensuring the charities and NGOs it supports are well run and professionally audited with a focus on controlling administrative costs and delivering services and outcomes.
He has already ruffled feathers in the aid industry which he argues is a closed shop to people like himself who are interested in providing practical help to people in places such as Cambodia but who are not players in the international game.
As Australia looks to boost its aid budget, paying attention to some critical comments from well-informed outsiders could have far more practical impact than listening to the do-gooding rants of another grandstanding rock star.
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
NGOs Urge Benchmarks, Extension for Tribunal
Mean Veasna, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
23 October 2007
Original report from Phnom Penh
23 October 2007
A group of NGOs has said they want better benchmarks for the Khmer Rouge tribunal, to ensure it will complete its work, which could take another year.
The groups put forth six benchmarks for the tribunal, which is sponsored by the UN at a cost of $56 million but has been beset with difficulties.
The groups sent a request to the tribunal for its administration to set a timetable to try former Khmer Rouge leaders and extend its mandate one year.
Observers worry the tribunal will run out of money before it can try former leaders of the regime, many of whom are old and dying.
Legal Aid of Cambodia Vice President Lor Chunthy said committee members on Monday met with Michelle Lee, the deputy director of tribunal's Office of Administration, requesting the first trial of a leader by June 2008.
"Next year, let's say in June, we should have the first hearing," he said. "Another point that we have is to have an extension from three to four years, so that we will have more information, so it is easy for us to prepare."
Civic groups were willing to do whatever necessary to help the tribunal succeed, he said.
The groups put forth six benchmarks for the tribunal, which is sponsored by the UN at a cost of $56 million but has been beset with difficulties.
The groups sent a request to the tribunal for its administration to set a timetable to try former Khmer Rouge leaders and extend its mandate one year.
Observers worry the tribunal will run out of money before it can try former leaders of the regime, many of whom are old and dying.
Legal Aid of Cambodia Vice President Lor Chunthy said committee members on Monday met with Michelle Lee, the deputy director of tribunal's Office of Administration, requesting the first trial of a leader by June 2008.
"Next year, let's say in June, we should have the first hearing," he said. "Another point that we have is to have an extension from three to four years, so that we will have more information, so it is easy for us to prepare."
Civic groups were willing to do whatever necessary to help the tribunal succeed, he said.
Labels:
Benchmarks,
ECCC,
KR Trial,
KR Tribunal,
NGOs
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)