Monday, May 30, 2011

Cambodia's king seen as a 'prisoner' in his palace [-The fate of a puppet king who no longer represents his people?]

The KING and his KINGMAKERS: In this Nov. 9, 2010 photo, Cambodia's King Norodom Sihamoni, center, applauds with Prime Minister Hun Sen, right, and Heng Samrin, left, National Assembly president, during an Independence Day celebration at the Independence Monument in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. The king may be heir to a royal line trailing back some 2,000 years, but he always seemed more suited to the arts scene in Europe, than the rough and tumble politics of his homeland. Now, close aides and experts say, he has become figuratively, and more, a prisoner in his own palace. (AP Photo/Heng Sinith)
PHNOM PENH, Cambodia (AP) — As the sun sets and the last tourist departs his vast, fairy-tale palace, the gentle, dignified man is left almost alone with memories of happier times, before he became the reluctant king of Cambodia — and perhaps its last.

King Norodom Sihamoni may be heir to a royal line trailing back some 2,000 years, but he always seemed more suited to the arts scene in Europe, where he was a ballet dancer, than the rough and tumble politics of his homeland. Now, close aides and experts say, he has become figuratively, and more, a prisoner in his own palace.

The chief warden: Prime Minister Hun Sen, who rose from a poor rural background to become a brilliant and crafty, some say ruthless, politician.

Hun Sen consolidated power in a 1997 coup as Cambodia slowly emerged from being dragged into the Vietnam War and its own civil war. While the country is nominally democratic, he uses all the machinery of government to lock up critics and ensure his re-election. Human rights groups allege that he and his business friends are enriching themselves, while most of the population remains mired in poverty.


His control extends over the palace. The king is surrounded by the government's watchdogs, overseen by Minister of Royal Affairs Kong Som Ol, an official close to Hun Sen. Sihamoni is closely chaperoned on his few trips outside palace walls, with the media kept away. Although the constitution endows him with considerable powers, these have never been granted.

"I think we can use the words 'puppet king.' His power has been reduced to nothing," says Son Chhay, an opposition member of Parliament and one of the government's few outspoken critics. "The king must please the prime minister as much as possible in order to survive. It is sad to see."

It wasn't always so. Sihamoni's flamboyant and charismatic father, Norodom Sihanouk, bestrode the country like a colossus for decades. Many regarded him as a god-king, and thousands flocked to the plaza fronting the Royal Palace for fireworks and other lavish celebrations on his birthday.

Sihanouk abruptly abdicated in 2004 following confrontations with Hun Sen. Son Chhay and others say Sihamoni accepted the crown under pressure from parents hoping to ensure the survival of the monarchy.

Seven years later, "sad, lonely, abandoned" are words sympathetic Cambodians often use when describing Sihamoni. The 58-year-old monarch spends much of each day signing documents, receiving guests and handling other routine business, then retires mostly to dine alone and read, says Prince Sisowath Thomico, Sihanouk's private secretary and an adviser to his son.

Unlike his father, who had six wives and numerous lovers, Sihamoni is a lifelong bachelor and unlikely to leave an heir.

His birthday passed recently with little notice. Within the palace's crenelated walls, among the graceful pavilions and gilt spires, there was no sign of activity. Outside, knots of people went about their normal evening pastimes at the grassy, riverfront square, feeding pigeons, lounging on reed mats and snacking on lotus seeds and noodles.

"The king is a good, gentle man, a symbol of Cambodia. But he has one problem: no power. He only stays inside the palace. On television the leaders bow down before him but behind his back there is no respect," said Sin Chhay, a young civil servant at the plaza. "You could say that Hun Sen is the real king of Cambodia."

Information Minister Khieu Kanharith insists the king is involved in social and religious affairs and judicial reviews, receives a monthly report from Hun Sen on government activities and makes recommendations on them.

"The current King Sihamoni has played an important role in restoring the ... monarchy. As a king and symbol of national unity he maintains strict neutrality and doesn't become involved in any political activities," he said. "To say that he's a prisoner in the palace would be inappropriate."

Sihamoni, a former ballet dancer and cultural ambassador, spent 25 years in Czechoslovakia and France. That European past, Western diplomats say, is his great escape.

He returns regularly to what is now the Czech Republic, calling it "my second homeland," and has said his time in Prague "belongs to the happiest in my life." Fluent in the language — which reportedly vexes his keepers trying to eavesdrop on conversations with Czech visitors — he avidly reads Czech theater reviews and savors DVDs of ballets and operas.

He keeps in close touch with the family that cared for him after he arrived in the Czech capital at age 9. Thirteen years later, he graduated from Prague's Academy of Musical Art.

Shortly after, he joined his parents, who were being kept under virtual house arrest within the palace by the brutal Khmer Rouge government, which came to power after defeating a U.S.-backed government in 1975. Sihamoni worked in the palace gardens and cleaned out the throne hall.

An estimated 1.7 million people died during the Khmer Rouge reign of terror, including more than a dozen of Sihanouk's children and relatives.

Three decades later, the country is still coming to terms with that period. A U.N.-assisted tribunal is trying a handful of the surviving leaders of the Khmer Rouge, but the trials have been plagued by long delays and corruption allegations.

Sihamoni has had only ceremonial involvement with the tribunal. Any deeper association would irritate both Hun Sen and Sihanouk, who for a time allied himself with the Khmer Rouge but has also supported the trials.

After the fall of the Khmer Rouge, Sihanouk went to Paris, from where he backed resistance against a Vietnamese-installed government that replaced it.

Sihamoni also went to the French capital and stayed on even after his father was restored as king in 1993. He taught, performed and choreographed classical Cambodian dance as well as Western ballet and served as ambassador to the U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization.

He gave up this much-cherished life to become king in 2004.

The king's high privy councilor, Son Soubert, who is aligned with one of the two small opposition parties with parliamentary seats, says the government has blocked passage of two constitutional provisions: the formation of a potentially powerful Supreme Council of National Defense headed by the king, and an annual National Congress that would continue the tradition of citizens appealing directly to the monarch.

Commenting on the congress, the information minister said that in today's Cambodia such a meeting would be a mess and powerless to override any decisions made by an elected National Assembly.

Some question just how much power Sihamoni wants to wield or is capable of exercising.

"If he were to try to take a political role I have no doubt Hun Sen would act to diminish him and the monarchy generally almost immediately. Which is why he is effectively a prisoner in the palace," says Milton Osborne, an Australian historian and author of a Sihanouk biography. "He could very well be the last king of Cambodia."

Prince Sisowath Thomico, the adviser, insists there is no animosity between king and prime minister and says Cambodia's monarchy has merely entered a new stage, shedding its political role.

"The king now serves as a guardian of the past, of tradition, the moral character of Cambodia and points the way ahead for future generations," he says. "We leave the present to the government."

By most accounts, Sihamoni is still largely respected, especially in the countryside. He is probably considered less relevant in urban areas, especially among an extremely young population — the median age is about 23 — that was not around during Sihanouk's heyday, before violence engulfed the country.

Prince Norodom Ranarridh, who heads a pro-monarchy party, believes Cambodians are "still royalists at heart" and holds a nuanced view of his half brother.

The king doesn't exercise his prerogatives under the constitution to avoid jeopardizing an institution he regards as more important than himself, Ranarridh said. At the same time, Sihamoni's personality is unassertive, so he falls comfortably into the role of doing the minimum.

"So both the king and prime minister are very happy with the situation. It is some kind of a gentlemen's agreement," the prince says, laughing.

But he adds: "I don't think my brother is very happy. He would like to be somewhere else."
__
Associated Press writer Grant Peck in Bangkok contributed to this story.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

I love king, he will use his constitute power when time has come.

It is good for article to show inside the wall of palace. like me have been brought up in the west, freedom is my way of life so as the king, but unlike the king I dine with many people, the king work alone is pretty bored.


The king will and must exercise his constitutional provisions: The formation of a potentially powerful Supreme Council of National Defense headed by the king, and an annual National Congress that would continue the tradition of citizens appealing directly to the monarch and jurisdiction of justice to serve people.

Government has no right to veto on this constitutional provisions.

Anonymous said...

Sihamoni is king? What the hell? I thought Preah Samdech Ah Pleur Sapung Yuon HunSenvarman was the king since he acts more so like an absolute monarch and is already grooming his son to succeed him in the Hun Sen Ah Jao-maciet Dynasty.

LOL...

Anonymous said...

it depends on your political point of view here. the analysis maybe true, however, i disagree with the author here for failing to see or accept changes in cambodia. cambodia's today is so different from say in the 1960s, etc. this is how it should be by law. monarchy shouldn't be allowed to break the law like papa sihanouk did in the 1960s, you know! the khmer king is not weak as some people think he is. the king is playing by the rule of law which is good for cambodia and khmer society at large, really! it is wrong to assume or expect cambodia to operate like in the past when king were absolute power and above the law, etc. that is why we called cambodia a constitutional monarchy with multiple democracy, you know!

keep in mind that cambodia has changed a lot since. of course with democratic pluralism, the king has to thread the water so to keep cambodia in the equilibrium of thing, you know! no individual should have the absolute power without regards to the rule of law, really! and of course, the people of cambodia are keeping a close eye on the monarchy, we always respect the monarchy, the king, etc; and it is mistake to assume that as a weakness, ok! i think king sihamoni is doing the right thing by not being greedy in politics and not having a good relation with the gov't etc... he is a very smart, wised king and well educated both in cambodia political history and the world as well, you know. god bless king sihamoni of cambodia and all khmer people and cambodia.

Anonymous said...

it's a sign that cambodia is entering a new era time and history. the king is playing by the rule, so don't expect his majesty to deviate from the rule of law, ok! the king young and does not need to rush with anything. khmer people love hime and respect him for playing by the rule of law and for setting a good example for cambodia and all khmer people and citizens. i think in the past, the monarchy always enter politics, not good for cambodia as that created conflict of interest, etc, etc. cambodia should be like england where the queen doesn't rule but existed as a constitutional monarchy. of course, the monarch learns from history as well, you know!

Anonymous said...

គណបក្សសិទ្ធិមនុស្ស ជាគណបក្សស៊ីឈ្នួល អោយពួកអាក្បត់ជាតិកញ្ជះយួន។
កឹម សុខា ជាប្រធានគណបក្សស៊ីឈ្នួល លក់ក្បាលអោយពួកអាក្បត់ជាតិកញ្ជះយួន។

ថ្ងៃនេះយើងស្ដាប់ឮជាក់និងត្រចៀករបស់យើង យ៉ាងច្បាស់លាស់ហើយ ថា៖

កឹម សុខា ពិតជាប្រធានគណបក្សស៊ីឈ្នួល លក់ក្បាលអោយពួកអាក្បត់ជាតិកញ្ជះយួនមែន។
រួមបញ្ចូលទាំងកូនស្ដេចសីហនុ ចូលរួមទៅលិតបាតជើង ពួកអាក្បត់ជាតិកញ្ជះយួនផងដែរ។

ពួកនេះជ្រៅតែមាត់ គំនិតរាក់កំផេល ...!
ពួកអាពូជខ្ញុំគេ ៥រយជាតិ....!

Anonymous said...

EVIDENCE OF POLITICALLY-MOTIVATED EXTRAJUDICIAL EXECUTIONS AND KILLINGS OF FUNCINPEC LOYALISTS.

LIST OF INSTANCES OF EXTRAJUDICIAL EXECUTIONS during 1997 coup by PM Hun Sen. These people with their name list below were murdered by PM Hun Sen.

• Ho Sok, 45, Secretary of State at the Ministry of Interior and second ranking FUNCINPEC official in the Ministry of Interior.
• 2-3. Gen Chao Sambath, alias Ngov, Deputy-Chief of the Intelligence and Espionage Department, RCAF Supreme Command since 1993
• 4 and 5. Maj. Gen. Ly Seng Hong, Deputy-Chief of Staff, RCAF General Staff (second highest-ranking FUNCINPEC official in the RCAF General
• 6. Colonel Sok Vireak, Chief, Transmission Bureau, Army General Staff. A former KPNLF General Staff officer in charge of military training who joined Nhek Bun Chhay after the Paris Agreements. Status
• 7. Colonel Thlang Chang Sovannarith, Deputy Chief-of-Staff of the Fifth Military Region, RCAF General Staff
• 8. Colonel Hov Sambath, Deputy-chief of Military Training Bureau, RCAF General Staff
• 9. Lietenant Colonel Sao Sophal, 42, an officer of the First Bureau of the RCAF General Staff.
• 10. Navy First Lt. Thach Soeung, aged about 30, an ethnic Khmer from southern Vietnam, stationed at Dang Kaum Navy base on the eastern bank of the Tonle Sap.
• 11 to 14. Seng Phally, Lt. Col. Chao Keang, Chao Tea and Thong Vickika - security officers working under Gen. Chao Sambath.
• Seng Phally, alias Huot Phally, aged 25, single, a gendarme who worked as chief of the security team at the Pipoplok 2 Hotel/Casino
• Lt. Col. Chao Keang, aged about 25. He was an officer in the Research and Intelligence Bureau of Chao Sambath
• Chao Tea, 29, brother of Chao Keang, a security guard at the Regal Hotel/Casino. His body bore a bullet hole in the left side of the chest and in the right side of the stomach. He was also handcuffed and blindfolded
• Thong Vicchika, aged about 27-28, a body-guard of Chao Sambath and a security staff at the Regal Hotel/Casino.
• Dr. Seng Kim Ly, a military medical doctor
• Major Lak Ki, Head of Operations, Research and Intelligence, RCAF High Command
• Four unnamed body-guards of Nhek Bun Chhay were summarily executed after his office-cum-house in Somnang
• Major Lak Ki, Head of Operations, Research and Intelligence, RCAF High Command
• Pheap, a body-guard of Major Lak Ki, in his late twenties
• Dok Rany, 27, an officer and body-guard of Gen. Chao Sambath who worked at the Research and Intelligence Bureau
• Ros Huon, aged 23, Sopheap, aged 25, two alleged members of the Gendarmerie
• Dok Sokhun, alias Michael Senior, a Khmer-Canadian journalist who taught English at ACE Language School in Phnom Penh
• Major Aek Eng (CPP), Head of Administration of Phnom Penh Thmei police station

Anonymous said...

• At least four, and possibly up to 22 persons described as FUNCINPEC soldiers executed and cremated in Pich Nil on 9, 10 and 11 July 1997 by Military Region 3 soldiers. Status: Confirmed executions in at least 4 cases
• 34 to 36 (and possibly 45). On 17 July, at about noon time, the body of a soldier was witnessed floating near the bank of the Tone Bassac near the Watt Chum Leap, in the village of the same name, Rokakpong commune, Saang district, Kandal province. The body was headless and both hands were tied up behind the back with a kramma. It was dressed in dark olive military uniform
• 37 and 38. Two unidentified men, blindfolded and with their hands tied behind the back. Status: Confirmed executions
• Pheap, aged 33, a bodyguard of the First Prime Minister. Status: Confirmed execution.
• Sok Vanthorn, 21 and Sou Sal, two villagers from Ampeov village, Kompong Speu province. Status: Confirmed execution.
• Brig. Gen. Chea Rittichutt, a founding member of the Moulinaka movement and the Governor of Kep-Bokor
• Navy officer Meas Sarou, Deputy-director, First Bureau, Navy, based in Chrouy Changvar, and one of his body-guards, and a third person, a woman named Luch.
• Ung Sim, Second Deputy Governor, Kompong Speu province - missing since his arrest, reportedly near Pich Nil by CPP soldiers on 7 or 8 July 1997.
• Col. Sam Sarath, Deputy Chief-of-Staff, Third Military Region
• Put Som Ang, male, aged 42, a KNP activisit in Siem Reap province, and Sam Sophan, 38, an activist in Takeo province
• Major So Lay Sak and Major Chin Vannak, officers working in the Logisitics department of the RCAF General Staff
• Som Taing, Deputy Chief, Inspection Office, Provincial Governor's Office, Kompong Speu
• Chum Sarith, Chief, Criminal Bureau, Provincial Police, Sihanoukville
Forty-six bodies were brought in and dumped at the crematorium of a Phnom Penh pagoda between 5 and 9 July
In the case of Ho Sok (executed on 7 July, brought to Watt Lanka on 8 July); of Seng Phally, Chao Keang, Chao Tea and Thong Viccheka (executed on 5-6 July and brought by the police to Wat Unalom on the morning of 7 July - see cases number 13-16 above) and in the case of a fifth corpse which was brought to the same pagoda on the same morning, but which could not be identified, the police ordered that cremation of the bodies be conducted without question and without proper cremation permit.
Between 9 and 11 July, according to a variety of reliable corroborating accounts, the bodies of 4 and probably up to 22 soldiers were alleged to have been executed in Pich Nil and burned
Plus many and many more names with lose count that order and executed by Hun Sen and CPP.

Anonymous said...

11:23 AM,

Did you read the Constitution of the Kingdom of Cambodia before you wrote your silly comment here?

They did not talk in the article about the kind of power you mentioned in your silly comment. They talked about the powers granted to the King by the constitution.

So before replying to my comment here, read the Constitution of the Kingdome of Cambodia.

Anonymous said...

Shamfull puppet king of CPP.

We Khmer used to have a wonderfull King during Kangkar Wat era.

But now even king is a puppet of a puppet.

Anonymous said...

THe King, the king families, prince Ranaridth and Funcinpec Party leaders are betray innocent khmer blood as list above. They don't want to find justice for the victims of 1997 coup at all, as long as they get comfort, money from Hun Sen. They will be silence above the victims blood 1997 coup.

Doctor PhD of Law from France University Prince Ranaridth is the biggest betrayer of all time in khmer history.

Anonymous said...

Who love Khmer kings, Sihanouk and Sihamony? Only the uneducated and stupid people who still love this stupid kings. I myself hate these asshole kings who do nonething, but help to destroy Khmer people and Khmer land. If Ah Sihanouk is good king, he should not allow Ah Hun Sen destroy Cambodia for Youn's interest. He should ask his long time friend, China, to kick Ah Hun Sen's butt out of power. But, China sees Ah Sihanouk is a useless person and China is no longer need his service. China can take all his salary and priviledge like medical care, transportation, and small palace away from him in anytime. These asshole kings are just going after their benefit and their goals to sit in the palace and don't care what the country becomes.

That's why I hate them.

Anonymous said...

ហ៊ុន សែនជាខ្ញុំយួនដាច់ថ្លៃ ហើយសីហនុជាខ្ញុំ
ហ៊ុន សែនផងនិងយួនទៀត។ តាមពិត យួនចង់
រក្សាពូជស្ដេចជាខែល ព្រោះខ្មែរនិយមស្ដេច។
សីហនុមានសគុណនិងយួនហើយយួនមាន
សគុណនិងសីហនុ។
ខ្មែរគួរតែបំបាត់ពូជស្ដេចដូចប្រទេសនានាដែល
បានធ្វើមកជាគំរូ ដូចជាលាវ យួន ភូមា។ល។

Anonymous said...

i only like smart, wise, enlightened people; i do not like the stupid, ignorant kind, you know!