Showing posts with label Simon Taylor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Simon Taylor. Show all posts

Sunday, June 17, 2007

Global Witness reacts to SGS report

16 June 2007
By Mayarith
Radio Free Asia

Translated from Khmer by Socheata
"... we don’t believe that SGS is a proper company to perform this task, we believe that the government should consult with donor countries to find an international organization to help investigate whether the information provided in our report is correct or not..." - Simon Taylor, Global Witness Director
Simon Taylor, Global Witness director, reacted to the investigation report provided by the Swiss firm SGS (Société Générale de Surveillance) by saying that the SGS report cannot be trusted.

This reaction came after SGS said in its report that it never received any report discussing about the names of the officials and businessmen involved in the illegal logging in Kompong Thom province mentioned by the Global Witness report.

Furthermore, the SGS report indicated that the Tumring area, located in Sandan district, which Global Witness claimed that it is subjected to illegal logging activities, it (SGS) did not notice the same observations as those provided by Global Witness.

Global Witness’ Simon Taylor said that a visit by SGS to the spot of the area mentioned would be beneficial for this Swiss company, rather than waiting to receive a report from someone else.

Simon Taylor said: “For a company such as SGS, which claims to be independent, it should have the ability and the duty to gather its own information, it should not wait for someone else to easily provide the information to them. I think that this is merely a poor excuse for a job poorly performed, and instead it (SGS) turns around to blame on the fact that it never receives any information or that it did not receive the information from the various institutions.”

In a televised report broadcasted this week, Robert Pannet, SGS director, accused the Global Witness report of having political motives and that this is a report provided by a group that lacks independence.

Simon Taylor said that the Cambodian government ought to find another investigation group that has better capability than SGS.

Simon Taylor said: “We believe that it is not good that the forestry monitoring company SGS participates in the investigation of this case. Nevertheless, we insist that the government investigates in details the activities we reported, and we also welcome the questions raised by Minister Khieu Kanharith who wants to see more monitoring done to confirm that our investigations were not done properly. However, we don’t believe that SGS is a proper company to perform this task, we believe that the government should consult with donor countries to find an international organization to help investigate whether the information provided in our report is correct or not. But we stress one more time that the Swiss forestry monitoring company SGS is a not a proper company to perform this task.”

There is no reaction yet from government officials regarding the latest comments made by Global Witness.

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

Global Witness deplores Hun Sen's "senseless censorship"

Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen waves to wellwishers in Phnom Penh, May 2007. A report released by London based watchdog Global Witness, a damning indictment of corruption in Cambodia, alleged that the country's most powerful illegal logging syndicate, the Seng Keang Company, is controlled by people related to Hun Sen.(AFP/File/Tang Chhin Sothy)

Environment group slams Cambodia ban on logging report
"Is the government sincere in its pledges to strengthen governance and the rule of law, or is it simply paying lip service to these ideals to secure aid and international respectability?" - Simon Taylor. Global Witness Director
PHNOM PENH (AFP) - Cambodia's ban on a report accusing the country's political elite of illegally plundering the kingdom's forests was denounced as "senseless censorship" Wednesday by the study's authors.

The London-based watchdog Global Witness, which released the report June 1, also condemned threats of violence against its staff that were made by Prime Minister Hun Sen's brother.

The report, a damning indictment of corruption in Cambodia, alleged that the country's most powerful illegal logging syndicate, the Seng Keang Company, is controlled by people related to Hun Sen.

Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Minister Chan Sarun and Forest Administration director Ty Sokhun were also fingered for their alleged role in robbing the country of tens of millions of dollars in natural resources.

The report enraged government officials, who called it "fiction," and prompted the information ministry to ban it from the country Sunday.

"This is senseless censorship," said Global Witness Director Simon Taylor in a statement.

"Attempts to suppress this report will not make the facts that it presents disappear. We would very much like to know the legal basis for this decision," he added.

While the government has ordered its own forest monitoring unit to investigate the Global Witness allegations, some officials continue to react angrily.

The premier's brother, provincial governor Hun Neng, is reportedly annoyed by allegations against his wife and son and was quoted in local press Tuesday as saying: "If they (Global Witness staff) come to Cambodia, I will hit them until their heads are broken."

Taylor called the threat against his staff "entirely unacceptable."

"Such crude intimidation by a senior public official says little for the government's commitment to upholding human rights and freedom of expression," he said.

The row comes just days before the June 19-20 annual meeting of Cambodia's foreign donors, whose pledges make up at least half of the impoverished country's national budget.

Donors have repeatedly said they are frustrated over Cambodia's lack of reform, particularly the government's apparent unwillingness to tackle rampant corruption.

Global Witness has urged more action from the international community to force Cambodia's government towards accountability.

"The reaction to this report raises a serious question for Cambodia's international donors," Taylor said.

"Is the government sincere in its pledges to strengthen governance and the rule of law, or is it simply paying lip service to these ideals to secure aid and international respectability?" he added.