Showing posts with label Graft scandals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Graft scandals. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

BHP bribe scandal could involve Cambodian project

Cambodia's Minister for Water Resources, Lim Kean Hor, told the National Assembly BHP had paid $US2.5 million to the government to secure a bauxite mining concession. ''Lim Kean Hor is reported to have described this payment as 'tea money', an unofficial payment in Cambodia''
April 22, 2010
BARRY FITZGERALD AND MATHEW MURPHY
The Sydney Morning Herald (Australia)


BHP BILLITON'S blue-chip reputation has been tarnished by a foreign bribes scandal, believed to involve the group's abandoned bauxite exploration project in Cambodia where the payment of ''tea money'' to gain access to exploration ground is rife.

The scandal has been under investigation by the US Securities and Exchange Commission since August but only became ominous for BHP in a reputational sense yesterday when the Australian resources giant admitted the bribery claims could have merit.

BHP disclosed that its own internal investigation - a response to inquiries from the SEC - had uncovered evidence ''regarding possible violations of applicable anti-corruption laws involving interactions with government officials''.

It did not name the country or the now abandoned projects involved. While Cambodia was the popular tip by the non-government organisations that monitor the behaviour of the global miners in Third World countries, a nickel project in the Philippines was also mentioned by the organisations.

Either way, the revelations are a blow to BHP Billiton's need to maintain a squeaky clean corporate image while waiting on clearance from global regulators for its $US115 billion ($123 billion) iron ore production joint venture with Rio Tinto, a proposed deal that has angered the Chinese steel industry, the world's biggest. It was notable that while BHP would not name the country at the heart of the bribery scandal, it was prepared to volunteer that it was not China.

''We are limited in what we can comment on as the matter is still under investigation,'' it said.

''However, we can confirm that the SEC's requests for information primarily relate to certain terminated minerals exploration projects and not any activity in China, BHP Billiton's marketing activities or the sale of any of the company's products.''

Rio itself has suffered damage to its reputation in recent weeks. Last month China jailed four iron ore traders, including the Australian citizen Stern Hu, for accepting bribes and stealing commercial secrets. They were sentenced to between seven and 14 years' jail.

BHP is being assisted in the investigation by the New York law firm Davis Polk & Wardell. BHP would not comment on whether any of its employees had been stood down pending completion of the inquiry.

The bombshell was contained on the third page of an exploration and development report to the stock exchange for the March quarter.

BHP believes it was not obliged to make an earlier disclosure on the SEC investigation. But it now considers it relevant information - at least in the context of announcing in the exploration and development report - following its more recent discovery of possible anti-corruption violations.

''The company is co-operating with the relevant authorities including conducting an internal investigation, which is continuing. It is not possible at this time to predict the scope or duration of the investigation or its likely outcome,'' BHP said.

Under the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, BHP could be fined up to $US2 million while ''officers, directors, stockholders, employees, and agents are subject to a fine of up to $US100,000 and imprisonment for up to five years''.

The laws were introduced in the 1970s after more than 400 US companies admitted making questionable or illegal payments to foreign government officials to secure favourable treatment.

In a report by the British advocacy group Global Witness, published in February last year, the group cites a 2007 article in The Cambodian Daily which says that Cambodia's Minister for Water Resources, Lim Kean Hor, told the National Assembly BHP had paid $US2.5 million to the government to secure a bauxite mining concession.

''Lim Kean Hor is reported to have described this payment as 'tea money', an unofficial payment in Cambodia,'' the report says.

BHP rejected the claim in a letter in November 2008 to Global Witness saying the money was used for a social development program. ''In … terms of the minerals exploration agreement with the Cambodian government, which granted BHP Billiton and Mitsubishi the right to explore for bauxite, an amount of $US1 million was formally paid to the Cambodian government in September 2006,'' BHP wrote.

''If the money appears elsewhere … it is not clear where,'' the Global Witness report said. ''This raises questions as to where BHP Billiton's $US1 million payment made in September 2006 has gone.''

Friday, February 22, 2008

World Bank boss farewells Cambodia with warning on future growth

Phnom Penh Post, Issue 17 / 03, February 8 - 21, 2008

Indian born Nisha Agrawal arrived in Cambodia as country manager for the World Bank in April 2003 to find herself eventually thrust into the bank’s biggest ever confrontation with the government of Cambodia over corruption. The problems culminated in June 2006 in the dramatic ten month suspension of funds for three World Bank projects. The ban was lifted in February 2007, but the bank cancelled over $2.5 million in project funding and the government subsequently was asked to repay the World Bank $2.9 million. The bank has since hired Crown Agents, a British company, to handle procurement in their Cambodia projects. At the end of February, Agrawal will leave the World Bank after 18 years to go back to India and take the helm of a new NGO, Oxfam India. In an interview with the Post’s Susan Postlewaite on February 7, the director discussed the highs and lows of her five-year tenure at the Bank, which, with a budget of $50 million, is one of Cambodia’s most influential development partners.

What do you count as the accomplishments of your five years as country manager for Cambodia?

Four things. Firstly we have done a lot of research that has generated very useful knowledge about what is happening in the Cambodian economy. Before I came we really didn’t know whether the growth that Cambodia has seen in the last decade was having an impact on poverty or not. The Poverty Report was a very important piece of work by the World Bank to show that growth was actually benefiting poor people and that their lives were getting better off as a result.

Secondly, a very big thing is helping Cambodia agree on the priorities for reform and supporting the reforms that are happening.

Third, the way the development community works together has changed very dramatically and the World Bank has played a key role in bringing all the donors together around a common agenda. When I came here everybody had different priorities. We helped put in place a very elaborate architecture – 18 technical groups which meet and talk together with the government, with NGOs, with the development partners. We have quarterly meetings at senior levels of the government to discuss major policy issues.

Finally, the World Bank has built a very strong and large country office. When I came we were about five people and now we are 45 and most of these are Cambodian staff, and very high capacity staff.

What do you leave for your successor? What needs to be done?

During my five years, the economy has almost doubled in size, and government revenues have almost doubled in size. Foreign investment has taken off and is now larger than foreign aid for the first time. The challenge ahead is to ensure there’s also high quality development going on at the same time as a high growth rate. These would be the things my successor would focus on. Cambodia after ten years has been having an impact on poverty but only about one percent of the population is being lifted out of poverty per year. Vietnam is able to raise four percent of its population out of poverty each year. The difference is the emphasis that Vietnam has on agriculture.

The second challenge is how to make sure the growth is not coming at the cost of just cannibalizing your natural resources. One big choice the government faces is in the mining sector. How the government decides to do mining in the future will have a big impact on how sustainable it will be. These debates should happen very openly and transparently. Do Cambodians really want to be mining everywhere including in the national parks, or do they value their national parks?

A second choice is on how to manage the oil and gas revenues. That is a huge challenge. Suppose there are these large orders of magnitude that people are talking about. How they are managed would really make or break this country. If the government doesn’t use those revenues well, Cambodia could go down a very bad path where the revenues not only kill off other industry and employment, but corruption levels rise to such a level that everything else could fall apart.

The World Bank has come under heavy criticism – from The Wall Street Journal and others – for allowing corruption in its programs in Cambodia. Are you satisfied that you’ve corrected the problems?

We are making a huge effort to make sure that funds from our own projects don’t leak. Our projects are implemented by the government and supervised by us. The biggest problem was in the way procurement was done and who got the contracts. Because there were systematic problems in procurement, we are taking a two-track approach to deal with this issue: in the short-run, all procurement will be done by an independent procurement agent, while in the medium to long term, we will work with government to build and strengthen their systems.

Ultimately it should not be just about whether the World Bank money is leaking or not, but it should be about the country’s own spending. Our funds in this country are $50 million a year. What we would like to do is work with the government to improve their procurement and financial management system in the long run to make sure that the whole $1.2-billion budget is spent wisely.

In retrospect was your decision to suspend disbursement on three World Bank projects in 2006 and then to reinstate the funding ten months later the most effective way to handle the corruption problem?

It was the best way. It was tough on our relationship with the government because it’s a very drastic measure to take. But once we have evidence that our funds are leaking, we really have no other choice but to halt disbursement while we put in place measures to prevent those kinds of leakages in the future. We wanted to send a very strong signal in this country that we are not going to tolerate corruption in our projects and the suspension did that. Many people in Cambodia felt reassured that the Bank was taking this issue very seriously.

Thursday, August 09, 2007

World Bank chief: stealing aid money is unacceptable [-A warning to the family of the thieves of the Khmer Nation]

TOKYO, Aug 9 (Reuters) - World Bank President Robert Zoellick on Thursday spoke out against corruption in poor countries that receive the bank's loans, echoing the anti-graft stance of his controversial predecessor, Paul Wolfowitz.

"If people are trying to steal the World Bank's money, we can't accept that," Zoellick told reporters.

"We are responsible to our contributors and the contributors have their taxpayers. Nobody wants their money stolen," he said at a news conference wrapping up his visit to Japan, the bank's second-largest shareholder.

Zoellick, visiting Asia for the first time as World Bank chief, said while countries have different views on how to tackle corruption, they do agree on the need to deal with the problem.

He added that some developing countries would need the bank's support in building social infrastructure, such as a solid judiciary system, to fight corruption.

Wolfowitz, who resigned earlier this year over a scandal involving the promotion of his companion, alarmed some African nations and even those within the bank with his strict anti-corruption drive, which critics feared would slow the flow of aid to the poor.

Zoellick himself has said little about whether he will stick with that strategy or change the way the bank approaches corruption in borrowing countries.

His five-year tenure begins in the middle of the bank's critical year-long fund-raising for its lending programs to its poorest borrowers, which will set the course of the bank for the next three years starting mid-2008.

Zoellick, a former U.S. chief trade negotiator and deputy secretary of state, stopped in Australia, Cambodia and Vietnam before arriving in Japan, a major donor of international development aid.

Zoellick said one of the key purposes of his visit was to urge Japan to maintain or even increase aid despite tight budgetary conditions. He added that the government officials he met expressed support and understanding for his request.

Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and Finance Minister Koji Omi were among the policymakers Zoellick met during his visit.

Sunday, August 05, 2007

Zoellick arrives for talks expected to focus on corruption and graft scandals

Zoellick arrives for talks in Cambodia

Sunday, 5 August, 2007
AFP
“This visit is an opportunity for Robert Zoellick to set the tone for his presidency and lay the foundations for the Bank’s approach to kleptocratic governments everywhere” - Global Witness
PHNOM PENH: World Bank president Robert Zoellick arrived in Cambodia yesterday for talks expected to focus on corruption in the impoverished kingdom and bank-supported projects hit by graft scandals.

Zoellick, who took office in July, is to meet with Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen today on his first visit to the kingdom. He is also supposed to travel to rural areas to see the bank’s development projects.

But his visit comes as Cambodia continues paying back millions of dollars siphoned off in a massive corruption scandal that forced the World Bank to suspend three key aid projects last year.

The projects have since been reinstated, but the bank has demanded Cambodia repay some $2.9mn after contractual irregularities involving agricultural and flood prevention funds were uncovered.

The issue sparked a row with the Hun Sen government, which initially refused to repay, saying the World Bank must provide more evidence of financial irregularities.

A major environmental group, which published a damning report in June accusing Cambodia’s political elite of illegally plundering the country’s forests, on Friday urged Zoellick to address corruption during his two-day visit.

“This visit is an opportunity for Robert Zoellick to set the tone for his presidency and lay the foundations for the Bank’s approach to kleptocratic governments everywhere,” Global Witness said in a statement.

Officials said Zoellick was also expected to visit the Khmer Rouge’s notorious Tuol Sleng prison, a former high school that was converted into a torture centre during the 1975-79 communist regime.

Cambodia, which is plagued by corruption at almost every level of government, also fell foul of the World Bank in 2003, when graft was uncovered in a project to demobilise some 30,000 soldiers.