Showing posts with label Journalist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Journalist. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2009

Cambodian Court Overlooks Civil Press Law in Defamation Case

Thursday, 12 November 2009
Press Release: International Federation of Journalists

The International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) is dismayed by a decision of the Phnom Penh Court in Cambodia to overlook the country’s civil Press Law in dealing with a defamation case against freelance journalist Ros Sokhet.

According to the Cambodian Association for the Protection of Journalists (CAPJ), an IFJ affiliate, the court applied an outdated law from the interim United Nations Transitional Authority of Cambodia (UNTAC) to sentence Sokhet to two years’ jail for defamation on November 6.

UNTAC was instituted by a United Nations peacekeeping mission to Cambodia in 1992-93 to support the country’s democratic transition.

In 1995, Cambodia’s National Assembly formally adopted Cambodia’s Press Law, under which defamation is to be dealt with as a civil matter.

“Criminal defamation remains a major hurdle in Cambodia’s process of securing press freedom and journalists’ rights,” IFJ Asia-Pacific Director Jacqueline Park said.

“But there are appropriate civil laws in place to resolve media-related disputes, and Cambodia’s Press Law should be applied to assist in the resolution of media-related disputes in all circumstances.”

The IFJ stands in solidarity with CAPJ in calling on Cambodia’s Government to ensure the laws appropriate to defamation do not contain criminal penalties.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Cambodian newspaper editor seriously hurt in hit-and-run

19 February 2008
Source: Southeast Asian Press Alliance (SEAPA)

The Southeast Asian Press Alliance (SEAPA) is concerned to learn that an editor of a weekly newspaper in the capital Phnom Penh was seriously injured in an apparent attack over his work.

On 15 February 2008, at around 8:30 p.m. (local time), "Sakal" editor Khuon Phlay Vy, who writes under the penname Sar Keo Virak, was chased on his motorcycle by a white car that crashed into his vehicle and sped off after that, reports the Cambodian Association for the Protection of Journalists (CAPJ), a SEAPA partner.

Khuon sustained serious bodily injuries and has been admitted to a nearby hospital.

Khuon said earlier in the morning, he received a phone call from an unidentified man who threatened him over a story he had published the same day involving an illegal gambling den in Phnom Penh’s Boeng Keng Kang II commune.

SEAPA said the case merits serious attention in the light of the verbal threat to the editor right before the hit-and-run.

SEAPA joins CAPJ in calling on the authorities to investigate the case.

"The perpetrator of this crime must not escape justice," CAPJ said in an 18 February release.

Cambodian journalists who expose wrongdoing write and publish under risk of reprisal from those implicated. CAPJ said 15 journalists received threats in 2007 for daring to bring up stories that affect the interests of the powerful and the rich. In this climate of fear and impunity, most newspapers practice self-censorship.

Sunday, December 30, 2007

She Was Supposed to Be Dead

Webb reported from smack in the middle of everything. (Photo: UPI/Bettmann/Corbis)

December 30, 2007
By MAGGIE JONES
The New York Times (USA)


Kate Webb | b. 1943

When Kate Webb reported from the battlefields of Cambodia, she kept her chestnut hair cropped G.I.-short and wore jeans and loose shirts to obscure her breasts. This was 1971. Only a handful of women were full-time correspondents in Vietnam, and even fewer women roughed the front lines next door in Cambodia, where military officers believed foreign women were, at best, a distraction. At worst, they were bad luck.

Bad luck was a virus among foreign correspondents in Cambodia. Unlike in Vietnam — where Webb arrived four years earlier at age 23 with a philosophy degree, a one-way ticket from Australia, a Remington typewriter, $200 in cash and a whiskey-and-cigarette voice so soft people leaned in to hear her — there were no reliable phone lines in Cambodia to call your editor in an emergency. There were no American military hospitals to sew up your bullet wounds; no helicopters to evacuate you when things got bloody. By April 1971, several years before the Killing Fields, at least 16 foreign correspondents were missing and 9 were dead.

On April 7, it was Webb’s turn. A 28-year-old bureau chief for United Press International, Webb was covering a clash on Highway 4, south of Phnom Penh. As bullets flew from every direction between North Vietnamese and United States-backed Cambodian troops, Webb and her Cambodian interpreter plunged into a ditch. By the time they eventually belly-crawled their way out, four other refugees from the attack had joined them: a Japanese photojournalist and his Cambodian interpreter along with a Cambodian newspaper cartoonist and a Cambodian photographer.

Throughout that afternoon and night, the six of them crept through the wooded foothills of Cambodia’s Elephant Mountains, holding their breath as they stood within inches of chatting North Vietnamese soldiers. At 11:30 the next morning, tired, thirsty, their clothes and skin shredded by branches, they were crouching in the underbrush when they looked up to see two skinny North Vietnamese soldiers with AK-47’s. The soldiers bound Webb’s arms behind her back with wire, vine and tape and roped all of the captives together in a single line. They confiscated their notebooks, their ID cards, their cameras, their watches. Then they took one thing that Webb held dear: a gold Chinese charm that she wore around her neck. She had clung to that charm in foxholes and always came out alive. Now without it, she felt naked.

After a soldier tossed her and other prisoners’ shoes into the trees, laughing, Webb was forced to walk barefoot on the hot asphalt and through woods littered with bamboo splinters and stones, until another soldier brought Webb a pair of thongs. She winced, knowing they had been stripped from a dead paratrooper.

Following a week of night marches, they arrived at a military camp where Webb slept in a hammock and alternated between stretches of numbing boredom and piercing fear. Why, she wondered, hadn’t they shot her? Did they believe her during the interrogations when she said she wasn’t an American, wasn’t with the C.I.A., wasn’t a soldier? Maybe they would turn her over to the Khmer Rouge, where death — perhaps preceded by starvation — was almost certain. Maybe they planned to march her to the Hanoi Hilton, where United States pilots were being brutally tortured. There are worse things than a single bullet to the head.

As Webb would later write in her memoirs, “On the Other Side: 23 Days With the Viet Cong,” there wasn’t all that much that separated soldier from prisoner. Both subsisted on two meals a day of rice and pork fat in a salted broth and wrestled with hunger, malaria, homesickness. Webb and a soldier she nicknamed Li’l Abner compared their scarred feet (his were worse) and, in French, discussed the Renaissance, the Reformation and the Napoleonic Wars. Three weeks into captivity, Webb had lost 25 pounds — down to 105, on her 5-foot-7-inch frame — and shook with fever from two strains of malaria. She longed to take a bath, to shave her legs, to eat an orange.

She was not, however, dead. On April 21, 1971 — while Webb was sitting in the jungles of Cambodia — this newspaper ran her obituary. Near Highway 4, two Cambodian officers had found a woman they believed was Webb with a bullet in the chest. In accordance with Cambodian military procedures, they cremated the body.

Around that same time, the North Vietnamese were telling Webb about their plans to free her. They figured out a drop-off spot where Cambodian forces might rescue them. And on April 30 — following what Webb would call a “Mad Hatter’s” farewell party with tea, cigarettes, candy and bananas — Webb and the other captives made their final night march, this time with their possessions returned, save for their notebooks and cameras. In the predawn darkness, the soldiers and their former prisoners said fast farewells and Webb and the others walked onto Highway 4 waving a small piece of white cloth. “Miss Webb,” said a Cambodian officer who spotted her on the roadside, “you are supposed to be dead!”

That night Webb stayed at a friend’s empty apartment, where three hot baths washed the filth from her skin and 15 glasses of iced orange juice finally quenched her thirst. A bed with clean sheets awaited her, but Webb chose the balcony; she missed her hammock. She thought about the soldiers she had nicknamed Dad, Gold Tooth and Mr. Lib, who risked their lives to walk her to safety.

Another journalist might have parlayed three weeks of captivity into celebrity status. Webb got back to work instead. For the next three decades, she wrote for wire services from Cambodia, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan, Indonesia, Korea, Hong Kong, the Philippines and India, living outside the usual expat neighborhoods, learning the languages, outreporting many of her younger colleagues and using her own modest income to supplement the salaries of in-country wire-service staff.

When she finally retired from front-line reporting at age 58, she returned to Australia, where her family had lived since leaving New Zealand when she was a child. There, she tended her garden and sketched nature scenes. And on some nights, with a cigarette in one hand and a beer in the other, and a rapt audience of friends and family, she told stories about a few of the places she had seen.

Friday, December 21, 2007

When the chief of the gov't resorted to use threats, gov't officials under him also adopt the same attitude

20/12/2007
Cambodian journalist receives death threats from government official

Cambodia has a track record in this regard

A journalist working for Koh Santepheap newspaper, Try Vantha, 46, has been threatened by a senior official of the social affairs department in Preah Vihear province of Cambodia. On 13 November 2007, Try was in a restaurant where the official, Kim Thany, was also present. While inside, Kim warned Try to refrain from writing reports about him otherwise he would be killed. Kim was angry over Try''s news report published in his newspaper in April 2007 exposing neglect in his work which results in long delays in the payment of pensions and allowances for disabled soldiers and their widows.

In April this year, Try Vantha, a disabled veteran and journalist working for Koh Santepheap newspaper wrote an article exposing Kim Thany's incompetence and neglect. Kim, director of the Social Affairs Department in the province, and his companions were said to be responsible for the long delays in payment of pensions to disabled soldiers and allowances to the widows of soldiers.

Try reported that because of Kim incompetence the pensioners have had to wait up to a year before receiving their supposedly monthly pensions or allowances. Try's report had reportedly angered Kim.

In the afternoon of November 13, Try happened to be in Tong Heng restaurant in Phearakech village, Palhal commune, where Kim was also present. At 5:40p.m., in the middle of the restaurant's crowd, Kim, who was seating next to a table where Try was seated, stood up and pointed his finger to him. Kim then ridiculed Try by calling him in a derogatory title for a person of inferior status.

Kim angrily threatened Try not to write anything more about him again or he would hire his military friend to kill him. Kim was heard telling Try as: 'If you write about me again, I'll spend USD 10,000 to get my friend, deputy Army Commander in Preah Vihear province, to kill you.' Kim further ridiculed him saying: 'The status of you [Try], journalist, cannot equal mine, [I am the] Director of the Social Affairs Department.'

When Kim was later asked about the threat he had made on Try, he denied it. He instead claimed that Try was drunk at the time of incident and that he could charge him with anything. In an apparent show off of arrogance, Kim added he and Try were not equal 'in weight' so he would not bother responding to Try's accusations.

Try had kept the threat to himself for several weeks before informing the editor of his newspaper about it. He had already filed a criminal complaint against Kim for attempted murder. In Cambodia, once a person made threats to another, they can be charged for attempted murder, unlike in other countries where they would be charged either for threats or grave threats. The Cambodian law does not define 'threat' as a criminal offense.

Other Incidents of same nature

There have been incidents of threats, targeted attacks and violence against journalists in Cambodia, in particular those involved in reporting or exposing corrupt and illegal practices by government officials and the security forces.

On November 27, a female journalist, Ms. Som Sithavry, was interviewing a military police commander in Sandan district in Kampong Thom province regarding a brawl involving two military police officers. While she was interviewing, a military police captain cut in and threatened her saying: 'Do the job properly, otherwise I will break your legs'.

On August 10, the house of journalist Phon Phat (41) was also torched in Ba Kan district, Posat. The torching happened days after he received two threatening telephone calls from numbers registered to members of security forces. He was threatened after he reported illegal logging activities to the forestry administration and for writing stories about it to his newspaper.

On August 4, another journalist, Mr. Heng Veasna, was also assaulted by a military police officer in Toul Kroh village, Posat province. Heng was on the way back home after collecting information on two illegal shooting cases by a military police officer and a chief prosecutor when he was assaulted.

On May 2, journalist Chim Chenda working for Kampuchea Thmei (New Cambodia) also received a death threat from an army general. General Pol Synoun, chief deputy for the international relations office of Cambodia-Thailand border affair, pointed his pistol at Chim whom he had forced to kneel down to and apologize for calling him 'Brother Noun'. Chim denied he had uttered such word to the general.

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

CAMBODIA: A military police officer threatened a woman journalist in Kompong Thom province

4 December 2007
CAMBODIA: Threats; illegal wire-tapping

Dear friends,

The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) has received information regarding threat of a journalist by military police captain on 27 November 2007. The journalist was interviewing with military police commander Lork Vong of Sandan district in Kampong Thom province regarding a brawl involving two military police officers. While the journalist was interviewing, a military police captain was wire-tapping the conversation, cut in and threatened her saying, "Do the job properly, otherwise I will break your legs". The journalist has since feared for her safety and security due to this threat.

CASE DETAILS:

At around 7:35am on 28 November 2007, Ms. Som Sithavry, a journalist from the Khmer-language newspaper Kampuchea Thmei, conducted a phone interview with the military police commander Lork Vong of Sandan district in the same province from her house. Her house is located at 6 kilometers from Kampong Thom City, the capital of Kampong Thom province. She had wanted to check with that commander the veracity of the story before she wrote it.

The story was about a brawl that occurred on November 27 and involved two military police officers. One officer is Ky from Sandan district whom Lork Wong assigned to keep law and order at a ceremony and dance party in the night of 27 November in Yeak Teay village, Khleng commune, Sandan district. The other, Ron from the neighbouring district Prasat Sambor was off duty and went to join the ceremony with a few villagers one of whom carried his rifle. Some people got drunk, started to quarrel and had a brawl which drew in both Ky and Ron who pointed their guns at each other. Villagers managed to stop and separate both of them in time before any shot was fired. Nevertheless, the armed confrontation between the two officers was very frightening to villagers who were taking part in the ceremony and the dance.

Lork Vong was at the provincial military police headquarters in Kompong Thom City when he received Som Sithavry's call. While she was in the middle of interviewing, a military police captain Bun Thy Soon, head of the crime investigation bureau of the provincial military police, wire-tapped this phone call. During the interview, Bun Thy Soon suddenly cut in and threaten her with saying "do your job properly; don't do anything stupid; abide by journalism ethics; otherwise, I'll break your legs."

Lork Vong also heard the threat while he was confirming the veracity of the story of the brawl. A few moments after the end of the interview, he called Som Sithavry to tell her that the threat was not from him; it was from Bun Thy.

Som Sithavry has since then had fear for her safety and security. She has been very worried about that threat as she is a woman and has to travel around in the province where there have been previous threats to journalists.

The AHRC holds that Military Police Captain Bun Thy's tapping of Ms Som Sithavry is a violation of her right to privacy, and his threat against her is a violation of her right to security and is also a violation of press freedom. All these rights are guaranteed and protected by the constitution of Cambodia. Observance of and respect for them are part of that country's international human rights obligations by virtue of its adherence to all human rights norms and standards.

Action should be taken against Bun Thy. Effective measures should also be taken to put an end to all intimidation and threats against Ms Som Sithavry and other journalists, and to protect press freedom in Cambodia.

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:

Earlier in June, a Radio Free Asia reporter named Lem Pichpisey received a death threat through his mobile phone after he reported on the illegal logging activities and massive deforestation in that province. Lem Pichpisey had to go into hiding for some time before resuming his journalism (See further; UP-088-2007, UP-148-2007).

BACKGROUND INFORMATION:

In Cambodia there are two different police forces to keep law and order. They are doing basically the same job. One force is called the national police. This force is a civilian force though its members have the same ranks as members of the army. It is placed under the Ministry of Interior. It is organized, in descendant order, in provincial units headed by provincial police commissioners, district units headed by police inspectors and commune units headed by police chiefs.

The other force is the military police which is a department of the Ministry of National Defence, but for all intents and purposes, it is under the direct command of the prime minister. It is organized in provincial units headed by commanders and district units also headed by commanders. Its members are army officers. They are better trained, better equipped and rougher in dealing with the public than their counterparts in the national police. People fear them more than national police officers. They wear military uniform, and they apply military discipline in their job.

SUGGESTED ACTION:
Please send your letters to the authorities listed below to call for action against the military police captain Bun Thy, for an end to all intimidation and threats against Ms Som Sithavry and other journalists, and for protection of press freedom in Cambodia. The AHRC is writing a separate letter to the UN Special Representative of the Secretary-General for human rights in Cambodia calling for intervention into this case.

Suggested letter:

Dear___________,

CAMBODIA: A military police officer threatened a woman journalist in Kompong Thom Province

Name of victim: Ms Som Sithavry, 28 years old, a journalist from the Khmer-language newspaper 'Kampuchea Thmei'
Name of alleged perpetrator: Bun Thy, Military Police Captain, head of the crime investigation bureau of the military police of Kompong Thom province
Date of incident: 27 November 2007
Place of incident: Kompong Thom City, Kompong Thom Province

I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the threat by the military police captain named Bun Thy against Ms Som Sithavry, a journalist for Kampuchea Thmei newspaper, on 27 November 2007.

I am informed that on 28 November at 7:35am, Ms Som Sithavry, 28, conducted a phone interview with the military police commander named Lork Vong of Sandan district in Kompong Thom Province. She had wanted to check with that commander the veracity of a story about a brawl that had happened the night before and involved two military police officers named Ky and Ron at a ceremony and dance party on the night of 27 November in Yeak Teay village, Khleng commune, Sandan district in Kompong Thom province.

Lork Vong was at the provincial military police headquarters in Kompong Thom City when he received Som Sithavry's call. A military police captain named Bun Thy Soon, head of the crime investigation bureau of the provincial military police, tapped her phone. A while after her interview, he cut in and gave orders followed by a threat to her, saying "do your job properly; don't do anything stupid; abide by journalism ethics; or else, I'll break your legs."

Lork Vong heard, and later confirmed, Bun Thy's threat while he was confirming the veracity of the story of the brawl in which the two officers had been involved.

Som Sithavry has since then had fear for her safety and security. She has been very worried about that threat as she is a woman and has to travel to do her job in the province where there have been previous intimidation and threats to journalists.

I hold that Bun Thy's tapping of Ms Som Sithavry is a violation of her right to privacy, and his threat against her is a violation of her right to security and is also a violation of press freedom. All these rights are guaranteed and protected by the constitution of Cambodia. Observance of and respect for them are part of that country's international human rights obligations by virtue of its adherence to all human rights norms and standards.

Therefore, I strongly urge you to take action against Military Police, Bun Thy, for his phone tapping, for his threat against Ms Som Sithavry and also his violation of press freedom. Effective measures should also be taken to end all intimidation and threats against Ms Som Sithavry and other journalists, and to protect press freedom in Cambodia.

I trust that you will take immediate action into this case.

Yours sincerely,

-----------------------

PLEASE SEND YOUR LETTERS TO:

1. Mr. Samdech Hun Sen
Prime Minister
Cabinet of the Prime Minister
No. 38, Russian Federation Street
Phnom Penh
CAMBODIA
Tel: +855 2321 9898
Fax: +855 23 36 0666
E-mail: cabinet1b@camnet.com.kh

2. Mr. Sar Kheng
Deputy-Prime Minister
Minister of Interior
No.275 Norodom Blvd., Phnom Penh
CAMBODIA
Fax/phone: +855 23 721 905 / 23 726 052 / 23 721 190
E-Mail: info@interior.gov.kh or moi@interior.gov.kh

3. Mr. Tea banh
Deputy Prime Minister
Minister of National Defence
Russian Federation Street
Phnom Penh
CAMBODIA
Tel: +855-23 883184 / 428171
Fax: +855-23 883184
E-mail: info@mond.gov.kh

4. Mr. Ang Vong Vathna
Minster of Justice
No 240, Sothearos Blvd.
Phnom Penh
CAMBODIA
Fax: +855 23 36 4119 / 21 6622
E-mail: moj@cambodia.gov.kh

5. Mr. Kiev Kanharith
Minister of Information
No 62 Monivong Blvd., Phnom Penh
Tel:+855-23 724159 / 426059 / 723389
Fax: +855-23 427475
E-mail: information@cambodia.gov.kh

6. Mr. Henro Raken
Prosecutor-General
Court of Appeal
No 240, Sothearos Blvd.
Phnom Penh
CAMBODIA
Tel: +855 11 86 27 70
Fax: +855 23 21 66 22

7. General Hok Lundy
National Police Commissioner
General-Commisariat of National Police
Phnom Penh
CAMBODIA
Tel: +855 23 21 65 85
Fax: +855 23 22 09 52

8. General Sao Sokha
Commander
Military Police
Mao Tse Tung Blvd
Khan Tuol Kok
Phnom Penh
Cambodia
Tel: +855 12 36 3636

9. Mr. Christophe Peschoux
Director
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights - Cambodia
N 10, Street 302
Sangkat Boeng Keng Kang I
Khan Chamcar Mon
Phnom Penh
Cambodia
Tel: +855 23 987 671 / 987 672, 993 590 / 993 591 or +855 23 216 342
Fax: +855 23 212 579 / 213 587
E-mail: cpeschoux@ohchr.org

Thank you.

Thursday, May 10, 2007

Groups Denounce General's Death-Threat to Journalist

Sok Khemara, VOA Khmer
Original report from Washington
08/05/2007

Rights groups and journalism associations Tuesday rebuked a provincial military commander who threatened to shoot a journalist and later said he was only joking.

Gen. Pol Sinuon threatened to shoot a reporter for Kampuchea Thmey, or New Cambodia, last week, according to the International Federation of Journalists, a Belgian free-press advocacy group.

The general later retracted his threat to Chim Chenda, saying he was "only kidding," the IFJ said in a statement, citing a report from an affiliate group, the Cambodian Association for the Protection of Journalists.

"The incident showed flagrant disregard for journalist safety," IFJ President Christopher Warren said.

Cambodia has some of the freest press laws in Southeast Asia, often leading to conflicts between aggressive reporters and recalcitrant sources. The country's press is counted "partly free" by the monitoring group Freedom House, but many reporters feel they cannot safely report on all goings on there.

The Hong-Kong based Asia Human Rights Commission called the general's threat an abuse of power, while outlining the reported details of the encounter.

Chim Chenda had been eating in a Battambang restaurant with several security officers when Gen. Pol Sinuon arrived, greeting each of the officers but ignoring Chim Chenda, the Rights Commission said in a statement.

When the general learned Chim Chenda was a journalist, he asked if the reporter knew who he was.

"Chim Chenda answered that he knew the general and called him 'Brother Nuon,'" the Rights Commission said.

The general, angered by such a familiar address, said he would "kill" Chim Chenda if he "did not get on his knees and apologize," the group said.

Chim Chenda has filed suit against the general in Battambang provincial court, the Rights Commission said, adding that it "urges the Cambodian government take this case seriously and immediately conduct a thorough and impartial investigation."

Gen. Pol Sinuon "cannot escape" the criminal charges, the group said, "no matter how high his position in the military."