Showing posts with label Violation of human rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Violation of human rights. Show all posts

Saturday, October 23, 2010

Cambodians Abroad To Demonstrate Ahead of Ban Visit

Cambodian demonstration in New York in September 2010 (Photo: Michael Duong)
Sok Khemara, VOA Khmer
Washington, DC Friday, 22 October 2010
“We want Cambodia's suffering heard by Ban Ki-moon.”
Cambodian groups abroad say they are preparing demonstrations this weekend, just ahead of the visit of UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon next week.

Organizers say they want to call attention to encroachment on Cambodia's sovereignty, its human right violations and backslides on principles of democracy.

Demonstrations, to be held in France, Canada and the US, will also coincide with the anniversary of the Paris Peace Agreement, the UN-brokered accord that brought peace to Cambodia after decades of fighting in 1991.



“We want Cambodia's suffering heard by Ban Ki-moon,” said Thach Vien, an organizer in France.

Ban is scheduled to visit Oct. 26 through Oct. 28. Thach Vien said Cambodians from Belgium, Switzerland and Germany would join a demonstration in Paris Oct. 23 and Oct. 24.

The French demonstrators will petition the French government requesting a review of the Cambodian government's violations of the peace agreement, he said.

In Canada, organizer Chea Sokha said demonstrations were planned for Ottawa over the weekend.

“All Cambodian people see that there are serious violations, and this is critically dangerous for our nation,” he said. Canadian-Cambodians want the peace agreement reactivated, he said.

A demonstration is also planned in New York, ahead of Ban's trip, said Yap Kim Tung, a Virginia-based organizer. “They want Mr. Ban to know about Cambodia and their dissatisfaction,” he said.

Pung Kek, founder of the rights group Licadho, told VOA Khmer the peace agreement was an important document Cambodians should not forget. Eighteen countries signed onto the agreement, including the US, Russia, China, the UK and France, she said.

Government spokesman Phay Siphan said the government has worked to build peace, the rule of law and democracy.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Rights envoy addresses UN council

UN Envoy Surya Subedi (Photo: The Phnom Penh Post)

Thursday, 30 September 2010
Sebastian Strangio
The Phnom Penh Post

He also criticised the conviction last week of opposition leader Sam Rainsy, who was sentenced to 10 years in prison for falsifying maps and spreading disinformation. Subedi urged that any appeal in Sam Rainsy’s case be conducted with “utmost attention to due process and the principles of a fair trial”.
THE United Nation’s rights envoy to Cambodia appeared at the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva on Tuesday to present a yearly report on the state of human rights in the Kingdom.

Land rights, freedom of expression and the state of the courts dominated the address given by Surya Subedi, the UN’s special rapporteur for human rights in Cambodia, who said that despite “noteworthy progress” in certain areas, the country still has a long way to go to meet international standards.

“Cambodia has established institutions to promote and protect human rights, but violations of human rights continue to take place,” he said.

“I also am concerned about the narrowing of political space in the country for people belonging to the opposition political parties and other political activists.”

In his address, Subedi highlighted shortcomings in the justice system, noting that those affected by a wave of land disputes and conflicts could not count on the courts and seemed to be “desperate for justice”.

He also criticised the conviction last week of opposition leader Sam Rainsy, who was sentenced to 10 years in prison for falsifying maps and spreading disinformation. Subedi urged that any appeal in Sam Rainsy’s case be conducted with “utmost attention to due process and the principles of a fair trial”.

Cambodia’s ambassador to the UN, Sun Suon, responded by saying that Cambodia welcomed Subedi’s engagement, but that it had already taken steps on rights issues.

“On legal and judicial reform, the government has accelerated the legislative process,” he said. On land issues, he said, the government had “further committed to its current agenda, that aims at solving land disputes in a comprehensive manner”.

He also addressed criticism that the government had restricted freedom of expression, saying that “the exercise of the right must be carried with special duty and responsibility”.

Western nations and rights groups present at Tuesday’s hearing largely agreed with Subedi’s main observations. The delegate from Human Rights Watch noted the recent “tightening of space for civil society, freedom of expression and peaceful political opposition”.

Sally Dawkins, representing Australia, said the country “strongly supported” the rapporteur’s focus on the rule of law and the state of the courts, and Michael Meier, from Switzerland, noted the “major challenges” that remained.

Asian nations, however, dwelled more on the country’s achievements. Evan P Garcia, from the Philippines, criticised Subedi’s approach for not being more “forward looking”, and hailed the government’s efforts to improve the rights situation.

Yim Sovann, spokesman for the Sam Rainsy Party, said he hoped the hearing would spur positive change in Cambodia.

“We want real measures – concrete action to be taken to improve the human rights situation in Cambodia,” he said.

Friday, June 18, 2010

UN official accuses Cambodia of human rights breaches

June 18, 2010
ABC Radio Australia

The United Nations Special Rapporteur on Cambodia says he has serious concerns about Cambodia's human rights record. Surya Prasad Subedi has just ended a ten day mission to Cambodia, focussing mainly on the judiciary, and says he's uncovered serious shortcomings. He says it's a judicial system that's critically underfunded and fails to appropriately train people in the basics of human rights law.

Presenter: Rob Sharp
Speakers: Surya Prasad Subedi, UN Special Rapporteur on human rights in Cambodia

Monday, April 05, 2010

Sacrava's Political Cartoon: Two Feet

Cartoon by Sacrava (on the web at http://sacrava.blogspot.com)

“Cambodia is a democratic country that other countries should stop directing and pointing orders at”: Oxymoron Yentieng

Oxymoron Yentieng, chairman of the government human rights commission (Photo: Sovannara, RFI)

03 April 2010
By Kuoch Kuntheara
Radio France Internationale

Translated from Khmer by Socheata
Click here to read the article in Khmer


In response to questions asked by Kuoch Kuntheara, Om Yentieng, chairman of the government human rights commission, thanked the UN for its support to the government direction in the additional strengthening and development of human rights. In the name of Cambodia which is one of the democratic countries, Om Yentieng called on other countries and a number of international organizations to stop directing Cambodia, and stop pointing orders to Cambodia as they please.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Government not happy about the US Human Rigths Report

Hun Xen's girly men (on the left: Koy Kuong, Ong Yentieng and Phay Siphan) vs Hillary Clinton

14 March 2010
By Pen Bona
Radio France Internationale
Translated from Khmer by Komping Puoy
Click here to read the article in Khmer


Government officials were displeased by the US Human Rights report which pointed out a number of negative aspects related to the violations of human rights in Cambodia. The 2009 report which was published by Washington at the end of this week noted the restriction on the freedom of expression, the forced evictions, and the deportation of Uighurs to China, etc…

Several government officials have reacted one after another to express their displeasure to the 2009 US Human Rights report for Cambodia .

The report which was issued at the end of this week noted 2 aspects of the human rights situation in Cambodia. The first aspect of the report pointed to a number of positive points that Cambodia strived to provide respect for human rights, such as the introduction of the law to protect the rights in disabled persons, the better protection for the rights of human trafficking victims, as well as a reduction of the number of arbitrary human killings. The reduction stems from a better respect of the rules by security force leaders based on the government effort to educate them.

Nevertheless, human rights violations in Cambodia still persist. Freedom of expression through the press is reduced due to the use of defamation and disinformation lawsuits. The deportation of 20 Uighur minority ethnics, who were applying for a refugee status, back to China at the end of 2009 is a flagrant violation of human rights, Washington stated. Furthermore, the government still continues its forced eviction policy.

However, government officials have rejected all these issues. At least 3 government officials reacted to this report: Koy Kuong, the spokesman for the ministry of Foreign Affairs, Om Yentieng, the chairman of the government human rights commission, and Phay Siphan, the mouthpiece of the Council of Ministers.

To all these 3 government officials, the lawsuits against reporters and the deportation of the Uighur people back to China are not human rights violation, but merely the application of the Cambodian law (sic!). These 3 Hun Xen’s regime officials scolded those who prepared the report of bypassing these issues. On the other hand, civil society organizations are in agreement with the US report.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Mr. Hun Sen in Paris


Click on the article in Khmer to zoom in


Unofficial translation from French by Tola Ek


Mr. Hun Sen in Paris

Mr. Hun Sen does not receive good press coverage in France. For several years now, major newspapers in Paris never ceased to harshly criticize the corruption gangrene, the violations of human rights, the relentless dictatorial violence and other “dirty jobs” of his regime. According to our French friends, his current visit to Paris was organized under his “insistent request” made during several months and following “serious preliminary discussions” between his representatives (including the one conducted by his minister Hor Nam Hong during last May) with the French authority.

We were assured also that the French government is fully aware of the facts and events which are taking place in Cambodia. Furthermore, in announcing the visit of Mr. Hun Sen, the [French] ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a communiqué recalling that France “co-presided the Paris Accords (on Cambodia) in 1991 which initiated the reconstruction process of this country.” It is hoped that during upcoming meetings between Mr. Hun Sen and his ministers with their French counterparts, the issues of human rights and the rule of law in Cambodia would be raised with a positive contribution from France because of the more than century-long links between France and the true Khmer Country and People who have suffered and endured so much during the past decades.

However, there is another aspect of the Cambodian prime minister’s visit to France that should be underscored: Mr. Hun Sen succeeded in securing an invitation to attend the 14 July parade commemorating the well known French Revolution in 1989 on the honorary podium. Therefore, it is clear that the Khmer kingdom’s “Strongman” is coming to Paris to try to dust off his tarnished image, and he is hoping that his presence among prestigious head of states would confer on him a “mark” of recognition of his power, at least from the outside, at a time when the economic crisis and internal, as well as border troubles seriously shake his regime.

In fact, Mr. Hun Sen is coming also to talk about “major regional issues” at a time when the regional context is rather dangerous: the impasse under which the Preah Vihear temple conflict was reignited by Thailand, the currently known increased tensions between Vietnam (which Mr. Hun Sen’s regime is largely a client of) and China, and the influence of these two countries on Cambodia currently.

Regarding the Thai military occupation of Preah Vihear, let’s recall that, on 22 July 2008, Mr. Maurice Ripert, France ambassador to the UN, following Cambodia’s complaint, called for an “immediate meeting” of the UN Security Council to find a peaceful solution – a legal solution abiding to the current international norms and conventions. His action was based on the procedure stipulated by the 1991 Paris Accords on Cambodia to resolve such problem. However, Mr. Hun Sen, hoping to obtain some cool off in order to spare his interests in the region, instead opted for “bilateral negotiations” demanded by Bangkok which resulted in spectacular bloody failures and Thailand’s categorical refusal to withdraw its troops from the temple area. On the other hand, all signs also point to the fact that Vietnam is readying itself to toughen its position against China, a situation that could cause a general conflict which would be very difficult to contain. Because he is linked to the engagement of “defense cooperation” with Hanoi, more so than ever, Mr. Hun Sen must obtain particular considerations and recognitions through either material support or, at least, political support from the West, and from France, in particular.

What will happen, if following this short visit in Paris, Cambodia’s “Strongman” would be able to “polish” his image on his return to Phnom Penh? The answer is that, Cambodia – which is already drowned under a culture of impunity, under a corrupt regime, under denial of rights, under violence, under generalized top-to-bottom irresponsibility, under the plundering of the national heritage to the benefit of neighboring hereditary enemies –could face a more painful fate that the one it has known for the past more than 30 years.

Paris, 11 July 2009
For Cambodia’s Border Committee in France and Worldwide,

(Signed) Dy Kareth
Vice President
----------

CFC/CBC 110709F

M. HUN SEN à Paris

M. Hun Sen n’a pas bonne presse en France. Les grands journaux parisiens ne cessent depuis des années de dénoncer durement la gangrène de la corruption, les violations des droits de l’homme, les allures suivies de violences dictatoriales et autres « basses oeuvres » de son régime. Sa visite à Paris d’aujourd’hui, selon nos amis français, a été organisée à sa « demande insistante » formulée depuis de nombreux mois, et après de « sérieuses discussions préliminaires » entre ses représentants (dont son ministre Hor Nam Hong, en mai dernier) avec les autorités françaises.

L’on nous a rassuré aussi que le Gouvernement français est bien au courant des faits et événements qui se déroulent au Cambodge. D’ailleurs, en annonçant la venue de M. Hun Sen, un communiqué du ministère des Affaires étrangères français a rappelé aussi que la France « a co-présidé, en 1991, les Accords de Paris (sur le Cambodge) qui initièrent le processus de reconstruction de ce pays ». Il est à espérer qu’au cours d’éventuelles entrevues de M. Hun Sen et ses ministres avec leurs homologues français, les questions des droits de l’homme et de l’Etat de droit au Cambodge, puissent être abordées dans l’esprit et avec l’apport d’une contribution positive de la France, en raison des liens plus que centenaires de cette dernière avec le vrai Pays et le vrai Peuple khmers qui n’ont que trop souffert et enduré durant ces dernières décades.

Mais, il y a un autre aspect de la visite du Premier Ministre cambodgien en France qui mérite d’être souligné : M. Hun Sen a réussi à se faire invité à la tribune d’honneur du défilé du 14 juillet commémorant la retentissante Révolution française de 1789. Ainsi, il est clair que l’« homme fort » du royaume khmer est venu à Paris pour essayer de bien redorer son terne blason, d’espérer par sa présence aux côtés des chefs d’Etat prestigieux obtenir, de l’extérieur, une « marque » de reconnaissance de son pouvoir, à l’heure où la crise économique et les troubles intérieurs et aux frontières agitent sérieusement son régime.

En effet, M. Hun Sen est venu parler « des principaux enjeux régionaux » également, au moment où le contexte régional est plutôt dangereux : l’impasse dans lequel se trouve le conflit du temple Preah Vihear rallumé par la Thailande, et les tensions de plus en plus vives entre le Vietnam (dont le régime Hun Sen est largement tributaire) et la Chine dans des conditions que l’on sait, et l’emprise de ces deux Etats sur le Cambodge actuel.

Sur l’occupation militaire thaïe de Preah Vihear, rappelons que l’ambassadeur de France à l’ONU, M. Maurice Ripert, le 22 juillet 2008, s’est prononcé, sur la plainte du Cambodge, pour une «réunion immédiate» du Conseil de sécurité de l’ONU pour trouver une solution pacifique, une solution de droit au regard des normes et conventions internationales en vigueur. C’était faire référence à la procédure prévue par les Accords de Paris de 1991 sur le Cambodge pour pareil problème. Mais, M. Hun Sen, pensant obtenir un certain apaisement de nature à ménager ses intérêts dans la zone, a cru devoir opter pour des « négociations bilatérales » exigées par Bangkok, avec des échecs sanglants que l’on sait et le refus catégorique des Thaïs de retirer leurs troupes des environs du temple. D’un autre côté, tout indique que le Vietnam se prépare activement à durcir sa position vis-à-vis de la Chine, ce qui risquerait de causer un conflit généralisé très difficilement maîtrisable. Et, lié par l’engagement de « coopération de défense » avec Hanoi, M. Hun Sen se doit, plus qu’à tout autre moment, de bénéficier des considérations et reconnaissances particulières, par le soutien matériel et autre, du moins politique de l’Occident, dont, en particulier, celui de la France.

Qu’adviendra-t-il, après cette courte visite à Paris, si jamais le blason de « l’homme fort » soit « redoré » à son retour à Phnom-Penh ? Le Cambodge, baigné interminablement dans la culture de l’impunité, le règne de la corruption, du déni de droit, et de la violence, la généralisation de l’irresponsabilité du sommet à la base, la spoliation du patrimoine national au profit des voisins-ennemis héréditaires, pourrait connaître un nouveau sort plus douloureux encore que celui qu’il a connu depuis trente ans.

Paris, le 11 juillet 2009
P. Le Comité des Frontières du Cambodge
en France et dans le monde.

Dy Kareth
Vice-Président

Saturday, April 19, 2008

From a communist regime that beat up monks, it's not surprising that its army wants to demolish Buddhist pagoda

Hun Sen's regime police beating Khmer Krom monk (Photo: Licadho)

Army Pushing Pagoda to Move: Monk

By Heng Reaksmey, VOA Khmer
Original report from Phnom Penh
18 April 2008


The armed forces is threatening to demolish a pagoda in Kampot province, if the leaders don’t move it first, a chief monk said Friday.

Division 11 soldiers have said the pagoda, which is home to seven monks and nine nuns, was built illegally in 2007, said Venerable In Sok, head monk at the pagoda.

Soldiers are not allowing villagers to hold ceremonies or pray at the pagoda and have threatened to destroy it if it is not moved, he said.

The pagoda is near a military headquarters and must be moved, said Phy Sokhen, secretary of the intervention forces of Division 11.

Not Norn, the district chief of the local Ministry of Religion office, said the pagoda had a legal permit to from the ministry to be built on the site.

The military was wrong in this matter, he said.

Kampot Governor Thach Khorn said he would conduct an investigation.

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Cambodia has peace, but no freedom

HONG KONG, China, Dec. 12
LAO MONG HAY
UPI Asia Online

Column: Rule by Fear


In October 1991, the warring factions in Cambodia and 17 concerned countries gathered in Paris to sign, in the presence of the secretary-general of the United Nations, a set of agreements to end the war in Cambodia.

All state signatories then recognized, among other things, that Cambodia's tragic history required special measures to assure the protection of human rights and to prevent the return of the policies and practices of the past.

Among these measures were Cambodia's adoption of pluralistic liberal democracy as its system of government and its undertaking to ensure respect for, and observance of, human rights and fundamental freedoms. For their part, the other state signatories also committed themselves to promoting and encouraging such respect and observance and for the United Nations to monitor human rights in this war-stricken country.

The United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia, or UNTAC, was established to ensure the implementation of these agreements. UNTAC deployed approximately 20,000 peacekeepers costing US$1.6 billion to keep the peace and organize the election of a new government.

Cambodia, however, did not enjoy peace and stability when the Khmer Rouge, the second strongest of the four Cambodian warring factions, defected from the peace process and resumed their armed struggle to disrupt the peacekeeping operation and the election held in 1993. Their struggle continued after the election of a new government and the departure of UNTAC.

In 1996, a group of Khmer Rouge fighters broke away from Pol Pot, the Khmer Rouge leader, and rallied to the government. In July 1997, another war broke out in the capital between the two warring factions in the coalition government formed after the election, a clash between the royalist FUNCINPEC Party and the former communist Cambodian People's Party.

FUNCINPEC was routed, and the CCP emerged a decisive victor. In April 1998, Pol Pot died. The CPP won the election in July of that year, and the remainder of Pol Pot's followers surrendered to the government at the end of the same year. Cambodia has since ushered in an era of peace, stability and economic growth.

With a weakened FUNCINPEC as a coalition partner in the government and a small opposition in the Parliament after the 1998 election, the CCP reasserted its grip on the power it had lost five years earlier. It soon signaled its disengagement from international human rights obligations when it abolished a public holiday on Oct. 23 in commemoration of the Paris Peace Agreements of 1991 which had bound Cambodia to these obligations.

Just prior to the election of 2003, which the CCP comfortably won, the CCP-led government began to practically ban peaceful public demonstrations and protests. Since then, organizers have to seek prior permission for their protest action. If they are given such permission, the authorities invariably assign a place where demonstrations can be held. Unauthorized demonstrations are broken up, with violence if need be.

Only strong pressure, especially from ambassadors of influential donor countries, can push the government to lift the ban. Thanks to such pressure, the government lifted its ban on a public demonstration to commemorate International Human Rights Day this year.

Meanwhile, protests or resistance against evictions in cases of land disputes with the rich and powerful are invariably met with the violence of the police or the arrests of leaders of these protests or resistance on the charge of incitement, wrongful damage to property, infringement upon public property, battery or fraud. This year a human rights non-governmental organization has recorded 320 cases of land disputes in which two people were killed, more than 10 were seriously injured and 138 were arrested, of whom 55 are still in detention.

Labor strikes have suffered the same fate. Last month about 2,000 workers staged a lawful and peaceful strike at their factory, Fortune Garment and Woolen Knitting Co., in Saang District in Kandal province. A mixed police force was sent to brutally break up that strike, causing serious injuries to two female workers. Four union officials were also arrested in this crackdown.

NGOs are facing the same restrictions as they cannot carry out their activities without "cooperation" from provincial and municipal authorities. From June to October of this year, an organization called Voice of Democracy organized 19 public forums in different localities for people to debate and address issues facing them. Eight of these forums experienced various degrees of disruption or obstruction by local authorities.

Press freedom is also restricted. Journalists have been facing threats and intimidation in their work. A few have faced lawsuits. Reporters of the Khmer-language program of the U.S. network Radio Free Asia are known to be "frequently singled out for harassment by government officials." The field editor of this radio network said that "news reports about illegal logging, malnutrition in impoverished areas and human rights abuses have resulted in angry, and sometimes threatening, calls from senior Ministry of Information officials."

The report of Global Witness on illegal logging was banned in June, and a magazine called The Free Press Magazine was confiscated in November of this year. In both cases, the authorities arbitrarily took action without any recourse to the due process of law to adjudicate the unlawfulness of these publications.

The human rights abuses above are but a sample, as there are numerous others. They nevertheless show that the Cambodian government has not honored its international human rights obligations, and policies and practices of the past, though in a milder form, have now returned in Cambodia.

The state signatories to the Paris Peace Agreements should honor their commitments to promote and encourage observance of, and respect for, human rights and fundamental freedoms in Cambodia and should work with the Cambodian government to put an end to these abuses so that the long-suffering people of Cambodia can enjoy peace, stability, human rights and their freedoms.
--
(Lao Mong Hay is currently a senior researcher at the Asian Human Rights Commission in Hong Kong. He was previously director of the Khmer Institute of Democracy in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, and a visiting professor at the University of Toronto in 2003. In 1997, he received an award from Human Rights Watch and the Nansen Medal in 2000 from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.)

Saturday, October 20, 2007

Burma holding 2,500 in prison and arrests continue, UK says

Saturday October 20, 2007
Julian Borger, diplomatic editor
The Guardian (UK)


The military regime in Burma is still holding up to 2,500 people in prisons and labour camps around the country, and continues to arrest suspected dissidents, the British government claimed yesterday.

The crackdown on the protest movement has only served to make Burma more unstable, a senior British diplomat argued, with acts of resistance widespread.

He added that the country's long-running ethnic conflict between the regime and the Karen minority could deepen, with former fighters who had signed a ceasefire with the government now talking of a return to armed resistance.

The military junta has come under increasing pressure in the form of US and European sanctions targeted on the regime's money-making ventures and a rebuke from the UN security council.

However, the sanctions do not include the oil and gas sector, and Amnesty International yesterday said the junta was still receiving military equipment from China, Russia, Ukraine, and India.

The Burmese generals claim to have released all but 500 of the Buddhist monks and other demonstrators detained since last month's pro-democracy protests. But the senior British diplomat, briefing journalists yesterday on condition of anonymity, gave a "conservative estimate" that 2,000 to 2,500 were still being held and more were being picked up.

"There are substantial night-time raids going on. They have scooped up hundreds of people," the diplomat said.

British officials and human rights activists believe there are four main detention centres in Rangoon: a racecourse, the city's institute of technology, the Insein prison, and the Mingladon detention facility.

But the diplomat said detainees were increasingly being dispersed around the country, particularly to centres the regime calls New Life camps - gulags where detainees are used as forced labour.

"We are hearing from people who have been locked up directly ... the conditions in which they are being held: in excrement-smeared rooms, hundreds to a room, not fed, interrogated," he said.

The official death toll of the crackdown is 10, but the diplomat said: "We believe it is very many multiples of that."

The protesters are being tried in secret, facing a minimum sentence of two years. British officials believe those found guilty of participation in the protests would face more than seven years in jail, and the leaders could be imprisoned for 20 years.

The diplomat said the monks' treatment had outraged a profoundly religious nation. "The anger is quite extraordinary when you scratch the surface. In fact you barely need to do that," he said. "We are still seeing incidents of low-level resistance with rocks and bricks being thrown at the police at night."

Monday, September 24, 2007

Constitution Day should remind the government of its obligations

AS-232-2007
September 24, 2007


A Statement by the Asian Human Rights Commission

CAMBODIA: Constitution Day should remind the government of its obligations

September 24 is Constitution Day in Cambodia; a public holiday called to celebrate the anniversary of promulgation of the country’s new constitution on the same day in 1993. This constitution was adopted by a constitutional assembly elected under the auspices of the United Nations, which administered the country in 1992 and 1993 pursuant to the Paris Peace Agreements of 1991 that put an end to the war in that country.

According to those international agreements and its new constitution, Cambodia is a democratic country governed by the rule of law, and has adhered to international human rights norms and standards. Yet 16 years after the signing of those agreements and 14 years after the promulgation of that constitution, it has continued to fail in its obligations to ensure respect for, and observance of, human rights and fundamental freedoms, and to support the right of all Cambodian citizens to undertake activities which would promote and protect human rights. Furthermore, it has continuously failed to act on certain important provisions of its constitution.

Cambodia’s performance on fundamental rights has remained very poor. As stipulated in the Paris Peace Agreements, these fundamental rights comprise of: the rights of life, personal liberty, security, freedom of movement, freedom of religion, assembly and association including political parties and trade unions, due process and equality before the law, protection from arbitrary deprivation of property or deprivation of private property without just compensation, and freedom from racial, ethnic, religious or sexual discrimination.

Despite the generous aid it has received, an average of over US0 million a year since 1993, and its exploitation of forests and the country's other natural resources, Cambodia has not been able to meet the right to life of its people. According to UNICEF, one in three Cambodians still lives below the poverty line of one US dollar a day. Cambodia has the highest infant and under-five mortality rate in the region, at 97 and 141 per 1,000 live births, respectively. It has a net primary school enrollment and attendance of 65 per cent. In 2005 the annual number of under-5 deaths was 61,000 for a country of 14 million inhabitants.

Cambodians have not been able to enjoy personal liberty and security when their country is rife with crime of all sorts. Nor have they been able to enjoy freedom of assembly and association, when peaceful public protests and demonstrations have been practically banned since early 2003. Requests for permission for demonstrations are subject to severe and meticulous scrutiny, and very few have been authoritsed. The police have used force to crack down on, and stop any unauthorised protests and demonstrations.

As regards political freedom and labour unions, opposition party activists and unionists have been harassed, intimidated, threatened and even killed. In March 2007, a candidate named Hak Sok from a newly formed political party, was shot dead in his own home, just days before the commune elections. In February 2007, a labour unionist, Hy Vuthy, was shot dead in Phnom Penh while riding home after his night shift.

Public authorities have undermined the due process of law when they have invariably issued orders, for instance to forcibly evict people from their land, or punish those who defy their orders. In April 2007, the governor of the seaport town of Sihanoukville did not apply for court orders, but simply sent armed police together with tractors to evict villagers and demolish their houses, turning those villagers homeless, on the charge that they had been illegally occupying other people’s property. Between the end of July and early August 2007, the government ignored the due process of law to get a luxurious housing development company to comply with its order to stop its construction work, it simply sent a team of officials together with workers and excavators to completely demolish a luxurious housing estate, estimated to be worth US million, that company had been building.

Cambodians have not enjoyed any equality before the law. The powerful and the rich can get away with their crimes while the weak and the poor, including the innocent, at times have to face the law for crimes that they may or may not have actually committed. In 2004 a prominent labour union leader, Chea Vichea, was murdered. Two men, Born Samnang and Sok Sam Oeun, were arrested and later sentenced to 20 years in prison, despite alibi proving they had not been at the scene of the crime at the time of the murder, and the absence of prosecution witnesses in court.

In recent years the right to protection from arbitrary deprivation of property or deprivation of private property without just compensation has been notoriously violated. The powerful and the rich, in connivance with the powerful have grabbed land from people who have legally owned or occupied it, and offered them compensation worth a fraction of the market price of their land. Armed police are sent in to quell any protests or resistance to evictions. In August 2007, a group of 100 people comprising of armed civilians and military police in uniform and some personnel with sticks, hammers and axes allegedly hired by a company known as 7NG, went to the Dey Krahorm community in Phnom Penh to demolish houses, huts and tents in the area, without having any court order. Some 400 families protested against and resisted the demolition. Clashes occurred in which four women were badly beaten up.

There are also violations of other constitutional rights such as freedom of expression and freedom of the press, but they are not enumerated here. Having said this, Cambodians enjoy have enjoyed freedom of movement since 1993 and can travel anywhere inside or outside the country. Until July, 2007 when the government has curtailed the proselytizing work of Christian activists, they also enjoyed freedom of belief and of religion.

Cambodia has also failed in its undertaking to support its citizens who are engaged in promoting and protecting human rights. Public authorities have controlled and restricted their activities, intimidated and threatened them, and even accused them of incitement to protests and riot. Many government officials have continued to see human rights activists as trouble-makers. In 2005 the Ministry of Interior issued an order prescribing that NGOs and associations must have permission from provincial governors before they can hold seminars or training sessions. In April 2007, the police in the seaport town of Sihanoukville set out to arrest a human rights activist for inciting villagers to protest against, and resist eviction from their land. That activist had to go into hiding to avoid arrest.

On this 14th anniversary of the constitution, reflection should also be focused on the functioning of certain institutions stipulated in that constitution, namely the Judiciary, the Constitutional Council, the Supreme Council of National Defense and the National Congress.

The Paris Peace Agreements spelled out unambiguously that “an independent judiciary will be established, empowered to enforce the rights provided under the constitution.” The constitution has affirmed the separation of powers and this judicial independence. It has even assigned the judiciary the task of “protecting the rights and freedoms of citizens.”

However, in practice, the judiciary is not independent and is not given adequate resources for its functioning. It is under political control through direct government action against judges, through discrete intervention by powerful government officials, and/or through the affiliation of judges and prosecutors to the ruling Cambodian People’s Party (CPP). The CPP is a former communist party whose discipline and control are as strict as ever. In August 2007 the government bypassed the Supreme Council of the Magistracy, a supposedly independent constitutional body whose one task is to nominate and discipline judges and prosecutors, and arbitrarily removed Ly Vouch Leng, President of the Court of Appeal, and nominated You Bun Leng as her replacement.

As a result of such political control and lack of resources, the judiciary cannot, or is unwilling to protect the rights and freedoms of the Cambodian people. The newly enacted code of criminal procedure does not offer much help to the judiciary to carry out its constitutional duties. This code, enacted in August 2007, does not have sufficient provision to ensure full protection of the constitutional rights of the Cambodian people. For instance, a suspect in police custody cannot have the right of access to legal counsel or the right to contact a person of his or her choosing until after the 24th hour of his or her arrest, and then for only 30 minutes. He or she does not have to the right to medical treatment while in police custody. Only the custodial officer or the prosecutor can assign a doctor to visit him or her.

There are long delays in the administration of justice, impunity for the powerful and the rich, no equal protection by the law and no equality before the law. Backlogs of thousands of cases and prolonged delays, especially at the Court of Appeal, are an additional punishment for those who languish in jails where the conditions are well below the UN minimum standards. Bail is an exception rather than the rule.

The Constitutional Council is not independent and impartial. This Council has nine members, but the most of them are political appointees and are members of the ruling party (CPP). Furthermore, not all of them have the qualifications and expertise in the fields stipulated in the constitution, that is, law, administration, diplomacy or economics. The constitution itself bars its accessibility to the public. Only the king, the prime minister, members of the parliament and senators can raise issues of constitutionality with it. Litigants in court may raise the constitutionality of laws or regulations with the Constitutional Council through a complex procedure to the Supreme Court first, when they feel that those laws or regulations affect their rights.

As to the Supreme Council of National Defense and the National Congress, they have not yet been set up, even 14 years after the promulgation of the constitution.

The King is the Supreme Commander of the Royal Cambodian Armed Forces (RCAF) and is to chair the Supreme Council of National Defence. It is not clear to whom or to which body the RCAF and their Commander-in-Chief is accountable if there is no such council. In the interim, it is apparent that they are accountable to the Prime Minister who is using them to reinforce his power.

The National Congress is a congregation of Cambodian people across the country which is supposed to be held every December, and to whom the government reports on various matters of national interests. All citizens have the right to participate in this forum. This congress can raise issues for state institutions to address. The Prime Minister convenes this congress, which is chaired by the king. In a way, through this forum, people can hold their leaders to account.

The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) urges the Cambodian government, parliament and the judiciary to fully honour Cambodia’s human rights and all other obligations under the Paris Peace Agreements of 1991 and the constitution of the country. The government and parliament should respect the separation of powers and the independence of the judiciary and allocate adequate resources for it to protect the rights and freedoms of the Cambodian people. They should ensure that the Constitutional Council is an independent body run by independent people with the qualifications and expertise required by the constitution. They should also ensure that this council is easily accessible to the public.

The AHRC also urges the government and parliament not to further delay the creation of the Supreme Council of National Defence and the National Congress. Any omission in this task is simply unconstitutional.

The AHRC further urges donors and UN and international agencies to work with the Cambodian government, parliament and judiciary to ensure that all of Cambodia's obligations under the Paris Peace Agreements and its constitution are fully honoured without any further delay, 16 years after the signing of those agreements and 14 years after the promulgation of that constitution.

# # #

About AHRC: The Asian Human Rights Commission is a regional non-governmental organisation monitoring and lobbying human rights issues in Asia. The Hong Kong-based group was founded in 1984.

Tuesday, August 14, 2007

CAMBODIA: Khmer Krom seek return of defrocked monk

14/08/2007
Radio Australia
Australian Broadcasting Corporation


The Khmer Krom Federation is applying international pressure to demand the return to Cambodia of defrocked monk, Tim Sakhorn. The Khmer Krom are a minority group in the Mekong Delta region of Vietnam and Cambodia. The former abbott of the Phnom Den pagoda in Cambodia went missing for a month after being defrocked in June for allegedly stirring unrest in Vietnam. He's now facing a charge in Vietnam for entering the country illegally.

Presenter - Sonja Heydeman Speaker - Giap Tran, Treasurer of the Khmer Krom Federation in the US); Director of the Hawaian Institute for Human Rights, Joshua Cooper

HEYDEMAN: The Director of the Hawaian Institute for Human Rights is concerned for the welfare of Tim Sakhorn.

Joshua Cooper says the Khmer Krom Federation, as well as its alliances of NGO's and activists have been working full-time since the first whisper of the former abbott's disappearance.

COOPER: From the issue of the disrobing which we find was not accurate in any way, to the issue of the deportation, which was also alarming, and then of course to the disappearance. We know that there's actually new international instrument on disappearances, we've actually utilised every international mechanism available from the special rapporteurs focussing on religious freedom to the special rapporteurs on indigenous people. So we've been active so that hopefully it wouldn't come to that level of a story about a sad situation, but more importantly about people standing up for their rights from the beginning.

HEYDEMAN: Joshua Cooper says he believes Tim Sakhorn will be successfully freed.

COOPER: And we believe that through our efforts of organising with our NGO networks as well as academics, and more importantly through the international institutions guaranteed to protect and promote human rights, they will be successful to secure his release.

HEYDEMAN: The Human Rights Institute Director says sources in Vietnam are trying to keep track of the location and condition of Tim Sakhorn.

Mr Cooper says this is not the only case they're watching.

COOPER: The case of the five who had been disrobed and then also faced charges and so I think this is important is that if we hadn't done the groundwork in the last five years these kind of things that are taking place to Khmer people I mean almost for centuries, and definitely in the last decades from the 70s onwards, but no one knew about the Khmer people and their struggle for self-determination. And what we have then is we've taken this case to the International Court of Justice, to the international human rights bodies such as SEDA focussing on women's rights. And so I think that work has made it then more of a story and more people are aware, whereas unfortunately these human rights violations have taken place consistently for a long period of time. The only difference now is the world is watching.

HEYDEMAN: The Director of the Hawaian Institute for Human Rights, Joshua Cooper.

The Treasurer of the Khmer Krom Federation in the US, Giap Tran, says Khmer Krom communities around the world are actively seeking the release of Tim Sakhorn.

Mr Tran says the Vietnamese government has systematically tried to erase the Khmer Krom entirely.

He says part of the dilemma is the lack of global awareness of their plight.

TRAN: Around the world it seems since the French colonised there they ceded the land to Vietnam, since then all the history has been erased and millions of Khmer Krom that be a part of that land that has been buried under Vietnamese regime.

HEYDEMAN: Mr Tran says he feels such a great sense of sadness for his people.

TRAN: Right now what I can feel for them is like a stateless people. When we lived in Vietnam, Vietnamese government never gave any respect as a people, as Vietnamese citizens. They tried to do all kinds of oppression to make Khmer people leave the country. When we left the country to Cambodia, Cambodian government announced that they recognised Khmer Krom as a citizen when we get to Cambodia. But in reality there's no protection, there's no legal mechanism to help us when we're in Cambodia. So when you look into both countries, not willing to recognise us as people, so it's got to be very, very emotional.

HEYDEMAN: Meanwhile, the Hawaian of Institute for Human Rights Director, Joshua Cooper says there needs to be mechanisms in place in the region to promote and protect human rights.

COOPER: The European Court of Human Rights exists, Africa's creating a court and inter-America has a court and a commission. We believe we don't want there to be more Tim Sakhorns and we believe the only way to do that is to build institutions on a regional level that will then take the cultures as well as the global customs and norms into account. So we believe a human rights instrument at the regional level in Asia would be one of those aspects. So we're not just focussing on Tim now, but also for the future for all people who stand up for their human rights.