Showing posts with label Growing poverty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Growing poverty. Show all posts

Friday, July 18, 2008

"I will vote to choose good leaders who take care of poor farmers and can lower the price of goods" - Voter from Prey Veng


High Costs Push Prey Veng Migration

By Chiep Mony, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
17 July 2008


Since she migrated to Phnom Penh nearly a year ago, 45-year-old Chhon Vanna has had no chance to visit her family in Prey Veng province.

"I don't have money to visit there," she said, as she boxed up dried fish to sell at a nearby garment factory. "Since I lost profits from rice cultivation, I've face shortages of money a lot, and sometimes my family doesn't have money to buy food."

As stark as her conditions are in Phnom Penh, she says, they are better than Prey Veng, where increased prices for fuel and fertilizer have forced her and thousands of others to quit farming and look for work elsewhere.

Chhon Vanna abandoned her rice fields in Choeung Teuk commune, Kampong Leav district, last year and began her small fish-selling business here, following sharp decreases to her income over three years.

She remains in debt in Prey Veng, owing about $1,000 to fertilizer and fuel sellers. She sought help from her home commune, but received none, forcing her to move to Phnom Penh.

In Phnom Penh, she, her husband and three children rent a small room adjacent to their landlord's home, for about $20 per month. Her fish sales bring in as much as $4 per day, but she can easily lose nearly as much, she said.

Her children have abandoned school and her 18-year-old son has become a porter, hauling bundles of factory garments into trucks.

Back in her home commune of Choeung Teuk, among the dirt roads, rice fields and a small river, many villagers say their children have been forced to leave to find work, in Phnom Penh, Sihanoukville, or as far away as Thailand.

About 5,500 residents live in the commune, but 400 of them have migrated to other provinces and cities of Cambodia and Thailand to find jobs and businesses, said Mao Roeurn, 56, Cambodian People's Party first deputy chief of Choeung Teuk commune.

Mao Roeurn noted that migration from her commune to Thailand occurred in 2003 and about seven migrants were imprisoned shortly for entering Thailand illegally.

Mao Roeurn said her four children, including two are daughters, unofficially migrated to Thailand a few years ago to work on fishing boats, adding that they have often sent money to her and her husband.

Chan Kanha, project assistant for the International Organization for Migration in Phnom Penh, said Cambodian migrants are sent to work in Malaysia, Thailand and South Korea.

From 1998 to 2008, nearly 12,000 Cambodians were sent to work as maids and factory workers in Malaysia, while more than 7,000 people between 2006 and 2008 went to work in factories and enterprises in Thailand. Nearly 4,000 found work in factories, farms and fisheries of South Korea between 2003 and 2006.

In Malaysia, some of them were forced to work overtime, but many workers abroad form associations to help them solve difficulties, she said.

It is unknown the total number of Cambodian migrants abroad. Nor is it known how many might return for the July 27 election.

The National Election Committee has sought to help migrants vote by pushing for days off around Election Day and appeals to taxi and bus operators to keep costs low for traveling voters.

Prey Veng has 11 National Assembly seats and nine political parties seeking to fill them.

Chhon Vanna says she will take time off from her fish-selling when it comes time to vote, and she will finally make her trip back to Prey Veng, along with her younger brother, Chhon Duongchan.

"I will vote to choose good leaders who take care of poor farmers and can lower the price of goods," he said.

Friday, March 21, 2008

Bowing to Regional Hydropower Demands

By Andrew Nette - Newsmekong

PHNOM PENH, Mar 21 (IPS) - For the Cambodian government, hydropower development represents great economic opportunities. But for non-government organisations (NGOs), and the communities they serve, dams pose severe social and environmental impacts.

Like neighbouring Laos in the 1990s, donors, electricity-hungry nations such as Thailand and Vietnam and business interests, particularly from China, are keen to make Cambodia a major generator of hydropower.

Plans for developing Cambodia’s hydropower potential remained on hold due to political instability and the economic crisis that struck the region in the latter part of the last decade. But with the rapid economic growth of countries in the region -- including Cambodia whose GDP growth in 2006 exceeded 10 percent -- hydropower is back on the agenda.

As he told a donors’ meeting last year, Cambodia’s Foreign Minister Hor Namhong said that his government wanted Cambodia to be the "battery of South-east Asia".

A 2003 plan developed by the Ministry of Mines, Minerals and Energy with the support of the Mekong River Commission estimated that Cambodia has the potential to generate 10,000 megawatts of energy for internal use and export. Almost 50 percent of this would come from projects along the mainstream Mekong River running through Cambodia.

"We are not against development or hydropower," said Ngy San, deputy executive director of the NGO Forum, the umbrella body representing Cambodia’s NGOs. "What we want to do is to ensure poverty reduction and sustainable development, which is also the government’s plan."

Cambodian and international NGOs are warning that large-scale hydropower development could create serious problems, impacting on some of the country’s most pristine ecosystems and reducing water flow and fisheries with major consequences for the livelihoods of thousands of people.

"We are also working to ensure that Cambodian decision-makers will learn the lesson of other countries in relation to hydropower, and not repeat those mistakes," said San.

What is different in Cambodia in 2008 is the role of China.

Political and economic ties between China and Cambodia have grown enormously over the last decade. China is the nation’s single largest investor, and Chinese state companies, often financed by state-owned financial institutions such as the Chinese Export-Import Bank, are the main players in hydropower dams.

Phnom Penh has identified approximately 14 priority projects of which six are currently under development, all by Chinese companies.

For instance, China’s Sinohydro is building a 145-metre dam on the Kamchay River in Kampot province. This is China’s biggest investment in the country. Another Yunnan-based company is working on the Steung Atai dam.

There is no disagreement that Cambodia needs to generate more power. Currently, only 20 percent of the population has access to cheap, reliable sources of electricity, mainly in urban areas. Demand for electricity is estimated to be growing at 20 percent a year.

"It is simple, development needs electricity," said Touch Seang Tana, an advisor to Cambodia’s Council of Ministers and fisheries expert. "Power is currently very expensive in Cambodia, particularly in regional areas that are the most disadvantaged. The government wants to provide services to the rural communities but this is difficult to do without electricity."

"The actual number of people impacted negatively (by dams) is small and overall the entire benefit to the nation is significant," he said. The government has to balance all these factors."

"The demand exists, that is true," agreed San. "The rush to develop our hydropower potential needs very careful study. However, it must include consultation with impacted communities, and comply with all relevant national and international laws."

"There are some in the government that share our concerns, but they find it difficult to act because they are not the real decision makers," he added.

As is the case with much government policymaking in Cambodia, exactly what the real decision-making process is in relation to hydropower is a major issue for NGOs, who say the process completely lacks transparency.

"The biggest barrier is actually getting to talk with the Cambodian government about what is going on," said San. "They just treat as us opponents, as people who complain and create problems."

While a plethora of departments and regulatory bodies participate in the process, observers say the agenda appears to be largely set by the Ministry of Industry Mines and Energy, with the direct support of Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen.

Donors continue to play an important supporting role, particularly the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) through its Mekong Power Grid Plan. This envisages an interconnected power grid across the region, a plan it has been pushing since the early nineties.

The Manila-based AsDB initially envisages that Cambodia will be a net electricity importer, but will become an exporter once the country’s full hydropower potential is realised.

The lack of transparency is accentuated in relation to China. "There is almost no information in the public domain on the financing arrangements for Cambodia’s hydropower projects," states a report released in January by the U.S.-based International Rivers Network (IRN) and the NGO Forum.

"The lack of information from the Chinese dam builders is very disturbing, they do not consult or share information," said Seng Bunra, country director for Conservation International in Cambodia.

His organisation works in the Cardamom Mountains Protected Forest Area in the south-west of the country. It is one of the largest continuous sections of rainforest left in South-east Asia and home to a number of globally endangered species, including some of the last remaining populations of Asian elephants and Siamese crocodiles.

There are plans to build a number of dams in the protected area, all by Chinese companies.

According to critics, the presence of so many potential hydropower projects in protected forest areas illustrates the fact that the laws to safeguard the environment are insufficient to protect affected communities. The situation is particularly serious, notes the report by the NGO Forum and IRN, given that "compared against the already less than admirable environmental and social standards of Western bilateral donors and export credit agencies ... Chinese institutions are noticeably weaker".

Cambodian and international NGOs are also worried about the impact on fish stocks, water quality and flow, and the relocation of thousands of villagers.

As evidence, they point to the 750 Mw Yali Falls dams on the Se San tributary of the Mekong in Vietnam, which began operating in 2001. Local people claim the dam has been responsible for sudden flooding, causing the deaths of residents in Cambodia and the collapse of fish stocks in the northern Cambodian provinces of Stung Treng and Ratanakiri.

Although Tana conceded that Se San is now a "dead river in terms of fisheries," he adds that the dam is in "Vietnam’s territory, so what can we do?"

"The surrounding countries are all doing this and we are getting the impacts," he continued. "Why should we keep our environment pristine, when our neighbours are doing projects that impact us?"

Tana also makes a distinction between development on the tributaries of the Mekong, the impacts of which he believes can be mitigated, and dam-building on the mainstream of the sort widely seen in China and soon to take place in southern Laos, which is far more serious.

One of the projects being examined in Cambodia is the Sambor dam on the mainstream Mekong in central Kratie province. A number of options are being studied, including one that would only block between one-quarter to one fifth of the river and have, according to Tana, only "minimal" impact.

San concedes there are mixed views about dam building among the potential communities that are going to be affected by these.

He insists, however, that even one of the core arguments in support of hydropower, that it will generate income from the sale of power, is unproven.

"Is there a real need for electricity in Thailand? Yes. But has the economics been thought through, have any preliminary contracts for power export from Cambodia to Thailand actually been signed? No. We want to see a good economic analysis, including a full cost-benefit analysis before projects go ahead," San added.

Saturday, November 10, 2007

World Bank Parliamentary Panel to Review Cambodia

By Sok Khemara, VOA Khmer
Original report from Washington
09 November 2007

"They will clearly learn about the realities on corruption and poverty, where people are victimized by land grabbing and the privatization of public property, which causes the poor to be poorer and poorer" - Opposition leader Sam Rainsy
A 14-member World Bank parliamentary delegation will arrive in Cambodia later this month to review some of the lending body's policies there.

The delegates, from 12 different countries, are part of the Parliamentary Network of the World Bank, which is tasked with strengthening accountability and transparency in lender countries.

The World Bank's programs have come under fire in Cambodia for widespread corruption. A Wall Street Journal editorial in October accused the World Bank in Cambodia of "smiling past corruption."

In response, the World Bank said bank staff had raised concerns about corruption in the first place, and in 2006 the bank suspended funding for three projects.

The delegation's six-day field visit will include meetings to determine Cambodia's development priorities and look at the work of the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research, Cambodia World Bank spokesman Bou Saroeun said.

About 35 percent of Cambodians still live below the poverty line, living on about $0.45 per person per day, despite billions of dollars in aid and grants from donor countries and lending groups like the World Bank.

"They will clearly learn about the realities on corruption and poverty, where people are victimized by land grabbing and the privatization of public property, which causes the poor to be poorer and poorer," opposition leader Sam Rainsy said.

CPP lawmaker Cheam Yiep welcomed the visit. Such delegations were common in other countries that received aid from the World Bank, he said.

"When the World Bank [delegation] arrives, it is to scrutinize their work, and we welcome that," he said.

Sunday, September 09, 2007

Sam Rainsy: Foreign property ownership could bring poverty to Cambodians

Foreign property ownership under study

07 September 2007
By Mondul Keo
Radio Free Asia

Translated from Khmer by Heng Soy

Opposition leader Sam Rainsy said that allowing foreign property ownership in Cambodia is a factor that could bring poverty to Cambodian people, and will prevent them from having housing in the future.

Sam Rainsy’s reaction came on the heel of Hun Sen’s speech at the government and private sector forum, in which Hun Sen said that he accepts that the government studies the question raised by the International Business Club asking for an authorization to foreign property ownership.

Sam Rainsy said that many poor countries in the world have clear policy to limit foreigners from owning properties.

Sam Rainsy said: “If these foreigners come to buy properties, they buy both the lands and the buildings, thereby pushing up the price of lands and buildings. And a large number of Cambodians cannot afford to buy lands and buildings. Our children will not have enough money to buy lands and decent houses because the foreigners have more money, they can buy a lot, thereby pushing up the price of lands and houses.”

On 05 September, at the government and private sector forum, Hun Sen said, in response to a question by Bretton Sciaroni, chairman of the International Business Club, who requested that the government allows foreigners to have the legal rights to own properties in Cambodia: “Regarding the issue and the ability to allow foreigners to own properties, lands, just like Mr. Bretton (Sciaroni) raised, and the fact that a number of countries in the region, such as Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, and The Philippines allow foreign ownerships of houses, apartments, however, here, the issued raised involves allowing the ownership of lands by foreigners. This issue, regardless of the comments provided, it needs clear study on this subject, because it is stipulated in our constitution related to the ownership of lands by foreigners.”

Nevertheless, economist Dr. Kang Chandararoth said that the authorization for foreigners to legally own properties in Cambodia is not a good way to attract investors for the development of the country. He said that only through the encouragement and the pushing of investors inside Cambodia that would help a good economic development.

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Inequality Check

August 21, 2007
The Wall Street Journal (USA)

A wise man once noted that a rising tide lifts all boats. So why are booming Asian countries so worried about income inequality? Such talk is hardly cheap. If these fears spur bad economic policies, it could end up costing Asia dearly.

The worries were fanned this month by a report from the Asian Development Bank. The study, comparing more than a decade's worth of data from 22 developing countries, found significant increases in inequality across the region. "Widening disparities in standards of living can threaten the growth process in one of the most dynamic regions of the world," the bank noted in its press release unveiling the report.

National leaders agree. India's newly installed President Pratibha Patil marked the 60th anniversary of her country's independence this week by claiming that "growth, when unevenly spread, dwarfs overall prosperity. We have to ensure equitable growth for all." In Tokyo, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's cabinet has floated the possibility of a negative income tax to stem growing income inequality. Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang has made battling inequality one of his top priorities. Singaporean Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong noted on the city-state's national day last week that the rising income gap is a "major challenge."

There is evidence that inequality is rising in Asia. The ADB's report finds that inequality as measured by the Gini coefficient -- a statistical tool commonly used to gauge the severity of income differentials -- is growing across Asia, from Nepal and China to South Korea, India and Bangladesh. In some places the uptick is marked. (The Gini coefficient ranks income on a percentile basis. In Asia, the ADB used consumption, rather than income data, due to lack of better data.)

But, as the ADB notes, this doesn't mean the rich are taking food from the mouths of the poor. Rather, the rich are getting richer faster than the poor are. In all but one developing country, per capita incomes for the bottom fifth of the work force increased at least slightly; Pakistan was the only exception. This trend is also evident from other measures of poverty. In China, the proportion of people living on $1 a day declined by an average of 8.75% a year between 1993 and 2004, even as inequality (measured by the Gini coefficient) increased by 1.35% a year.

Other measures also point at dramatic improvements in the lives of the region's poor. India's statistical office reported earlier this year that 54% of rural households (which are more likely than the urban to be poor) had electricity in 2004-05, up from 34% in 1993-94. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh complained in June that inequality breeds social unrest because "the electronic media carries the lifestyles of the rich and famous into every village and every slum." That's because the poor can increasingly afford television sets: The percentage of rural households with TVs increased to 26% in 2004-05, up 7% from 1999-2000.

It's a story that's being repeated in the unlikeliest of places. In Cambodia, whose Gini-measured inequality clocked the third-greatest increase in the ADB study, life expectancy at birth has increased to 57 years in 2005 from 42.6 years in 1960, according to the World Bank. The proportion of births attended by trained medical staff increased to 43.8% in 2005 from 34% in 1998.

And while developed countries like South Korea saw an increase in inequality, according to the ADB, and Japan and Singapore (not included in the bank's report) worry about their own income disparities, citizens aren't exactly suffering the pangs of hunger. They're too busy talking on the phone. For every 100 people in these countries, there are, respectively, 131.4, 118.22 and 132.67 mobile- and land-based telephone lines.

* * *
Poverty remains a serious problem throughout Asia -- the ADB estimates 600 million people still live below the $1-a-day line, to use one popular measure. But "fixing" inequality won't fix poverty.

As even the ADB recognizes, inequality can be a symptom of economic growth. Not everyone can experience equal income growth simultaneously. China's rising inequality, for example, is fueled by growing numbers of people transitioning to higher-paying manufacturing and construction jobs from low-income agricultural work. A policy of allowing successful people to keep their gains -- by not subjecting them to redistributive tax policies -- rewards risk takers and creates incentives for others to try to emulate them.

Likewise, not all inequality is, well, equal. While inequality of outcome can be a good thing, inequality of opportunity is another matter. A caste system or corrupt government can contribute to the kind of "structural inequality" that hinders development by making it harder for entrepreneurial people to get ahead.

The ADB worries that too much of the good inequality can lead to the bad variety by entrenching a new set of self-interested elites. But to the extent that's a danger, the best solution is political, not economic. Economists like New York University's William Easterly have filled books with stories of how corrupt, unaccountable governments embezzled money out of programs designed to tackle inequality of opportunity. True democracy, complete with universal suffrage, rule of law and transparent government, is the most reliable method for keeping oligarchs in line.

The danger is that all this talk of "inequality" will lead to policies that, in the name of redistributing income, reduce economic growth and thus make it harder for Asia's poor to join the middle class. The Asian "pie" is growing for everyone. The challenge is to keep it that way, instead of quarreling over the relative size of the pieces.

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Hun Sen finally admits growing poverty even though the opposition had indicated so long time ago

Hun Sen recognizes people’s growing poverty

13 June 2007
By Kesor Raniya
Radio Free Asia

Translated from Khmer by Heng Soy

The World Bank (WB) report issued on Tuesday 22 June shows that there is a wide wealth gap between the rich and the poor in Cambodia. Up to now, people living in rural areas still remain poor, whereas those living in urban areas have become more prosperous.

Along with the publication of the WB report, Prime Minister Hun Sen also recognizes the growing poverty of people living in rural areas.

In an outline of a plan detailing 5 key priority policies his government intent to put into application for the short to medium range term, in order to share equal benefits to all the Cambodian population, Hun Sen recognizes that the growing poverty is a major cause of vulnerability in the country.

Hun Sen said: “Even though we have made remarkable and proud achievements in our past effort to reduce poverty, the Royal Government also acknowledges that the vulnerability of becoming poor again is still high for a certain vulnerable group of people, especially those living in the rural areas due to health and unpredicted reasons such as natural disasters.”

It should be noted that in the past, opposition officials often noted the growing poverty for rural people that is caused by drought, loss of natural resources such as forests etc… But their claims have always been rejected by all CPP officials.