Friday, February 20, 2009

CACJE questions authenticity of the Vietnamese films on S-21 immediately following the Vietnamese aggression of Cambodia

Cambodian Action Committee for Justice & Equity (CACJE)
No: 3 Fountain Ave. Cranston RI, 02920 Web: www.cacje.net, Email: cacjepress9@gmail.com
“CACJE is an Alliance for People Power, Promote Social Justice and Support Human Equity”

Official Translation in English
No: 0044/CACJE

Immediate Press Release
Februay 19, 2009

Press Statement

Cambodian Action Committee for Justice & Equity (CACJE) expressed strong supports the position of Mr. KA SAVUTH, the co-defense attorney of Mr. KAING GUEK EAV alias Duch, ex-Director of TUOL SLENG Prison and the position of Co-Prosecutor against the use of a film documenting torture shot by Vietnamese soldiers shortly after they drove the Khmer Rouge from power in 1979 as evidence before the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC). The document film served Hanoi political purpose. The orphan witness claiming living inside TUOL SLENG Prison raised more questions than answers.

Moreover, CACJE expressed displeasure relative to the declaration of CHHANG YOUK, Director of Cambodia Documentation Centre (DC-CAM) which is an organization financed by the American tax- payers. CHHANG YOUK had shown his no-professionalism, not independent, lack of deep understanding of the documentation, not be able to produce trustful documents and witnesses for the ECCC. Instead DC-CAM produces falsified, manipulated and fictive documents to serve political purpose in order to bury the truth about the Khmer Rouge. Therefore, DC-CAM induced in error the scholar studies of Khmer Rouge Era because of her published fabricated documents

To have a fair and transparent trial, and for the truth, the ECCC must reject all the documents and witnesses provided by Vietnam and China.

CACJE urges the international judges and Co-prosecutors to investigate more people, widening their scope to reach all the Khmer Rouge rulers from the top Chief of State to the region (DAMBAN) chief security forces. International judges and co-prosecutors must focus notably on the documents and witnesses. The polygraph machine might be used to sort out the witnesses.

Signed:
SEREYRATHA SOURN

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

Tuol Sleng killings alone would not constitute genocide, the prison may hav had actual anti-Khmer Rouge prisoners. The whole world seems to forget that the genocide included the killings that took place all over Cambodia starting from 04/17/75.

To use a possible propaganda film shot by invading troops who had every possible reason to defeat their enemy in the name of finding justice for over a million of the dead innocents is not truly a process of true justice.

Anonymous said...

I wish we can all see the film, but I don't think they used actors and actresses to create propaganda. If it is a real live clip, is should be admitted. You don't want to throw away the truth as they are very hard to come by. Plus, they say camera doesn't lie.

Anonymous said...

You are right, Suorn. To have a fair and transparent trial, and for the truth, the ECCC must reject all the documents and witnesses provided by Vietnam and China, even if they are truth.
We should reject everything.

Anonymous said...

I am one of the khmer rouge victim too, For the pass years Chhang Youk had served bias to the Khmer Vietminh ruling party, and many of khmer observers have notice that.

Anonymous said...

I just wonder if Youk Chhang wants to bury the truth, why he initiated the idea to produce the Khmer Rouge history textbook to be educated at all the high schools in the country. Be a thinkable person, please. You have to know that he the victim of the Khmer Rouge as well, and his main purpose justice and truth. If he's bias or serves for any political party, so how can he get lot of support from many European countries, and including the US. Bear in mind that those countries are strongly anti-government.

Anonymous said...

Everyone have to let the court to decide on this matter. And i think the defendant lawyers have right to challenge anything that oppose their client, it is their role. If the lawyers accept everything, the defendant doesn't need them.

Anonymous said...

KI-Media!

I want you to publish news from Khmer, Vietnamese and Chinese sources but NOT from Western sources!

Your site is very biased.

Anonymous said...

Dear CACJE,

How do you think about the soul of victim parent (parent of Mr. Norng Chanphal and other orphan)who killed in S-21?

Anonymous said...

The souls of ALL VICTIMS should be respected - S-21 was just a tiny part of the Killing Field. S-21 was a political prison. The mass killings occurred outside of Tuol Sleng and there were many, many more perpetrators than just Duch. Many of S-21 were either active or Khmer Rouge supporters. A good number were communists who returned from Europe, like HNH. The break-up and paranoia took place when Vietnam, China, and Soviet broke apart, thus the purge and counter-purge between the Viet-backed (current ruling clique) and the defeated China-backed groups. This trial could do some damage to Chinese reputation, but not much at all for the innocent Khmer Rouge victims.

Anonymous said...

I support CACJE, Khmer Rouge victims does not presents only S-21 but more in countrywide. The soul of victims have to be respected but justice and trush be decided by brain not by heart.

I am also one Khmer Rouge victim but I don't want to trial only killer because the order person, in charge person and other on behind have to be included and trial too.

The person whose work and serve Cmmunist and were bought by Hun Sen, does not only Chhang Yuk but there are alot person from US and from EU, they are all still have supported by US & EU but is because of donor in Cambodia does not have enough of resource and lack of monitoring tool.

Anonymous said...

Who would believe the YOUN's film in here? Why they had their military filming the scene instead of independent film maker??

This is really got the UN or people think twice.

YOUN never have good intention for Cambodia since the beginning. They have had always causing chaotics for Cambodia since they set foot southward.

Believe me the film is just the profit of the YOUN. They had blended in KR and slaughtered many Khmer.

That's whay POL POT got paranoid and kill whoever in front of his way.

Khmer Komsot,

Anonymous said...

I really don't understood in this case. why Sihanouk he got away from prosecute ?
he the once whom was lead the war and declared to all Khmer nation to join
him did the revolution with him at the jungle .

Anonymous said...

Yes shihanouk had the motive! He did just said a few weeks ago that all who not joint the fucking Khmer rouge like ah Hun Xen were Lon Nolian and he is hatting and want to kill Lon Nolian!

May Lightningstrike the killers and let they rot in hell!!!!!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

1:53 AM and 4:43 AM. You are Vietnamese. Stop fooling.

Anonymous said...

Yes ! I agree with you but Sihanouk himself he known more than any body else in these case were .
In the first whom were against his policy to support Viet Cong communist that were stay in Khmer territory and he had to command to arrest all of them and kill all them
in Tro Pang Kro Leung during 1964, The first person Preb En and others 11 more person etc.
2nd after march 18th during April
24th and 25th 1970 he had meeting with Thoun Van Dong and SoPha No vong Lao, and Sihanouk himself , talking all their plant what were
they going to do , The meeting was
take place at Tang Tong, Tang tong
may be in China .
And I also saw Sihanouk and his wife were stand with Viet Cong Troop in Viet namese territory .
At lease Sihanouk himself he interpret to his nation what were
going on in those situation in the
past , if he really love his own nation and honest to the whole nation .

Anonymous said...

12:54 PM. Camera does not lie, but the Vietnamese and Thais always lie to Cambodians.

How people make movie of superman flied? Man cannot fly, so camera lies.

Anonymous said...

Hi azzhole 7;59. So the pictures of the King and Queen standing there means that there're no sheep-dip Vietnamese in Cambodia?

Anonymous said...

Hey I saw pictures of Stalin of Soviet killer, Truman US Prez and Churchill shoook hands and hugged each others smiling, then the next thing the US and OK fought against Vietnam backed by Soviet army.

Anonymous said...

You just meet the dumbest talking. They said if King Sihanouk is honest with his nation he should tell these dumbest Cambodians what his mission was. You see these dumbest don't even udnerstand what is secret mission?

How can anyone expect these dumbest to understand the real world?

Take the US as an example, all the spies they sent abroad are kept from the public, some reported as missing and some reported dead. But the facts they changed their ID to live as another persons protecting from the enemies go after.

Anonymous said...

My post in 8:07 AM. UK not OK.

Anonymous said...

Camera doe not lie, but cameraman can lie...

Propaganda shots are nothing new, particularly by an invading troops trying to justify their cause...

Anonymous said...

If you voted for CPP (Cambodian People's Party):

Also known as:

Communist People's Party
Khmer Rouge People's Party
Khmer Krorhorm People's Party


You're support the killing of 1.7 million innocent Khmer peoples.

You're support the killing of innocent men, women and children in Cambodia on March 30, 1997.

You're support murder of Piseth Pilika.

You're support assassination of journalists in Cambodia.

You're support political assassination and killing.

You're support attemted assassination and murder of leader of the free trade union in Cambodia.

You're support corruption in Cambodia.

You're support Hun Sen Regime burn poor people's house down to the ground and leave them homeless.


These are the Trade Mark of Hun Sen Regime.


Hun Sen, Chea Sim and Heng Samrin are Khmer Rouge commanders.
When is the ECCC going to bring these three criminals to U.N. Khmer Rouge Trail?

Khmer Rouge Regime is a genocide organization.

Hun Sen Regime is a terrorist organization.
Hun Sen Bodyguards is a terrorist organization.
Hun Sen Death Squad is a terrorist organization.
Cambodian People's Party is a terrorist organization.

I have declare the current Cambodian government which is lead by the Cambodian People's Party as a terrorist organization.

Whoever associate with the current Cambodian government are associate with a terrorist organization.