Showing posts with label Lack of respect of freedom of speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lack of respect of freedom of speech. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Human rights head 'seriously concerned' at pursuit of opposition MP

Tue, 13 Jul 2010
DPA

Phnom Penh - Navi Pillay, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, expressed "serious concern" Tuesday at the Cambodian government's pursuit of a criminal case against opposition parliamentarian Mu Sochua.

Speaking on Pillay's behalf, UN spokesman Rupert Colville said in Geneva the manner in which a defamation case filed by Prime Minister Hun Sen had been conducted appeared to show "an alarming erosion of both freedom of expression and the independence of the judiciary."

The UN body said Hun Sen's lawyer had produced no evidence during the "highly politicized" court case, but had instead relied on a letter written by Mu Sochua to an international parliamentary grouping, which was "totally unacceptable."

"Communicating with international organizations - including the UN Human Rights office itself - is part of the fundamental right to freedom of expression," Colville said, adding the courts should try freedom of expression cases using civil law, not criminal law.

"Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights - which has been ratified by Cambodia - states that everyone has the right to freedom of expression," Colville said.

"The criminal justice system is the bedrock of human rights protection," said Colville. "However, in this case it has become a blunt instrument to silence freedom of expression."

The case between Hun Sen and the former women's affairs minister culminated in a Supreme Court ruling last month that upheld the premier's victory for defamation in the lower courts.

Mu Sochua now faces arrest after missing a July 10 deadline to pay compensation of 1,900 dollars to Hun Sen. The deadline to pay a second court-imposed fine of 2,000 dollars levied in the same case expires on Friday.

Mu Sochua has said she would rather go to jail than pay - a stance she reiterated Tuesday.

The case followed Hun Sen's comments in a speech two years ago when he used the term "strong leg," described by some as derogatory, against an unnamed woman from Kampot province.

Mu Sochua, who represents Kampot province, said the comment was aimed at her, was defamatory, and announced she would sue. Hun Sen countersued saying her defamation allegation was itself defamatory. Mu Sochua's case was thrown out of court.

The case was one of several brought against the government's critics in politics and civil society over the past 18 months, and has led to fears of increasing repression.

Wednesday, August 05, 2009

UN appeals to Cambodia to respect free speech obligations

Aug 5, 2009
DPA

Phnom Penh - The UN's human rights office in Cambodia Wednesday appealed to the judiciary to respect the country's national and international obligations on freedom of speech, saying that a recent spate of lawsuits risks stifling public debate.

Cambodia's courts have found against three defendants in recent weeks, and fined or jailed them for disinformation or defamation.

Human rights groups have complained that the cases, which were brought by the government against perceived critics, are politically motivated.

'Under international law, freedom of expression is to be restricted only in exceptional cases, where clearly necessary and proportionate to the value that the restriction seeks to protect,' the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights said in a statement.

Opposition parliamentarian Mu Sochua was found guilty Tuesday of defaming Prime Minister Hun Sen and fined 16.5 million riel (4,124 dollars).

In June, the editor of an opposition-aligned newspaper was fined and jailed for a year for articles alleging corruption within the government.

And last month, the director of a local cultural organization was fined and sentenced to two years in prison, in absentia, for suggesting that new lighting at Cambodia's Angkor Wat temple could damage the stonework.

The government has consistently denied the charges are politically motivated, saying it is acting only to maintain social order.