Showing posts with label Kleptocracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kleptocracy. Show all posts

Saturday, June 13, 2009

Obama okays U.S. Exim bank loans for Cambodia, Laos

Fri Jun 12, 2009

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President Barack Obama has cleared the way for the U.S. Export-Import Bank to help finance exports of U.S. goods to Laos and Cambodia, the White House said on Friday.

Obama issued a pair of memorandums saying each of the two Southeast Asian nations has "ceased to be a Marxist-Leninist country," as defined under the 1945 Export-Import Bank Act.

"This designation will now allow U.S. companies to apply for financing thru the US Export-Import bank, which provides working capital guarantees, export credit insurance and loan guarantees," the White House spokesman said.

The policy change in is response to the commitment of both countries to open up their markets, the spokesman said.

It comes as some in Congress are pressing for renewal of U.S. trade sanctions on another Southeast Asian nation, Myanmar, which has charged pro-democracy advocate Aung San Suu Kyi with violating the terms of her house arrest. She faces a maximum five-year term if found guilty of the charges.

Cambodia and Laos, with a combined population of more than 20 million, are small markets for the United States.

Last year, the United States exported $154 million worth of goods to Cambodia and just $18 million to Laos.

U.S. imports of mostly clothing and other textiles from Cambodia totaled more than $2.4 billion last year. The United States bought $42 million worth of goods from Laos in 2008.

(Reporting by Doug Palmer and Ross Colvin; editing by Todd Eastham)

US removes Laos, Cambodia from trade blacklist [-Cambodia is no longer a Marxist-Leninist country ... it is now a Kleptocracy!]

Saturday, June 13, 2009

WASHINGTON (AFP) — US President Barack Obama on Friday removed Laos and Cambodia from a blacklist, opening the way for US loans to companies doing business in the former US adversaries.

In brief declarations, Obama said Cambodia and Laos had each "ceased to be a Marxist-Leninist country," a designation that prevents financial support by the US Export-Import Bank.

The move, which still must go through formalities, means that US businesses would be eligible for US government-backed loans and credit guarantees as they can receive when operating in most countries.

"Given the commitment of Cambodia and Laos to open markets, the president has determined that this designation is no longer applicable," an Obama administration official said.

But the decision to boost trade ties with Laos came under criticism from campaigners for the Hmong minority, a hill people who supported US forces during the Vietnam War and recount retaliatory abuse decades later.

A recent report by Paris-based Medicins Sans Frontieres, or Doctors Without Borders, said Hmong who fled since 2005 to Thailand have said they suffered killings, gang-rape and malnutrition at the hands of Laotian forces.

Obama's declaration "is completely shocking and outrageous," said Philip Smith, executive director of the Center for Public Policy Analysis, which promotes Hmong rights.

"This is a one-party regime which is closely allied with Burma (Myanmar) and North Korea," he said. "This will embolden the Laos government to continue to slaughter and massacre civilians."

Many Hmong are still in hiding in Laos. Another 250,000 Hmong have resettled in the United States.

The United States established normal trade relations with Laos in 2004, part of an effort under then president George W. Bush to reconcile after years of friction.

US relations with Cambodia have been marred by US concerns over accounting for Khmer Rouge war crimes along with corruption. Washington lifted all remaining restrictions on assistance to Cambodia in 2007.

The United States still forbids US-backed loans to businesses to operate in six countries -- Cuba, Iran, Myanmar, North Korea, Sudan and Syria.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Somdech Ta and the Kleptocracy in Cambodia

Monday, February 9, 2009
Op-Ed by Khmer Young
On the web at http://cambodianbrightfuture.blogspot.com


Today, Somdech Ta's BMD clip has intrigued my concerns. Somdech Ta has tried to show his gut in fighting against Lon Nolians, and tried to flatter those who are serving his interests.

Of course, Somdech Ta has learned nothing through recent progress of world politics particularly the appearance of globalization. Somdech Ta is still esteeming his past and revenging his eternal enemies, and boasting his current supporter regardless of what their behavior worse would be. This is very pathetic for Somdech Ta who is not only old of age, but old of vision and wisdom.

More than this, his admiring to those current Cambodian top leaders who have personally donated money for him to use for personal purposes. What is a very uneducated statement and admiration of Somdech Ta is that he has never interested the good source of those money donated by those top leaders of Cambodia. To be sure, Somdech Ta should think that is those money legal or illegal? But Somdech Ta is happy with this donation and wealth donated to him. It is truly an ugly money that good leaders will not suck blood of their own people for their own interests.

Cambodia has been listed by the international transparency as a most corrupted country. The same leaders who are clinging to power like Hun Sen and his group will exacerbate the corruption phenomena in Cambodia.

When Somdech Ta is admiring these leaders, it means Somdech Ta himself had practiced this way to gain personal accumulation in the past or present time. Somdech Ta might not interest in anti-corruption and the transparent leadership improvement for Cambodia.

Somdech Ta's statement and admiration has well illustrated the continual nepotism, patronage embedding, kleptocracy, and predatory state in Cambodia. Hun Sen has learned so well from Somdech Ta and he is continued to grab in power till his death arrives like Somdech Ta will cling to the titling as Cambodian Father until his death arrives.

How Cambodia can move forward in a very constructive way when Cambodian leaders are self-interest clinger like this?

KY

Saturday, April 26, 2008

Khmer Intelligence News - 25 April 2008

25 April 2008
KHMER INTELLIGENCE NEWS

U.S. Congress considers Phnom Penh regime a "kleptocracy" and denies entry visas to corrupt Cambodian officials (1)

House Resolution # 2764 dated January 4, 2007. Section "Anti-Kleptocracy":

Sec. 699L. (a) In furtherance of the National Strategy to Internationalize Efforts Against Kleptocracy and Presidential Proclamation 7750, the Secretary of State shall compile and maintain a list of officials of foreign governments and their immediate family members who the Secretary determines there is credible evidence to believe have been involved in corruption relating to the extraction of natural resources in their countries.

(b) Any individual on the list submitted under subsection (a) shall be ineligible for admission to the United States.

Senate Report # 110-128 dated July 10, 2007 from the Committee on Appropriations (To accompany H.R. 2764):

Cambodia. (…) The Committee urges the Administration to exercise Presidential Proclamation 7750 to prohibit corrupt Cambodian officials identified in the June 2007 Global Witness report [about deforestation] entitled "Cambodia's Family Trees: Illegal Logging and the Stripping of Public Assets by Cambodia's Elite" from entering the United States. The Committee encourages other countries, particularly in Europe and Asia, to implement similar restrictions. [Prime Minister Hun Sen sits on the top of the "Family Trees" described by the UK-based Global Witness environmental organization].

Subsequently, "The [House] Appropriation Committees endorse language in Senate Report 110-128 regarding corrupt Cambodian officials and Presidential Proclamation 7750."

Human Rights Watch recalls Hun Sen's involvement in the 1997 deadly grenade attack (1)

In their March 30, 2008 statement entitled "Cambodia: Infamous Grenade Attack Still Unpunished – FBI Should Revive Probe of Alleged Perpetrators Promoted by Hun Sen", the New York-based Human Rights Watch organization recalled: On June 29, 1997, the Washington Post wrote:

"In a classified report that could pose some awkward problems for U.S. policymakers, the FBI tentatively has pinned responsibility for the blasts, and the subsequent interference, on personal bodyguard forces employed by Hun Sen, one of Cambodia's two prime ministers, according to four U.S. government sources familiar with its contents. The preliminary report was based on a two-month investigation by FBI agents sent here under a federal law giving the bureau jurisdiction whenever a U.S. citizen is injured by terrorism. … The bureau says its investigation is continuing, but agents involved reportedly have complained that additional informants here are too frightened to come forward [given the atmosphere of fear and intimidation prevailing in Cambodia]."

Human Rights Watch concluded: "The FBI was close to solving the case when its lead investigator was suddenly ordered out of the county by the U.S. ambassador, Kenneth Quinn. The FBI has damning evidence in its files that suggests that Prime Minister Hun Sen ordered the attack, but it has refused to fully cooperate with congressional enquiries or follow through on its initial investigation. Instead of trying to protect U.S. relations with Cambodia, it should now finish what it started."

One can hope that the new U.S. President to be elected later this year will order the FBI to complete its job for the sake of justice.

Cambodian opposition to unite against Hun Sen (2)

There are increasing indications that the Cambodian opposition made up of more than fifty political parties is considering forming a united front against the authoritarian and corrupt Hun Sen regime. However, efforts are first being made to identify some newly created parties that are in fact working for, and being protected and paid, by the Hun Sen's ruling Cambodian People's People (CPP) in order to subsequently destroy the united front.

For more information about "Hun Sen's divide and rule strategy" please click here.

[End]

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

The price of peace [: kleptocracy, massive corruption, impunity, human rights abuses, and repressive, undemocratic governance]

October 22, 2007
Simon Taylor
The Guardian (UK)


Today marks the anniversary of the 1991 Paris Peace Accords - the agreement which signalled the beginning of the end of decades of violent conflict in Cambodia and the start of the biggest and most costly peacekeeping operation in history. Yet 16 years later, the country once regarded as the international poster-boy for post-conflict nation building is fast becoming South-East Asia's newest kleptocracy; its reputation marred by allegations of massive corruption, impunity, human rights abuses, and repressive, undemocratic governance. The international community - whose money has bankrolled this shattered state's rehabilitation - has singularly failed to stop the rot. Lessons must be learned if other fragile, newly post-conflict states are to avoid a similarly disastrous outcome.

On paper, Cambodia's natural resources and state assets - the land, forests, minerals and heritage sites - were the basis for kickstarting the post-conflict economy. The revenue generated from this exercise should have gone towards poverty alleviation and rebuilding infrastructure. Instead, systematic and institutionalized corruption has deprived the entire population of the revenue that could have come from these public goods.

A cursory glance at today's Cambodian business sector reveals the country's forests, land, mining, ports, national buildings and casinos to be predominantly controlled by a handful of government-affiliated tycoons or family members of senior political figures. Information about these deals is not made available to the Cambodian people to whom the state's resources belong. Similarly, consultation with local populations dependent upon the country's forests or land for their livelihoods is often non-existent. For many Cambodians, the first they know of such deals is the sound of a chainsaw revving or a bulldozer arriving to flatten their crops.

Cambodia's forests are a case in point. In the 1990s they were described by the World Bank as the country's "most developmentally important resource". Today they are largely degraded, having been sold off over the years by the political elite to private companies or individuals intent on logging as much as possible to turn a quick buck. Most of the vast wealth generated from this logging has not reached the national coffers: instead it appears to have been siphoned off into the private bank accounts of the loggers and their political patrons.

While a booming textile and tourism industry has resulted in double-digit economic growth in recent years, the reality is that Cambodians are still among the world's poorest people and wealth inequality is increasing. With an estimated 35% of the population living below the poverty line, and the vast majority without electricity or mains water, survival remains a challenge for millions. Meanwhile, government-sanctioned forced evictions and land grabs are rife, human rights violations are common, corruption is endemic and impunity is the norm. Over the past five years, this has been accompanied by a backward-slide in space for civil society and political opposition to operate, resulting in a governance system recently described by the UN Rapporteur on Human Rights as "a shaky façade of democracy".

Cambodia's donors have provided the equivalent of over 50% of the government's annual budget for over a decade now. Having spent billions of dollars in setting up a democratic system in Cambodia, one would assume that its donors and their domestic tax payers have an interest in preserving it. Yet the international donor community has consistently failed to bring the government to book for blatant violations of its commitments to protect human rights, fight corruption, and ensure the protection of land and natural resources. In the 1990's, turning a blind eye to these actions was justified by the need to ensure 'stability'. From stability would flow economic development, and from economic development would flow political pluralism. The past 16 years have revealed the impotence of such logic. With each successive failure of the donor community to ask tough questions and deal realistically with the regime's failure to honour commitments to good governance, those responsible have increased their wealth and impunity. The end result is that Cambodians find it harder and harder to call their government to account.

It is not too late for the international community to redefine its terms of engagement with Cambodia, but it will require a fundamental shift in mindset. At its core must be a recognition that stripping a country of its assets for personal gain represents a mass violation of the social and economic rights of the country's people. Next, Cambodia's donors must impose sanctions on those individuals and their family members who they have good reason to believe are corruptly profiteering from the exploitation of the state's resources. These measures should include a freeze on all assets, restrictions on international travel and a ban on doing business with nationals of the donor country.

This will be a bitter pill to swallow for those donors who would prefer to enjoy an amicable relationship with the Cambodian government. Yet, if the international community cannot get it right in a small and relatively non-strategic country such as Cambodia, what hope for the likes of Sudan, Liberia, Sierra Leone and the Democratic Republic of Congo? To continue to give overseas aid without the courage to tackle blatant mass corruption and poor governance is the equivalent of pouring good money after bad. Worse, it confers a badge of approval and reinforces the legitimacy of a government which is not acting in the interests of its own population. Cambodia and its people deserve better.

Friday, June 01, 2007

Cambodia's natural resources looted by "kleptocratic mafia"

The close-knit circle first dynasty of Cambodia

Cambodian elite and army accused of illegal logging racket
  • 'PM and family complicit as troops loot forests'
  • Watchdog says world's donors turn blind eye
Friday June 1, 2007
John Vidal, environment editor
The Guardian (UK)


Cambodia is being systematically stripped of its natural assets by a small elite of politicians, relatives of its prime minister, and businessmen working with the army the government's former official independent forestry watchdog said yesterday.

Global Witness, the UK-based human rights and environment group which monitored Cambodia's forests for the government until it was thrown out of the country in 2006, says logging is in the hands of a "small kleptocratic mafia". In a report today they accuse officials and senators of misappropriating public assets, extortion, tax avoidance, looting the forests and managing an extensive illicit economy under the eyes of the international donors who turn a blind eye but give the country $600m (£300m) annually in aid.

The group claims to have uncovered evidence of heavily armed soldiers from an elite army unit with close connections to senior politicians, including the prime minister, Hun Sen. Brigade 70, says the report, transports logs and other smuggled goods from all over Cambodia for tycoons and politicians, and the timber is sold to Vietnam or sent to China.

"These timber trafficking activities are worth many millions a year and the profits are split between timber traders and the brigade commanders," it says. Brigade 70, which has a reputation for violence, is also hired by Cambodian industrialists to smuggle alcohol, sugar, cigarettes, perfume, drugs and construction materials for prominent tycoons, says the report.

"The armed forces are major players in logging and drug trafficking. They have kept up an assault on the country's forests that does not pretend to be legitimate. Many units are stationed around forests and carry out illegal operations geared towards enriching their commanders."

Yesterday the Cambodian government declined to comment on the report. In the past it has threatened to prosecute the group. Letters sent to people identified in the report, including the prime minister, were not answered.

Cambodia has one of the world's worst deforestation rates. Since 1970, its virgin forest cover has fallen from over 70% to 3.1%. Global Witness investigated illegal logging in Cambodia and its links with corruption and human rights abuses in 1995. The group was in 1999 appointed independent monitor of Cambodia's forestry crime monitoring programme with the help of the UK government and other international donors, and Prime Minister Hun Sen staked his job on the crackdown on logging.

In the 1990s illegal logging was so rife that the IMF cancelled a $120m loan and the World Bank suspended aid.

The government suspended commercial logging but in 2003, Global Witness reported a rebound in the illegal trade which it linked to relatives of the prime minister and Brigade 70. Following threats of prosecution by the government the organisation was ejected from Cambodia in 2006 and the prime minister declared that the group was "finished".

The new report, which was compiled in London from material gathered secretly in Cambodia, estimates the trade could be worth "tens of millions of dollars a year." It accuses Hun Sen of "building a shadow state on patronage, coercion and corruption" with family members actively involved in corrupt business dealings. It says the armed forces are involved in high-level deals via secret military development zones that cover 700,000 hectares (1.7m acres) of forest and other land.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Does Moldova's first family reminds you that of another former communist country in SE Asia?

Oleg Voronin, son of Moldova's president and the richest man in Europe's poorest country, shown on the cover of VIP-Magazin

Son of Moldova's president defends his riches: "I don't steal other companies"

The richest man in Moldova is the son of the president. At the same time, the country just happens to be the poorest in Europe. Coincidence?

07/Mar/2007
By Karen Ryan
The Tirapol Times (Moldova Republic)


CHISINAU (Tiraspol Times) - He is the richest man in Moldova. His name: Oleg Voronin. A biologist, and the son of a former Soviet-era General, Vladimir Voronin, today leader of the Communist Party and the Communist President of Moldova.

Under Papa Voronin's rule, two things happened in Moldova: With spiralling poverty and record emigration out of control, the country officially got classified as a failed state in 2006. At the same time, Oleg Voronin's business empire expanded like never before, making him the richest man in Europe's poorest country.

Meanwhile, Moldova - with Voronin as its leader - has kept up a smear campaign against Pridnestrovie, discrediting the unrecognized country and its elected leaders. Many in Tiraspol ask if this is not a case of the pot calling the kettle black, and now some in Chisinau are beginning to ask themselves the same.

By now, it has long been well-documented that there are no ownership ties between Igor Smirnov or his sons Oleg and Vladimir to large Pridnestrovie firms such as 'Sheriff Ltd' or 'Green'. In contrast, ties between Vladimir Voronin or his son Oleg and a number of large Moldova firms are well known and no longer denied by the family.

Today, while admitting ownership and control of large holdings in Moldova, the younger Voronin now merely limits his defense to saying that he obtained the businesses legally and that his enormous wealth is not the result of corruption.

Oleg Voronin: "There's no family corruption"
In a just-published interview with Chisinau's VIP-Magazin, the Moldovan president's son maintains that he is not an usurper of other people's businesses. In the interview, Oleg Voronin said that he does not, in a dishonest way, take over the businesses of others. He said that he was "shocked" at such ridiculous and ungrounded gossip.

" - They say, for example, that I am withdrawing the marshroutkas [route taxi minibuses] currently working in Chisinau's city streets in order to replace them with my vehicles. They also claim that I have allegedly bought up the companies of the fast food chain Andy's Pizza, Supraten, and DAAC-Hermes. That's delirious. I stand ready to expose and energetically combat every effort of the banditry businesses that are being imputed to me, or, rather, to my dad - President Voronin", the younger Voronin said.

" - Those around President Voronin are all honest citizens of Moldova," he said, adding that "any 'family corruption' is absolutely out of the question."

" - I know what business is for an entrepreneur. This is your life, and that's why I do not accept treating other people's businesses in such a [usurping] way, like I shall never let anyone treat my business so, either", said the President's son.

But not everyone agrees. Moldova's own "Centrul de Investigatii Jurnalistice" (Investigative Journalism Center) looked into Vladimir Voronin's dealings and, despite heavy official secrecy, concluded that he promoted clan interests and what can most kindly be described as shady business.

During Vladimir Voronin's presidency, his son, Oleg Voronin, quickly became Moldova's most successful businessman. He and persons from his entourage took over the control over most of the country's profitable business sectors, including, but not limited to, large holdings in energy, financial/banking, constructions, sugar and the lucrative wine and brandy industry, according to the Center's report.

The Center states that with Voronin in the presidency, companies and government entities transferred their finances to to “FinComBank”, a bank owned by Voronin's son Oleg, and whose Chairman of the Board of Directors is also Oleg Voronin. Charity money, like that earmarked for reconstructing Moldova's Căpriana monastery, also ended up in the Voronin-family's bank. When the General Prosecutor’s Office began investigating, it was told in no uncertain terms to back off and the case never saw a satisfactory conclusion. Three other criminal cases involving companies owned by Oleg Voronin also never got off the ground, leading the Investigative Journalism Center to use the clear term "companies protected by Voronin".

Unlikely business-success
He has his Daddy's eyes, say those who known him. That is one of the few good things they can say about Oleg Voronin. His classmates from Class of 1984, Chisinau's State University, would never had thought that the slow kid with the bad grades would become Moldova's richest man less than twenty years later.

Oleg, who graduated as a biology major, got his first job with a dusty non-profit called Vierul. The mediocre biologist hang around the college campus for most of the nineteen-eighties, doing some postgraduate work in the university's biophysics lab, and, in 1988, establishing with some other academics a so called Laboratory Cooperative to look for better yields in milk production.

The Voronin family first got involved in serious business in 1993. That year, Oleg Voronin obtained control of the Bricansky sugar plant in a privatization scheme. The son of the country's most prominent Communist leader promptly fired hundreds of workers and was for a few years known in the local press as "Moldova's Sugar King."

Also in 1993, Oleg Voronin found $50,000 and applied for a banking license. For the past 14 years, he has been head of his own bank, FinComBank, which from humble beginnings has now grown into becoming one of Moldova's largest and most powerful financial institutions.

Opposition journalists in Moldova have frequently claimed, but not been able to provide any proof, that while Vladimir Voronin was a Soviet general and head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in the former Moldavian SSR, he siphoned off 34 million rubles and "parked" it with a Stasi friend in a party office in the DDR. Later, that same money appeared for use by Oleg Voronin through a German shell company with the unfortunate name of Orbit GMBH.

Money in Orbit

In 1996, as part of that year's election campaign, the Communist Party of China arranged an aid shipment of medicines to be distributed for free to the poor and elderly in Moldova by the Communist Party of Moldova. The cargo, with a value estimated at $1.5m, was instead diverted to a a company called Orbit Enterprises Ltd and, from there, ended up on the store shelves of pharmacies throughout Moldova. Then, just like now, Vladimir Voronin was head of the Communist Party of Moldova. The selling of humanitarian aid went unpunished, but caused the Chinese to recall their Ambassador from Chisinau.

A similar pattern was seen when, during the visit to Cuba, the Communist leader obtained more than one hundred tons of sugar in aid for Moldova. Instead of bringing the sugar to Moldova, as planned, the load was instead diverted to Kaliningrad and sold in the open market by Orbit Enterprises Ltd.

Orbit Enterprises Ltd is the successor to Orbit Gmbh, and is an offshore shell company registered in Gibraltar, a sunny-but-shady tax haven. Company documents lodged with Chases Manhattan in New York reveal that the firm's beneficiary owner was Oleg Voronin. In both the medicines and the sugar deals, the money was ended up in a Swiss bank account controlled by Oleg Voronin, having first been transferred to Chase Manhattan in New York and then re-routed to #1-841897, Uberseebank, CH-8024 Zurich, Switzerland, for final credit to Orbit Enterprises Ltd.

Family business
The Voronin name has long been tied to Moldova's lucrative wine exports. The firm Wine International Project (WIP) is another offshore holding, established in 1994 in Nicosia, Cyprus. Through WIP, Oleg Voronin now owns the Garling Collection, one of Moldova's leading export brands of wines and spirits.
According to information provided by Garling corporate press office, to date the company has more than 2,000 hectares of wholly-owned vineyards in one of the most favorable zones in Moldova in terms of soil composition and climatic conditions.

Father and son have often tried to downplay their tentacles in the world of Moldovan business. Oleg Voronin himself has often stated that his only business activities are concentrated in FinComBank, and that any other business activities tied to him and his father are fictious.
When his father, President Voronin, was asked a question at a press conference about his son's businesses, he answered that "basically, my son is really not involved in business. He is a biologist by education, he majored in the protection of plants and has worked on the development of a project to produce mineral fertilizers."

Apart from Oleg Voronin's FinComBank, he also owns a large publishing empire with some of the best-known media titles in Chisinau under his control. And the list of companies which the opposition links to Voronin is longer than just FinComBank and his publishing interests. It includes Garling Collection, Jolly Allon, Zahar, Transline (shipping), Orbit (sale of sugar and medicine), Trimol (passport manufacturing), M.S.I. Trading Company, Metal Market, MedAzur, Andys Pizza, Boena Group and a number of others.

But it wasn't until 2001, when Vladimir Voronin became Moldova's President, that the family business really took off.

Foreign press reports now put the monthly turnover of Oleg Voronin at $30 million from imports of oil and gasoline, alcohol, cigarettes and a number of goods and products on government contracts. It also states that he has a stake in a Moldovan-Romanian car joint venture, DEU, and that he until recently had the contract to manufacture Moldova's passports through a company named Trimol. The family also had a stake in Chisinau's wellknown Jolly Allon hotel, and - through a company named Zahar - controls a large portion of Moldova's sugar exports.

Like many international businessmen, Oleg Voronin prefers the use of foreign-registered companies. One of his firms, bearing the name of M.S.I. Trading Company, is located in Iasi in Romania. Others are pure offshore plays, with brassplate registrations in Gibraltar, Bahamas and Cyprus. Through one of his Gibraltar entities, Oleg Voronin handled a public procurement contract for coal deliveries to Moldova.

Moldova's own Centrul de Investigatii Jurnalistice has publicly stated that the companies protected by Voronin and by those around him have been involved in public scandals related to smuggling.

Nevertheless, the president’s son is still one of the most prominent businessmen in the country, and, says the Center, the companies owned by Oleg Voronin are in control of the most advantageous state contracts and orders. According to the Center, in Moldova the government lets this happen without the organization of public tenders.

How to make money in a failed state
In June 2006, Moldova was officially placed on the Failed State Index. The index, compiled in Washington DC, is a select list of places with serious governance problems. In its ranking, Moldova scored even worse than Nicaragua, the poorest country in Central America.

Economically, Moldova ranked equal to Afghanistan and Sudan ... and, on average, much worse than most of the failed African countries on the list. In terms of human rights, it tied with Eritrea for the "honors" of an equally terrible human rights record; just a step below Cambodia and Sierra Leone.

All of this bad news didn't prevent the Voronin family from making money like never before. In 2006, Vladimir Voronin set his sights on Pridnestrovie, or Transnistria as his government prefers to call it. Through his reintegration ministry, he announced that privatizations done in Transnistria were "illegal" and would be undone once Moldova took control of the region.

The announcement was not lost on current owners of companies in Pridnestrovie: If a joint state with Moldova ever happens, their right to private property would be in danger. With Moldova openly telling them in advance that earlier privatizations would not be recognized by the Moldovan government as valid, the new owners feared a renationalization and subsequent transfer to none other than Oleg Voronin.

" - I guess that is one way to make money," said the owner of textile factory the same week the announcement was made.
" - You pass a law saying that everything done before you arrived to the scene is now illegal. Then you redo the whole thing and pocket the cash."

Predictably, no single business owner in Pridnestrovie is in favor of a joint state or common state with Moldova. Many businesses openly campaigned for independence and sovereign statehood in Pridnestrovie's 17 September 2006 independence referendum.

Pridnestrovie declared independence in 1990 and has functioned as a de facto independent state for nearly 17 years. Its strongly independent-minded population is mostly Slav, but even its ethnic Moldovan minority has no wish to integrate with Moldova in a common state. Voters overwhelmingly prefer independence and have expressed their wish to see Pridnestrovie recognized internationally as a sovereign, independent state.

" - What Moldova does is up to them. Keep stealing and running your country into the ground," says one voter, a Rybnitsa resident of 44. "Just don't force us to be part of your mess."

Refusing to become part of a failed state, officially Europe's poorest country and what many here see as a kleptocracy, voters in Pridnestrovie prefer independence. The new and emerging country of 555,000 inhabitants has decided that independent statehood is the best way forward and is currently seeking formal diplomatic recognition and integration into the international community. (With information from Infotag)

Monday, March 05, 2007

Cambodia welcomes its oil wealth, but will it do more harm than good? [- Cambodia to slide into a kleptocracy?]

Aid workers fear resource bonanza offers new potential for corruption

Ian MacKinnon in Sihanoukville
Monday March 5, 2007
The Guardian (UK)

Behind the tall fences and taller cranes of Cambodia's sole deep-water port lurks a compound filled with rusty pipes and drilling equipment. Unlikely as it seems, this collection of shipping containers represents the best hope in years for the impoverished country still recovering from decades of war.

The base in sleepy Sihanoukville is US oil giant Chevron's springboard for operations 100 miles off shore. It struck "significant" oil and gas deposits, and is confirming the discovery's scale. The initial find, estimated by the World Bank and United Nations' Development Programme to be 400m to 500m barrels of oil, has already sparked something of a "black gold" rush with Chinese, Japanese, French and Korean companies battling for lucrative rights.

Yet international donors whose aid propped up Cambodia for years fear that a bonanza pumping up to $4.6bn (£2.5bn) into the nation's coffers every year for the next two decades could make things worse. They warn that Cambodia could be blighted by the "resource curse" that has dogged so many developing nations.

Newly oil-rich countries with fragile state institutions have repeatedly fallen victim to sluggish growth despite vast earnings, leaving the poor worse off. The UN Development Programme points to Nigeria, highlighting how it grew more slowly than nations which had no resource windfall. Today 70% of Nigerians live on less than $1 a day despite $450bn in oil revenues in the past 35 years.

Corruption

Diplomats fret that Cambodia, with endemic corruption and weak institutions that are the legacy of the murderous Khmer Rouge regime, could slide into the mire of a full-blown kleptocracy. "At this stage we're all rather nervous," said one senior Western diplomat. "Suddenly there's going to be this avalanche of cash. There's endemic corruption and a weak system of governance with few checks and balances on which these huge revenues will be imposed. We've only got two or three years' leverage."

Oil revenues offer huge new potential for corruption in a country that cleaves to its communist traditions of secrecy. Most oil contracts have been signed by the powerful deputy prime minister, Sok An, a close ally of the prime minister, Hun Sen, with the senior bureaucrats and even the finance ministry out of the loop. Aid workers wryly look forward to the days of "Lagos on the Mekong" in a nation of 14m that is already "run like an episode of The Sopranos" because everyone gets their cut. "Cambodia's like a pyramid scheme of corruption," said one development staffer in Phnom Penh.

Energy-hungry China is keen to get its hands on the oil. It matched international donors' cash with a "no-strings" $600m gift last year as two global Chinese oil firms compete for contracts.

"My concern is, the government sees these revenues and think they've won the lottery," said one international aid worker. "Right now they're saying, 'bring it on, it's going to save Cambodia'. They don't understand our caution."

The argument reached such a pitch that Hun Sen was forced to address the concerns recently. "We will make sure oil is a blessing, not a curse," he said.

He pledged that the money would bolster long-term growth and cut poverty in a country where half the children fail to finish primary school and 35% of people live on less than 25p a day. It is the poor who will continue to suffer if the prime minister does not make good on his pledges. "The signs aren't great," said Warwick Browne, East Asia programme officer of Oxfam America. "But the future doesn't have to be determined by past bad practices. If we look at the past we're worried, but if we look forward there are encouraging signs."

Pitfalls

Even without kickbacks being pocketed by Phnom Penh's elite, the pitfalls remain enormous. Huge revenues rolling into government coffers will make it less reliant on the meagre tax earnings, isolating it from the people it serves and exacerbating authoritarian tendencies, all too evident in Cambodia even now.

The final threat of the "resource curse" is that the revenues trigger inflation and drive up the price of Cambodia's currency, the riel, robbing fledgling export industries of their competitive edge. The garment industry churning out cheap clothes for the west and is vulnerable to the so-called "Dutch disease", after the fate of the Netherlands following its 1960s oil bonanza. Cambodia's rag trade was partly responsible for last year's 13.7% growth.

International donors worry that their conditional aid could be swamped by the oil money. Last year development aid was $601m , but initial oil revenues could reach $1bn. Time is running out.

Backstory

Cambodia was only fully under the iron grip of Pol Pot's genocidal Khmer Rouge regime for less than four years, from 1975 to 1979. But the effects are still being felt. The country remains one of the world's poorest, with GDP per head barely $300 (£154). The economy is largely agrarian and more than 30% of people live below the poverty line. The average government spending on health services annually is just £1-£2 per person. Hun Sen, below, a long-time prime minister whose Cambodian People's Party has governed since the restoration of multi-party democracy in 1993, is the dominant political figure, consolidating his hold on power following electoral victory in 2003.