Showing posts with label Hun Sen's regime in denial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hun Sen's regime in denial. Show all posts

Thursday, April 29, 2010

ANALYSIS: Graft likely to remain dominant feature in Cambodia

The corruptor-in-chief? (Photo: AFP)

Thu, 29 Apr 2010

By Robert Carmichael
DPA


Phnom Penh - Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen this week told a gathering of business leaders and government officials in Phnom Penh that there was no corruption in a deal by mining giant BHP Billiton Ltd, which pulled out of the country last year.

BHP Billiton, which is not saying much, is being investigated by the authorities in the United States and Britain for possible corruption offences. A number of media reports have cited Cambodia as one country where it might have paid bribes.

"They say that the company that explored for bauxite gave money illegally to Cambodia," Hun Sen was quoted as saying in the Phnom Penh Post newspaper. "We should ask: How can they bribe? It cannot be possible."

However, that seeming impossibility is well in line with international perceptions of the impoverished nation. Corruption monitor Transparency International rated Cambodia as one of the world's most corrupt countries, placing it 158th out of 180 countries with first spot going to the least corrupt country.

And you do not need to look hard in Phnom Penh to see the fruits of corruption. The streets are full of luxury vehicles, often driven by government employees whose official monthly earnings are just a few hundred dollars yet who live in expensive homes.

No one knows how much is siphoned off each year, but the US ambassador provided some indication last year - and riled the government - when she publicly said that graft costs Cambodia 500 million US dollars annually. That is around one-quarter of the national budget.

Cambodians are well aware of the problem. A 2007 study by independent market researchers Indochina Research examined attitudes toward corruption and found it is pervasive.

The report, called Perceiving and Fighting Corruption in Cambodia, noted that government employees routinely pay to get their low-paid jobs which means they need to extort money to recoup their "investment."

Half the respondents in the study blamed government salaries of less than 100 dollars a month as the main cause of corruption although they also pointed to greed and lust for power.

But likely the most significant finding was that Cambodia's judiciary was perceived as the most corrupt body. It is hard to fight graft when the mechanism needed to solve corruption is its biggest obstacle.

"Rigorous law enforcement must go together with salary improvement: The former is considered a necessary factor to reduce corruption," the report concluded. "This is a challenge given that the judiciary is unanimously considered the peak of corruption."

The extent and importance of graft explains why it has been on the donor reform wish list for 15 years. Finally in March, there was some good news when parliament passed a law the government claimed would combat the scourge.

But the law's many critics were not persuaded. They said the law is weak and flawed and maintained that political will to act against corruption is lacking.

But the new law does have some supporters. Bertrand de Speville is a leading international anti-corruption specialist and until 1996 headed Hong Kong's Independent Commission Against Corruption.

De Speville said a successful anti-corruption drive requires three elements: enforcement of the law, measures to prevent corruption and educating people about it.

"Their close coordination is the key," he said via e-mail. "Each of them is essential [and] they are interdependent - a success in any one of them enhances the other two."

But he warned that neglecting one would see the effort fail and added that political will is the "first essential."

De Speville was broadly positive about Cambodia's new law, saying it "provides a reasonably sound foundation" to combat graft, but he also pointed out some problems.

"The declaration of assets and liabilities regime is of very limited value," he said by way of example. "It fails to meet its true objective, namely the identification of conflicts of interests, and does not require declaration of the assets of spouses, parents and children."

Chea Vannath, an independent analyst and prominent campaigner against corruption, echoed de Speville's emphasis on education. So does she think the law is strong enough and the political will exists to make it work?

"Not in the near future because we are talking about reform, and for reform, you need a critical mass to make things change," Chea Vannath said. "[But] if among people in government [there are those] with a strong willingness to fight corruption, we might see hope."

Vaguely, Ministry Lambastes Embassies

Hor 5 Hong (AFP)

Kong Sothanarith, VOA Khmer
Phnom Penh Wednesday, 28 April 2010

“They indulged themselves to criticize or to give lessons to the Royal Government of Cambodia. Such behaviors are not acceptable for Cambodia as a sovereign country and a member of the United Nations,” the note said, adding, “Cambodia is not a ‘BANANA REPUBLIC.’”
Son Chhay said the note could have something to do with a potential probe by the US Securities and Exchange Commission into allegations of corruption between Australian mining giant BHP Billiton and the government
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued an unexplained letter to embassies on Tuesday, reminding them not to interfere in the internal affairs of state.

The note was a sharp reprimand in diplomatic terms, but it was not addressed to any specific mission. It was issued to embassies throughout Phnom Penh.

“There have been many occasions, in which some heads of diplomatic missions behaved like a ‘Proconsul’ of his/her country to the Kingdom of Cambodia,” the ministry said in its note, without naming a specific country.

“They indulged themselves to criticize or to give lessons to the Royal Government of Cambodia. Such behaviors are not acceptable for Cambodia as a sovereign country and a member of the United Nations,” the note said, adding, “Cambodia is not a ‘BANANA REPUBLIC.’”

The ministry said diplomatic protocols called for envoys to avoid interfering in the affairs of a host country, “regardless of the power of his or her home country.”

Ministry spokesman Koy Kuong said some diplomats had previously exceeded the limit of their mandate, but he declined to give an example.

Cambodia relies heavily on aid from donor countries, who contribute about half of its national budget each year.

Officials at the French, US and Vietnamese embassies declined to comment Wednesday. Other embassy officials could not be reached for comment.

Opposition lawmakers and rights workers on Wednesday said they had been unable to ascertain the meaning of the note.

However, Sam Rainsy Party parliamentarian Son Chhay said the note could have something to do with a potential probe by the US Securities and Exchange Commission into allegations of corruption between Australian mining giant BHP Billiton and the government.

Kek Galabru, president of the rights group Licadho, said Cambodia needs the advice of foreign countries.

“The government should accept the recommendations of those countries to make Cambodia a country of the rule of law, respect for human rights and the application of democratic rule,” she said.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Cambodia tells diplomats it is no 'banana republic'

Wednesday, April 28, 2010
AFP

PHNOM PENH — The Cambodian government has told all foreign diplomatic envoys to avoid criticising the country, insisting it is not a "banana republic", in a letter seen by AFP Wednesday.

The foreign ministry letter sent to all diplomatic missions in Cambodia asked them to "avoid interfering in the internal affairs" of the country, regardless of the power of their home nations.

"There have been many occasions, in which some heads of diplomatic missions behaved like a 'proconsul' of his/her country to the Kingdom of Cambodia. They indulged themselves to criticise or to give lessons to the Royal Government of Cambodia," the letter said.

"Such behaviours are not acceptable for Cambodia as a sovereign country and a member of the United Nations. Cambodia is not a BANANA REPUBLIC," it added.

Asked about the letter dated April 26, foreign ministry spokesman Koy Kuong told AFP it was issued to remind all diplomats not to "exceed the limit of their mandate".

Cambodia last month threatened to expel a United Nations envoy if UN agencies continued "unacceptable interference" in the country.

The move came after UN agencies in Cambodia urged "a transparent and participatory" process as parliament debated an anti-corruption law that was criticised by the opposition and rights groups.

Ranked one of the world's most corrupt countries, Cambodia passed the anti-graft law in parliament on March 11, more than 15 years after legislation was first proposed, but only days after the draft was shared publicly.

Cambodian government warns foreign embassies not to criticise it

Wed, 28 Apr 2010
DPA

Phnom Penh - A Cambodian government spokesman on Wednesday warned foreign embassies and institutions against criticising the authorities or interfering in internal affairs.

The comments came one day after the Ministry of Foreign Affairssent a blunt letter to embassies complaining that some mission heads had behaved like proconsuls in giving lessons to the government.

"Such behaviours are not acceptable for Cambodia as a sovereign country," the letter stated. "Cambodia is not a BANANA REPUBLIC."

Ministry spokesman Koy Kuong said the purpose was to remind diplomats to adhere to the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which prohibits interference in the internal affairs of host nations.

"We cannot accept lessons like lectures from foreign envoys and diplomats," Koy Kuong said. "We cannot accept any negative criticism."

The letter followed a statement last month by the United Nations country head Douglas Broderick calling on the government to allow more time for civil society and donors to comment on a long-awaited draft anti-corruption law.

Cambodia is ranked by Transparency International as one of the most corrupt countries in the world.

The law, 15 years in the making, was made public just days before being pushed through parliament, which is dominated by the ruling party.

Broderick's statement infuriated Phnom Penh, and the government threatened to expel him for meddling in legislative matters.

Koy Kuong refused to name the missions which had earned the government's wrath.

"We do not specify, and we do not focus on a specific case," he said. "I would rather not say a specific country or institution. We just remind them of the contents of the Vienna Convention."

Cambodia relies heavily on donors for funding. Foreign nations provided 951 million dollars in 2009, or roughly half of the government's budget.

Saturday, November 14, 2009

US asked to take tough action on Cambodian human rights [-Cambodia in denial]

Opposition leader Sam Rainsy will be the third member of parliament to lose his immunity this year following an allegedly pulling out border markers with Vietnam (Photo: Eurasie)
Hang Chakra (Photo: Sok Serey, RFA)

By Chun Sakada, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
13 November 2009


A prominent US human rights group on Friday urged the US to take tough action on Cambodia for its harsh moves against government critics.

“Human Rights Watch urges [US President] Obama to openly challenge Prime Minister Hun Sen’s increasing authoritarian practices, in which he and other ruling party officials use violence, threats, and the country’s notoriously corrupt judiciary to silence and imprison opposition party members, journalists, land rights activists, and other government critics,” Human Rights Watch said in a statement.

The statement was made just two days before President Barack Obama is due to meet Asean leaders on Sunday, after attending the annual Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum in Singapore.

“This statement is unrealistic and untrue. It has a political intention to attack the government,” said Phay Siphan, secretary of state and spokesman for the Council of Ministers.

Phay Siphan said that what was raised in the statement is ruthless and not honest with a “bad intention to unfairly slander the government of Cambodia”.

But opposition party welcomes the statement.

“I thank Human Rights Watch for helping to remind the US President Barack Obama who is the leader of a superpower to pay attention to the rights and freedom of Cambodian people and democracy in Cambodia,” said Kem Sokha, president of the Human Rights Party, calling the government to accept criticism.

Opposition leader Sam Rainsy will be the third member of parliament to lose his immunity this year following an allegedly pulling out border markers with Vietnam. Two other opposition parliamentarians Mu Sokhua and Ho Vann have been stripped off their immunity for criticizing premier Hun Sen and military officers.

The editor of an opposition Khmer Mchas Srok newspaper was sentenced to one year jail term for writing on corruption issues.

Monday, June 15, 2009

Do Khmers really love Khmers?

Monday, 15 June 2009
Written by Ambassador Julio A Jeldres
Letter to The Phnom Penh Post

Dear Editor,

Reading the article "Deputy Governor faults land-grabbing report as biased, un-Cambodian", (June 9) made me realise with sadness that Cambodian government officials do not seem to appreciate that by continuing to hide evictions beneath the banner of development, they are pushing the people being evicted to desperate actions that may lead to instability.

The Licadho report is a compassionate, well-researched, factual and moving report on the plight of the people who have lost their land through forced evictions by powerful elites that control today's Cambodia.

It is becoming more and more common for Cambodian officials to respond to factual criticism on forced land grabbing, corruption and other violations of human rights as "foreign interference in Cambodia's internal affairs".

The logo "No one loves Khmer more than Khmer" is becoming the fashionable mantra of the government's response to any critical remark to its actions. I often wonder if this "No one loves Khmer more than Khmer" really comes from the heart of the officials who use it.

Otherwise, how do you explain the violent deaths of Piseth Pilika, Chea Vichea and so many other Khmers?
Yet, while Cambodian officials become more and more "anti-foreigner", they do not seem to have any compunction to constantly request further funds from foreign countries, which continue to support the Cambodian government's request for assistance because of their genuine concern for the welfare of the people of Cambodia.

The contemptuous manner in which Professor Yash Ghai, the former special representative of the UN Secretary General for Human Rights, and Ms Carol Rodley, the US Ambassador to Cambodia, have been treated by government officials for drawing attention to genuine violations of human rights, such as land grabbing, and other problems such as the corruption affecting the livelihood of the less privileged of Cambodia, is morally wrong, historically unsound and totally unacceptable.

Cambodian government officials need to understand that foreign governments, in particular the signatories of the 1991 Paris Agreements who are the guarantors of the Cambodian people's rights, cannot remain silent in front of so much injustice.

Likewise, we ordinary citizens of the countries that provide multiform assistance to Cambodia, contribute through our taxes to the national reconstruction of Cambodia and, therefore, have the right to expect our respective governments not to remain silent when these continuous violations of human rights take place in Cambodia.

Ambassador Julio A Jeldres
Adjunct Research Fellow
The Asia Institute, Monash University