Showing posts with label Cambodia sex trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cambodia sex trade. Show all posts

Thursday, September 13, 2012

No turning back for virgin trade victims

A 16-year-old Cambodian girl hiding behind shutters, cautiously peers out into the streets of Phnom Penh from her hiding place after being rescued from a brothel were she was forced to work. The girl who wants to keep her identity unknown, was forced to have sex with male clients before she was plucked from the trafficking racket. Photograph: AFP/Rob Elliott

Thursday, 13 September 2012
Claire Knox
The Phnom Penh Post

Victims of Cambodia’s virgin trade often face extended exploitation as they turn to prostitution and isolate themselves from their home communities, anti-exploitation groups said, calling for increased education and a shift in mentality toward the trade.

Nget Thy, executive director for the Cambodian Center for the Protection of Children’s Rights, told the Post sexually exploited virgins were “incredibly challenging” for NGOs to rehabilitate.

“Brokers have an ideal market – they know many men want to do this, and that the families are so poor they can often be talked into it … we’ve had girls as young as 13 in these situations.”

Girls who had originally been sold as virgins by their families would be later taken in by local authorities or NGOs after they had turned to a life of prostitution, Thy said.

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

A Thorn in the Heart: Cambodian Men who Buy Sex [-Staggering and shameful statistics]

Executive Summary

We interviewed 133 Cambodian men who had bought sex from adult women in prostitution, with 37% also acknowledging having bought sex from minor girls. Almost all (95%) of the men interviewed for this study stated that children were available for paid sexual abuse in brothels, bars, and massage parlors in Phnom Penh. In order to measure the men's attitudes and behavior, we used previously validated and standardized questionnaires, and a structured interview, yielding both quantitative and qualitative data. Conducted by a specially trained team of 8 interviewers, the interviews each lasted about 2-3 hours. Most of the men said that they had a wife or girlfriend when they used a woman in prostitution. They reported having many sex partners throughout their lifetime (21% had 21-50 sex partners and 35% had 50 or more sex partners). Prostitution was the first sexual experience of most interviewees, many of them having responded to peer pressure and the need to prove their manhood by using a woman in prostitution. Almost all of the men bought sex once a month or more often. Like men in other countries, they bought sex both indoors and on the street. Almost all the men bought women in brothels where they reported observing extreme violence, coercion and threats - evidence that may indicate sex trafficking. Thirty-nine percent of the interviewees described having seen trafficking of women and children. Almost all had bought sex from a woman who was controlled by a pimp. Most frequently the pimps were women but sometimes they were men.

In these interviews, the men dehumanized women in prostitution, seeing them as inferior to other women. They tended to blame prostituted women for the spread of HIV. The sex buyers believe that prostitution prevents rape, although there is no empirical evidence for that. In fact the opposite is more likely to be true: men's prostitution activity is associated with an increased incidence of rape. 1 The men who most strongly supported the institution of prostitution were also those men who had a hostile masculine self-identity. Such men think that dominance is important in love relationships and see relationships with women in adversarial terms. Those men with hostile masculine identities also tended to believe rape myths (for example they believed that women say no to sex when they mean yes, and women who dress provocatively are seeking to be raped).

The study found that men who bought women for sex generally lacked empathy for the women, failing to grasp the extremely negative feelings that the women say that they feel during prostitution. Most of the men in the study told us that in addition to acts of violence against the women they bought for use in prostitution, they had also committed sexually aggressive acts against their non-prostituted partners.

Pornography was used by almost all sex buyers. The men who watched the most pornography bought sex most often. The men who watched more violent pornography reported more frequent incidences of sexually coercive behaviors against both prostituted women and non-prostituted women. Most of the men explained that they copied what they saw in pornography with the prostituted women they bought.

An important component of this research study was the development of a greater understanding of gang rape/bauk prostitution, assumed by some to be a uniquely Cambodian form of gender based violence. From the men's narrative responses to the structured interview and also from statistical analyses, it is clear that viewing gang rape pornography from other cultures (especially western/Caucasian, Japanese, Chinese, and Thai) has a strong effect on some men's decision to perpetrate gang rape against women in prostitution. Many Khmer men reported that they watched gang rape pornography from other cultures and imitated what they saw when they perpetrated bauk against prostituted and non-prostituted women.

The sex buyers indicated that effective deterrents to prostitution would include greater criminal penalty and public exposure. Recommendations based on this research include enforcement of existing laws on prostitution and trafficking against buyers while at the same time decriminalizing women in prostitution, educational programs about the toxic influence of pornography in Khmer culture, and education and prevention programs for youth that challenge the notion that buying sex enhances masculinity.






https://www.box.com/s/4535374ec410a1d4fe32

Gang rape in Cambodia an increasing trend [-Shameful statistics for Cambodian men (mouse?)]


Wednesday, 18 July 2012
Mom Kunthear and Bridget Di Certo
The Phnom Penh Post
What would Chou Bun Eng say if she is the victim of gang rape?
Chou Bun Eng, secretary of state at the Ministry of Interior, said that the government today does not want to criminalise the perpetrators or victims. (sicko!!!)
"At the end, she was in so much pain, I was afraid she had died,” a Cambodian sex buyer recounted to the Cambodian Women’s Crisis Centre and US-based Prostitution Research & Education in reference to a gang rape in which he had participated.

Gang rape is an increasingly normalised human rights violation in Cambodia, research presented by the CWCC and PR&E yesterday highlighted as part of their campaign to discourage men’s demand for prostitution.

Sex buyers have negative attitudes toward all women, not only women in prostitution,” PR&E’s Melissa Farley said at yesterday’s presentation.

“We are here to shine a light on these men who buy sex and cause such great harms to women,” Farley said, emphasising that too often the perpetrators of violence against women in prostitution were “invisible”.

Nearly 40 per cent of Cambodian sex buyers interviewed for the research blamed the prevalence of Western pornography in Cambodia for a fascination with gang rape.

“The sex buyers we interviewed described gang rape as an opportunity to relax with their friends, (sick!!!) the three-year research presented by the two groups reads.

Friday, June 08, 2012

Tackling human trafficking [in Cambodia]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jpmBV4l077Q

This week's Global Journalist panelists used vastly different methods to fight a modern version of slavery: the global sex trade.

By Rehman Tungekar
KBIA 91.3 (USA)

Guy Jacobson was backpacking in Cambodia, when a group of very young girls aggressively tried to offer him sex for money. After he repeatedly refused, they revealed to him that they would be beaten by the brothel owners if they returned empty-handed.

The appalling experience a decade ago motivated Jacobson to create a non-profit organization -- the Redlight Children Campaign -- and the New York lawyer began producing documentary films about child prostitution in Cambodia. The crews went undercover in brothels using espionage equipment and secret cameras.

Jane Tafel is the executive director of Hagar USA. The religious organization operates in Cambodia, Vietnam and Afghanistan to improve the lives of severely abused women and children.

Mark Morris is a Pulitzer-prize-winning investigative reporter for the Kansas City Star. Morris and his team spent six months investigating the effectiveness of America’s efforts to stop human trafficking.

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Effects of climate change fuels up sex trade in Cambodia

Photo Credit: http://www.burgessct.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/HumanTrafficking.jpg

Tue, 01/24/2012
By Jessica Chang
GreenAnswers.com

Cambodia, an exotic land filled with bright colors, city lights and ancient temples is a popular vacation spot. A remarkable country with exquisite culture holds one of the darkest secrets alive today. Very much a real and disturbing reality; we come to unfold this problem and discuss the problems of the sex trade in this area. In fact, children as young as 5 are being sold as slaves in exchange for sex. A problem that has been around for a while is being made worse by the problems caused by climate change.

The sex trade in Cambodia has been around since 1999. The sex trade is happening due to thousands of victims in need of natural resources like food, water and trees. Human trafficking affects 2-3 thousand children and young teens each year. Families are deceived by con artists telling them that their daughters will work for hotels, restaurants, hair salons or complete clerical work in order for them to bring money for their families. Truth is, con artists actually take their daughters into sex industries and force them to have intercourse with older men.

The livelihoods of most families that live in rural villages are affected by the changes brought on by climate change in that area. According to the United Nations, women feel these affects the most. United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) reports that, “Lifestyle and well being of women is put in greater danger by climate change, associated with a high rate of human trafficking.”

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

The world’s oldest oppression


Rapha House Trailer from Unearthed on Vimeo.

April 26, 2011
By Martha Groppo
Kentucky Kernel (USA)
We’ve got to get thinking differently about how we treat women and children.”
After working on the score for a documentary on sex trafficking, one college student wanted to do something about the dehumanization he saw in his client’s video. Tony Anderson decided he was tired of hearing about injustice. He said he wanted to know why there was so much discussion and so little real change.

So Anderson did something a little unusual to answer his questions. To investigate the issue, Anderson and his friend, Derek Hammeke, decided to take a camera into the most notorious areas for sex trafficking they could find.

“We got a ton of crazy undercover stuff on camera,” Anderson said.

Posing as western sex clients, they went undercover, investigating one of the world’s most lucrative criminal industries. With the footage they collected, they created Unearthed, an organization based in Lexington that describes itself as “a nonprofit that produces media that prompts people to act against injustice.”

Anderson remembers one night during their months of filming when he saw a group of women gathered around an underage prostitution hotspot with a western man in Phnom Penh, Cambodia.

He was groping this girl — maybe 7 years old — almost like you’d see somebody feeling produce at the grocery store to ensure its quality before buying it,” Anderson said. “She was being sold for sex.”

The little girl in Cambodia was just one of thousands the Unearthed team saw while collecting footage.

Monday, June 21, 2010

Former sex slave fights illegal trade

"Girls are taught only shame and ignorance about their bodies and men have their first sexual experience in brothels. Rape is the only thing they know." Photo: AFP

June 22, 2010

AAP

Somaly Mam emerged from a life of sex slavery in Cambodia to become a champion of women's rights and one of Time Magazine's 100 most influential people on the planet.

Abandoned by her parents, Mam was raped at 12, forced to marry at 14 and then sold into prostitution.

She suffered years of abuse before escaping with the help of a Medicin Sans Frontieres worker, whom she later married.

Mam has never had any formal schooling, yet she now speaks five languages.

She has become a tireless activist heading two organisations which fight sexual slavery, and has received international humanitarian awards.

Mam spoke about her extraordinary life during her first visit to Australia, in between a flurry of book signings, public lectures and meetings with politicians.

Her autobiography, The Road of Lost Innocence, has been reprinted many times.

It is a grim story of abuse - young lives broken by rape, torture and starvation together with betrayal by the very people who should have protected their own children.

Poverty also causes Cambodian families to sell their daughters into prostitution.

Mam says her story is symptomatic of a country with a long history of treating females worse than livestock.

"Cambodian society is about violence and submission," she told AAP.

"That smile people associate with gentle Cambodian women is a lie.

"It's always been like that. Women have been beaten slaves since before the Khmer Rouge, who killed any compassion there was.

"Although the situation is changing, 30 years later Cambodian society is still struggling. People only care about themselves."

Cambodians are a silent people, Mam says, and women's suffering is also endured in silence, compounded by a lack of education in all spheres.

"Girls are taught only shame and ignorance about their bodies and men have their first sexual experience in brothels. Rape is the only thing they know."

Up to 70 per cent of brothel clients are Cambodian men and the remaining 30 per cent are foreigners including paedophiles targeting children, she says.

Although Mam was able to escape her past by living in France for a while with her French husband Pierre, she continues to be haunted by nightmares and post-traumatic stress.

Mam says she felt driven to rescue girls like herself. Together with Pierre she started saving victims of sexual slavery in Cambodia even though police and corrupt politicians were as bad as the pimps and clients who wanted her gone.

She was one of the founding members of AFESIP (Acting for Women in Distressing Circumstances), which has rescued and rehabilitated over 4000 women since 1996.

Now divorced, Mam says her traumatic past makes it impossible for her to be in a relationship.

But becoming a mother helped her feel love for the first time.

Mam has three children aged 18, 14 and eight. The oldest girl, Ning, is her sister's daughter whom she adopted.

"I'm not a gentle girl and life has been a fight, but out of this, and becoming a mother, came love."

The motherly love she discovered now fuels her mission in Cambodia, where she lives, to maintain three shelters for rescued sex slaves where their dignity is rebuilt through nurturing and education.

"It takes five minutes to rescue a girl and then the hard work starts," she says.

"First give them love until they feel it and they feel safe. Prove to them they can trust, and then start building life skills."

Bill Livermore, the US head of the Somaly Mam Foundation, says a key to ending trafficking is empowering women.

"Access to education, law and the economy is a must. If you take 50 per cent of the population out of those areas, countries do not thrive. Cambodia is very poor".

Livermore also advocates embarrassing governments who tolerate the sex slavery scourge "because governments won't change unless they are embarrassed to change".

He says the rehabilitation success rate in Cambodia soared after survivors were encouraged to rescue other girls.

"It went up from 65 per cent to 90 per cent because they were able to bond with the prostitutes and that's the kind of skill that a PhD from Harvard will never give you," he says.

The foundation was created in the US in 2007 and has a combination of corporate and private funding - not a cent comes from the United Nations or any government body.

Mam's high international profile helps, although old enemies remain. There have been threats on her life and she has a driver and a full-time bodyguard.

"If they kill me, there will be many more to take my place," she says.

SEX SLAVERY: THE FACTS
  • One in 40 Cambodian girls is sold into sexual slavery
  • Human trafficking is the second-largest organised crime in the world, even bigger than the drugs trade
  • 2-4 million women and girls will be sold into prostitution worldwide over the next 12 months
  • Over a million will be small children
  • Some girls will be sold for as little as $US10 and will be as young as five
  • Profits from sexual slavery are estimated at up to $US12 billion annually
Sources: US State Department, UNICEF, UN Office of Drugs and Crime
The Road of Lost Innocence, by Somaly Mam, is published by Virago Press.
For more info go to www.somaly.org and www.projectfutures.com

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Mu Sochua to be guest speaker at the Red Carpet Screening of REDLIGHT in New York City

REDLIGHT Trailer from jillian selsky on Vimeo.

The World Premier Red-Carpet Screening & Fundraising Event of "Redlight" the movie - NYC

You are cordially invited to: The World Premier Red Carpet Screening of highly acclaimed “REDLIGHT” Monday, June 21st 2010 at Sva Theater, New York City, 6:00 PM and 9:00 PM screenings SVA Theatre, 333 West 23rd Street, New York City.

Hosted by:
  • Congresswomen Carolyn Maloney
  • Ambassador Mark Lagon
  • Ambassador Swanee Hunt
  • Cécilia Attias
  • Ashley Judd
  • Cindi Leive
  • Ron Livingston
  • Lauren Bush
  • Julia Ormond
  • Petra Nemcova
  • Elizabeth Berkley
  • Greg Lauren
Please join us for the Red-Carpet World Premier Screening and Fundraising Event of Redlight on Monday, June 21st 2010, at the Sva Theater, located at 333 West 23rd Street in New York City. This special evening will be a multi-pronged event with two screenings offered.

Join us at 6:00 PM for the Official World Premier Red-Carpet Screening with limited tickets open to the public and 9:00 PM for the general public screening. Both screenings will be followed by a Q&A session featuring, Nobel Peace Prize nominee Mu Sochua, and Filmmakers Guy Jacobson and Adi Ezroni who both won the prestigious State Department’s Tip Report Global Hero Award for their work in combating human trafficking.

As a VIP guest, please join us for the VIP reception at the Cue Gallery, located nearby at 511 West 25th Street after the first screening. After the second screening, please join us for beverages in the Sva reception lobby. The proceeds from this event will go towards two nonprofit 501(c)(3), anti-trafficking organizations, RedLight Children and Restore NYC, both working tirelessly in the fight against human slavery.

6:00 PM for the Official World Premier Red Carpet Screening (with limited tickets open to the public)

Red Carpet VIP Tickets - $1000 (As a VIP guest please join us for the VIP reception at CUE Gallery, 511 West 25th Street.)

Red Carpet General Public Tickets - $100 (with open bar at the After-Party from 11:00-12:00 midnight at Juliette Supper Club at 538 W. 21st St. (between 10th Ave & West St.)

9:00 PM for the Red Carpet Premier Screening open to the General Public

Red Carpet General Public Tickets - $50 (with open bar at the After-Party from 11:00-12:00 midnight at Juliette Supper Club at 538 W. 21st St. (between 10th Ave & West St.) Please see below for a full outline of the evening:

First Screening at 6:00 PM:
5:00 PM – Press arrives 5:30-6:30 PM – Red-Carpet and Step & Repeat Photo Opportunities
6:30 PM - Introduction by Keynote Speaker (TBD)
6:45 PM- Screening of the film “Redlight” (1 hour, 10 minutes)
8:00 PM- Q&A with Filmmakers Guy, Jacobson and Adi Ezroni, & Mu Sochua
8:30 -11:00 PM – VIP reception @ The Cue Gallery, 511 West 25th Street (8 min. walk)

Second Screening at 9:00 PM:
9:00 PM- Red-Carpet and Step & Repeat Photo Opportunities
9:30 PM – Short introduction – Faith Huckel, Executive Director of Restore NYC
9:35 PM – Screening of the film “REDLIGHT” (1 hour, 10 minutes)
10:45 PM – Q&A with Filmmakers Guy, Jacobson and Adi Ezroni, Mu Sochua
11:00-12:00 Midnight- Reception in main lobby

About the Film:
Redlight Trailer from Jillian Selsky on Vimeo . UNICEF Goodwill Ambassador Lucy Liu produced and narrated Redlight, an inspiring and powerful feature documentary about child sexploitation. Filmed over a four year period, REDLIGHT focuses on the personal stories of the victims and two remarkable advocates for change: grass-roots activist Somaly Mam and politician Mu Sochua. Both have since been nominated for the Noble Peace Prize and won other numerous human rights awards around the world.

For more information about the film, visit http://www.redlightthemovie.com

PLEASE CLICK HERE TO VIEW CAMPAIGN ARCHIVE

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

‘Beer girls’ underpaid: report

A beer seller refills glasses for young men at a beer garden in Phnom Penh. A report has found that beer promotion women in Siem Reap town are underpaid. (Photo by: Sovan Philong)

Tuesday, 27 April 2010

Will Baxter
The Phnom Penh Post


FEMALE beer promotion workers in Siem Reap town earned salaries that covered only half of their living expenses last year, a fact that led some 57 percent to engage in sex work, according to a report released last week by a Siem Reap-based NGO.

The report, co-authored by Ian Lubek, a psychology professor at the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada, is an updated version of an older report, and draws from interviews with 900 women.

International and domestic beer companies operating in Cambodia offered average monthly incomes of about US$81, but workers, often referred to around the country as “beer girls”, said they needed between US$160 and $209 to cover monthly expenses and support their families, according to the report.

Those women who did engage in sex work to supplement their salaries said they had accepted a standard price of US$25 per session, and participated in 2.5 sessions per month, giving them an additional monthly income of $62.50, the report said.

“Most of the problem is that these women are underpaid. They need a living wage,” Lubek said Monday. “The average beer seller has about 3.5 dependants for whom they are responsible.”

The salaries on offer, he added, place “additional pressure on each woman to bring in extra income”.

“About half of these women feel obliged to sell sex,” he said.

The report, produced for the NGO Siem Reap Citizens for Health, Educational and Social Issues, is titled: “Health, safety and security for Cambodian women beer sellers were substandard in 2009: Urgent actions are still required by all major brewers (AB/INBEV, Carlsberg, HEINEKEN/Asia Pacific Breweries, SAB/Miller, Guinness, San Miguel, Bavaria, Asahi, etc.)”.

Lack of education

Women interviewed for the report said they had limited access to HIV/AIDS treatment and sex-education programmes, and the report recommends that basic health and sex education be provided to beer sellers on their first day of work.

Lubek said that 37 percent of beer sellers do not receive health training for more than a year after they begin work, and that some never do. He added that most reported consuming an average of 1.5 litres of beer per night.

“Unless they know about the dangers of alcohol and unsafe sex, in a country with a high rate of HIV infection, this puts them at greater risk,” he said.

In 2006, Heineken International, Carlsberg A/S, Guinness and Co, Asia Pacific Breweries, Cambodia Brewery Ltd and Cambrew Ltd formed the organisation Beer Selling Industry Cambodia (BSIC), “with the objective of improving the health, safety and working conditions of beer promoters by setting industry standards,” according to its website.

A spokesman for the Heineken-affiliated Cambodia Brewery Ltd, 80 percent of which is owned by Asia Pacific Breweries, declined to comment on Monday. Representatives of Cambrew Ltd, of which Carlsberg has a majority stake, could not be reached for comment.

Wednesday, March 03, 2010

"One Black Coffee with a Happy Ending"

03/03/2010
ShortNews.com
Source: www.phnompenhpost.com


Phnom Penh, Cambodia, police have recently closed down a coffee shop that was serving sex as well as coffee. Police rounded up seven women working there and sent them to be educated.

Earlier in the week, anti-human trafficking police shut down an upstanding massage parlor claiming that customers could pay for sex as well as a massage at that establishment. They arrested the owner, a customer, and eight alleged sex workers.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Sex Trade Continues Despite Laws: Group

By Taing Sarada, VOA Khmer
Original report from Washington
28 October 2009


The sex trade continues to thrive in Cambodia, despite an anti-trafficking law and crackdowns on brothels, an advocate for a leading foundation says.

“The brothels have closed, but the brothel owners won’t be defeated, said Vann Sina, a monitor for the anti-trafficking Mam Somaly Foundation. “It means that they’ve changed into something else, but are still in the sex trade. They’ve changed from brothels to guesthouses, small grocery stores, small karaoke parlors, cafes, massage clubs, restaurants, and sex businesses along the parks. As I said, it’s almost everywhere.”

The foundation was started by Mam Somaly, who herself escaped the sex trade and has become an award-winning advocate protecting young women and girls. Vann Sina gave a talk in Washington last week, in talks sponsored by Free the Slaves, a US non-profit group.

While some brothels have gone underground, Vann Sina said, others remain, with girls as young as five years old serving clients.

Vann Sina, too, was a victim of sex trafficking, brought from Vietnam to Cambodia at age 13, her virginity sold to a Westerner. She suffered druggings and constant abuse when she refused to serve clients until she was rescued by Afesip, another organization run by Mam Somaly, where she became staff.

She urged Cambodia police and other authorities to strengthen their laws and work to end the trade.

“The laws may be ineffective or they may not be implemented well,” said Betsy Bramon, of Free the Slaves, which is based in Washington. “Maybe the system is very corrupt, and that is a very serious problem in Cambodia.”

Law enforcement officials in Cambodia say the Ministry of Interior and local authorities have greatly reduced human trafficking.

Cambodian police have never tolerated any trafficking of women and children, which contradicts the dignity of Cambodian culture, said police spokesman Kirt Chantharith.

“Anyone who knows about the activities related to the women and children trafficking or any other crimes, please report to our police,” he said. “We have two lines for phone calls. You can call free via 117 and 118.”

Sources are confidential, he said.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Cambodians back doctor's Bruni snub [-Scent (of money) and sensiblities]

Cambodian King Norodom Sihamoni (C), Premier Hun Sen (L) and doctor Beat Richner (R)

April 16, 2008
From correspondents in Phnom Penh
AFP


PARENTS of Cambodian children have backed a Swiss doctor working in the kingdom who refused a donation from money raised by the sale of a nude photo of the French first lady.

Beat Richner, who heads a Cambodian children's medical group, reportedly turned down the sale proceeds of the 1993 picture of Italian ex-model Carla Bruni, who is now married to President Nicolas Sarkozy.

The nude eventually sold to an anonymous man of Asian descent at a New York auction last week for $US91,000 ($98,300), but Dr Richner told media that he would not take any money since the picture would shock Cambodian sensibilities.

Parents in impoverished Cambodia said they approved of Dr Richner's decision.

"There are many ways that people can raise money and donate it to the hospital, not by nudity," said Bou Koeun, the father of a two-month-old boy who is being cared for at Dr Richner's Kantha Bopha hospital in Phnom Penh.

Song Lai Sreng, 25, whose baby girl is also receiving treatment at the hospital, said the paediatrician had made the right decision.

"Talking about nudity, it is not acceptable in our culture," she said.

Dr Richner told The Cambodia Daily newspaper today that Swiss photographer Michel Comte, who took the picture, said he had a buyer lined up who would acquire the photo if the money went to the Kantha Bopha Children's Hospital Association.

But Dr Richner turned him down, the paper said.

Cambodia has a visible sex trade, but at the same time conservatives laud modesty as part of the local culture.