Showing posts with label Poor Cambodian bride. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Poor Cambodian bride. Show all posts

Thursday, July 08, 2010

The changing face of Asia's 'mail order' brides

July 8, 2010
ABC Radio Australia

Every year thousands of women migrate to richer, neighbouring countries as brides. But it's not always a happy ending, with many women feeling isolated or trapped in abusive relationships.

Several countries are now acting to improve the situation, but - with gender imbalances worsening in some parts of Asia, and more women looking to escape tough economic times - the issue is an increasingly complex one.

Presenter: Helene Hofman
Speakers: Ching Lung Tsay, Professor of Asian Studies, Tamkang University, Taiwan; Regina Galias, Chief Immigrant Services Officer, Migrant Education and Integration Division, Commission on Filipinos Overseas; Andrew Bruce, Representative for South-East Asia, International Organisation's for Migration


Professor Ching Lung Tsay from Tamkang University in Taiwan has been monitoring marriage migration trends for decades.


HOFMAN: It's a practice that's no longer reserved for the rich.

In certain parts of China, Japan and South Korea gender imbalances are making it increasingly difficult for men to find wives and they're turning to their poorer neighbours for a solution.

Every year thousands of women from Philippines, Vietnam, Thailand and Cambodia take up offers of marriage abroad.

They're usually young, disadvantaged women in search of a better life, but the profile of their husbands is changing.

TSAY: With the economic developments, people tend to delay their marriage, especially among females so the men find it more and more difficult to find a spouse, especially if they are so-called disadvantaged in some sense, like they are agricultural workers and low skilled workers or they are already too old to get married or they are in a lower education group.

HOFMAN: Both Japan and Singapore have seen a gradual growth in the number of men recruiting women from abroad.

But more notable has been the increase in interest from China - which has traditionally exported brides. Now men from male-dominated regions are also looking to other parts of China or abroad for wives.

And in South Korea - where the practice is more established - over a third of fisherman and farmers who married in the 12 months to May 2009 took foreign brides.

Andrew Bruce, the International Organisation's for Migration's Representative for South-East Asia, says attempting to correct a gender imbalance in this way is dangerous.

BRUCE: What we're finding is that with large flows of young women you will then cause a situation similar to what you have in China today with a shortage of marriageable women and then of course this is the possibility for trafficking. You've got people watching and bringing in people from other parts of the region, trafficking them in to fulfil that shortage of women and it's worrying for countries just to have a great shortage of women. It can be disruptive and it's not great for the social structure as well.

HOFMAN: And as for the women themselves?

A study completed by Uma Narayan from Vassar College in the United States last year showed women who's immigration status depended on their marriage, were much more likely to be subjected to domestic violence.

Earlier this decade, there were a handful of high-profile suicide attempts and even murders.

Now, those stories are less common but many women are complaining of feeling isolated and depressed by their new situations.

The Philippines, which has seen over 300-thousand women leave to marry foreigners since 1989.

It has had a ban on commercial international match making agencies for over a decade and all couples are interviewed to ensure the marriage is legitimate.

Despite this Regina Galias, the chief immigrant services officer for the migrant education and integration division of the Commission on Filipinos Overseas says they are still contacted by women who have found themselves in difficult situations.

GALIAS: There's an issue of domestic violence, there are verbal, sexual and physical abuses. Some of them have been victims of human trafficking in the guise of marriage. There's actually a case in Japan where they were brought to a club, where they were forced to work as prostitutes and they never saw their husbands and then there's also abandonment. So when they got there, they found that their husbands actually have another wife and they were just brought to the country for domestic work. So we try to help them because a lot of them want to go back to the Philippines or maybe file for divorce. If they want to stay in the country we try and help them relate to their spouse even if they haven't known each other a long time. So those are the cases that we encounter.

HOFMAN: Many countries are working to address the issues arising from marriage migration.

Last year, Taiwan responded to complaints that many migrant brides were being mistreated and banned commercial international match-making services.

South Korea is also looking at ways to tackle abuses of the system.

18 months ago, Cambodia set up the Association for People Protection to regulate marriages to foreigners, while Indonesia is currently revising its marriage legislation.

Thursday, April 03, 2008

Concerns about exploitation prompts Cambodia to halt processing foreign marriages

Thursday, April 3, 2008
The Associated Press

PHNOM PENH, Cambodia: The Cambodian government has halted processing all documents for marriages of its citizens with foreigners as a new step to minimize the possibility of human trafficking, officials said Thursday.

The suspension was prompted by concerns about the potential for exploitation and trafficking following a recent surge in the number of Cambodian women marrying South Korean men, said Deputy Minister of Women's Affairs You Ay.

She said that as of last Saturday, approval for all paperwork needed for marrying foreigners has been put on hold.

She did not say how long the measure will last, but that it was introduced so that government agencies involved in processing foreign marriage requests "can work to strengthen their procedures."

"We are not denying our people's rights to marry foreigners, nor are we being discriminatory," she said.

"But we have also seen the negative aspects out of such marriages" recently, she said, adding that the suspension affects all foreigners, not just South Koreans.

She was not able to say how many Cambodian nationals have married foreigners.

The South Korean connection made headlines here last month after a report by the Geneva-based International Organization of Migration revealed that thousands of men had come to marry Cambodian women through brokers. Over the past four years, some 2,500 Cambodian women have wedded South Korean men, mostly through the services of underground matchmaking businesses, according to the report.

It said each man would pay up to US$20,000 (€12,790) to marry a woman but that a bride's family would collect only about US$1,000 (€640), while the rest of the money would go to brokers.

Although their marriages appeared to be legal, the government has expressed concerns that brokered marriages could become a cover for human trafficking, in which women are tricked or forced into marriage.

Last month, it shut down two South Korean companies for engaging in the matchmaking business. Interior Minister Sar Kheng denounced the firms' activities as "human trafficking."

"You're bound to have this type of problem when it's a business-oriented, profit-making type of environment," said John McGeoghan, an IOM project coordinator in Cambodia.

He said the suspension "probably is going to upset a lot of people" but is "a good preventive measure" especially "if you want to protect these girls and have more potential for a better marriage."

Cambodia suspends foreign marriages: official [-S. Korea stops issuing residency visas to Cambodian women wishing to marry Korean men]

April 3, 2008
AFP

Cambodia has suspended marriages between foreigners and Cambodians amid concerns over an explosion in the number of brokered unions involving poor, uneducated women, an official said Thursday.

The move follows an International Organisation for Migration (IOM) report highlighting the plight of an increasing number of Cambodian brides migrating to South Korea in marriages hastily arranged by brokers who make large profits.

Some 1,759 marriage visas were issued by South Korea in 2007, up from just 72 in 2004, the report said.

While no systematic exploitation was uncovered, several cases of abuse did raise a red flag with the government, said You Ay, secretary of state with the Women's Affairs Ministry.

"Seven women have returned from South Korea because they could not stand what happened to them there," You Ay told AFP.

"The government has temporarily suspended all (paperwork) for Cambodia women to marry foreigners," she said.

You Ay said the ban, which was approved last week, would be lifted after the government developed a legal framework to address mixed marriages.

"This suspension is to prevent human trafficking through marriage," she said, adding that while the brides often receive as little as 1,000 US US dollars, agencies can make tens of thousands of US dollars on each marriage.

"Cambodia is working to strengthen the laws on marriage," You Ay said.

IOM project coordinator John McGeoghan said that while the report targeted marriages between Cambodians and South Koreans, the potential for problems exists globally and that brokered unions needed to be better regulated.

Three South Korean marriage agencies have been closed down in Cambodia pending the government's decision on marriages to foreigners.

The South Korean embassy in Cambodia earlier this week halted issuing residency visas to Cambodian women wishing to marry Korean men.