Showing posts with label Boeng Trabek jail chief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Boeng Trabek jail chief. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

Nuon Chea, Ieng Sary defence claims ‘subterfuge’

Nuon Chea, aka Brother No 2, attends a hearing at the ECCC last year. Photograph: Reuters

Tuesday, 28 August 2012
Stuart White
The Phnom Penh Post

Witness Ton Rochoem, alias Phy Phuon, continued to be a source of controversy at the Khmer Rouge tribunal yesterday, with defence teams for both co-accused Nuon Chea and Ieng Sary calling on the court to address issues with the former Khmer Rouge administrator’s testimony.

In an addendum to a previous filing calling for summary action against Minister for Foreign Affairs Hor Namhong for interference in the tribunal’s work, Nuon Chea’s defence drew a timeline linking the testimony of Phuon that Namhong was in charge of the Boeung Trabek detention facility, to Namhong’s statement to the press the next day refuting the testimony and to Phuon’s subsequent retraction of his remarks to local media.

[Namhong’s] statement appears to have efficiently and effectively achieved one of its intended results,” the filing read, going on to argue that the court should take “summary action” against Namhong for comments amounting to governmental interference in the court.

Nuon Chea defence counsel Andrew Ianuzzi said that at a minimum the court should issue a statement condemning Namhong’s actions.

Friday, August 03, 2012

Comrade Yaem (aka Hor 5 Hong) denies his VIP role in the Khmer Rouge regime

Comrade Yaem


Short Comment of HE Deputy Prime Minister Hor Namhong
Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation

It is unfortunate that those who continue to defend the legacy of the Khmer Rouge regime seek, in the interest of their defense, to deflect attention from themselves and their cases, by way of stirring up controversy around public figures like myself. I want to offer this brief statement about my history to dispel this controversy. The Khmer Rouge regime is an epic tragedy that continues to haunt Cambodia's people today. As a prisoner at Boeng Trabek reeducation camp where I lost two sisters, their husbands, children and a niece as well as countless colleagues, I have nothing but sorrow and empathy for the victims and their families. Cambodians continue to suffer from the crimes of the Khmer Rouge even today. The Khmer Rouge not only destroyed a generation of Cambodian people but also, in many ways, a civilization. We are still rebuilding this civilization today. The Extraordinary Chamber in the Courts of Cambodia is a court of law, and not a political forum, and I believe attempts to politicize the court or stir up controversy are inappropriate. (sic!)

My greatest hope is that one day justice is done and the legacy of the Khmer Rouge is given its proper place in the dustbin of history— without defense or controversy.

Phnom Penh, August 2, 2012

Friday, July 15, 2011

Hor 5 Hong’s reaction to US officials on Wikileaks publication about his biography as Boeung Trabek jail chief

15 July 2011
By Rithypol
Free Press Magazine Online
Translated from Khmer by Soch
Click here to read the original article in Khmer

The Cambodian minister of Foreign Affairs reacted to the publication of his biography which was leaked by Wikileaks on 11 July, indicating that he was the Beoung Trabek jail chief during the Khmer Rouge era.

A press communiqué issued by the ministry of Foreign Affairs on Friday 15 July, indicated that Hor 5 Hong summoned Jeff Daigle, the US Deputy Head of Mission and Chargé d’Affaires in Phnom Penh, to reply to the secret revelations of the 2002 report written by Alexander A. Arvizu on Hor 5 Hong’s biography published online by Wikileaks on Monday of this week.

Hor 5 Hong raised to Jeff Daigle about the report written by Alexander Arvizu to the US State Department. The Cambodian ministry of Foreign Affairs called for comments from the US Embassy in Phnom Penh on this issue.

According to Wikileaks’ publication posted on 11 July, Hor 5 Hong and his wife were close to Ieng Sary, the former KR deputy prime minister and minister of Foreign Affairs. Wikileaks’ report indicated that Hor 5 Hong’s wife saw her daughter’s picture in Tuol Sleng jail, and it also reported about her request to Ien Sary’s for intervention. The Wikileaks report claims that Hor 5 Hong is involved with people [sent] to Tuol Sleng during that era.

Comrade 5, ex-Boeung Trabek jail chief, protest US charge


Tuesday, March 30, 2010

French Verdict Delayed in Sam Rainsy Lawsuit

Hor 5 Hong (L) and Sam Rainsy (R)

By Men Kimseng, VOA Khmer
Original report from Washington
29 March 2010


The French Court of Appeals has delayed until May 20 the verdict in a lawsuit brought against opposition leader Sam Rainsy by Cambodia’s foreign minister.

There is no decision yet, because the court will need to take the case under further consideration,” Sam Rainsy told VOA Khmer Friday.

Sam Rainsy was found guilty in a lower court of defamation, for alleging in a memoir the minister, Hor Namhong, had colluded with the Khmer Rouge while supervising a Phnom Penh work camp under the regime.

Hor Namhong has said he was a victim within the Boeung Trabek camp, where several inmates died.

Hor Namhong brought four witnesses to testify in his favor, including Khmer Rouge historian Raoul Jennar, sources who attended a March 25 hearing in Paris told VOA Khmer. Around 50 Cambodians attended the hearing. Sam Rainsy said those who would have come forward on his behalf were afraid for the safety of their families in Cambodia.

“We regret that some of the witnesses who were in the Boeung Trabek correction camp dared not to step forward to be my witnesses,” Sam Rainsy said.

Hor Namhong declined to comment on the case, but a spokesman for the ministry, Koy Kuong, said Hor Namhong had attended the hearing in person.

“This is an important case in which he must try to make sure the French appeals court provides him justice,” Koy Kuong told VOA Khmer.

Sam Rainsy said Friday he had submitted additional evidence to the French court to defend his writing.

Hor Namhong is also among six Cambodian government officials who have refused to appear before the Khmer Rouge tribunal in Phnom Penh, claiming they did not want to create bias in the UN-backed court.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Khmer Intelligence News - 21 March 2010

KHMER INTELLIGENCE NEWS

21 March 2010

Secret oil deal between Hun Sen and Thaksin Shinawatra (2)

In early 2006 Cambodia’s Prime Minister Hun Sen and Thailand’s Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra concluded a secret oil deal to personally share “under the table” a portion of royalties to be paid by oil exploitation companies. Those companies had been exploring very promising offshore oil and gas deposits in the Gulf of Thailand, including in the overlapping zones claimed by both Cambodia and Thailand.

For revenue stemming from these overlapping zones, a tentative agreement has been reached whereby:
  • Revenue from zones closest to Cambodia’s shores will be shared as follows: 70 percent to Cambodia; 30 percent to Thailand.
  • Revenue from zones closest to Thailand’s shores: 70 percent to Thailand; 30 percent to Cambodia.
However, the two prime ministers mutually agreed to mislead their respective public opinions by accepting to “recognize” that some of the zones closest to Cambodia be instead considered as closest to Thailand, and vice versa.

Therefore, in the case of Cambodia, instead of receiving 70 percent, the country would receive only 30 percent of the royalties paid by the concerned oil companies, the remaining 40 percent would be split fifty-fifty between Hun Sen and Thaksin, meaning twenty percent each for the two leaders on a personal base.

The same sharing scheme would apply to the overlapping zones closest to Thailand, with Thaksin and Hun Sen also secretly receiving 20 percent each of the royalties.

Interrelation between secret oil agreement and Preah Vihear Temple issue (2)

In order to ensure a smooth implementation of the above-exposed secret oil agreement, Thaksin promised Hun Sen to let the Cambodian government deal, as it pleases, with the Preah Vihear Temple, including registering the Temple as a World Heritage site with UNESCO.

However, Thailand’s new governments following Thaksin’s fall from power in late 2006, decided they were not bound by the secret and personal deal between Thaksin and Hun Sen. Border incidents started in 2008 when Hun Sen tried to exacerbate Khmer nationalistic fervor a few weeks before the July general elections in Cambodia, prompting Thailand’s authorities to react by also asserting their own nationalistic stance.

Cambodian citizenship to protect and reassure “ex-foreign” investors (2)

Because Cambodia’s law does not allow foreigners to own land in our country, the Hun Sen government has granted Cambodian citizenship to countless investors (from China, Malaysia, Hong Kong, Taiwan but also some European countries) who are willing to invest large amounts of money to buy land and engage in “development projects.” Among the most prominent “ex-foreign” investors is Mr. Thaksin Shinawatra from Thailand who was given Khmer citizenship in March 2009. Mr. Thaksin has reportedly bought large chunks of land in Cambodia’s maritime Koh Kong province bordering Thailand for economic, financial and possibly other reasons.

Army generals amass fortune from standoff with Thailand (2)

The ongoing military tension on the border between Cambodia and Thailand brings about a windfall for Army generals close to Prime Minister Hun Sen. Tens of millions of dollars have been collected every month by the corrupt military brass from systemic diversion of financial support officially intended for “soldiers fighting on the frontline to defend the Motherland.” The Generals are also collecting ghost soldiers’ salaries (about one third of the whole Army staff) while selling on the market food and equipment earmarked for the Army. Last but not least, illegal logging (deforestation) has resumed on a large scale since 2008 thanks to the security reasons invoked to justify the secrecy surrounding any military initiative and movement.

New evidence of border encroachment by Vietnam to be made public next week (2)

Cambodia is reportedly victim of border encroachment by her more powerful neighbours. Regarding recent incidents in the Eastern province of Svay Rieng bordering Vietnam, Sam Rainsy earlier this week announced a “good news” to King-Father Norodom Sihanouk who presided over the now-defunct Supreme National Council on Border Affairs. In his letter to the Retired King, the opposition leader said “top leading experts” he consulted in Europe, confirmed “the validity of what we all know and of what I recently denounced, namely the displacing of the border posts by Vietnam to the detriment of Cambodia.” Details of the technical reports by French and Swiss map experts are expected to be made public next week

Read Sam Rainsy’s original letter in French http://tinyurl.com/ydtv57l with translation in Khmer http://tinyurl.com/ybuvbym and in English http://tinyurl.com/yl6674u.

Towards a confrontation between Ieng Sary and Hor Namhong at the ECCC? (2)

Lawyers defending Ieng Sary at the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC) want Foreign Minister Hor Nam Hong, who was chairman of a prisoners’ committee at the Boeng Trabek re-education camp under the Pol Pot regime, to be confronted with their client Ieng Sary who was Foreign Minister of Democratic Kampuchea from April 1975 to January 1979.

Ieng Sary was Hor Nam Hong’s boss. The pair went together to Lima in August 1975 when Hor Nam Hong was ambassador to Cuba before he was recalled to Phnom Penh in December 1975 (see Justin Corfield and Laura Summers’ “Historical Dictionary of Cambodia” published in the USA in 2003). At Boeng Trabek, Foreign Minister Ieng Sary continued to frequently communicate with his protégé Hor Nam Hong whom he “rehabilitated” in 1978. According to the defence at the ECCC, Hor Nam Hong “was privy to the operation of Ieng Sary’s Foreign Ministry in Phnom Penh and the treatment of intellectuals at the Boeng Trabek prison camp, where Mr Namhong was also a prisoner” (The Cambodia Daily, 17 March 2010).

The defence’s request follows Co-Investigating Judge Marcel Lemonde’s decision in October 2009 to summon Hor Nam Hong to testify before the ECCC. Hor Nam Hong refuses to appear before the Judge.

Hor Nam Hong will face opposition leader Sam Rainsy before a French court in Paris on 25 March 2010 following a defamation lawsuit filed by the former against the latter. Read Sam Rainsy’s open letter to Hor Nam Hong in French at http://tinyurl.com/yhcan48

[End]

Tuesday, November 03, 2009

Kiss, but ... do not tell?

In 1989, Sihanouk was quoted in a French newspaper as saying: "Mr Hun Sen's team is made up of former arch−criminal Khmer Rouge officials. For instance, Hor Namhong, ex−commander of a Khmer Rouge concentration camp, is responsible for the death, after atrocious torture, of many former members of the anti−American resistance...."

Hor Namhong has enlisted as a legal precedent a 1991 defamation ruling by a French court against former king Norodom Sihanouk.

Friday, January 30, 2009

"Even though Sam Rainsy has lost for now, that accusation [against Hor Nam Hong] is still going around": Chea Vannath

Hor Nam Hong (L) and Sam Rainsy (R)

In Cambodia, Sam Rainsy no worse for wear: legal officials

Friday, 30 January 2009
Written by Brendan Brady and Neth Pheaktra
The Phnom Penh Post


PPenh legal minds say defamation ruling against Sam Rainsy will not reverberate locally; Hor Namhong waits for Cambodian case to progress.

ALTHOUGH the local fallout of a French court ruling Tuesday against opposition leader Sam Rainsy for disinformation and defamation has yet to materialise, Phnom Penh legal officials doubt the verdict will hold sway in a Cambodian court.

Foreign Minister Hor Namhong, who sought to sue Sam Rainsy for defamation in both French and Cambodian courts, has yet to deliver any resounding words calling for further punishment of the opposition leader, but Foreign Affairs Ministry spokesman Koy Kuong said his boss was waiting for local officials to "further their investigation".
"Even though Sam Rainsy has lost for now, that accusation is still going around. "
In his autobiography, Rooted in Stone, published in May last year, Sam Rainsy accused Hor Namhong of heading the Boeung Trabek "re-education" camp, where former diplomats and government officials from the Lon Nol and Sihanouk regimes were detained.

Hor Namhong had previously filed a lawsuit in Phnom Penh in April after the opposition leader alluded to the minister's involvement in the leadership of the Khmer Rouge in a speech at the Choeung Ek "killing fields". Hor Namhong shelved the case, however, awaiting the French verdict addressing the more explicit comment Sam Rainsy made in his book.

According to Phnom Penh Municipal Court President Chiv Keng, while the local case was ongoing, it would not be impacted by Tuesday's ruling, since that case "depended on facts from a different place".

For Sok Sam Ouen, director of the Cambodian Defenders Project, more charges against the opposition leader would, in his opinion, effectively amount to double jeopardy, as the claim Hor Namhong objects to is the same.

Sam Rainsy's lawyer, Kong Sam Onn, said any local legal action would require his client first be stripped of political immunity by order of the National Assembly.

He also denied tremors from the French verdict would register in Phnom Penh since, he said, "there is no law allowing a Cambodian court to use an international decision to rule on a case".

Sam Rainsy, for his part, remains unrepentant, telling the Post he "has no regrets and would not change a word."

Accusation not debunked
While legal minds may see the opposition leader's local legal standing as no worse off, Chea Vannath, a commentator on domestic social and political affairs, described the verdict as a political victory for the ruling Cambodian People's Party, whose membership has been publicly linked to leadership roles in the Khmer Rouge.

She said, however, the charge against Hor Namhong had not been laid to rest.

"Even though Sam Rainsy has lost for now, that accusation is still going around," she said.

She said she expected the ruling party would continue to address public remarks linking it to the brutality of the ultra-Maoist regime when expedient.

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Hor Namhong versus Sam Rainsy: Hearing at The French Court on December 9, 2008

Source: SRP

December 11, 2008

HOR NAMHONG VERSUS SAM RAINSY :
HEARING AT THE FRENCH COURT ON DECEMBER 9, 2008

Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Affairs Minister Hor Namhong has filed a defamation lawsuit against Sam Rainsy before the French Court following the publication this year in France of a book by the opposition leader titled "Des racines dans la pierre" (Rooted in Stone).

The hearing which took place at Le Palais de Justice in Paris started at 4:50 pm and ended at 8:30 pm.

Hor Namhong was there with five lawyers. They brought Raoul Jennar, a Belgian "expert on Cambodia", as a witness. Sam Rainsy was there too but with only one lawyer and no witness.

Hor Namhong's arguments

1- Former King Norodom Sihanouk was condemned by the French Court on January 23, 1991 after being quoted as saying in the French newspaper Le Journal du Dimanche dated July 23, 1989:

"L'équipe de Monsieur Hun Sen est composée d'anciens Khmers rouges archi-criminels. Par exemple, Hor Nam Hong, ex-commandant d'un camp de concentration Khmer rouge, est responsable de la mort après d'atroces tortures de beaucoup d'anciens membres de la résistance anti-américaine, tels mon cousin le prince Sisowath Méthavi et son épouse, sœur aînée de ma femme… "

"Mr. Hun Sen's team is made up of former arch-criminal Khmer Rouge officials. For instance, Hor Nam Hong, ex-commander of a Khmer Rouge concentration camp, is responsible for the death, after atrocious tortures, of many former members of the anti-American resistance, such as my cousin Prince Sisowath Methavy and his spouse, who was my wife's elder sister…"

According to Hor Namhong, Sam Rainsy in his book made against him the same allegations as the ones Norodom Sihanouk made nearly twenty years ago; Sam Rainsy should then be condemned in the same way as the former King was condemned by the same Court.

2- Hor Namhong lost many relatives under the Khmer Rouge regime. Therefore, he could not have cooperated in any way with the Khmer Rouge.

Sam Rainsy's arguments

1- In his book Sam Rainsy actually wrote:

"Hun Sen n'était pas seul dans son cas: la plupart des supplétifs du régime vietnamien avaient frayé avec les Khmers rouges. Quand Ranariddh et Hun Sen eurent définitivement scellé mon compte, ils ne trouvèrent pas mieux que de nommer à la tête de mon ministère Keat Chhon, celui qui, pendant tant d'années, fut le principal conseiller de Pol Pot. Et quelques années plus tard, le Ministre des Affaires Etrangères serait un ancien collaborateur du pouvoir khmer rouge soupçonné d'avoir causé la mort de nombreuses personnes dont des membres de la famille royale".

"Hun Sen was not alone in his case: most of the Vietnamese regime's auxiliary staff had cooperated in one way or another with the Khmer Rouge. When Ranariddh and Hun Sen had definitively decided on my fate, they did not find anything better than appointing at the head of my ministry Keat Chhon, the man who, for so many years had been the main adviser to Pol Pot. And several years later, the Foreign Affairs Minister could be a former collaborator of the Khmer Rouge regime suspected of having caused the death of many people including members of the royal family."

Sam Rainsy points to the fact that what he wrote is not exactly the same, in the content and in the form, as what former King Norodom Sihanouk had reportedly said.

2- There have been new developments and new evidence against Hor Namhong since 1991 when the former King lost the first lawsuit filed by Hor Namhong before the French Court. Sam Rainsy refers to The Cambodia Daily report "Clouded History" published on July 1-2, 2000, the interview of Senator Keo Bunthouk (Mrs. Ieng Kounsaky) titled "A camp called Boeng Trabek" published in The Phnom Penh Post dated January 19 - February 1, 2001 and the book by Ong Thong Hoeung "J'ai cru aux Khmers Rouges" (I believed in the Khmer Rouge) published in Europe in 2003. Related documents at http://tinyurl.com/56czqh

Hor Namhong said that he had filed a defamation lawsuit in Phnom Penh against The Cambodia Daily for the above-mentioned report and that he won the case. Out of the two authors of the report, only the Cambodian reporter [Thet Sambath] was condemned by the Cambodian Court because the other one, who is an American national [Kelly McEvers], "ran away." He said that all the defamation cases initiated by him in Cambodia have been closed because all the concerned journalists [including Dam Sith, the editor of Moneaksekar Khmer (Khmer Conscience) who was jailed for one week this summer], have apologized to him.

Raoul Jennar said that he has been hired by the Khmer Rouge Tribunal in Phnom Penh (ECCC) as an "independent expert." To defend Hor Namhong he said that the genocide perpetrated by the Khmer Rouge was "centralized" in such a way that "only six persons in the Khmer Rouge top leadership could make the decision to kill any person." He also said that the Cambodian government is in no way responsible for any delay in the judicial proceedings at the ECCC.

The French Court will decide on the case on January 27, 2009.

Friday, October 10, 2008

Khmer Intelligence News - 10 October 2008

10 October 2008

Police's involvement in journalist Khim Sambo's murder (3)

The Hong Kong-based South China Morning Post, October 3, 2008, gave some clues that might be helpful for any serious investigation into the recent murder in Phnom Penh of opposition journalist Khim Sambo. Press correspondent Vincent Maclsaac writes in his report, « In the June 28-29 weekend edition of the daily Khmer Conscience, which is affiliated with the opposition Sam Rainsy Party (…), Khim Sambo (…) [mocked] the behaviour of a senior police officer described by many as "one of the most dangerous men in Cambodia". He reported on an incident that allegedly occurred (…) on June 25 at a casino complex at a border crossing with Vietnam in the town of Bavet in Svay Rieng province. After losing his shirt at Le Macau Casino and Hotel, the officer borrowed [money] from the casino, lost that, borrowed more - and lost again. When the casino manager refused to lend any more, he had him arrested by the junior [police] officers accompanying him, Khim Sambo reported (…). Several [sources] - all of whom requested anonymity, citing concern for personal security - said that Khim Sambo was writing about Cambodian National Police Commissioner Hok Lundy. »

Khim Sambo, 47, and his 21-year-old son Sarinpheatra were shot dead in broad daylight by unknown killers on July 11, 2008.

On May 18, 1996, journalist Thun Bun Ly was also shot dead in similar circumstances after mocking in opposition newspaper Khmer Ideal a few days before his death the wife of a powerful political leader.

Read South China Morning Post's whole article at http://tinyurl.com/3ed232

New evidence of massive election fraud on July 27, 2008 (2)

Over the last few weeks new evidence of fraud at the July 27, 2008 national election has been exposed. Fraud was systemic because the election was totally controlled by the ruling CPP through the National Election Committee (NEC). The evidence shown is related to manipulation of voter lists leading to a massive disenfranchisement of legitimate non-CPP voters and a broad mobilization of illegitimate voters to cast ballots for the CPP by using ghosts' names. These are two manoeuvres with far-reaching implications that most international election observers did not see because they took place before Voting Day and outside the polling stations.

As a result of the fraud, the last poll has obviously distorted the will of the Cambodian people.

Evidence of fraud is contained in three main documents:
  1. "What election observers did not see in a rigged election" at http://tinyurl.com/6gw3rz
  2. "Voter list cleaning (by the NEC) and political opponent cleansing (by the CPP)" at http://tinyurl.com/45mfpu
  3. "International election observers must open their eyes" at http://tinyurl.com/52t3eg
No democratic government has congratulated the CPP following its landslide victory (2)

As of today, only the government of North Korea has sent a message of congratulations to the CPP and to Cambodia's new/old leaders following their landslide election victory on July 27, 2008. Democratic governments have refrained from doing so, possibly because of doubts about the election's integrity (see evidence of fraud exposed above) and reservations about the controversial "package vote" on September 25 whereby the legislative and executive branches of the government had their respective leaderships elected at the same time, through the same single vote!

Read a relevant press article in Khmer published today at http://tinyurl.com/3kcqkk

No position for Ranariddh (2)

Even though the Norodom Ranariddh Party (NRP) has finally recognized and accepted the results of the July 27 election and declared that it is no longer an opposition party, Prince Norodom Ranariddh was not given any position in the new government. The NRP ex-President had thought that he could be appointed President of the Constitutional Council (replacing Ek Sam Ol) or Royal Palace Minister (replacing Kong Sam Ol). But the first position is a highly strategic one for the CPP and must be occupied by a CPP stalwart, and any pretender to the second position must have the support of the King, which does not seem to be the case for Prince Ranariddh.

Hor Namhong gave false information about Princess Nanette and Prince Sisowath Methavy (2)

French weekly Le Journal du Dimanche, July 23, 1989, quoted [then Prince now] King Father Norodom Sihanouk as declaring, "Hor Nam Hong, former commander of a Khmer Rouge concentration camp [Boeng Trabek detention camp], is responsible for the death, after atrocious tortures, of many former members of the anti-American Resistance, such as my cousin Prince Sisowath Methavy, and his spouse [Princess Nanette], the elder sister of my wife [now Queen Mother Norodom Monineath Sihanouk]."

Princess Sisowath Nanette arrived at Boeng Trabek camp in October 1977, directly from France, to join her husband Prince Sisowath Methavy who had returned to Cambodia since 1976, only one year after the Khmer Rouge take over. Following a short stay in Chraing Chamres, Prince Methavy was sent to Boeng Trabek camp in February 1977. Princess Nanette actually lived in Boeng Trabek camp for only six months before she and her husband were taken away to be executed in April 1978. This is confirmed by many surviving prisoners from the three sections of Boeng Trabek camp (B30, B31 and B32), who all confirm that they last saw Princess Nanette and her husband around the Cambodian New Year that took place in April 1978.

In an interview published in Khmer-language newspaper Rasmei Kampuchea, April 23, 2008, Hor Nam Hong says the Sisowath couple lived with him "until the end of 1978" before being taken away and killed by the Khmer Rouge. However, surviving witnesses say that the Khmer Rouge had stopped taking away and killing Boeng Trabek prisoners since August-September 1978, when living conditions suddenly started to improve as the Pol Pot regime tried to mobilize all Cambodian forces to counter increasing pressure from Vietnamese troops.

The late CPP Justice Minister Chem Sgnuon, who was detained at Boeng Trabek camp until Vietnamese troops arrived in January 1979, used to tell many people how cruel Hor Nam Hong was when he was the Khmer Rouge-appointed camp chief. Chem Snguon avoided talking with Hor Nam Hong because of this bitter past.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Cambodian prince calls for family's Khmer Rouge killers to be brought to justice

19/07/2008
by Nick Meo in Phnom Penh
The Telegraph (UK)


In a whitewashed mansion of the Royal Palace in Phnom Penh, Prince Thomico Sisowath gestured wistfully towards a table covered with black and white photos of his parents from the happy time before they were arrested by the Khmer Rouge.

Outside, an election slogan blared from a van's loudspeaker, interrupting the murmur of chanting at a nearby temple.

Next Sunday, almost 30 years after his mother and father were led out to the killing fields after years of being starved and beaten in a "re-education" camp, Cambodia will go to the polls.

One of those standing for re-election is a man whose role in the camp where they were held has become the subject of a furious argument in the election campaign: Cambodia's foreign minister, Hor Namhong.

Early in the campaign, an opposition leader publicly accused Mr Namhong of having been a member of the Khmer Rouge, whose four-year reign of terror ended only after an estimated 1.7 million Cambodians had died from starvation or mass murder – about one third of the country's population.

Mr Namhong angrily denied that he was ever part of the Khmer Rouge and has always insisted that he himself was among its victims – as an inmate of Boeng Trabek, the special prison camp for the Marxist re-education of diplomats and civil servants, where Prince Thomico's family was also held.

The camp's name remains a deeply emotive one for Cambodia's educated middle and upper classes. For many, it was the last place where their relations were seen before they were taken away and murdered. Out of 3,000 men, women and children who were held there, an estimated 2,700 perished, Prince Thomico's parents among them.

The accusation against Mr Namhong is that he was among prisoners recruited by the Khmer Rouge to run the camp, and thus had a hand in the fate of its other inmates.

The editor of an opposition newspaper which printed the claims about Mr Namhong was jailed, and the minister threatened legal action against Sam Rainsy, the opposition leader concerned. Genocide investigators say there is no evidence against the foreign minister.

Even if there were, he would not be the only member of Cambodia's ruling party who was once in the Khmer Rouge.

The prime minister, Hun Sen, in power since 1985, has never denied that he was in the party for a time, although it has not been suggested that he was involved in the mass killing. But it is Mr Namhong, an ambitious politician in his mid-seventies who is described by both friends and enemies as a man with a brilliant mind, whose past has become part of the election campaign. Prince Thomico would not be drawn on whether he held Mr Namhong responsible for the deaths of his parents. A small, wiry man with a mischievous grin, he spoke quietly but intensely.

"There is a question mark over who took decisions," he said. "This is very difficult for me and I have thought about what happened to my parents for 30 years. So have other Cambodians, though – the whole nation was bereaved."

He said that as a good Buddhist he bore no grudge against the foreign minister, who had personally assured him with an earnest handshake several years ago that he was not in a position of authority at the camp when his parents died. But he added that those who might have led the killings should be investigated, and justice done. "So many people had to join the Khmer Rouge in order to survive," Prince Thomico said. "Now the main problem is to find out whether they were in a position to give orders for murder or torture."

The fate of Prince Thomico's family was typical of almost anyone of his generation in Cambodia, whether royalty, middle-class professionals or peasants. His three-year-old daughter was lost in the chaos, and his parents were humiliated, then murdered. Five of his cousins, princes and princesses of the ancient Sisowath line of the royal family, are all presumed to have died in the killing fields, along with their 14 children.

No one has ever been charged with the murders, and there are no witnesses to any of their killings.

Now, semi-retired after a career in opposition politics, Prince Thomico, 59, lives surrounded by scented gardens and gilded spires in the palace, which was confiscated by the Khmer Rouge and used as a prison after it came to power in 1975. Recalling those grim days, the prince tells how his father, Methavi Sisowath, was Cambodia's ambassador to East Germany at the time, appointed by his uncle, the then King Sihanouk.

The king was so popular with Cambodians that the Maoist Khmer Rouge at first appointed him head of state. Like many other diplomats who were abroad as Phnom Pehn fell, Methavi swallowed his fears and answered the Khmer Rouge's call to return home, hoping that Sihanouk could protect him. "My father thought it was his duty to go home but I think he guessed he could be going to his death," said Prince Thomico. It was a fatal mistake. The next year, King Sihanouk was arrested, sent to the Boeng Trabek camp, along with Methavi and other family members.

Methavi's wife, Princess Anne-Marie, defied her children's pleas and also returned from Europe, to find him. They were reunited in the prison camp, and were last seen being led away in November 1978. No one doubts that they were killed soon afterwards, but how they died is one of the many questions about that time that haunts modern Cambodia. There is scant prospect of any answers. The prince is one of many disillusioned with the Khmer Rouge Tribunal, which has cost £25 million in the past two years and put just five men on trial

"It is painful, but I think this question about my parents' deaths will remain unanswered," said Prince Thomico.

Terror of the Pol Pot regime

The Khmer Rouge guerrillas seized power in Cambodia in 1975 after overthrowing King Norodom Sihanouk in a bloody agrarian revolution.

Led by Pol Pot, also known as “brother number one”, they declared “year zero” and set about abolishing money, private property and religion.

In a quest to create a peasant paradise they emptied the cities, forcing people to work as labourers in the paddy fields.

Anyone deemed too intellectual was killed, sometimes just because they wore glasses.

The violence was so extreme that communist Vietnam invaded in 1978 to install a more moderate regime and drive Pol Pot’s guerrillas back into the jungle.

Many former party members stayed in power, including Hun Sen, the current prime minister.

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Thomico not happy that Sam Rainsy is using his parents’ names in the lawsuit

11 July 2008
Rasmei Kampuchea
Translation from Khmer by Heng Soy

On 10 July, Prince Sisowath Thomico expressed his unhappiness that opposition leader Sam Rainsy used his parents’ names in the lawsuit brought by Hor Namhong against him.

In an interview over the phone on Thursday morning, Thomico said: “I don’t want my parents’ names involved in the country politics because they are not involved in the current politics.” The prince added that Sam Rainsy should not mix a legal issue with politics.

Prince Thomico indicated that Princess Nanette and Prince Sisowath Methavy lived in the Boeng Trabek camp until November 1978 before they were taken away. Since then, Thomico lost track of his parents, and he did not know how his parents were killed. However, Thomico indicated that his parents dedicated their lives to serve the nation and to follow the Hero-King Norodom Sihanouk.

Thomico refused to comment on the letter Sam Rainsy handed over the tribunal on 09 July. Nevertheless, Thomico indicated that there are a number of people who used to live in Boeng Trabek with his parents, and they are still alive now.

On 09 July, Sam Rainsy read a letter confirming that Hor Namhong was the Boeng Trabek jail chief after Van Piny (the former Boeng Trabel jail chief).

While being unhappy to see Sam Rainsy’s involving his parents’ names in the lawsuit brought up by Hor Namhong, Thomico said that if Sam Rainsy wants to find justice, he should bring the case to the KR Tribunal [KI-Media note: Sam Rainsy did ask the KRT to take up the case, but the KRT refused]. Nonetheless, Sam Rainsy took this case to comment in a political speech instead, Thomico claimed.

Based on the past court victory on a similar case against King-Father, people believed that Hor Namhong has the advantage over Sam Rainsy, therefore, some commentators are concerned that this lawsuit could affect Sam Rainsy’s political life after the election.

Hor Namhong sued Sam Rainsy for cursing and misinformation, after Sam Rainsy declared that the Choeung Ek Memorial site, in April, that Hor Namhong was the Boeng Trabek jail chief. This case is still in the hands of the tribunal.

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

'Biased' Courts Close Doors to Sam Rainsy

By Heng Reaksmey, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
09 July 2008


Phnom Penh Municipal Court officials refused to meet with opposition leader Sam Rainsy Wednesday, as he sought to provide what he says is evidence of Foreign Minister Hor Namhong's involvement in a Khmer Rouge prison camp.

Sam Rainsy has been summoned several times to the court since April, but he said he had gone of his own volition Wednesday.

He sought to submit to the court the alleged testimony of a former Boeung Trabek camp inmate that accuses Hor Namhong of being the chief of the prison.

Hor Namhong, who has maintained he was a prisoner at the camp, sued Sam Rainsy for defamation and disinformation for similar accusations made at a public rally in April.

Sam Rainsy said Wednesday the courts were "cheap" and "biased" to the ruling Cambodian People's Party.

Court officials were not immediately available to for comment.

Tuesday, July 08, 2008

On July 9, 2008 at 8am, MP Sam Rainsy will go to the tribunal

Phnom Penh , 8 July 2008

PRESS RELEASE


ON JULY 9, 2008 AT 8AM,
MP SAM RAINSY WILL GO TO THE TRIBUNAL

In relation to the defamation lawsuit filed by Minister of Foreign Affairs Hor Nam Hong and following the request made by the Phnom Penh Municipal Court to lift his parliamentary immunity, Member of Parliament Sam Rainsy will go to the Phnom Penh Municipal Court on July 9, 2008 , at 8am .

Tribunals, judges and prosecutors can interview Parliamentarians any time, and do not need to wait until their parliamentary immunity is lifted.

After his meeting with the Phnom Penh Municipal Court magistrates, MP Sam Rainsy will address questions from the press.

SRP Members of Parliament

For more information please contact Tioulong Saumura 092 888 002

Saturday, June 28, 2008

Hor Namhong double-dipping? He sues Sam Rainsy twice: in Cambodia and in France for the same case

Hor Namhong (Photo: DR, Cambodge Soir Hebdo)

Hor Namhong withdraw his lawsuit against Dam Sith

27 June 2008
Leang Delux Cambodge Soir Hebdo
Translated from French by Luc Sâr
Click here to read the original article in French


Hor Namhong, the Foreign Affair minister, announced on Friday 27 June that he will withdraw his lawsuit against Dam Sith, the opposition journalist.

“Dam Sith came to ask me for an amicable settlement, I will ask the tribunal to withdraw my lawsuit,” Hor Namhong said during an interview with a representative of the Cambodian Club of Journalists (CCJ) and Dam Sith who was accompanied by his lawyer.

“I told Dam Sith that I did not wish to have a lawsuit between journalists and politicians during the run up to the election. I am happy to end this affair,” Hor Namhong added.

Kong Sam Onn, Dam Sith’s lawyer, said that he was also satisfied, and that this withdrawal would allow the journalist as well as the minister to turn the page and avoid any disturbance to the election campaign.

How Namhong did not withdraw his lawsuit against opposition leader Sam Rainsy whom the Moneakseka Khmer newspaper quoted.

I brought a lawsuit in the French tribunal and one more with the Cambodian tribunal for defamation and disinformation. If the Cambodian justice is under coercion, we will see how the French justice will decide the case,” Hor Namhong said.

Sam Rainsy reacted by saying: “It is normal that Hor Namhong withdraw his lawsuit against Dam Sith. This affair shouldn’t have started to begin with.” Sam Rainsy is also happy to learn that Hor Namhong brought a lawsuit against him in France. “The French justice is free, and I have enough proofs and witnesses to support what I said,” he added.

In April, Hor Namhong brought a lawsuit against Sam Rainsy for defamation in disinformation, and also against the Moneakseka Khmer newspaper for disinformation. He blamed the opposition newspaper of quoting Sam Rainsy’s claim, according to which Hor Namhong directed the Boeng Trabek jail under the KR regime.

“This is not an ordinary case, especially for me who had particularly suffered under the KR regime,” Hor Namhong explained.

Dam Sith: "Hor Namhong doesn't want to be reminded of the past" [-Too many bad memories from the past for Hor Namhong?]

Foreign Minister Hor Namhong said Friday he was dropping a defamation suit to help a secure election environment.

Minister Drops Suit Against Opposition Editor

By Chun Sakada, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
27 June 2008


Foreign Minister Hor Namhong announced Friday he will drop his defamation suit against an opposition newspaper editor who was jailed for a week earlier this month.

Hor Namhong said he was dropping his suit against Dam Sith because he did not want to interfere with the political atmosphere ahead of general elections.

The defamation suit, filed in April, stemmed from a story published in Dam Sith's newspaper, Moneaksekar Khmer, which quoted opposition leader Sam Rainsy accusing the foreign minister of involvement in the Khmer Rouge. Dam Sith spent a week in jail following Phnom Penh Municipal Court investigations, worrying observers that press freedom was eroding ahead of July's national election.

"I am very happy to drop the complaint against Dam Sith, in the spirit of compatriotism," Hor Namhong told reporters Friday, following an hour-long meeting with Dam Sith at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. "I told Dam Sith that although we occupy different political tendencies, we are all Khmer, and this compromise will lead to a good atmosphere for the election."

Hor Namhong said he would officially request the court to drop the case.

"Hor Namhong doesn't want to be reminded of the past," Dam Sith said following the announcement Friday. "He decided to drop his complaint against me."

"I did not apologize to Hor Namhong," he said of the meeting, "but I only asked that he compromise and he get his complaint out of court, so that I have the right to walk around without restriction."

Um Sarin, president of the Cambodian Association for the Protection of Journalists, called the minister's decision a "positive step" and "good example for other high-ranking officials."

Friday, June 27, 2008

Rainsy's immunity assured until after election

Hor Namhong (L) and Sam Rainsy (R)

Friday, 27 June 2008

Written by Vong Sokheng and Cheang Sokha
The Phnom Penh Post


Cambodian lawmakers will wait until after the July 27 general election to debate whether to strip opposition leader Sam Rainsy of his parliamentary immunity, in a bid to ease political tensions ahead of the polls, European Union elections observers said.

Rainsy faces investigation and possible arrest over defamation claims made by Foreign Minister Hor Namhong if he loses his legislative protection.

Phnom Penh Municipal Court issued a request on June 16 that the National Assembly “temporarily suspend the immunity of Sam Rainsy,” adding that the court had collected enough evidence to warrant further investigation into the accusations made against him by Namhong.

Namhong alleges he was defamed when Rainsy said during a speech on April 17 that under the Khmer Rouge regime he was the director of Boeng Trabek prison, a detention center for intellectuals and members of the royal family.

Namhong has repeatedly said that he was an ordinary prisoner at Boeng Trabek, denying that he worked for the regime, whose 1975-79 rule over Cambodia resulted in 1.7 million deaths in one of the darkest chapters of the 20th century.

But the EU’s chief election observer, Martin Callanan, told reporter’s on June 20 that Namhong had assured poll monitors that no move would be made against Rainsy until after the election.

Hor Namhong ... assured [EU] election observers that parliamentary immunity of the opposition leader Sam Rainsy would not be stripped before the July national elections,” Callanan said.

Election monitors said they welcomed the decision, saying Rainsy’s participation in the vote would help ensure a stabile political atmosphere.

It’s a good that Rainsy can join the campaign because it will make the election go smoothly,” said Mar Sophal of the election monitor Comfrel.

Rainsy last lost his parliamentary immunity in 1995 while he was in self-imposed exile in France, shortly before he was convicted of defaming Prime Minister Hun Sen in a case that drew heavy international criticism.

Although he was later pardoned and returned to Cambodia, Rainsy says the ruling Cambodian People’s Party, of which Hun Sen is a member, is still trying to shut him down and earlier dismissed the July polls as “meaningless” in the face of the CPP’s political maneuvering.

In the weeks leading up to the campaign season Hun Sen ordered an investigation into the Sam Rainsy Party, claiming that defectors had implicated the opposition in a number of violent plots, including the 1998 rocket attack against the prime minister and a 2000 attack in the capital by the Cambodian Freedom Fighters, a band of self-proclaimed coup makers led by a Cambodian-American.

In a letter to the CPP on June 18, the opposition called on Hun Sen to stop intimidating Sam Rainsy followers with threats of prosecution over phantom plots.

The accusations that the SRP is involved in violence is unacceptable.... The SRP has no culture of violence,” the party’s statement said.

Hor Namhong withdraws his lawsuit against Dam Sith, Moneaksekar Khmer Editor-in-chief and SRP MP candidate

Hor Namhong (L) and Sam Rainsy (R) (Photo: RFA)

Cambodian minister drops defamation suit against news editor

Jun 27, 2008

DPA

Phnom Penh - A senior Cambodian minister will withdraw a defamation complaint against an opposition newspaper editor who is also a candidate in upcoming national elections, he announced at a press conference Friday.

On June 8, Dam Sith, editor of pro-Sam Rainsy Party newspaper Moneaksekar Khmer, was arrested as he washed his car in the capital and spent a week in the notorious Prey Sar prison before Prime Minister Hun Sen intervened on his behalf.

His arrest followed a complaint by Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Hor Namhong accusing Sith of defamation, 'insult' and disinformation regarding quotes by opposition leader Sam Rainsy his paper had published.

The quotes concerned claims made by Sam Rainsy in connection with the 1975-79 Khmer Rouge regime which the minister said were deeply hurtful and completely untrue.

'I was a victim of the regime, not a perpetrator,' he said.

He gave no reason for dropping the charges, but a board member for the Club of Cambodian Journalists said later Sith had written to Hor Namhong saying publishing the quotes had been 'a mistake.'

Hor Namhong said he would continue to sue Rainsy for defamation through the Paris courts. Rainsy holds a French passport.

'Some people claim the Cambodian courts are not independent, so I am taking legal action in France,' he said.

Sith's arrest provoked howls of protest from human rights and media activists around the world.

His unprecedented detention on civil charges also came at a politically sensitive time, with Cambodia gearing up for national elections on July 27 which Hor Namhong's dominant Cambodian People's Party is expected to win handsomely.