Showing posts with label Bikkhu Tim Sakhorn's sentence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bikkhu Tim Sakhorn's sentence. Show all posts

Monday, November 19, 2007

Khmer Krom activist jailed for political agitation

Forum Asia
Asian Forum for Human Rights and Development


(Bangkok, 14 November 2007) Prominent Khmer Krom human rights defender and former Buddhist Abbot Tim Sa Khorn was by Vietnamese authorities for “sentenced on 9 November to one year in prisonundermining the solidarity between Cambodia and Vietnam”, according to a report by Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organisation (1).

This was his first appearance in public since he was detained in Vietnam, after being defrocked and deported by Cambodian authorities in June. The circumstances of his disappearance, detention, and sentencing were shrouded in secrecy, in what seems to be Cambodia and Vietnam’s latest attempt to repress unwelcome political activism and advocacy by the Khmer Krom.

The Khmer Krom are an indigenous people living in southern Vietnam. Khmer in ethnicity and Vietnamese in nationality, the Khmer Krom are victims of long-standing persecution by both Vietnamese and Cambodian authorities.

Tim Sa Khorn is an active member of the Khmer Krom community in Cambodia and has used his position as a Buddhist abbot to advocate Khmer Krom issues. He reportedly educated his temple’s followers about Khmer Krom history, distributed human rights material to Khmer Krom in Vietnam, and provided asylum for Khmer Krom refugees at his Pagoda. As a result of this ongoing and political activism, Tim Sa Khorn was targeted by the Vietnamese government, Cambodian authorities, and even factions within the Buddhist order in Cambodia.

In the wake of forced relocation by the Vietnamese government in 1979, Tim Sa Khorn fled to Cambodia at the age of 11. He became a Cambodian citizen, joined the Buddhist monkhood, and became the Abbot at Phnom Den Pagoda until he was defrocked under obscure circumstances in June.

The evidence of a conspiracy led Tim Sa Khorn to his imprisonment in Vietnam. Reportedly, the decision to disrobe him was influenced by the Vietnamese government and was based on grounds of “misconduct [which] impaired…solidarity between the two countries”.

In a letter dated 28 September 2007 to King Sihanouk, Prime Minister Hun Sen accused Tim Sa Khorn of violating a number of Buddhist rules, including violence and breaking his vow of celibacy (2). Hanoi claimed that Tim Sa Khorn is a Vietnamese citizen and is therefore liable for prosecution under Vietnamese law. Regardless of this claim, the fact that the Cambodian authorities deported a Cambodian citizen for imprisonment in Vietnam demonstrates the close relationship between the two.

FORUM-ASIA received information from other sources saying that the circumstances surrounding the sentencing of Tim Sa Khorn were also suspicious. The hearing was orchestrated as swiftly as possible, lasting only an hour. There was no defense lawyer present and no opportunity for appeal. In addition to his sentence, there were unconfirmed reports that he faces 14 years probation once his prison term concludes. It is unclear whether or not he will be returned to Cambodia after his sentence.

(1) http://www.unpo.org/article.php?id=7319
(2) http://www.khmerkrom.net/?q=node/1076

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Khmer Krom: Appeal For Fair Trial

2007-11-14
UNPO

The Hague, 8 November 2007 - Buddhist Abbot Tim Sa Khorn was brought before the People’s Court of Justice of the An Giang Province (Vietnam) today to be tried for “Sabotaging the unification policy” under Article 87 of Vietnam’s Penal Code

Tim Sa Khorn, a prominent Khmer Krom religious figure and human rights defender, had disappeared on 30 June 2007 after having been disrobed by the Cambodian religious authorities.

On the day of his disappearance, Tim Sa Khorn was summoned to the office of the religious head of the Takeo Province (Cambodia). Once arrived, he was disrobed in the presence of religious and lay officials who had come from the capital. He was not allowed to challenge this decision.

Eyewitnesses later saw men in uniforms force Tim Sa Khorn to enter a car. He had not been seen since this event, until his trial on 08 November 2007.

On 03 July 2007, a spokesperson for the Cambodian Minister of Interior announced that Tim Sa Khorn had returned to Vietnam of his own free will.

A month later, on 02 August 2007, the Vietnamese authorities announced that Tim Sa Khorn had been arrested for ‘illegally entering the country” but did not provide any information as to his health or whether he would be tried.

Despite numerous requests from UNPO and United Nations’ High Commissioner for Human Rights, the Vietnamese authorities have not disclosed information on the detention of Tim Sa Khorn.

With barely any forewarning, it was announced by Vietnamese authorities that he would stand trial on 08 November 2007. The trial lasted scarcely an hour. During the trial, Tim Sa Khorn was asked to repeat a text prepared in advance and read out by the judge. Following this, Tim Sa Khorn was sentenced to one year’s imprisonment.

Crucially, the defendant was denied appropriate legal representation and time to prepare and present his defence , including the opportunity to present his own witnesses or cross-examine prosecution witnesses. Moreover, despite Tim Sa Khorn and his family having been out of Vietnam since 1979, the witnesses whose testimonies were retained by the court against him were local Vietnamese citizens. Finally, it appears Tim Sa Khorn has been denied the right to appeal.

Holding the defendant incommunicado during his detention (more than four months) and denying repeated requests by his family (namely his father and brother) for visitation rights appears to be a grossly disproportionate and unjustified treatment, given the nature of the charges and the sentence.

By repeatedly refusing to release information on the case and announcing the trial with little prior notice to the international community, Vietnam has not demonstrated the levels of transparency consistent with the country’s commitment to human rights.

Given the information received, it is clear that Tim Sa Khorn did not receive a fair trial. Evidence strongly suggests that a number of articles of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), which Vietnam has ratified, were breached, including articles 9 and 14. These articles guarantee, amongst other things, the right to a timely trial, the right to contest one’s detention before a court, and the right to a fair trial with access to legal counsel, and the right to present and cross-examine witnesses.


UNPO therefore kindly appeals to the Vietnamese authorities to:
  • Grant Tim Sa Khorn the right to appeal the judgement enshrined in Article 14 of the ICCPR;
  • Grant Tim Sa Khorn access to legal counsel of his choosing;
  • Implement the full procedures and rights, as set out by the ICCPR, in any possible appeal or retrial, including legal representation for Tim Sa Khorn, the right to speak in his own defence, and the opportunity to present and cross-examine witnesses;
  • Allow visitation rights to Tim Sa Khorn whilst in detention.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Group of Cambodian MPs visiting Vietnam

Monday, November 12, 2007
By Kim Pov Sottan
Radio Free Asia

Translated from Khmer by Socheata

Committee No. 5 of the National Assembly (NA) which is in charge of foreign affairs, will start its visit to Vietnam on Tuesday in order to negotiate further for the release of former Monk Tim Sakhorn.

MP Son Chhay, Chairman of Committee No. 5, said that his group will persevere to meet with Monk Tim Sakhorn, and it will ask for the release of the former abbot in the name of the respect of the sovereignty between the two countries.

Son Chhay said: “… I want to take this opportunity during the visit to discuss and explain to each other, so that there is a new beginning in the recognition of important issues in the friendship that includes mutual respect starting from human rights respect. We will move quickly to Khleang province in order to visit Venerable Tim Sakhorn, whatever it will take, we need his release.”

This visit was agreed upon when the Vietnamese parliament delegation came to visit Cambodia at the beginning of September of this year.

The 8 MPs and 3 aids will spend 6 days in Hanoi and several other provinces located in Kampuchea Krom (South Vietnam).

The NA delegation plans to meet with top Vietnamese leaders to talk about the sovereignty of Cambodia, the rights issue of indigenous people, the construction of hydro-electrical dams in the Northern part of Vietnam which affects Cambodia. The delegation will visit Cambodia people living in Preah Trapaing and Kleang provinces, and it will also visit Monk Tim Sakhorn, the former abbot of Phnom Den pagoda who is currently jailed in Motr Chrouk province (An Giang in Vietnamese).

Elder Tim Thiem, the father of Monk Tim Sakhorn, who never had the chance to meet his son since his defrocking, is happy and hopeful about the NA delegation visit. Elder Tim Thiem said: “They should clearly review the state of health of my son, this would provide some feedback information for me also. Since my son was arrested, nobody talked much about this issue … I am asking (the NA delegation) to resolve this issue and provide justice (for my son), I only want his return back home, whatever happens to him, let him die here in Cambodia.”

The NA delegation visit is taking place after the former abbot of Phnom Den pagoda, Monk Tim Sakhorn, was sentenced by the Vietnamese authority to one year in jail, he was accused of undermining the solidarity between Cambodia and Vietnam.

All hopes will be pinned in one week time, after the NA delegation completes its visit to Vietnam.

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Monk Tim Sakhorn's case: Phnom Penh dare contradict Hanoi?

Ministry of Interior rejects responsibility in the case of Monk Tim Sakhorn

10 November 2007
By Kim Pov Sottan Radio Free Asia
Translated from Khmer by Socheata

On Saturday, following the publication by a Vietnamese newspaper in Can Tho accusing the Cambodian government of deporting Monk Tim Sakhorn and his subsequent sentencing by Vietnam, a high-ranking official from the Ministry of Interior (MoI) of the Cambodian government, said that the sentencing of Monk Tim Sakhorn was done by the Vietnamese tribunal, and it is a Vietnamese issue only, it does not involve Cambodia at all.

General Khieu Sopheak, MoI spokesman, said that Monk Tim Sakhorn wrote a letter asking to go live in Kampuchea Krom (South Vietnam) which is his birthplace and the Vietnamese government itself recognizes him as being a Vietnamese citizen.

General Khieu Sopheak said: “The MoI didn’t know, Mr. Tim Sakhorn declared himself to be a Vietnamese citizen, he wrote it with his own hand. I believe that the newspapers, when they write a story, they don’t know the entire story. However, we have a document which says that during his defrocking, he asks to go there (in Vietnam).”

Khieu Sopheak’s rejection was made after the Vietnamese Can Tho newspaper reported on Friday that Monk Tim Sakhorn was deported by the Cambodian government, and he entered Vietnam illegally, this then led to his one-year jail sentence stemming from his opposition to the Vietnamese solidarity policy.

Khieu Sopheak said that the one-year jail sentence handed down to Monk Tim Sakhorn is in fact a leniency offered by Vietnam to Cambodia, after Cambodia worked hard to intervene in the case,

The claim by the Cambodian authority that Monk Tim Sakhorn volunteered to go live in his native village, and the claim made by Vietnam saying that Monk Tim Sakhorn is a Vietnamese citizen, but that he entered Vietnam illegally (even though he is allegedly a Vietnamese citizen), all these claims are nothing but mumbo jumbo which led Monk Tim Sakhorn’s family, and Cambodian organizations and associations to accuse that the action taken against Monk Tim Sakhorn is nothing but a subterfuge used only to sentence Monk Tim Sakhorn.

Elder Tim Thiem, the father of Monk Tim Sakhorn, said that Monk Tm Sakhorn does not have any relative left in Kampuchea Krom any more, so there is no reason form him to return there by himself to be jailed there.

Elder Tim Thiem called the sentencing of Monk Tim Sakhorn, a severe injustice: “… They couldn’t find a real charge against him (Tim Sakhorn). I am his father who took care of him, furthermore, when he was still in school, he was ordained as a monk, I was in charge of all of that, but they create subterfuge like this, so I say that’s the end of it.” When asked if he was present in his son’s trial of not? Elder Tim Thiem said: “No, as I told you, I don’t want anyone to say anything about me, but I see that this is extremely unfair.”

Monk Tim Sakhorn, the former abbot of Phnom Den North pagoda in Takeo province, was sentenced to one year of jail based on the Vietnamese claim that they found several VCDs and magazines which oppose Vietnam, however, the Khmer Kampuchea-Krom Federation (KKF) rejected this Vietnamese claim.

On that same day, the US-based KKF indicated that it will pursue this case at the International Court of Justice to demand for the release of Tim Sakhorn.

Friday, November 09, 2007

Vietnam: Hun Sen's gov't deported and handed over Ven. Tim Sakhorn to Vietnam to be arrested and jailed there

The following is an unofficial English translation of the News in Vietnamese.

An Giang: The Trial of Tim Sakhorn regarding to the Crime of “Sabotaging the Unification Policy”

On November 8, the Court of People of An Giang province opened a trial of Tim Sakhorn regarding to the crime of “sabotaging the unification policy” in front of many people.

According to the board of the investigation of An Giang province: Tim Sakhorn, born in 1968 in Ba Chuc village, Tri Ton district, until 1978, he went to live at North Phnom Den, Kirivong province (Kampuchea). During the time at this temple, Tim Sakhorn received the documentation and money from the anti-Vietnam government organizations in exile to distribute 500 documents, 300 VCD disks with the contents against the Vietnamese government and to arouse the Khmer people in An Giang to file complaints, disturb the society. Until June 2007, Tim Sakhorn was deported by the Cambodia government and was arrested at the International Custom Tinh Bien (An Giang) for entering Vietnam illegally.

Because Tim Sa Khorn is remorseful and truthfully urged for forgiveness, the council of the judge sentenced him to 1 year in prison. Many people witnessed the trial and all agreed with the judgment.

Source: http://www.baocantho.com.vn/vietnam/dbscl/58590/

KKF: The trial of Venerable Tim Sakhorn is a mockery of justice

VENERABLE TIM SAKHORN TRIAL: A MOCKERY OF JUSTICE

PRESS RELEASE: 08 November 2007
Pennsauken, NJ, USA


On November 8, 2007, the Vietnam Court of An Giang Province brought Venerable Tim Sakhorn to the court for a trial after imprisoning him since June 30, 2007.

In June 2007, Venerable Tim Sakhorn was arrested, defrocked, and deported to Vietnam by Supreme Patriarch Tep Vong and the Cambodian government. Disturbing details reveal that Vietnam arrested and was interrogating Venerable Tim Sakhorn right the defrocking. Tim Sakhorn. Cambodia government were flip-flopping with the whereabouts of Venerable Tim Sakhorn.

On July 12, 2007, Venerable Tim Sakhorn was seen at a police station in Can Tho City and his whereabouts were reported to KKF. KKF promptly sent a report to the US State Department and other UN Human Rights organizations to notify them that Venerable Tim Sakhorn was being interrogated in Can Tho city, Vietnam.

On August 1, 2007, Vietnam admitted that it had arrested Venerable Tim Sakhorn for attempting to enter Vietnam illegally. However, instead of accusing Venerable Tim Sakhorn for the crime of entering the country illegally, Vietnam accused him for the crime of “Sabotaging the unification policy” under Article 87 of Vietnam’s Penal Code.

Faced with a lack of evidence for the above crime, Vietnamese officials proceeded to arrest and torture two Khmer-Krom women, Mrs. Neang Phe and Mrs. Neang De. They were forced to become witnesses and say that Venerable Tim Sakhorn was guilty. On August 23, 2007, the Khmer program of Radio Free Asia reported on how those two innocent Khmer-Krom women were threatened and tortured by the Vietnam authorities.

Venerable Tim Sakhorn is a Cambodian citizen. His parents and siblings currently live in Cambodia. If Vietnam intends to maintain credible diplomatic ties with Cambodia, its government should invite the representatives of the Cambodia government as well as Venerable Tim Sakhorn’s parents and siblings to attend the trial. None were presented at the trial. Is this a real friendship between Vietnam and Cambodia that Venerable Tim Sakhorn had tried to undermine or merely an excuse to halt human right movement? If Cambodia is an actually Independent country, why is Cambodia government scared to stand up to protect its own citizen?

Vietnam had tried to force Khmer-Krom famers including Mr. Chau In, to be a witness at the trial; however he refused to go because he felt that it was a set up. Mr. Chau In and other Khmer-Krom farmers have been filing complaints to demand returning their farmlands that have been confiscated by the Vietnamese authority. Instead of returning their farmlands back, Vietnam authority has used traditional dirty tactics to frame Mr. Chau In and other Khmer-Krom farmers and accused them of contacting Venerable Tim Sakhorn and contributes to undermining the relationship between Vietnam and Cambodia.

Khmer-Krom residents in An Giang province are aware that the Vietnamese government does not have a free and fair trial for Venerable Tim Sakhorn. Thus, many of the invited residents did not want to attend. At 4 a.m. of the November 8, 2007, the Vietnam authority sent a car to pick up Khmer-Krom Buddhist monks from a couple temples in Swaiton and Kro-Bao districts and some Khmer-Krom people to attend the trial to show to the world that Vietnam does allow Khmer-Krom to attend Venerable Tim Sakhorn trial.

At the trial, no lawyer was assigned to represent Venerable Tim Sakhorn and with no means to defend himself, the Vietnamese judge read the following,
“According to the judgment, Ven. Tim Sakhorn must be sentenced to 15 years. Since Tim Sakhorn admitted his crime (without letting him to defend himself), so he will be imprisoned for 1 year.”
In an attempt to make it legal so that they can imprison a Cambodia citizen, the Vietnamese judge proceeded to say,
“Since Tim Sakhorn was already imprisoned since June 30, Venerable Tim Sakhorn does not need to be in prison. Vietnam will take Tim Sakhorn around the country to see the development of Vietnam nowadays and will let him free after the one year sentence is over.”
Based on the judgment, Vietnam must be a “very big and very developed” country that's why it takes couple months for Ven. Tim Sakhorn to see all of it.

We are concerned about the safety and well being of Venerable Tim Sakhorn after this trial. There is no guarantee that Venerable Tim Sakhorn will not be placed in prison and be relocated to various provinces to avoid the truth being revealed.

The trial of Venerable Tim Sakhorn is a mockery of justice. It shows that the Khmer-Krom people have no rights to defend for themselves under the Vietnamese Communist regime. Not on one occasion did we hear the testimony of Venerable Tim Sakhorn since his arrest in Cambodia. It is also disconcerting to see the Cambodian government violating its own constitution by sending its own citizens to let other country judge and imprison. If Cambodia cannot protect its own citizen, especially the Khmer-Krom people who escaped the oppression of the Vietnamese Communist regime to live in Cambodia, then it should issue an official document to give Khmer-Krom people in Cambodia as refugee status so the UNHCR can protect them.

The Khmer-Krom people in Kampuchea-Krom will continue to be denied justice if they do not have the fundamental freedom as stated in international treaties and declarations. If Vietnam keeps violating the Human Rights of the Khmer-Krom people, the demand for the basic freedom of the Khmer-Krom people will never stop.

On behalf of the Khmer Krom people, we seek your help in an international cooperation to urge Vietnam to respect the Human Rights of the Khmer-Krom people, so the mockery trial as seen in Venerable Tim Sakhorn’s case will not happen again with the innocent Khmer-Krom people.

Respectfully Yours,

Thach Ngoc Thach
President of Khmers Kampuchea-Krom Federation