Friday, July 02, 2010

In Time of Strife

Friday, July 02, 2010
Op-Ed by MP

THE future of Cambodia - for good or ill - will be determined by all Cambodians. It would be wise not to place too much store by what the Opposition parties alone can achieve for the Khmer people.

The facade of parliamentary democracy that we have seen since 1993 is just that - a facade fostered by the ruling party with cosmetic constitutional compromises and ultimately unenforceable legal niceties. One wonders whether the key players in the Paris Peace Accords had foreseen this development as a likely reality and outcome of their resolve to commit themselves to this 'platonic' relationship that has no chance of being consummated into an equitable political marriage for the good of the nation in every aspect beside providing a temporary lull to armed conflict and the reassurances obtained in respect of the reinstitution of the Monarchy as a mere nominal institution.

The power and influence of this ancient institution remains an important factor in the Khmer people's daily life and more crucially as a unifying symbol for Khmer unity and focus of Khmer identity and revival after all the recent upheavals and on-going external threats and hegemony. Whether one likes it or not, a sizable Khmer population, particularly, in rural areas, are still in awe of this Institution that has been part of their existence since the dawn of Khmer civilisation which in all likelihood predates even the arrival of religious influences from India in the forms of Brahmanism and Theravada Buddhism that in turn instilled the sanctity and sacredness of Royalty in the minds of the populace further by introducing the concept of Deva Raja or God-King - a conditioned reverence that many Cambodians today still project towards not only their King or Queen as such, but also their non-royal patrons and social superiors with binding power and patronage.

How strong this force and conditioning is cannot be quantified or evaluated in precise terms, but what is worth noting is that the Institution is essentially a facet of the nation's collective psyche rather than of any enduring charismatic figures born into it. Funcinpec's electoral success of 1993 owed more to this ingrained loyalty to the Monarchy as a mental state than to any of the wayward royals and princes that had the good fortune of being at the right place at the right time, despite the systematic anti-royalist desecration and propaganda over the preceding decades of Hanoi- backed Communist rule and briefly during the Republican era. Even today, one suspects a royalist political movement sensibly managed and granted sufficient mass media representation and coverage is capable of regaining enough electoral momentum to oust the ruling party at the next general election. Hence, the reversion to the 1980s style single party monopoly, albeit with allusions in token to Western model of political pluralism and democracy.

Politics could be a grand delusional exercise in perpetual failure and disappointment unless rooted in, and gravitated to, evolving historical events and circumstances. Individuals who have put their lives on the line by pursuing a risky career in the country's political Opposition can ill afford to comfort themselves with the knowledge that they have done enough and gone as far as they have through mere personal endeavours, but must constantly appraise their party’s policies and actions to see how best national interests could be accommodated in view of both growing domestic and external threats.

Mohandas K Ghandi was once asked whether he considered his ahimsa (non-violence) movement 'passive' - a common charge and perception which he firmly rejected, pointing out that ‘non-violence’ in political resistance does not equate passivity as such, but if anything, in his understanding, denotes the opposite in meaning to being passive. Rather, it requires an active, resolute co-ordinated action in response and in proportion to injustices, and indeed, to acts of violence as witnessed by ordinary men and women who, otherwise, owing to their restricted world views and cultural confinements, lack the intellectual tool and sophistication to see things clearly and objectively beyond their local hills and market stands. Ghandi, in short, was an activist and a militant of his time. And it is this ‘militant’ dimension of his movement and philosophy that I wish to highlight here in context of Cambodia’s current struggle for self-determination and democracy rather than his non-violent method per se.

People will rise up against repression and injustice, and these realities are being dished out in their abundance to the Khmer people, but they need due direction and guidance to begin with. Although, certain issues such as violated territorial integrity or land encroachments and political tension with neighbouring states attract more public interest and discussion, these are no less 'real' and relevant to ordinary Khmers than say their employments or livelihoods in the immediate and longer terms.

It is incumbent upon all Cambodians with informed, alert minds and good social conscience to go to villages and communities, specifically, places that have been under attack from land concessions and forced displacements as well as border encroachments and explain in simple terms what is at stake for them and their country if they go on being governed by this self-serving clique of unreconstructed former Communist cadres who have sold off just about everything at their disposal including their own souls in return for personal gains and the power to retain themselves in public offices they are ill qualified to assume. People need to be informed about the merits or flaws inherent in political representation, about democracy in action, and be educated to detect differences between calculated bribes/ handouts and genuine gestures in unequivocal solidarity and nationalism.

Truth may be as old as the hills, as Ghandi himself once claimed, and it is bound to prevail in the end, even if it may take a thousand years to do so. But within even less than half the time allowed for the hundreds of thousands of hectares of land leased to Vietnam at merciless expense of already destitute or near destitute Cambodians in the guise of commercial projects and investments, the Khmer nation will likely be completely routed in every sense – i.e. it may not be there anymore; not as the Khmers and their ancestors have known and loved well over two thousand years.

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

It is very enlightening ro read MP's opinion and analysis. Thank you Lok MP. You always have the last word.

Anonymous said...

We're making great strides in kicking the immigrants and refugees out of Cambodia to pave a way for the influx of Chinese immigrants.

I'm GAY said...

It is only one best article I ever read in Ki media. I just hope some of the readers can understand what you're saying.

All of us Khmers are the ones who can decide the future of our homeland.

We have been facing the same historic enemy for few hundred years whose avowed objective is to destroy our nation, and why are we still fighting with each others?

We need not only freedom but completely independence.

How do we start and how do we get there?

Banksy said...

How do you get there? Start asking questions, don't let political parties divert your attention from the real issues, don't let groups use 'nationality' and 'race' etc. as a way of diverting you from the real issues, and don't simply believe everything that you read on KI Media or hear in a politicians speech.

I don't see how kicking out all immigrants and Khmer unity will help develop the country.

I can see how it would divide the country and leave the people, essentially, fighting each other rather than focusing on the things that will develop the nation: schools, hospitals and employment. People who are divided and in fear of each other are much easier to control.

It would seem that expelling all immigrants, as some seem to want, would dramatically reduce the human resources of the country as many immigrants / migrants bring skills and knowledge with them - they wouldn't come if they couldn't make money here. Plus, would we ban the celebrating of Chinese New Year as it is not Khmer culture and the Chinese were encouraged to come here, like the Vietnamese, by the French colonial administration over a hundred years ago?

Also, calls for Khmer unity forget the role ethnic minorities (Pear, Kuoy etc) have played in this country's history and culture and, therefore, are an integral part of any discussion of Cambodian culture and should not be ignored. This country has not been built by Khmer hands alone.

Banksy said...

Also, it appears to me that the concept of Deva Raja or God-King is actually the problem.

How often has Cambodia been brought to the brink of destruction because of the decisions or opinions of 'the leader'? Unquestioned power in the hands of any individual or group of individuals is inherently dangerous whether they are a politician, monarch, businessman, or despotic maoist recluse.

It strikes me that we should be working to remove this trait from our culture. Seems to me that this is the source of many of our problems. We need to create an ability to question our superiors and to confidently disagree with them without fearing the results.

In this regard, a system of meritocracy needs to be introduced: promotion on ability / merit. This will mean that the best people will be in the most important positions and will be expert at what they do.

Anonymous said...

1;31pm.

Building the nation is one, but we cannot keep allowing the illegal immigrants from srok Yuon continue to come.

Is there a way to stop them?

Who really controls Cambodia right now?

What is the land size of Cambodia now?

Who owned the rubber plantation?

More questions ...coming.

I'm GAY said...

2:28pm.
I like the ideas, but you forget you are talking about Cambodia, the country has not been freed.

The majority of Khmer people in Cambodia love the monarchy and the current monarchy is like in England, and for a symbol of a nation they prefer to keep.

Cambodia has too many issues, and you come up with all good systems like in the US forget about the border issue and illegal immigrants.

I won't fall into "La stratégie de consolidation" by Yuon Hanoi, and you know why? Because I knew million Yuon are in Cambodia hold Hun Sen by the throat.

Justus M. Van Der Kroef wrote an article "Le Vietnam au Kampuchea: La strategie de Consolidation".

Anonymous said...

Banksy runs so fast after border and illegal immigrants questions.

Leadership said...

Two things to consider:

- Meritocracy = a social system or society in which people have power because of their abilities, not because of their wealth or social position

- Autocracy = government by a single person or small group that has unlimited power or athourity, or the power or authority of such a person or group

According to your knowledge and conscience, which one do you wish to see it would be developed in Cambodia?

SS

Anonymous said...

i know, it's not right for opposition to go around the world and fight with gov't of cambodia because they (opposition) don't want to recognize the gov't and so forth. that's not right, to say the least, really!

also, cambodia is not all about opposition, either. it should be about what can we all do better for cambodia and khmer people and society and forth, that is if we are smart enough to think wisely and soundly and reasonable, etc... don't forget that there are more to cambodia than just some politicians, etc..., really! the future of a better cambodia relies or depends on all of us to work together in order to shape cambodia's future for all. if we fail to understand that, then we are acting childish like a problematic child. we all should know better by now, really! life does go on in cambodia and all over the world as well. i like to think of it as a job, nothing personal, really!

Anonymous said...

8:46pm.
The public would go for Meritocracy rewarding the people based on their abilities.

But Cambodia cannot reach the meritocracy while she has been continued to be invaded by Yuon Hanoi.

The autocracy was installed by Hanoi not by the will of the Khmer people. Does it answer you that the people of Cambodia want the meritocracy? Yes they do.

And why didn't they get it? Why did Yuon Hanoi keep the autocrats like Hun Sen, Chea Sim and Heng Sam Rin in power?


Khmer people are fully understood what is going on in Cambodia that is why the majority prefer to keep the monarchy like in England.

Why does Hanoi think that Cambodia does not have people with talent and abilities to govern the country but only Hun Sen?

I do not believe nor respect what Yuon Hanoi is doing in my country.
As everyone sees the autocracy in Cambodia helps speed the strategy of consolidation of Yuon Hanoi in Cambodia.

While you ask me which form of the government I want, I ask you how many Yuon party cadres and Yuon farmers and business Yuon in Cambodia? Is this new border after Hun Sen gave a big portion of Cambodian land a final or just a pretext while Yuon are in process to complete their consolidation?

Can Khmer citizen move to live in Vietnam? Why can only Yuon come to live in Cambodia? Those Yuon who went to school learn Khmer languages have been infiltrated in Khmer government, and you don't want to talk about it?

We ask you. Where is Banksy now? Can Banksy answer our questions?

Anonymous said...

9:00 PM,
So you believe that Cambodia should be a one state party?
Do you think this CPP is the only one party must decide the fate of Cambodia?
What the opposition means to you?
Where are you living now? US I think. Do you embrace the autocracy and the invaders? What do you think of the land Khmers lost to Yuon recently?

Anonymous said...

Thank you Mr. MP for your thought on Cambodia and her future.

Anet Khmer

Anonymous said...

To I'm Gay (3:17PM)

It is your right to speak highly of the current Monarchy, but please don't make it sounds like the majority of Khmers have favorable opinion of the current Monarchy. I for once wanted to believe that the current Monarchy is a respectable icon for our nation, only to be repeatedly disappointed by the self-serving agenda of these royal figures.

Anonymous said...

1:07am, nobody wants to see cambodia withou opposition or a one-party system and so forth. all i'm saying here is that why can't we be like america election system, that is, during election all candidates debates and tried to convince all the american people with their vision and agenda and plan for gov't, if they win. the only difference with the opposition party of cambodia is that they failed to realized that the election is over already; it's a 5 year mandate election; so, why is opposition party still fighting and contesting the election even after the lost? why can't they wait until the next general or national election to debate and challenge their opponents?, etc! whether opposition don't want to recognize the winner in the election or not, the final decision has been made and the winners took office for 5 years; opposition should know better not to continue their challenge, etc... there are a time and a place to do it, but no, opposition do it all of the time, almost 24/7, 365 days a years, etc... stop it already! opposition is fighting a lost cause. enough already, ok! set your agenda better and be more effective next time around, that's all! and imagine if the political system in america is like in america i.e. continue to challenge and fight even after election is official determined the winner, etc... give me a break, ok! not funny!

Anonymous said...

4:25 AM,
Why didn't you answer him(gay) all questions he asked?
I don't believe you. I stayed in Cambodia for 4 months and everywhere I went to the Khmer people still love this King.
The people are worrying why Hun Sen does not do anything about the illegal immigrants from Vietnam and abou the border. They said Hun Sen sold a big portion of their land to Viets. To them they look for parent and that is the monarchy.

For a while you bragged about the good systems, but you are mum about the presence of Viets in Cambodia.

Ignorant wise boy said...

6:21 AM,
Hun Sen said if he lost to the opposition, he ordered the military to not taking any order from the new PM elected.

Does it strike you at all?
What do you think the call from the opposition to Hun Sen to do his job to help the Khmer people at the border whose farms were robbed by the intruders from eastern Cambodia?


Ignorant wise boy

wattanak said...

9.00 PM & 6.21 AM, I'm sure you're the same person. All this talk of yours about the opposition, I wonder if you actually understand the job of an opposition party, whether in Cambodia or elsewhere. They are called "the Opposition" because their responsibility is to OPPOSE! They are not there to make the Government look good! Really! In the case of Cambodia, there are enough arse kissers in the government already. They never oppose anything Hun Sen says, even when the result is loss if Khmer land. What have those government officials ever done to make Cambodia a fairer place to live. Each one of them is hell bent on sucking up to their superiors so they can continue to keep their positions. So what Cambodia needs is more people who are willing to point out the CPP's shortcomings, and the Opposition is doing that. Perhaps if the CPP manages to do a fair and correct thing once in a while, then the Opposition won't need to be so vocal. In the meantime, with all the corruption, the nepotism, the extrajudicial killings, the terrible management, the silencing of reasonable opposing voices, and the bad day to day running of the country altogether, how can any Opposition worth its salt stay quiet? Only those benefitting from the CPP are staying quiet. They are the immoral ones. Are you in that group 9.00PM? Perhaps you are, REALLY!

ignorant wise boy said...

Sure he or she is in the group. Why do you have to ask 10;00am?
Unlike him or her you are in opposition group.
Nothing wrong with that.
I only have the problems why CPP's members want to have a one state party?

Kulen Monorom said...

Thank you Lauk MP for your acticle.

And it was great to read all civilised comments on Mr. MP acticle. Please keep it up gentlemen, so I can learn more from all your wisdoms.

Please, allow me to say that more than 181,435 kilo metre square should belong to all Khmer who are living on this planet Earth. No one Khmer political party or one Khmer group of people can just sold our land to YUON as they did now.

Can all the elite Khmers unite now to guide all Khmer inside Cambodia to liberate ourself from YUON occupation?

It does not matter if you are CPP,Monarchist, SRP or even Republican supporters, if YUON completely consolidate the whole of Cambodia, they will turn to destroy all of you one by one like they did to Champa people.

Hun Sen think always that he is the King and the King maker in Cambodia, he used Royal Cambodian Armforces to oppress innocent Khmers, I wonder when can Hun Sen realised and liberate himself and his cronies CPP from YUON's slavery.

I wonder also when can the King father and His Majesty King Sihamoni including all the Royal family members realised of their past mistake and lead all Khmer people inside Cambodia to be free and independant from a foreign Armforces like other free nation around the world.

May almighty God bless Cambodia and all good Khmer citizen.

Kulen Monorom
(The rice farmer's son)

I'm GAY said...

12;56am
Good kiddo. You learned fast.
We haven't seen them reply.
They talked of eliminating the monarchy and bringing new systems for Cambodia. After that Hun Sen will be removed, and their strategy of consolidation finishes at last. The border problem is just a pretext to fool us. They are in our home. We

ignorant savant boy said...

Eh Gay boy. You didn't finish your sentence. (We) what?

Write some more, I just begin to invest reading your ideas. You get very good plan, but be careful Viets will trace you and shut you up.

Anonymous said...

i know, it's right for opposition to go around the world and fight with gov't of cambodia because they (opposition) don't want to recognize the gov't and so forth. that's not right for Hun Xen's goverment to dictated people , to say the least, really!

also, cambodia is not all about opposition, either. it should be about what can we all do better for cambodia and khmer people and society and forth, that is if we are smart enough to think wisely and soundly and reasonable, etc... don't forget that there are more to cambodia than just some politicians, etc..., really! the future of a better cambodia relies or depends on all of us to work together in order to shape cambodia's future for all. if we fail to understand that, then we are acting childish like a problematic child. we all should know better by now, really! life does go on in cambodia and all over the world as well. i like to think of it as a job, nothing personal, really!

Anonymous said...

"THE future of Cambodia - for good or ill - will be determined by all Cambodians. It would be wise not to place too much store by what the Opposition parties alone can achieve for the Khmer people."

+++++WHO PLACE TOO MUCH STORE ON OPPOSITION????? AH KDOR NA DOCH AH KDOR NA! ALL WORM IN THE SAME SHIT WHOLE!

"The facade of parliamentary democracy that we have seen since 1993 is just that - a facade fostered by the ruling party with of the reinstitution of the Monarchy as a mere nominal institution."

++++++THAT WAS THE FUCKING GAME THAT FOOL US ALL!

"The power and influence of this ancient institution remains an important factor in the Khmer people's daily life and more King or Queen as such, but also their non-royal patrons and social superiors with binding power and patronage."

+++ WHAT CAN WE DO WITH ALL THE EXPERIANCE TO SURVIVE? TRY TO LIVE IN CAMBODIA AND BE JUST SND BRAVE!

"How strong this force and conditioning is cannot be quantified or evaluated in precise style single party monopoly, albeit with allusions in token to Western model of political pluralism and democracy."\

===hEY! PEOPLE TRY TO WIND THE BEST THING THEY CAN REMEMBER! AND SOME TIME IS WRONG! AND WE HAVE NOCHOICE TOO FOR UN GIVE CAMBODIA TO THE WARLODS AND ARM MEN BUT NOT THE REAL PEOPLE OF CAMBODIA! TO GIVE THE PEOPLE UN SHOULD REFORME THE ARMY AND JUSTICE GIVE PEOPLE EQUAL ABILITY TO DO POLITIC NOT ONLY WHEN YOU CAN KILLE!

"Politics could be a grand delusional exercise in perpetual failure and disappointment unless e there anymore; not as the Khmers and their ancestors have known and loved well over two thousand years."

DONT BE A FOOL WE ARE NOT LIVE UP TO 1000 YEARS! WE CHOOSE THAT WHAT IS THE BEST AVAILABLE! GIVE ME MORE CHOICES AND I WILL SHOW YOU THAT I AM A 21 CENTERY NOT VAVE MAN!

REFORM THE FUCKING FOECES AND FUCKING JUSTICE SYSTEM AND SEE WHAT WE CAN COME OUT TO HELP OURSELF! UNITED NATION (UN) COMPLET THE PARIS ACORD AND GIVE US REAL CHANCES, FOOL!!!!

Anonymous said...

"THE future of Cambodia - for good or ill - will be determined by all Cambodians. It would be wise not to place too much store by what the Opposition parties alone can achieve for the Khmer people."

+++++WHO PLACE TOO MUCH STORE ON OPPOSITION????? AH KDOR NA DOCH AH KDOR NA! ALL WORM IN THE SAME SHIT WHOLE!

"The facade of parliamentary democracy that we have seen since 1993 is just that - a facade fostered by the ruling party with of the reinstitution of the Monarchy as a mere nominal institution."

++++++THAT WAS THE FUCKING GAME THAT FOOL US ALL!

"The power and influence of this ancient institution remains an important factor in the Khmer people's daily life and more King or Queen as such, but also their non-royal patrons and social superiors with binding power and patronage."

+++ WHAT CAN WE DO WITH ALL THE EXPERIANCE TO SURVIVE? TRY TO LIVE IN CAMBODIA AND BE JUST SND BRAVE!

"How strong this force and conditioning is cannot be quantified or evaluated in precise style single party monopoly, albeit with allusions in token to Western model of political pluralism and democracy."\

===hEY! PEOPLE TRY TO WIND THE BEST THING THEY CAN REMEMBER! AND SOME TIME IS WRONG! AND WE HAVE NOCHOICE TOO FOR UN GIVE CAMBODIA TO THE WARLODS AND ARM MEN BUT NOT THE REAL PEOPLE OF CAMBODIA! TO GIVE THE PEOPLE UN SHOULD REFORME THE ARMY AND JUSTICE GIVE PEOPLE EQUAL ABILITY TO DO POLITIC NOT ONLY WHEN YOU CAN KILLE!

"Politics could be a grand delusional exercise in perpetual failure and disappointment unless e there anymore; not as the Khmers and their ancestors have known and loved well over two thousand years."

DONT BE A FOOL WE ARE NOT LIVE UP TO 1000 YEARS! WE CHOOSE THAT WHAT IS THE BEST AVAILABLE! GIVE ME MORE CHOICES AND I WILL SHOW YOU THAT I AM A 21 CENTERY NOT VAVE MAN!

REFORM THE FUCKING FOECES AND FUCKING JUSTICE SYSTEM AND SEE WHAT WE CAN COME OUT TO HELP OURSELF! UNITED NATION (UN) COMPLET THE PARIS ACORD AND GIVE US REAL CHANCES, FOOL!!!!