Sunday, October 03, 2010

Why supporting Tibetan struggle?

October 2, 2010
By MP Son Chhay
As a matter of principle, if we can not support Vietnam or Thailand's invasion of Cambodia, then how can we turn around and support or ignore China's invasion of Tibet? The reality is that to have any international credibility, Cambodia must not put itself into any position that will be viewed as supporting crimes against humanity – whether this be in Cambodia, in Burma or, in Tibet.
SRP MP Son Chhay
My recent trip to take part in Tibet's 50th Anniversary of its Parliament in Exile has been criticised as potentially damaging to Cambodia's national interest. Some going so far as to suggest that during this period when Cambodia is facing strong undue control from Vietnam which has unfortunately led to the fear that this will eventually lead to the swallowing of our motherland as a whole I, as a Cambodian politician should look up to China for protection.

I myself used to believe in this kind of propaganda but after many years of being involved in the affairs of human rights and the active promotion of democratic principles in our , as well as within the region and, having been involved in supporting our own struggle in the 1980s, against the invasion of Cambodia by the Vietnamese armed forces, further compounded by my own personal testimony of suffering under regimes which were influenced by the policies of communist doctrine either through the practice of Mao or Uncle Ho, I, now believe differently. All countries have their own agenda and China has not proven to be a reliable ally and certainly does not advocate human rights even in its own country.

In the past, the Khmer Rouge were ideologically very close with China. They did not work to unify our people and strengthen our country's institutions but instead isolated Cambodia from the world and created damaging relationships with our neighbouring countries. The Khmer Rouge were dependent solely on China, and were keen to show their full support to their Chinese 'masters' by putting into practice, the Mao's communist ideology which resulted in the genocide of millions of our people and set Cambodia back to year zero. It was this serious of events that eventually gave the Vietnamese the 'excuse' to invade Cambodia and, to this present time China has not protected us.



In fact, China's current objective is to search for resources to feed her booming economy. It is, in fact, Cambodia's raw materials, including timber, minerals and petroleum, that are the real reason for China's feigned interest with our weak and corrupt government. Our government has provided China with many generous concessions including a hundred thousand hectares of land, contracts on projects building hydro dams, roads, bridges to the point where are economy is debt ridden for unbelievable amounts of money which our people will have to pay for many generations to come.

It is important that all countries have a right to the principles of self determination. Our government has failed to provide Cambodia with policies that will protect Cambodia's interests for all generations and instead continues to compromise our country's wealth with questionable 'deals' with other countries, including China.

As a matter of principle, if we can not support Vietnam or Thailand's invasion of Cambodia, then how can we turn around and support or ignore China's invasion of Tibet? The reality is that to have any international credibility, Cambodia must not put itself into any position that will be viewed as supporting crimes against humanity – whether this be in Cambodia, in Burma or, in Tibet. Even as a small country, we can still defend ourselves as a proud independent nation and it is foolish to think that another external country especially one with a record such as China will 'protect' own interests better! But we must first nurture and protect our own people by working hard to promote a unified nation with good institutions that will serve our people through the implementation of democratic principles and a sound foreign policy that will be the envy of our neighbours!

33 comments:

Anonymous said...

As the regional and world powers move to strengthen their dominance, they will always support authoritarian and corrupt governments who will always bow to their political and economic demands in return for financial support and political backing if not military backing.
Note hun sen backing every chinese initiatives at the UN and Sihanouk kissing chinese behinds at every occasion.

Cambodia as well as every small nations will have to beg and kiss ass if they want to flourish or survive. that is the law of the jungle. But with the current government, it is called prostitution.

Jayavarman

Anonymous said...

Mr Son Chhay,
You have made big mistake and your political future is now very limited.
You cannot compare vietnamese or Thailand invasion to Cambodia to Tibet integration within China at all.
First you must understood that Tibet was part of China since 1279 during Mongol invation of all China ( Han dynasty , Xingjiang, Manchury and Tibet ). China was established first by Mongol empire called Yuo Dynasty. When Ming Dynasty liberated herself from Mongol, every part of China has liberated themselves. But Manchury emperor has again united China in 1661.
So the world China is included of Tibet. Without Tibet, China wouldn't be China.
To intefer China internal politic is to destroy your own relationship with China and to insult China citizen.
During the fall of Qing Dynasty of 1911, the new administration hasn't got power to enter Tibet, therefore, Tibet had become disconnected from China. At the same time, China has it own war with Japanese and then second world war. China has fully recobered Tibet again 1959. So please don't make this mistake and your mistake is to serious which will harm Cambodia as well.
As China now is the world economic power, China will not interest your party and your political fight for Cambodian at all. They will treat you asd their ennemy, thus they will use all their power to call all their allies which is now 90% of the world leaders to reject all your struggle for Cambodia.

Areak Prey

Anonymous said...

Son Chhay knows very well what you know, Areak Prey, but that's really politic, the way to play the last card: force CPP to be with Chineses and SRP takes the side of Americans. I feel year 1970.
Good luck SRP!

Anonymous said...

Stupid idea, how come he present people in parliament? Why he don't oppose US invade Iraq? Protest Israel embargo on Palestine? He is in politics for long time, why don't he know? I just tell the truth, even CCTV chinese TV, it includes Angkor Wat, Apsara in its travel log program, it show the Chinese understanding our country very well. We have a good relation since Funan empire till today. I think what he is to support US policy no matter what happen to Cambodia. He can do like that because he is US citizen but Cambodian can not afford to do that, we just want peace and stability. We want to have this time to develop our country, do not try to take to the turmoil again.

Anonymous said...

That's not true,
CPP doesn't only develop Cambodia
but also
implement DICTATORSHIP in Cambodia
by processing Hun Sen PERSONALITY CULT.
Hun Sen imitates Kim Jong-Il, Nicolai ChaoSescu..

Anonymous said...

Areak Prey,
Do you read Chinese history or you watch Chinese movies? Regardless of what you said, Tibet is a country invaded and took over by China, which is not right. Taiwan was a part of China, why doesn't China take it back than? Of course China can, but before China can win, it must lose a big deal, for America will help Taiwan no matter what.

Anonymous said...

Son Chhay is a politian and you, you're a WANT-TO-BE political expert, I hope you know the difference.

Anonymous said...

Why does Mr. Son Chhay stick he nose where it does not belong? I wish he focusses on developing the strength for his party rather than offending China. No doubt that's why SRP is going nowhere - they can not focuss and prioritize!

Anonymous said...

That's because, he is smart. Mr. son Chay is a man with great conscience and many SRP are brillinat. God Bless and may your party win in the up coming election!

Anonymous said...

That's because, he is smart. Mr. Son Chay is a man with great conscience and many SRP are brilliant. God bless and may your party win in the up coming election!

Anonymous said...

MP Son Chhay,

This is very stupid of you to play with fire, and for that stupidity, your political career will be burned!

When the trouble comes, don't say we haven't told you MP Son Chhay...

Anonymous said...

Areak Prey is spreading a fault statement about Tibet exactly like Thai government tells its people that Khmer Invaded Thailand over 100 years ago that why Khmer people are all over Thailand .
to 8:36 PM
You can keep kissing Hun Sen's ass as long as you like to . That's all I can say about you.
Khmer Ga

Anonymous said...

Areak Prey has been watching Chinese movies and thinking its real . I am wondering what he is doing to make a living.

Anonymous said...

I'm not a politician like Mr. Son Chhay, but let me try to understand what he's doing...

US, England, France, Russia and China are the only five countries with veto power at UN, meaning no UN resolution can be adopted if one of these five countries does not approve.

SRP supporters were/are protesting at UN to condem Hun Sen's government and want UN to intervene. Well, UN can not do anything if China object. Oh then, how do SRP supporters expect China to get onboard if their MP like Mr. Son Chhay is offending her!

Can anyone tell what Mr. Son Chhay is trying to accomplish now? Destroying SRP, perhaps!

Anonymous said...

SRP is full of idiots. From their top leader to their secondary leaders. If they are full of idiots and fools, how can they hope to win over the CPP!!

I tell you this, if you fuck with China, you are finish. Even the USA owed the Chinese billions dollars debt, and they are very careful with China now, even kissing China ass sometimes, they dare not offend that economic supper power.

Tibet is better to be with China. They receive millions of economic aid to develop their region. If they are on their own, with 90% of male population become monk, how can they improve their economy and develop their country. They will stay in stone age forever.

Anonymous said...

Ted Turner is wasting his billion giving to the UN of today. The future honorable UN needs to be established. It will contain no f* up regime like the Communist in charge. They don't deserve it.

Anonymous said...

As long as the word has mentality of Arak Prey, the world will never get anywhere, but give in to China and the more everyone will suffer greater consequence. Deosn't Arak Prey know that China kills? 2 millions and more of our people died, because of the Communist China and other country like Russia and Vietnam, yet we look the other way. Giving in isn't going to help and hear this Arak Prey,

You're holding a murderer's leg. It's just a matter of time that this monster will turn its head and change its mind about you and you will be finished! Do something!

Anonymous said...

I think Sam Rainsy should fire MP Son Chhay and appoints Areak Prey as his representative in the next election.

Anonymous said...

Compared to Son Chhay, politically Areak Prey is a kid who thinks he is an educated man..

Anonymous said...

oh oh, Watch out! ...<> is being drilled and nailed by <> now!

Anonymous said...

Oh oh, Watch out! ..."Areak Prey" is being drilled thru the back door and nailed by "Areak Srok" now! ROFL!!!

Anonymous said...

Oh oh, Watch out! ..."Areak Prey" is being drilled thru the back door and nailed to the floor by "Areak Srok" now! ROFL!!!

Anonymous said...

Dear Folks,
When you are adopting your life into politic, you have to play politic very well to protect your Nation and your people.
First you have to understand other country history well before you are trying to be judge of that country. China is a name of a country with 56 Nationalities which included Han, Tibetan, Xingjiang, Mongol innners, Manchury, Tuangjiang, Miaos, Li, etc.. etc..
People who are speaking Chao Zhou, Fujian, Gaungdong, Hainan, Madarin, Shanghainese etc.. and etc.. are Han Natinality and they are just part of Chinese citizen. Without these Tibetans, Mongols, and other, this great empire is not China anymore. Therefore, which Nationality has invaded which Nationality?
I just have a dinner with delegation from Lhaza last week. I ask them the same question if they want to separate from other Chinese nationlities? They told me that most tibetans are very prouded to be part of China to prosper.
They cannot be prospered as they are today without part of China as their region is a landlocked region and they used to suffer very badly as slavery society under their own people between 1911-1959. Each year, the central government of China has poured trillions of yuons to develop their region so that everyone can enjoy as dignity citizen. All their children have now enjoyed free education, free accommodation and free foods and have maintained very well their own culture and their own scripts.
Has Dalai Lama ever promoted Tibet to be fully independent from China ? Why your guys?
Dalai Lama has only demanded more authonomy from China which is presently adopted in Tibet. The Govenor of Tibet is presently Tibetan people.
China is now a powerfull country with all areas of economic, social, technology and military. China has built a net works of friendships all around the globe from Asia, afric, Americ, Europe and all pacific Nations. Can you tell which leader of which Nation dare to talk with China about Tibet? Why Son Chhay?
If you are very sure about this history, please write a Chinese history book and I tell you that you will find very hard a publisher to print your book unless you are printing in Cambodia and selling among your friends.

Areak Prey

Anonymous said...

នរណាក៏ដោយឲ្យតែយកព្រះមហាក្សត្ររបស់ប្រ
ទេសកម្ពុជាមកលេងសើចអ្នកនោះឯងនឹងវិនាស
នៅថ្ងៃណាមួយមិនខានឡើយទោះជាអ្នកជាពលរដ្ធ
ខ្មែរក៏ដោយ។សូមទេវតាបរាមុខពួកវាមួយម្ភៃបួនម៉ោង
អាពួកនេះបើតាមការគិតទៅនៅក្នុងផ្ទះរបស់ពួកវា
គឺគ្មានអាណាមួយស្គាល់ម៉ែស្គាល់ឪនោះទេ។អាពួកនេះមិនដែលចេះចូលនៅក្នុងសង្គមនឹងគេទេ
ហើយម្យ៉ាងវិញទៀតអាពួកនេះវាកើតមកសត្វ
តេរច្ឆានសុទ្ធសាទអាពួកនេះវាមិនដែលកើតមកពី
រន្ធរបស់ម៉ែវាទេវាកើតវាកើតដោយសារពេទ្យវះ
ម៉ែវាទេបានជាអាពួកនេះមិនចេះស្គាល់សង្គម
ចេះស្គាល់បងប្អូនស្គាល់អាក្រកស្គាល់ល្អវាស្គាល់តែក្តិតពួកអាបស្ចឹមប្រទេសប៉ុណ្ណឹងឯង។អាពួកនេះបើអាស្បែកសវាចង់ធើក្តិតម៉ែវាកូនស្រីវារួចវាសប្បាយចិត្តណាស់មានអាខ្លះមិនចង់កើតជាខ្មែរទេហើយមានអាខ្លះមិនឲ្យកូនវាយកខ្មែរគ្នាឯងធ្វើជាប្រពន្ធប្តីទេ។លុះពួកអាស្បែកសយកកូនពួកវាធើក្តិត
អស់ចិត្តរត់ចោលទៅបាត់ទើបបានពួកស្រែកថា
ខុសហើយ៕

Anonymous said...

Mr. Son Chhay please don't say you represent Cambodia, I am not with you in this game......I don't know how to say, you should ask to be removed your nationality and change to tibetian, but I am not sure many Tibetian want independence from China or not. Can I ask you a question? Are you american?

Anonymous said...

That's how democracy works. Keep doing a good job. Hun Sen can oppress the Cambodian people in Cambodia but NOT in the USA. All Cambodian have freedom to demonstration and send him messages said you are the dictatorship leader for a long time and you'll be out one of these day.

Anonymous said...

Hey you fucking Viet slave @3:41AM,

If you want to be Viet's slave for life, go ahead - it is your right, your freedom of choice, but do not drag the Cambodian people along with you or you will be eliminated from the face of this green planet earth. This is not a warning nor is it a threat but rather a promise to you!

[Connard, l’esclave des Viêts à 3:41 AM,
Si tu veux être l'esclave des Viêts à vie, vas-y: c'est ton droit, ta liberté de choix, mais ne pas essayer de prendre le peuple cambodgien libre avec toi ou tu seras éliminé de cette verte planète. Ce n'est pas un avertissement ni une menace mais plutôt une promesse sûre!]

ហេ អា/មី ងាប់ផុតពូជ ៣:៤១AM
បើ អា/មី ងាប់ផុតពូជឯងចង់ធ្វើខ្ញុំកញ្ជះយួនអស់
មួយជីវិតនោះ ក៏ធ្វើទៅ តែកុំមកបញ្ចុះបញ្ចូលនាំខ្មែរ
អ្នកជា ផ្សេងៗទៀតទៅជាមួយអា/មី ងាប់ផុតពូជ
ឯងអោយសោះ ពុំនោះសោតទេ អា/មី ងាប់ផុត
ពូជឯងនឹងត្រូវអ្នកស្នេហាជាតិសំឡាប់អោយផុត
ពូជបាត់ពីលើផែនដីខៀវស្រងាត់នេះទៅមិនខាន។
នេះមិនមែនជាពាក្យព្រមានសំឡុតគំរាមកំហែងឬ
បន្លាចនោះទេ តែវាជាពាក្យ សន្យាដ៏ពិតប្រាកដតែ
មួយម៉ាត់ប៉ុណ្ណោះសំរាប់អាផុតពូជឯង!!!

អញឪ អា ហ៊ុន សែន!

Anonymous said...

4.41amអាមួយនេះប្រហែលជាត្រូវរឿងវាហើយ
បានជាវាឆ្លងឆ្លើយមកវិញ។អាមួយនេះម៉ែវាថាសម្លាប់
វាចោលទៅតាំងទើបនឹងកើតមកក៏ប៉ុន្តែខ្ញុំបានសុំ
ម៉ែវាកុំធ្វើបាបវាអីទុកឲ្យវាធំឡើងក្រែងវាបានធ្វើនៅ
អំពើល្អប៉ុន្តែអាមួយនេះវាមិនចេះស្តាប់នរណាទេ
វាចង់ចូលតែគុកមួយថ្ងៃទល់មួយថ្ងៃពីព្រោះវា
មិនចេះធ្វើការបានល្អចំពោះប្រពន្ធកូនម៉ែឪវាទេ
អាមួយនេះដល់ពេលវាខឹងខ្លាំងវាចង់តែកាត់ក្តវាចោលទេកុំឲ្យធ្វើក្តិតអីកើតនឹងគេទឿតទៅអនាគត
អាមួយនេះវាចោតតាំងពីវានៅពីក្មេងម្លេះសូមបងប្អូនកុំខឹងនឹងវាសូមអរវរ។
ពីអញអ្នកជួយជីវិតអ្ហែង!!!!ហាស់ហាស់!!!
អាភ្លើ!!!

Anonymous said...

អា៦.៣០am(6:30AM)មួយនេះប្រហែលជាត្រូវរឿងវាហើយ
បានជាវាឆ្លងឆ្លើយមកវិញ។អាមួយនេះម៉ែវាថាសម្លាប់
វាចោលទៅតាំងទើបនឹងកើតមកក៏ប៉ុន្តែខ្ញុំបានសុំ
ម៉ែវាកុំធ្វើបាបវាអីទុកឲ្យវាធំឡើងក្រែងវាបានធ្វើនៅ
អំពើល្អប៉ុន្តែអាមួយនេះវាមិនចេះស្តាប់នរណាទេ
វាចង់ចូលតែគុកមួយថ្ងៃទល់មួយថ្ងៃពីព្រោះវា
មិនចេះធ្វើការបានល្អចំពោះប្រពន្ធកូនម៉ែឪវាទេ
អាមួយនេះដល់ពេលវាខឹងខ្លាំងវាចង់តែកាត់ក្តវាចោលទេកុំឲ្យធ្វើក្តិតអីកើតនឹងគេទឿតទៅអនាគត
អាមួយនេះវាចោតតាំងពីវានៅពីក្មេងម្លេះសូមបងប្អូនកុំខឹងនឹងវាសូមអរវរ។
ពីអញអ្នកជួយជីវិតអ្ហែង!!!!ហាស់ហាស់!!!
អាភ្លើ!!!

Anonymous said...

I would like to send a message to MP Son Chhay that now is not the right time to look far away yet. If you want to protect some bodies you have to think and calculate the depth of the occean first.
In your ship there are millions of Cambodian that need your leadership.
As you are one of the prominent politicient, wich option you are willing to sacrify your life for Cambodians people?By China's bullet or by viet's sword?

*viet's sword stained with Khmer's blood from 1975 up to this present in making Indichina Federations under viet controle and obviously to bite Chna as its's plan.

Anonymous said...

CPP said after the fall of POL POt that China was very ambitious and greedy and expansionist country. I never forget and they said Pol Pot was China's puppet. Now they ally with China. They make us as Cambodian confuse. They forget everything, they remember money for their own families and clan. They don't care Viet, China or America, what they care is about their pocket money and our Cambodian citizen have nothing just two eyes to cry.

I pray to the CPP leaders such as Hor Nam Hong, Ing You Tek Hor( Cham Praseth), Sok An to care of Khmer people and mind about their welfare and social well being if you are not thinking as your are Khmer but please think that you were born in Cambodia and this territory is your motherland. China or Viet don't consider you as their citizen because your ancestors escaped their own country of hunger and Cambodian land provide you and your ancestors to survive easily and even became rich. How about your next generations may be the Karma will punish them no land to survive because of all of your action against poor Cambodian. Don't revenge poor Khmer that used by Pol Pot, Viet or China.

On the other hand,I just let you know guy, Tibet has his own culture, his own language for long time like Cambodia,but Tibet was under colonies to some dynasties that ruled by foreigners such as Mongolia or Manchuria. Mongolia and Manchuria are not Chinese and they ruled China for many centuries. they also ruled Tibet. Under Ching Dynasty ruled by Manchuria, Tibet was independent but Communist Mao invaded Tibet again.

Anonymous said...

Whatever you ally with some countries or take their aids, please leaders think of our nation interests first. Because Cambodia is weak and small country we need aids,but we need to be assertive before signing contract. Don't think for your own and family interests before the nation's interests, the nation's future is under your own hands and your next generations would have no land to stand and you have no land for and your grave if you did wrong thing especially Hor nam Hong, Cham Praseth, Sok An because you are crazy intellectuals and if I don't make a mistake you are thinking that you are not Khmer. Don't forget Viet or China never put your name as their heros and you will be in the hell after you died and cannot spent a cent of your money from corruption and your next generations would blame you and you will die in a misery like Pol Pol. I'm not jealous of you it's the reality. I think you know what you are doing and you live with your conscience that blame you every day because of your greediness and corruption. Why I don't include Hun Sen because Hun's family are ignorant and illitteral but you are intellectual especially Sok An and Ing you Tek Hor. You werer a high grade student from ENA and Commerce. Where were your conscience.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.