Showing posts with label Reinstatement of Sam Rainsy's parliamentary immunity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reinstatement of Sam Rainsy's parliamentary immunity. Show all posts

Monday, October 19, 2009

Return of SRP MP’s immunity is a complicated affair

SRP MP Ho Vann (L) and SRP MP Mu Sochua (R)

17 October 2009

By Sopheap
Khmer Express News
Translated from Khmer by Socheata


The parliamentary immunity of 2 SRP MPs – Kampot MP Mu Sochua and Phnom Penh MP Ho Vann – which was lifted on 22 June 2009 stemming from defamation lawsuits brought up by Hun Xen (in the case of Mu Sochua) and 22 high-ranking army officers (in the case of Ho Vann), has not been restored yet.

The Committee for Free and Fair Elections in Cambodia (Comfrel), an election watchdog group, issued a report for August and September titled: “Complications in the return of parliamentary immunity to MPs” in which it indicated that these complications stem from the lack of clear law providing the procedure for such return. Such shortcoming led to MPs, politicians, government officials and legal scholars to provide diverging opinions.

Prey Veng SRP MP Yem Ponharith is also of the same opinion. He indicated that, according to the spirit of Article 16 of the MP statute law, MP should automatically receive their parliamentary immunity without the need for a parliamentary vote to return it back to them.

Prey Veng CPP MP Cheam Yeap said that MPs receive their parliamentary immunity once they gave their oath at the start of their office position. He claimed that the removal of the parliamentary immunity was initiated by a request from the tribunal to the ministry of Justice, but if it should be restored back, the court should also ask the ministry of Justice to tell the National Assembly to vote to return the parliamentary immunity to the MP back.

Koul Panha, Executive Director of Comfrel, indicated that rule to lift or return the parliamentary immunity for MPs should be clearly stated in a law. The National Assembly seems to decide as it pleases: the parliamentary immunity could be lifted by the permanent committee of the NA, or that it requires a 2/3 votes from the NA to restore the parliamentary immunity back, but in fact, there is no law to stipulate all the above.

Currently, the NA seems to function under the rule that whichever way was used to lift the parliamentary immunity, the same way must be used to restore it back. Even Hun Xen himself made this claim.

Mrs. Mu Sochua was sued by Ky Tech on behalf of Hun Xen on 27 April 2009. She was accused of defamation. Ho Vann was sued by a lawyer representing 22 high-ranking army officers on 30 April 2009. He was also accused of defamation. Both MPs saw their parliamentary immunity lifted on the same day on 22 June 2009.

Monday, March 02, 2009

Sam Rainsy asks Heng Samrin to cancel the suspension of his parliamentary immunity

01 March 2009
By Khim Sarang
Radio Free Asia

Translated from Khmer by Socheata

Click here to read the article in Khmer

It has been 3 days that opposition leader Sam Rainsy lost his parliamentary immunity. Recently, Sam Rainsy sent a letter to Heng Samrin, president of the National Assembly (NA), asking him to cancel the suspension of his parliamentary immunity.

Up until Sunday morning, the NA has maintained the decision to lift Sam Rainsy’s immunity even though the National Election Committee (NEC) had already withdrawn its lawsuit against the opposition leader in this case.

Sam Rainsy considers the lifting of his parliamentary immunity a threat to shut down the opposition voice: “What they did was illegal, they did it in haste to threaten the opposition spirit.”

Sam Rainsy gave this reaction after he sent a letter to Heng Samrin to request for the cancellation of the decision to lift his parliamentary immunity.

On 26 Feb, based on the request made by the NA permanent committee, Heng Samrin agreed to lift Sam Rainsy’s parliamentary immunity.

The request to lift Sam Rainsy’s immunity was aimed at bringing him to court to face a NEC lawsuit in regards to the NEC fine imposed on Sam Rainsy for his disparaging remarks on Hun Sen during the 2008 election campaign.

A few hours following the decision to lift Sam Rainsy’s immunity, the SRP had decided to pay off the 10 million riels fine as imposed by the NEC. After this pay off, the NEC decided to drop its lawsuit against Sam Rainsy, all that remains now is for the NA to cancel the lifting of his parliamentary immunity.

On Satruday, Sam Rainsy said that he wrote a letter to Hen Samrin regarding this issue. Sam Rainsy said: “I saw a letter issued by Mr. Im Suosdey, NEC president. Mr. Im Suosdey wrote a letter to the prosecutor of the Phnom Penh municipal court to withdraw the NEC lawsuit against me. Therefore, the NEC considers this case closed, and it asked the court to end this lawsuit. So, I also wrote to Samdach Heng Samrin telling him that, since the NEC withdrew its lawsuit, the NA also must urgently give me back my immunity.”

On Saturday, and again on Sunday, Heng Samrin could not be reached, and neither are the officials involved in the decision to lift Sam Rainsy’s immunity.